How Hangman Page Will Change Everything About Pro Wrestling
How AEW's Hangman Page has elevated Dynamite to the realms of prestige TV.
To fully understand and appreciate the incredible arc mapped by and for Hangman Adam Page, one must remember the enormity of the task he faced at All Out 2019.
He had signed with a new upstart billionaire-funded pro wrestling company, one that by rights should never have existed, looking at WWE's monopoly and the almost bottomless resources they had to maintain it. That company, AEW, was fronted by the most ambitious and talented field of free agents ever - it was Cody Rhodes who bet everything to will All In into existence, and it was the Elite who created the market conditions that encouraged him to place it.
It was the destination promotion before President Tony Khan even promoted the first show; PAC joined immediately, and the legendary Chris Jericho was so won over by the pitch that he elected to work for a non-WWE company after deciding years ago to only ever work for Vince McMahon. Between Jericho, Cody, Kenny Omega and the Young Bucks, AEW boasted the best talkers, best bell-to-bell workers and, on the strength of Being The Elite, the best episodic storytellers in the business. This thing wasn't just going to be big; it was going to be good. Really good. And it had to be. They talked it up as the next great chapter in North American wrestling, and there was giant to topple.
Page starred at that first event, Double Or Nothing, by winning the Casino Battle Royal.
CONT'D...(1 of 6)
At Fight For The Fallen, he narrowly got by Kip Sabian in an overlong and unfocused match, the shrugging reception to which layered, at least, what would become AEW's greatest long-term story - and, one day, the blueprint for pro wrestling narrative deeper into the 21st century. Page was a main event bust in the company that could not afford to fail.
This feeling became canon at All Out. Jericho pinned Page clean in the middle of the ring. Page wasn't screwed. He failed. On the post-PPV Being The Elite, Page cut a shattered figure. The Bucks attempted to console him, but he was inconsolable. That the Bucks had rejected his plea to second him at the show deepened his sadness. He no longer felt worthy of the Elite name, and as Dynamite launched, he quietly distanced himself from it.
This was handled so elegantly; as those early Elite Vs. Inner Circle brawls erupted, Page was either slow to make the save, or barely participated at all. In the meantime, he renewed hostilities with PAC, his snake-bitten rival. In yet more careful, subtle booking, he won a nuanced banger at Full Gear, but lost the trilogy. This was crucial; Page in storylines always remained a great wrestler, just one experiencing a dip in form and confidence. The balance was exquisite, in that fans were still allowed to believe in him, but he couldn't believe in himself.
Kenny Omega still believed in him, or at least, that's how the next, seminal chapter seemed to begin. Driven by their respective failures in the singles division, the two men at Omega's urging joined forces in the tag ranks.
CONT'D...(2 of 6)
In a stunning story arc pulsing with as much intrigue as match quality, these diametrically opposed men - the hard-drinking cowboy and the affected teetotaller Canadian - developed an instant chemistry. Omega was fabulous at blitzing his opponents and had the stamina to endure the double-team; Page's explosive stopping power marked him as the perfect hot tag guy. They were made for one another as professionals as much as they were distanced as human beings.
The storytelling threaded across their matches and interactions with the Young Bucks was unrivalled in the history of North American TV. Barely any of it was expositional under wrestling's standard tell-don't-show framework, which in part positions the medium beneath art in the minds of its critics or those apathetic towards it. The timing and the motive behind those hot tags was something else. The audience was asked as many questions as they thrilled by the incredible moves bell-to-bell: Is Hangman Page the glory-hogging heel? Or should we be sympathetic towards his need to overcompensate? Is he selfish, by celebrating alone? Or are Omega and the Bucks sharing in Page's breakout success to mask their own failures?
And Page was the breakout star of the storyline; fans loved his ass-kicking physicality and drunken swagger. But it was always a front, as revealed to quiet devastation at Revolution. In the genre's masterpiece, the sight of Page using the One-Winged Angel to connect with Omega - where Omega has borrowed from the arsenals of most every peer other than the Hangman - was a sad moment masquerading as a babyface pop. What an unbelievable distillation of the character this was.
CONT'D...(3 of 6)
After the events of Stadium Stampede, in which Page and Omega seemed to fully reconcile, the debut of FTR followed. In just exquisite long-term booking, Dax Harwood and Cash Wheeler set in motion a masterplan to shatter the Elite from within, and they wormed their way in by targeting Page's drinking habit. They themselves were beer-swilling mid-Atlantic boys, and they knew that they could fake a connection, and they did, knowing that Page's alcoholism was the source of the fracture.
They eventually convinced Page to turn on the Bucks - they were after that spotlight again - and he did. At All Out - a very rich pattern is emerging here - Page lost the title match. His poisoned mind scattered, he f*cked up a double team, and in the end, he reached out. Kenny Omega let him fall like a drunk over a stool, and the Cleaner defeated his former partner at Full Gear. But again, the balance was perfect; Page won the Eliminator quarter and semi-final. He is a great professional wrestler. He just doesn't believe himself to be Elite, and he couldn't join in the celebrations after the Bucks finally vanquished FTR later that night. He hovered, uncertain, by the entrance tunnel. That his failure was brought into starker focus by the success of the original Elite was such expert, big picture booking. 'Deft' is a word your writer uses often, to describe the best of AEW. That particular orchestration of events was majestic. That failure stung so sharply that it led him down a path no top babyface has ever travelled.
Because Hangman Page is quietly redefining what it means to be a professional wrestling babyface.
CONT'D...(4 of 6)
Wrestlers don't just dip in confidence in storylines. They are confident alpha males who are meant to appeal in an aspirational sense. Headline wrestlers don't just join comedic undercard cults to feel like they belong some place. They stay in the mix, "protected" via some traditional mechanism or other, so as to not lose their value as ticket-selling performers. They don't sink to their lowest ebb. They don't feel "head to toe like poison"; they issue badass threats.
Page isn't cynically gunning for the top spot in any Wrestler of the Year lists, if the beginning of 2021 is any indication. He doesn't think in years, nor indeed in the vein of any traditional accolades. He is, using the expressive AEW platform, curating a career rich in continuity as inspired by Kenny Omega.
David Lynch upon making Twin Peaks talked up the potential of television when it was thought by some critics that he'd lowered himself to the medium. He luxuriated in the idea of the "continuing story," feeling that film was limited in that regard. The sheer expanse of television, in Lynch's mind, allowed for an immense deepening of investment and possibility. It appears, whether with knowledge of the quote or not, that Page has applied it to his work. It all feels like one long continuing story not marked by the old hoary machinations of heel turns and sharp narrative pivots designed to get his "heat back". Hangman Page is elevating the soap opera of professional wrestling into prestige drama.
There's a brand new sense of heft and reality to Hangman's arc that is as powerful as it is ambitious.
CONT'D...(5 of 6)
Hangman Page is ruggedly handsome, irreverently witty, and exceptionally talented. He has all of his thick, flowing hair. He shouldn't walk the streets with any fear; he has a forearm that could take anybody's head clean off. But he is plagued by mental health issues. His is a very brave story to tell, and it's even powerful that he is the one telling it. The message is inconvenient, scary, but crucial: anxiety and depression are indiscriminate. His whiskey doubles as a totem of masculinity and insecurity. The work is rooted in the classic form, but he is taking it to a place nobody else has - with the ironic exception of Omega.
A former schoolteacher, the keenly intelligent Page flecks this arc with touching symbolism and so much rewarding subtext.
At Full Gear, he switched trunks for tights in a visual plea to the partner he knew was going to desert him. He clutched tightly to Omega's legs, mirroring his betrayal of Nick Jackson, to prevent him from taking a suplex. Hangman Page tells better stories with his hands than most do with a microphone in hand, whether he's nursing a drink or desperately holding onto a lost connection. The level of detail Page puts into his work, even in his flippant lower thirds, is almost unparalleled.
Page is playing a real and vulnerable man in a cartoon world of badasses, and he trusts you to get it, to stay with him always, even when he's stuck in place, not knowing which direction to take. The discourse surrounding babyfaces and heels is tedious, mostly. The "tweener" is usually just poorly booked. The heel and face roles can and should be situational; if it's good enough for Hiroshi Tanahashi, really, it should be good enough for everybody. But it's difficult to think of a deeper and more well-drawn character than the Hangman.
One day, the evolution of professional wrestling narrative will be traced back to this very arc.