How WrestleMania 40 Will Ruin Triple H's WWE Story

Forget 'Mania, it's WWE story-ruining season, folks!

WWE Royal Rumble 2024 Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

What a difference a few weeks makes, eh?

As 2024 got underway, WWE honestly looked like a company on the verge of producing a WrestleMania every bit as stupendous as Vince McMahon forced you to believe the 38th edition would be.

Genuine megastars had made returns that weren't just shocking, they were once unthinkable, with the likes of CM Punk and The Rock both strutting back into the world of sports entertainment just in time for what could be the biggest 'Show of Shows' ever.

Cody Rhodes, Bayley, Rhea Ripley, Becky Lynch, Drew McIntyre, Gunther and many more had all been patiently and consistently pushed as figures to actually give a damn about over the previous year, creating an organic desire to see each of those full-time characters get their well-earned spot in Philadelphia.

But then the wheels spectacularly/horrifyingly fell off.

The Rock - Raw 2024
WWE.com

After Rocky's Day 1 return left those banging the drum for a certain story to be finished feeling a touch nervous, that tiny drama - and WWE finalising a gigantic deal with Netflix - was soon completely overshadowed by the horrifying allegations made against the former Chairman of the Board.

From that moment on, a dark cloud has quite rightly sat over anything going down in-between the ropes.

However, horribly handled press conference aside, Triple H did somehow manage to restore at least some of the positive vibes by having Rhodes and 'The Role Model' walk out of Florida with a main event spot at 'The Showcase of the Immortals' guaranteed.

Hell, Cody even pointed at Roman Reigns in a box!

The story was being finished.

Punk and Seth Rollins were about to finally get their precious 'Mania main events - and the newest member of the TKO board of directors would likely just do the right thing and set-up a magnificent 'Head of the Table' clash in 2025, right?

That was a whopping 10-days ago (at time of writing). Feel old yet?

Now, after a legendarily disastrous SmackDown segment, Rhodes' story isn't the only one in danger of being irreparably ruined...

CONT'D...


WWE Royal Rumble 2024 Triple H Paul Levesque
WWE

Even before 'The Great One' seemingly shoved Cody out of the way and completely undermined one of the most important matches/shows of the year in the Rumble, 'Papa H' and WWE had made a pig's ear of the real most important story of the year.

In what was the first proper opportunity the company had to openly discuss the disgusting sexual assault and sex trafficking accusations found in the lawsuit against Vince McMahon, John Laurinaitis, and WWE as a company, how did Paul Levesque respond to questions about the disturbing subject during the post-Rumble press conference?

By admitting he hadn't read the aforementioned document and talking up the otherwise positive week WWE had experienced because he didn't want to "get bogged down in the negatives of it."

Sure, Triple H did also note how the company were doing "everything possible" to keep WWE employees safe. But the feeling felt by many coming out of that presser was that things could have definitely been handled far better, with Levesque's deflecting and evading of the uncomfortable but vital questions now becoming yet another self-inflicted scar on his WWE legacy.

While folks were less than impressed with the king of creative's handling of real-life situations, though, at least he was still rewarding faith and giving WWE fans the hotly anticipated babyface triumphs they'd been begging for all year.

Yeah, about that.

In the time it takes to deliver a project-shattering People's Elbow, Trips' dreams of adding another terrific chapter into his own creative story were seemingly shattered. Before Rhodes even pointed at the sign, bizarrely...

CONT'D...


The Rock Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

Though there are some out there who insist that the emergence of 'The Great One' on the blue show last Friday was simply WWE's way of reacting to a heartbreaking Punk injury or the already noted dreadful McMahon story, the truth is that this utterly baffling development was apparently a part of the plan from as early as January 3 - back when Rock signed his deal to come back "home".

Why, then, would WWE still insist on having their most adored babyface win the Rumble at a time when Punk vs. Rollins was still being reported as the World Heavyweight Championship 'Mania encounter?

Well, judging from Dave Meltzer's comments on Wrestling Observer Radio recently, it seems very few were actually aware of Rocky's impending in-ring comeback being official, with only the likes of WWE President Nick Khan, and Endeavor CEO Ari Emanuel knowing about the plan - "It was way above the head of everybody in WWE other than Nick", was how Meltzer put it.

The Rock Roman Reigns
WWE.com

So, if that was the case - and that's still a speculative "if" at this point, it must be stressed - then it doesn't half make Triple H and his team look like fools for committing to the Rhodes/Reigns Rumble visual that all-but confirmed a 'Mania 39 rematch.

And even if this was just all part of a grand plan to "Daniel Bryan" the Rumble winner, congrats lads, you've also managed to completely undermine what could have been one of the most exciting showdowns of all time, make winning the Rumble feel like an inconsequential feat, and potentially turn Rocky heel for what will likely be his final-ever match in the process.

The whole thing just stinks of right hand not knowing what the left one is doing. And it will be a rather embarrassed 'Cerebral Assassin' who is left picking up the pieces should his poster boy project be shoved into a spot lower down the 'Mania XL card in the end.

Maybe we're all just being worked, though, and a mind-blowing, 'Mania-saving swerve is on its way this Thursday...

CONT'D...


WWE WrestleMania XL Kickoff
WWE

If the miraculous does actually go down and Rhodes tells Dwayne to do one during the Las Vegas press conference set to go down inside of the T-Mobile Arena on February 8, then... what was the point of all this again?

Sure, the ordeal has added more fuel to the fires that burn for the 'American Nightmare', but they would've been blazing without Rock threatening to spoil the party.

It's worth noting that the Hollywood megastar had reportedly been pushing for a 'Mania match with his cousin for some time.

And while interest in a Rock/Roman war would have unquestionably still been there in a year's time, perhaps the TKO board member saw an opportunity to be front and centre at a time when the company had almost never been hotter and didn't care who he stepped over (Cody), or on (Trips), to take it.

At this point, the damage has been done.

Cody Rhodes Seth Rollins
WWE.com

Rhodes could whip Johnson out of Vegas with his weight belt on Thursday and the story will still be one of WWE once again stupidly fumbling the easiest of open goals. The more things change, eh.

Will having the most successful wrestling crossover star of all time on the card bring more eyes and money to the two-night extravaganza? Undoubtedly.

But enough to justify the conversation going from being on an exciting WWE future focused on sensational rising stars like Tiffany Stratton, Jade Cargill, Bron Breakker, and the present top names who've made the promotion as popular as it is today, to all about Dwayne's game? Perhaps not.

WrestleMania XL once looked like the event that would act as both a celebration of all Triple H has achieved over the last 12-months - getting multiple babyfaces ridiculously over, making the jump up from NXT the seamless/thrilling one it always should have been, telling logical stories over long periods of time, breaking many an attendance and grossing record - and the beginning of yet another rewarding chapter.

Now it just feels like another Rock vehicle designed to get 'The People's Champion' back in the spotlight after a few hit-and-miss years at the box office.

If Trips' time on the creative throne has shown fans one thing, however, it's that nothing is over 'til it's over...

CONT'D...


WWE WrestleMania XL Cody Rhodes Undisputed Title
WWE

CM Punk wasn't returning... until he did.

Cody Rhodes wasn't winning back-to-back Rumbles... until he did.

The increasingly batsh*t "never say never" rule, even at a time when it seems like there is "no scenario" where Rock/Reigns isn't the Night Two conclusion at 'Mania XL, is still in play.

There are opportunities there for Levesque to still achieve some much-needed good at a time when he's found himself penning so many unwanted paragraphs into his ongoing novel in Gorilla, too - even away from The Rock potentially shrugging off Rhodes' and Trips' stories for his own.

'Papa H' still seemingly has the power to give the terrifically booked Gunther the WrestleMania showcase his world class run with the Intercontinental Championship deserves.

He could give Bayley the once unlikely Night One main event spot as a crowd-pleasing "thank you" for years of being her division's ever-reliable Horsewoman.

WWE Royal Rumble 2024 Bayley
WWE.com

Stratton, Cargill, Breakker, The Creed Brothers, Pete Dunne & Tyler Bate, and the other well handled stars of tomorrow can be rewarded with the chance to establish themselves on that stadium stage.

And the countless heroes and villains (and somewhere in-between) who have carried this product back into the general public's minds - LA Knight, Sami Zayn, Kevin Owens, Drew McIntyre, Becky Lynch, Rhea Ripley, Randy Orton, Seth Rollins, Jimmy & Jey Uso? Surely Trips will find a way to give them all something meaningful to do across two-nights of Moments.

As last year's Los Angeles epic highlighted, though, (ironically) it doesn't matter how hard you work and how well you book the rest of the biggest nights of the year. If you blow that ending, very few will fondly remember the rest of the story.

Put simply, so many stories are hanging in the balance coming into the most crucial press conference since... well, the last one.

Will a Rocky who once again "sucks!" get his match and WrestleMania XL end up becoming the point when folks finally lose faith in the 'King of Kings' holding the creative pen? Or will WWE find a way to somehow have their cake and eat it, too, unexpectedly salvaging a Road to WrestleMania that's becoming more volatile by the week?

Over to you, Vegas...


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Gareth has 6 years experience writing and presenting articles/videos covering all things professional wrestling within the fantastic WhatCulture team. Gareth is also a life long wrestling fan, so is clearly living the dream!