MAJOR Wrestling Stars Who Jumped Ship (...And FLOPPED!)
WWE has had its fair share of 'the grass isn't always greener' moments!
Success in one promotion doesn't guarantee stardom in another.
That one sentence perhaps sums the entries on this list up best, and it's one recent AEW > WWE jumpers like Jade Cargill or brave WWE > AEW leaps made by Adam Copeland should pay close attention to. Of course, early signs are that both will smash it on their new platforms, but they wouldn't be the first to show flashes of promise before totally tanking.
Copeland has decades of experience and star power to draw from, granted. Nothing is certain in the 'Wild, Wild West' world of pro wrestling though, and the folks here prove it. These heroes from WWF/WWE, WCW and ECW surely thought they'd become made men after jumping ship, but then reality hit them harder than a peak ROH-era Nigel McGuinness clothesline.
It was all downhill for most from there, sadly. Others managed to bounce back by jumping to yet another company - follow up success there only made miserable flops beforehand even more glaring. These workers shouldn't have experienced such hardships or despair.
Strap in, because this one will be rather bumpy!
10. Davey Boy Smith (WWF > WCW)
When: 1993
Why He Flopped: The British Bulldog was hot sh*t when he landed on WCW television in 1993. Davey was fairly fresh off headlining SummerSlam '92, and that main event opposite Bret Hart was the best match of his career. Sure, Bret carried a knackered and drug-addled Bulldog through the entire thing, but people didn't know that at the time.
He was a star on the rise.
Typically, WCW couldn't capitalise. Smith wasn't joining a company mid-nWo boom - WCW was WWF-lite, and simply didn't have the know-how to make the most of an incoming McMahon-made star. Despite teaming with top babyface Sting, Bulldog was mired in some seriously dreadful mini-movies during a feud vs. Vader and Sid.
He'd last a year with the chaotic group before working some indy dates back home in the UK then rejoining the WWF by 1994. That WCW run probably wasn't as fruitful as Smith (or Turner suits) had hoped it'd be when the ink dried.
9. The Steiner Brothers (WCW > WWF)
When: 1992
Why They Flopped: Some acts just feel more at home in certain organisations. For proof, check out The Steiner Brothers' run in the WWF between 1992-1994. Their old-school NWA, no-frills pro wrasslin' vibes felt totally at odds with the federation's cartoonish presentation.
Rick and Scott had two runs with the WWF Tag belts (both wins came on non-televised house shows, weirdly), but they never seemed comfortable under Vince McMahon's umbrella at all. Rugged matches vs. teams like The Headshrinkers didn't fit in with what the fed fancied producing, and it became clear that The Steiner weren't especially chuffed by how things were going.
Both yearned for WCW.
In fact, they longed to be anywhere but the WWF. So, in mid-1994, Rick and Scott departed for a brief stint in ECW before heading back home "Where The Big Boys Play". They'd never return to WWE as an active duo; Scott had a less-than-stellar two year run as a singles between 2002-2004, but that was it.
8. Mike Awesome (ECW > WCW)
When: 2000
Why He Flopped: Just feast your eyes on the image above!
That was Mike Awesome in his "That 70s Guy" phase. It was definitely less offensive than his dire "Fat Chick Thrilla" gimmick (a Vince Russo special, that one), but failed to catch on with fans much the same. People didn't want this version of Awesome, they wanted the awesome ECW Awesome that was...awesome.
Paul Heyman must've been palming his forehead when he witnessed what the creative braintrust in Atlanta had done to one of his most well-protected acts. In ECW, Mike had been a powerhouse to be proud of. In WCW, he was just one in a long line of wrestlers ruined by an increasingly-crap writing process.
Gone were big-bumping battles vs. hardened warriors like Masato Tanaka. Nah, why have that when you can turn Awesome into a lame parody of some cast off character from That 70s Show? That'll put some butts in seats.
Or not.
7. Taz (ECW > WWF)
When: 2000
Why He Flopped: Bruce Prichard's podcast comments on Taz reveal that the incoming ECW hard nut was DOA during his first night with the company at the 2000 Royal Rumble. Even though fans in MSG were thrilled by Tazz (extra 'z'!) choking out Kurt Angle, WWF officials were not.
Backstage, some expressed concerns about Tazz's suplexes. Those, despite looking phenomenal on camera and opening the pay-per-view brilliantly, would come to cripple the guy's upward mobility overnight. It certainly didn't help that some also believed he was "too small". Y'know, even though the WWF had scouted then signed him.
It's hardly like Tazz was doing anything differently to his blistering run in the original ECW - Vince McMahon seemingly wanted this! Tazz slipped down the pecking order quickly, and was on colour commentary by the following year.
Injuries were catching up with him anyway, but man...his WWF/WWE run is a definite what-might've-been. At least he's been thriving for decades as an announcer. That role in WWE, TNA and AEW has been kind to the one-time 'Human Suplex Machine'.
WWF politicking was not.
6. Lex Luger (WCW > WWF)
When: 1992
Why He Flopped: Lex Luger's WWF run can be summed up with three words/phrases: "Bodybuilding", "Wannabe Hulk Hogan" and "Fans wanted Bret Hart instead". That's why the people cheered louder for the 'Hitman' during a 1994 Royal Rumble tie, and it's why Luger's run with the company as a babyface hero ultimately failed.
The core audience had been fed Hogan for almost a full decade by the time Lex donned some stars and stripes in '93. Seeing a watered down remix of 'Hulkamania' wasn't appealing to those folks, so they rejected Lex as the number one baby and firmly rooted for the much fresher style of Hart instead.
Most watching from the sidelines probably thought Lex would smash it under Vince. After all, he was one hell of a physical specimen, and had shown promising signs in-ring when placed in there with better workers like Ric Flair over on the NWA/WCW side.
Oddly, after flopping in the WWF, Lex returned to WCW and picked right back up where he'd left off.
5. DDP (WCW > WWF)
When: 2001
Why He Flopped: Some might regard this one as cheating, because WCW was dead by the time Diamond Dallas Page signed on the dotted line with the WWF. The kicker? Page agreed to a cut price buyout of his AOL/Time Warner deal, and backed himself to succeed in the only major company left.
That proved to be a mistake.
DDP technically did jump ship before he had to, but wasn't allowed the chance to play up to his wildly successful 'People's Champ' persona post-WCW. That idea belonged to The Rock, and there wasn't room for two workers doing the same sort of thing. Instead, the WWF turned Page into a creepy stalker who followed The Undertaker's wife.
Yeah. Remember that, "...proved to be a mistake" line?
Creative eventually ended that hell for DDP and went mediocre babyface by booking him as a motivational smiler. Nothing on the WWF/WWE side could touch to Page's remarkable rise up the ranks in Atlanta. Not even close.
4. Sting (TNA > WWE)
When: 2014
Why He Flopped: It was WWE's fault. End of story.
OK, not really end of story, but that one sentence sums things up. Sting was introduced as an antidote to The Authority's tyrannical reign of power at Survivor Series 2014, then battled Triple H in a marquee bout at WrestleMania 31...and lost. Yep, this "antidote" to Trips' heel faction stared at the lights.
Look, everyone has their individual opinions on certain wins and losses, but most agree this was a terrible decision. Later in 2015, the Stinger also lost to Seth Rollins at Night Of Champions. He was injured during that match and temporarily retired from the ring before turning up in AEW years later.
The icon's WWE run was a mess and a waste of everybody's time.
Sting was the 'one that got away' post-WCW closure in 2001, so you'd think WWE would use him properly when they finally got mitts on the guy. Nope. No elusive Undertaker dream match, and exactly zero pay-per-view wins. Fabulous.
3. The Ultimate Warrior (WWF > WCW)
When: 1998
Why He Flopped: It's difficult to judge The Ultimate Warrior's 1996 return fairly as a fan, because he wasn't on WWF TV/pay-per-view long enough to have any meaningful impact on flagging business. By all accounts, Warrior was a nightmare to deal with behind the scenes though. Again.
WCW didn't necessarily get that side of him in 1998, but they did get some diminishing returns in terms of overall fan interest in a revived feud vs. Hulk Hogan. Although Eric Bischoff might not have wanted to admit it, there just wasn't that much juice in a Halloween Havoc sequel to their remarkably-fun WrestleMania VI original.
In WCW, Warrior stumped fans with nonsensical promos (that went over their allotted time on Nitro) and he clearly sucked in-ring. There was nothing to be thrilled by, and that made his run for the competition way worse than a WWF reprise had been two years earlier.
Semi-ripping off Adam West's Batman by encouraging people to tune in "at the same Warrior time, on the same Warrior channel" was also flat out cringeworthy.
2. Vader (WCW > WWF)
When: 1996
Why He Flopped: Leon White wasn't the same romping, stomping monster he'd been in Japan or in WCW when he landed on the WWF's doorstep in early-1996. Looking back, folks like Bruce Prichard and Jim Ross believe Big Van Vader's confidence had taken a knock following a backstage fight with Paul Orndorff before jumping.
Being fair, Vader was hampered by injuries too when Vince McMahon decided to debut him at the '96 Royal Rumble anyway. The big man asked to wait, but bosses wanted some return on their investment ASAP. A thumping angle with then-on screen authority figure Gorilla Monsoon wrote the new heel off TV 24 hours later.
It was all downhill from there.
Vader struggled to jive with resident poster boy Shawn Michaels during their World Title feud, and he was also finding it hard to keep his weight in check. The WWF acted by sending Leon to a clinic, but it didn't work. His entire two-year stint was rife with missed opportunities, wasted potential and a lack of true faith from higher-ups.
1. Bret Hart (WWF > WCW)
When: 1997
Why He Flopped: Bret realised he didn't want to be in WCW rather swiftly.
His heart (no pun intended) was ripped out by an infamous 'Montreal Screwjob' at the 1997 Survivor Series, and it became clear Bret's appetite for full-time wrestling waned the longer he was in WCW. The 'Hitman' was never a neat fit for the promotion, one totally caught up in Hulk Hogan and nWo fever when he arrived.
The nWo story dominated WCW's product, so Hart became a bit-part player. He was a mere pawn in the overarching narrative, and that sucked when Bret was one of the biggest gets for Eric Bischoff during this whole war with the WWF. WCW had the WWF star of the 1990s, and they didn't have an f'n clue how to book him.
Hart has to take some of the blame too, of course. He was visibly apathetic to WCW life, and appeared to phone in some of his appearances. In retrospect, it's actually kinda surprising he lasted up until 2000, because Bret's run with the company was flopping long before that.
Which other top names jumped from one promotion to another and flopped? For more like this, check out 10 Obscure WWE Tag Teams You Totally Don't Remember and 10 Lost Gimmicks WWE Should Bring Back!