It's Official: WWE NXT Has Jumped The Shark
Why is it so violent?
Last night's NXT proved very divisive.
The hardcores loved it, those less emotionally invested laughed at it. It was headlined by 'One Final Beat', the last and purportedly conclusive chapter in the epic Johnny Gargano Vs. Tommaso Ciampa saga. This was a cinematic match.
It was a wrestling match that lasted as long as a f*cking film.
It was the Ganryujima Island Death Match rebooted by Zack Snyder. It was 48 minutes of excruciatingly tedious melodrama worked with a stunning level of pointless violence. It made Edge Vs. Randy Orton look like lucha libre. Danger in pro wrestling is - or should be - linked inextricably to excitement. The risk is taken to pop the crowd, whether it serves the story or not. Violence has no right to be as boring as it was in that match. It's meant to arouse our inner bloodlust. It's meant to transfix the worst part of us. This was just dull, attritional, and devoid of drama.
It was also very, unintentionally funny. The match played with the intimacy of their relationship - the finish undermined it, of course - in such a way that accelerated well beyond the farcical. It was Top Gun without the fun. It was Top Gun rebooted by Zack Snyder. Johnny Gargano - knowing damn well of his own masterplan that...relied on not losing a match for 40 minutes - reached out gingerly to touch Ciampa's hand. Maybe...all along...he couldn't do this himself. And he couldn't!
CONT'D...(1 of 6)
Plot twist: his wife had to do it for him, with a single, difference-making kick to the balls struck after some of the most gratuitous, thudding brutality witnessed in an age.
The crutch made an appearance, because you can't forget the crutch. They fought on top of a truck before politely scaling back down it. This was an anti-spectacle. This was 48 minutes of heavy grunting, heavy breathing, heavy shots, goofy trash talk and gratuitous, off-putting violence. It ended when Gargano turned once more on Ciampa after another moment of intimacy teased a reconciliation.
You see, the theme of the story is that you either die a hero, or live long enough to become the villain. This feud, and there's so damn much of it, thinks a 2008 superhero blockbuster is the most profound exploration of the very nature of man.
The problem here is Triple f*cking H and Shawn f*cking Michaels, and how they are no different to Vince McMahon. They control the pawns of the NXT roster and over-produce them under their own, preferred vision. They are a pair of raging egomaniacs vicariously imposing their epic melodrama onto virtually every main event. Every TakeOver might as well be suffixed Bad Blood, since the vast majority under Shawn's production echo his old, monstrously indulgent slogs with - yes - Triple H.
CONT'D...(2 of 6)
The pair of them clearly value their philosophy over the creativity and skill of the performers they exist - in theory - to enhance and guide, not mould. A teacher or coach in any discipline is meant to extract something from the pupil. Michaels lumbers his students with his ideas. When Shawn Michaels enters the Performance Center, does he say "Time to act, my talking props!"?
NXT has felt increasingly produced in recent years, and this can't go without mention, much as the hardcores will not like it: AEW has thrown this sentiment into sharp relief, and this is NXT's fault by broadcasting itself at the exact same time. The scripted promos feel more scripted, the solid angles feel more mid, the excellent in-ring action feels less vital.
Something changed within NXT's DNA over the last couple of years as it shifted from soulful developmental/SuperIndy hybrid to WWE's third brand proper. Critical acclaim and hardcore fan devotion was its clear objective, and for a while, this was attained. The wrestling was blow-away great and arrived at via at-worst functional TV that rewarded the intelligence the main roster had insulted. TakeOvers were fantastic in 2018 - we are talking greatest wrestling ever quality - but the Network show had become skippable. It had become a mere platform to showcase some of the best talent in the world. With no need for heavy lifting, nor the old Ryan Ward verve, NXT grew complacent and unadventurous.
CONT'D...(3 of 6)
Formula crept in. Fans loved most the serious business of the TakeOver shows, and so that became the tone: super-intense Great Wrestling put over and built towards with generic operatic writing and its one-note semantic field of moments and legacies and the like.
And, all the while, Mauro Ranallo and Corey Graves screamed directly into your eardrums, furthering the effect of non-stop intensity. NXT by 2018 had begun to take itself with the utmost seriousness. It then extended an invitation to parody as an inevitable result.
It may not be fair to make this judgment now, what with NXT playing to no crowds. But the empty gym is not the problem; the empty gym brings the root problem into focus.
This growing synthetic quality now cannot be escaped with no fans to obscure it. It's as if the complacency has set in to such a weird extent that the NXT think tank operates now on autopilot with no real thought behind it. It's almost as if NXT is not written, but programmed. Look at what the bot coded for last week's North American Title main event between Keith Lee, Damien Priest and Dominik Dijakovic. Beyond the usual regulation entrances and crowd appeals that look bizarre now, that match played almost entirely to a crowd that wasn't there. It was the strangest, dumbest thing.
CONT'D...(4 of 6)
Priest and Dijakovic at one point tumbled theatrically into an exhausted double pin. Whomever agented that spot clearly had no conception of how stupid it might have looked with no fans in attendance. It was a spot you'd never see in a shoot, and the more realistic or stiff matches have worked best in this environment. That the main roster agents have grasped this first is quite the indictment. This looked like an obvious performance for nobody. It was as if NXT - once the knowing antidote to the main roster - has now also encased itself in a weird bubble.
NXT clearly has no interesting or congruous ideas with which to adjust to the empty arena environment - and that is because this team has few new ideas at all.
The run on USA has lost steam. The hotshot booking was always going to lead to this dead end. NXT went big and went big early in a reactive fit. A sense of desperation permeated everything. The brand pit its most popular babyface, Matt Riddle, in an NXT Championship match against Adam Cole in the very first head-to-head segment against Dynamite. Where else was there to go?
Short of real imagination or a trust in itself to map gripping long-term stories, NXT continued its heavy artillery assault. Ladder matches, as an example, were booked to gain the WarGames advantage in what was genuine Vince Russo-adjacent overkill. And if the story beats were not wildly over-the-top, they were ritually dry. How many times have we seen a rival emerge on the entrance ramp to stare down their opponent?
CONT'D...(5 of 6)
More recently, Malcolm Bivens has taken charge of an ostensible Authors of Pain reboot in Rinki and Saurav. The parking lot remains an inexplicably unsecured danger zone. The Women's division, its best movement back in November, now feels confused and at the condescending mercy of the AEW counter strategy.
And, most tellingly, the TakeOver formula has faltered. This is a more contentious point to make - TakeOver: Portland was incredibly well-received - but there's a creeping counter-narrative emerging. Short of advancing the formula, NXT is intensifying it to a preposterous extent. The amount of content and near-falls in every match - the genre of which never really changes - is as exhausting as a Mauro Ranallo pop culture reference. The finishes to any match involving Gargano, Ciampa and the Undisputed Era is overbooked.
NXT is a show with next to no levity, creative freedom or range, and a show that is a heightened and repetitive version of its peak. It has descended into parody. The memes, the ratings, and the lack of buzz all bear this out.
"NXT is brought to you live on Wednesdays on USA. But Mondays, Tuesdays - we're rockin' all week with you because we have jumped the shark, Nigel!"