Inside AEW's Creative Process | How It Works

OR, how it's no longer working: a deep-dive into the evolution of All Elite Wrestling's creative...

AEW Tony Khan Belt
AEW

When AEW launched, the creative was booked via committee.

President Tony Khan and the Executive Vice President team of Cody Rhodes, Kenny Omega and the Young Bucks mapped out a long stretch of programming. While they had to contend with the small matter of building the infrastructure of a major cable outfit from nothing, they did benefit from the (obvious) fact that AEW hadn't actually made its debut in the early months of 2019. They had not yet found themselves in the voracious maw of politics. They had not yet signed a major free-agent star for whom existing top-level creative had to be shredded. They had not yet had to contend with injuries disrupting plans. They hadn't endured the reality of a huge week-to-week operation and the frazzle that comes with it. It's difficult to map out multiple intricate long-term storylines when the demand for content is relentless.

The committee envisioned and followed through with various plans, even booking the first handful of World champions well in advance. While taking a market share from WWE was an unenviable task, a star-studded company debuting at the arena level months away was key. Five passionate, intelligent minds, totally fresh, raring to go, not yet pummelled by the intensive soap opera workload requirement: it was an unprecedented advantage, and AEW grabbed it.

Chris Jericho was the recognisable mainstream-adjacent star whose endless creativity allowed him to develop a priceless 'Le Champion' act as the first World champion. MJF was a sensational heel prodigy, and because of that precious time, AEW was able to plot a long evil masterplan to get the character over. The Elite's internal strife was explored through respective losing streaks, which while controversial at the time - Dave Meltzer, despite his apparent bias, was adamant that this was a huge mistake - allowed AEW to do a lot. It allowed Jericho to establish the brand as a trustworthy concern on top. It allowed Jon Moxley, as the best version of his awesome self, to carry the company through 2020. This in turn allowed AEW to propel the Elite to the forefront in 2021. The famous shot at Full Gear 2020, with a despondent Hangman Page in the tunnel unaware that he would be redeemed a year later, proved that AEW was right. The World singles and tags title scenes were reimagined in the image of the Elite, who were instrumental in that white-hot summer of 2021.

By this point, though, the committee had been abandoned. After the dismal December 18, 2019 episode of Dynamite, Tony Khan broke it up and took "final cut" of the promotion where, previously, he had allowed certain developments to unfold that he wasn't happy with. "I just needed to probably take more ownership of what I was doing because at the end of the day, there were a lot of cooks in one show," he told Moose & Maggie on WFAN in 2021 (h/t the Sportster). His language was euphemistic.

Nobody has spoken on record about this change, at least candidly, and nor have they disclosed any details behind the heavily rumoured fall-out between Cody Rhodes and the Elite (and the rumoured power struggle between Kenny Omega and Brandi Rhodes).

Nonetheless, by 2021, AEW had established the perfect model.

CONT'D...(1 of 5)


Keith Lee SS
WWE.com

With full editorial control, Khan booked the hottest wrestling promotion in years. His self-appointed ability to cut the most self-indulgent ideas helped the Elite rehabilitate their star aura, but his continued willingness to allow these diamond-sharp wrestling minds to tell their own story, albeit with an editor, was a masterstroke. In the summer of 2021, AEW was, mostly, in perfect harmony. This was the glory era of collaboration.

All the while, even down to the lowest spots on the card, Khan encouraged his wrestlers to cut promos unscripted. The results were mixed, but this model allowed some of the best promo artists of their generation - Jon Moxley, MJF, Eddie Kingston et al. - to play their own music. Poor Marina Shafir was stigmatised for her dire, unintentionally funny attempts as a virtual novice, the response to which was wildly disproportionate in this social media age. Calls for some scripting were whispered, and this noise intensified when the widespread political unrest set in. Khan may well have listened.

This harmony was disturbed by more than one factor subsequently, and what followed was a series of overcorrections that ultimately created a gigantic mess that is increasingly difficult to clean.

Firstly, Tony Khan expanded his roster to a preposterous size with an impulsive greed. He did so with no calculated long-term vision as to where every piece would fit. On a case-by-case basis, most of the signings were shrewd. Understandable.

Keith Lee is the best example to use here, because why wouldn’t a promoter pick up a talent with such vast, unfulfilled potential? Lee was a one-of-a-kind act on the indies, a wrestler nobody else could train to become, a living oxymoron of agility and size who had stolen the show on two consecutive WWE Big Four pay-per-views.

The answer to that question is that Khan had no room with which to accommodate him and, after an inspired team with Swerve In Our Glory, Lee more or less vanished. Tony Khan to this day hasn't booked a singles grudge match between Lee and Swerve Strickland. So much more content got in the way, and now that the feud is ice-cold, a lot of time has been wasted. If Lee as is tradition won the theoretical blow-off, under the old rankings system, he'd have to nearing contention for a title. It was either that, or book him 50/50, but with no room in a crowded scene, neither development happened. It was easier for AEW to just pretend that he no longer existed. The rankings system was abandoned in part because it no longer worked in the context of the new super-sized AEW. It wasn't practical.

A problem (too many star names) created another problem (too few meaningful match results), which might explain why AEW's creative decline feels exponential.

CONT'D...(2 of 5)


Chris Jericho
AEW

Khan's attempts to accommodate the changes that have swept through AEW have failed. He has attempted to solve problems with additions, but the additions have become a problem.

How AEW creative works now is, well, it's messy. The general gist is that Tony Khan books every show with an arcane strategy involving flipped rows and columns on a spreadsheet, as he revealed on the Wrestling With Marc podcast (h/t F4WOnline): "I put the columns where the rows were and now I organise everything like this since Full Gear and I feel like I’m more organised, even though it's all the same information."

Tony Khan booking via spreadsheet has become a meme. He is hardly crafting a direct personal issue, quite the opposite and his process might explain the mazy, "Hang on, why are these people fighting again?" quality of, for example, the All In Stadium Stampede build. The results are often fantastic, but on an episodic basis, the storytelling can feel convoluted and unfocused.

Khan maps everything out in a complex way that feels increasingly complicated and alienating. His top stars meanwhile have a great degree of creative freedom. MJF, CM Punk, the Elite and Chris Jericho all have considerable input over their direction. Underneath, other wrestlers are allowed input, though not to the same extent. The results are uneven; while MJF is on fire at the moment, having crafted a sensation of a programme with Adam Cole, the Elite's ambition can become a bit tangled, which has happened more than once this year.

The imminent content farm era will not help, and is already concerning. Consider the role of Konosuke Takeshita this summer; after portraying his turn as the big story emerging from Double Or Nothing, after two weeks of heavy presence on TV, Khan sort of disappeared. Don Callis was torn between two programmes, and Chris Jericho's feud with him took precedence over Kenny Omega's - which was downright bizarre, and deflating, since Callis has been tied to Omega for much longer.

Omega and Callis seemed to stop caring about one another immediately after their split. This was arse-backwards and undid a lot of hard work over the course of 2023. Getting Chris Jericho his big Wembley match a week before All Out came at the expense of a story Omega and Callis have been telling all year. Omega Vs. Takeshita feels nowhere near as big as it did in May.

Then, there's CM Punk.

CONT'D...(3 of 5)


CM Punk
AEW

Collision is (or was!) very much his show. Khan books it, but as reported by Voices of Wrestling - and as is abundantly clear to everybody else - he is very "hands-on". The WCW Saturday Night-inspired Collision can feel beautifully simple or boring, depending on your perspective, but it does benefit a lot from a single vision (see the heating up of Ricky Starks for evidence of that). It's clean. It doesn't feel like a million ideas are colliding at once, but certain philosophies do collide with Dynamite.

Khan has spent four years trying to establish that AEW is a fixtures-first promotion in which every match is announced in advance. Impromptu matches are happening quite often on Saturdays. This, in addition to other recent developments, begs the question: What does Tony Khan want AEW to look like? Didn't he hate the invisible camera, which has been insidiously introduced to AEW in recent months?

To borrow Khan's analogy, more cooks are back in the kitchen. There are more cooks now than there were when Khan initially identified this cliched analogy as an issue, which underscores the extent to which the original vision is fading.

On the Double Or Nothing '23 media call, Tony Khan revealed the complexion of his formal creative team, which does not include the top wrestlers, MJF et al., who dictate their own arcs. He listed QT Marshall, Sonjay Dutt, Bryan Danielson, Pat Buck, Jerry Lynn, Dean Malenko, Madison Rayne, Sarah Stock, BJ Whitmer (who has since been fired), and Will Washington. All are at the table. Matt Hardy revealed in August on his The Extreme Life podcast (h/t Fightful) that, where he would once liaise directly with Khan, he now as a "starting point" talks with QT or Sonjay Dutt. While it should be mentioned here that Matt himself referred to the process as working "more smoothly", Khan being at one remove can't be a good thing.

At his best, he is one of the best bookers in wrestling history. This is inference/speculation, but it's not a good omen that he, with a blasé attitude about the end result, is seemingly delegating what is hardly life-affirming material to staffers and bunging it on Rampage. Khan being directly present with just two hours of weekly TV was far better than what the AEW product has evolved into.

PWInsider noted in June that Dax Harwood has also contributed to the creative process. Dave Meltzer reported that Dutt and Marshall, echoing Hardy's comments, are "said to be" the two main voices below Khan. Is it any coincidence that Jeff Jarrett's heel stable and QTV are all over television?

Is mildly amusing midcard filler really a valuable use of TV time when scores of talents in their primes can't buy a match on Dynamite?

CONT'D...(4 of 5)


Sleepy Tony Khan
AEW

The creative writing team is almost as big as the talent roster in August of 2023.

Konosuke Takeshita was de-emphasised on TV as the summer unfolded. This isn't a problem specific to him. Wardlow is off the radar entirely. Hikaru Shida dipped in and out of the Outcasts storyline so often that it was easy to forget that she existed. Action Andretti is a ghost. The Dark Order have since vanished, and if they return this week or next, few will care, since their programme with Hangman Page - who appears on TV sporadically himself - was binned. Talent inexplicably disappearing along with their momentum was meant to be a problem that had been acknowledged internally. Expanding the creative team was meant to lighten Khan's burden and correct the recurring issues with continuity. Why hasn't this happened?

Nobody knows what it's like to be inside creative other than those in the inner sanctum, but this approach has had a detrimental effect on programming. It's more messy than ever before. It's inscrutable, almost. Adding more competing voices to the room has directly correlated with the decline of the promotion's creative. What's the value in it? Has Khan taken criticisms of his booking to heart? Has he lost interest? Or has he simply, gradually, expanded his operation to such an extent that it has become a dysfunctional and incoherent mess?

In spite of everything, all things considered, artistically, one could argue that AEW is still the premier wrestling organisation on the planet, although "organisation" is heavily ironic. It's just not the same. Khan, more self-aware than most people within the wrestling bubble. appears to have reflected upon certain problems. He has prided himself on listening in the past. The problem with that is, in true Tony Khan style, the man who fits three hours of content into most episodes of Dynamite, and signed every wrestler who has pulled on a pair of kick pads, has done too much in his attempts to correct them.

AEW is experiencing an identity crisis. The range used to be the selling point; now, it feels like several visions exist only to accommodate the egos and demands of a roster that is much too big. Fittingly, for a promotion with a gambling theme and indeed origin story, AEW was better - significantly - when Tony Khan bet on himself.

After this annus horribilis, perhaps it's time he backed himself again.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!