It's Official: WWE Has Debuted A New Era
A new 'Theory' on the next phase of the WWE product...
Back in 2018, not that WWE nor even Wikipedia will acknowledge it, the promotion entered a new and decisive phase of its existence.
When Vince McMahon bought the company from his father in the early 1980s, he launched what is generally referred to as the 'Golden Era'; a cartoonish and enormously successful gimmick world under an old glory aesthetic. The bronzed, muscled heroes were quintessentially Reagan's '80s. When the bubble burst, and when Vince felt that the old relics were no longer cool - or couldn't afford them - he marketed the likes of Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels under the 'New Generation' label. The booking was far better than the reductive occupational gimmick narrative suggests, and the action was incredible at its peak, but the term was a euphemism for "Business is in the sh*tter and consider this a fresh start after all that unseemly scandal business".
The stratospheric rise of Steve Austin converged with Vince Russo's ambition and a generous sprinkle of ECW plagiarism to drive the 'Attitude Era' between 1998 and 2001, after which, strangely, a two-week Vince McMahon obsession as brief as Hade Vansen's entire run informed the name of WWE's next six-year "era": 'Ruthless Aggression'. In 2008, the next name was projected onto WWE by fans who wished to compartmentalise the company's history for an easy frame of reference: 'PG'.
Things got a bit more blurry as WWE refused to change a single thing about its aesthetic and booking mentality as the 21st century dragged on.
CONT'D...(1 of 6)
As authority figures continued to make matches next against an unchanging and charmless LED set, those fans struggled to form a consensus on how to define the times.
'Reality' and 'Network' were floated around, but really, this half-facetious take wasn't remotely incorrect with hindsight; by 2018, and deep into 2021, WWE entered its So-Bad-It's-Good era as a total laughing stock. Crown Jewel 2018 was a perversely hilarious disaster for longtime fans. With no competition, and inability to create new stars, the promotion was insistent that the old guard, who had fended off the supposedly existential threat of WCW, were something more than legendary. They were 'Phenoms', 'Kings of Kings'. To watch as they embarrassed themselves more than Hulk Hogan and Ric Flair ever did in 2000 was a remarkable indictment of such arrogant rhetoric.
A deadly worldwide pandemic was just as effective as 10 minutes of dire slow motion action at removing the mask from Kane's face. The Undertaker bumped for blowing a strand of hair out of his face, where he once wouldn't bump for Diamond Dallas Page. Triple H tore his pectoral muscle off the bone. An unrecognisable Shawn Michaels sat somewhere between Ricky Steamboat and Roddy Piper on the WrestleMania 25 legends scale, and compared to the other three, he was working like it was October 1997. 2019 was an hysterical disaster, and this year followed a late '18 period so fantastically awful that the McMahon clan had to apologise for it on national television. It wasn't a full-scale abomination. Planet's Champion Daniel Bryan was a great bit, and he wasn't quite the rule-proving exception, but Jesus Christ, almost everything else was such a creative atrocity that lapsed hate-watchers sprinted into the away end of Wrestling Twitter with their shirts off just to gleefully rip the absolute piss out of it.
This is key: WWE was so bad that a lot of fans buried it as a hobby.
CONT'D...(2 of 6)
WWE's worst output was an engagement generator as much as a collective in-joke.
WWE generated buzz - terrible, humiliating buzz - but it was still in the conversation. Roman Reigns suspected that Erick Rowan had attempted to kill him on SmackDown, but was temporarily appeased when Daniel Bryan hired and pinned the blame on a doppelgänger. Despite this being literally the most convenient explanation ever, the episode ended on a cliffhanger, as if to suggest Roman couldn't be absolutely sure. He was the top babyface at the time. For a while, every other match was worked under two out of three falls rules, because it was thought that WWE action was so hot that fans turned off in despair at missing some of it. The cross-brand Wild Card rule was introduced and immediately broken, and of course, WWE lied to your face later in the year with its Survivor Series marketing.
The Fiend was at large, and while every supernatural character is considered a "wasted opportunity" by fans who love that sort of sh*t, his matches were routinely greeted with mystified silence. Can you hurt the killer clown, or...?
Erick Rowan terrorised Mojo Rawley with a wacky-faced animatronic spider. Kairi Sane was turned heel before she even had a proper babyface run, which isn't as sensational as some of the other b*llocks on WWE TV - like Shorty G - but it was probably more of an indictment. 2019 was somehow as bad and deranged as 2020, the insane pandemic year in which Rey Mysterio was killed and lost an eye, in that order, and WWE inadvertently penned a storyline in which a malevolent supernatural entity groomed a performer playing a character who exhibited childlike behaviour.
2022 is something entirely different, and thus requires a new designation.
CONT'D...(3 of 6)
If WWE and Vince McMahon in particular didn't suffer from such a chronic lack of self-awareness, you'd be forgiven for thinking that some sort of crisis meeting took place inside of Titan Towers, in which it was decided that the promotion simply must stop ritually embarrassing itself.
WWE is almost inoffensive in 2022, as if by design. It is as if the product is precision-engineered to elicit a response like "That was actually solid". SmackDown is dire most weeks, but the days of Shayna Baszler being murdered by a sentient doll are all but over. You have to forget about the existence of NXT 2.0 for this hypothesis to work, but the WWE of 2022 is a far more drab and less perversely amusing animal than it was a couple of years ago. It's still very easy to rip apart from a simple, logical standpoint most weeks, but it isn't stunningly awful. When Roman Reigns is actually on the show, he's one of the best, coolest and most credible characters WWE has developed this century.
WWE had quietly developed a fairly strong tag team division highlighted by genuinely excellent action at its peak before Randy Orton's injury forced him off television. The Cody Vs. Seth Rollins programme wasn't revolutionary or even that compelling week-to-week, but in crafting an excellent signature PPV trilogy, WWE - and this isn't snark, it was great - did what it does best.
Chad Gable best illustrates this shift.
CONT'D...(4 of 6)
He was Shorty G in 2019, a risible underdog geek that was never getting over, but in 2022, as part of the Alpha Academy, he isn't a disgrace at all to the Kurt Angle comparison.
He's a technical marvel with an amusingly irreverent character. Similarly, while this is milage-will-vary WWE "comedy", Ezekiel is at least a quintessentially 'WWE' creation, and Kevin Owens is tremendous value as the disbelieving Seinfeldian hothead. Sami Zayn is enjoying his best run as a slimy, snivelling heel.
If the jokes aren't that funny, WWE isn't the punchline anymore, at least. WWE in 2022 is not so good that lapsed fans are racing to see what the buzz is all about, or anything, but stars are being made (or well-booked enough). Isn't that what the point of wrestling is, and what WWE was accused of failing to do for years and years?
Riddle drew a monster of a rating by modern standards in his challenge of Undisputed Universal Champion Roman Reigns, fans have responded very favourably to Liv Morgan as SmackDown Women's champion, and Bobby Lashley as United States champion is more over than he's ever been. All the while, there's nothing so bad, other than the 24/7 Title picture, that is going to get "numbers" with a caustic social media tweet. Even the announcing is better; Jimmy Smith is the best play-by-play man WWE has recruited in years, and WWE devotees are really into Michael Cole and Pat McAfee's chemistry. If this is a new era, Theory is "face" of it; telegenic and talented but bland and lacking intangibles, he's almost the perfect fit for WWE's new "it exists" philosophy.
As CM Punk famously said, however, WWE can always be better.
CONT'D...(5 of 6)
Given the immense, almost endless resources it has to create stars and tell stories, it probably still is closer to a disgrace than a success. Look at Ronda Rousey: the most famous person on the roster is rendered unrecognisable with the make-up she wears and her jokes are cringe-worthy. Anybody with a semblance of an imagination knows that the character could be presented in an exponentially more flattering way.
Subjectively, the TV is still brutally dull, repetitive and infested with dire tropes, but objectively, WWE is doing very well in the Nielsens.
In the late summer of 2021, when AEW defeated RAW in the demo across two consecutive weeks, it was felt that a paradigm shift was imminent. It never happened. WWE's vision - of presenting TV matches between established weekly members of a small cast in situations that aren't drastically stupid - appears to be a winning one.
So what is this new era called?
'The Isn't Interesting Enough To Bury, But The TV Audience Is Shockingly Into It Era' isn't snappy, but that's where we are, and it's actually a long way away from the Wild Card rule. Think about this: when was the last time WWE was unfavourably compared to the very worst of death throes WCW? That was once the ultimate frame of reference on podcasts, but you don't hear it much these days.
WWE appears to have located the rarest of niches - the sports entertainment hardcores - and they're winning as a result of delivering to them what passes in contrast to its modern history for solid, inoffensive product.