NXT: 10 Worst Creative Decisions Of The Full Sail Era
Sometimes you'd swear you were watching Raw.
WWE's NXT is generally considered the best weekly wrestling show on television. In my opinion, it is.
The storylines are logical, the characters are engaging, the championships matter and the women's division is outstanding. The locker room is comprised of some of the most talented young wrestlers from around the globe and they are all hungry and motivated to deliver the best matches possible.
NXT is awesome, yes, but that hasn't always been the case.
Many will remember when NXT originally aired in 2010, and the so called "Rookies" were paired up with their "Pros". It was apparent early on that WWE hadn't put much thought into it. The rookies competed in ill-conceived "challenges" like carrying a keg around the ring and cutting promos on moustaches.
Wade Barrett would "win" the contract, but then the other Rookies joined him on the main roster anyway as the Nexus, rendering the contest pointless. The next two years wouldn't get much better.
The NXT we all know and love today was born in the Summer of 2012 when the brand relaunched and began taping exclusively at Full Sail University in Winter Park, Florida. Under the guidance of Triple H and the late, great Dusty Rhodes, the show slowly evolved into the hottest brand in wrestling. But there were hiccups along the way.
As much as we love NXT, we must remember not to take it for granted. Here are ten creative decisions from 2012 onward that have prevented NXT from achieving absolute perfection.
10. Triple H Shows Up As A Babyface
NXT is Triple H's baby. We all know he is the driving force behind its success and he deserves credit for making the brand what it is. But all too often he likes to remind us of that himself.
Throughout NXT's run Triple H has shown up every now and again to make crowd-pleasing announcements, introduce Takeover events, celebrate the crowning of new champions and generally soak in the love for his product. It would be perfectly acceptable - if he wasn't supposed to be the biggest, baddest heel of the last 15 years.
It's pretty damn distracting seeing the likes of Paige, Neville and Sami Zayn have their arms raised by the despicable dictator who fought tooth and nail to prevent Daniel Bryan from winning the WWE World Heavyweight Championship last year.
It's the same (but to a lesser extent) with his wife Stephanie McMahon, who plays the most loathsome character on WWE television, yet wants to get the pop for bringing the NXT Divas to Raw. They're both trying to have their cake and eat it too.
The future of WWE is in safe hands with Triple H, but he still has to decide whether he is 100% face or heel. Trying to play both at once is only serving to stroke his own ego.
9. Pushing Mojo Rawley
Mojo Rawley has never been over during his two year run in NXT.
I'll preface this by saying that it's not entirely his fault. If anything he is a victim of the current state of WWE's developmental system, which is focused on fetching the hottest talents from the independents and Japan and combining them to create a super roster.
As much as we love having Finn Balor, Sami Zayn, Samoa Joe and Apollo Crews on one roster, it actually hinders young men like Rawley who don't have the years of indie experience. NXT is a developmental system after all, and it should exist for rookies like Rawley, Baron Corbin, and Bull Dempsey, who actually need the training.
Because of the insane amount of talented indy stars, NXT fans tend to switch off whenever homegrown college football players enter the NXT arena, and as such Mojo Rawley found himself booed almost from the start. Having never worked in ROH or New Japan, and possessing no flashy moves (his finsher was a hip attack!), fans remained silent for his debut.
The silence would escalate to "go away heat" when Rawley was given several squash victories and the announcers tried in vain to get his "Stay Hyped" catchphrase over.
Mojo was simply not ready for the push he very nearly received. Fortunately the powers that be recognized this and pulled the plug. Maybe we fans should be more open minded towards these non indy wrestlers, but at the time absolutely no one was "hyped" for Mojo.
8. Beck Lynch's Irish Dancing Gimmick
Before she became the "Lass Kicker" Becky Lynch struggled to find her identity on NXT.
Starting out as a punky rock 'n' roll chick, she would go on to be Sasha Bank's partner/lackey before breaking out into a solo babyface earlier this year with an awesome new look and innovative submission style. However, before all that, her first few appearances in NXT in 2014 saw her dancing her way to the ring like an Irish folk dancer.
Yes, in 2014.
It wasn't exactly racist (that honor goes to Christian for attempting to bribe Sheamus with a potato), but it was extremely lazy cliched booking at it's worst. It was as if someone decided that Lynch's nationality was enough of a gimmick.
Thankfully it was dropped within two weeks.
7. Kassius Ohno Loses His Edge
Ah Kassius Ohno. So much potential wasted...
I'm not going to include WWE's decision to release Ohno here - that was all on him. But towards the end of his run, WWE seemed determined to weaken the Knockout Artist.
During a scorching feud with William Regal, Ohno came across as a vicious psycho heel, attacking the commentator repeatedly and threatening to end his career. The two had a superb match on the April 10th NXT which Regal won. Then two weeks later Ohno came out to make amends.
However, instead of playing the reluctant heel, forced to shake his opponents hand and admit he's the better man, Ohno apologized for interrupting the show, begged for a moment of everybody's time, and proceeded to ask Regal for forgiveness. The psycho heel now looked like a nervous school boy forced to apologize in front of the class.
Worse still, this was his way of turning face!
Ohno would then be attacked by the Wyatt Family and taken off TV in order to lose weight. It seemed as punishment for his loose physique, Ohno was forced to look as humbled and pathetic as possible during the segment, while his sterling match with Regal was ignored.
Maybe he should have worn a shirt like Kevin Owens.
6. Baron Corbin Loses - To The Wrong Man
Baron Corbin was an unstoppable force in NXT. Tall, imposing and possessing a unique and devastating finisher, he plowed through NXTs finest jobbers for over a year. His streak could have really meant something - if it was saved for the right opponent. Like Samoa Joe back at TakeOver: Brooklyn. Or Apollo Crews somewhere down the line.
Instead, the Lone Wolf of NXT suffered his first loss to Neville earlier this year. They met in the semi finals of a tournament to determine the number one contender to Sami Zayn's NXT Championship. During the match, Corbin was pulled out of the ring and attacked by his rival Bull Dempsey. It seemed a count out loss was forthcoming. It would have at least protected the streak.
Instead Dempsey threw Corbin back in the ring and Neville pinned him with the Red Arrow. Neville who had held the NXT Championship for nearly a year. Neville who was on his way up to the main roster. Neville who had absolutely nothing to gain. Neville, who would go on to lose in the finals to Finn Balor anyway. What a waste.
5. Sasha Banks' Secret Admirer
Here's something we don't see enough of in wrestling: romance angles!
Back before the NXT women's division was awesome, Sasha Banks was just a generic babyface jobber. While Paige, Emma and Summer Rae were kickstarting the division, the future Boss of NXT really had nothing going for her.
She was finally given something to do when she started receiving letters from a "Secret Admirer". Of course this being WWE, the story was not going to end well for Banks. The secret admirer was revealed in a backstage segment to be heel Diva Audrey Marie (they couldn't even be bothered shooting it in the ring).
Before you get too excited, Marie was not actually an admirer of Banks, but just a heel looking to take her spot by blindsiding her. The busty Texan had talent in the ring, but apparently not the physique required to be Diva. She was already released by the time the pre-taped segment aired.
Aside from making their female wrestlers look like naive high school girls, the story was too familiar. Over on Raw, WWE had just done a similar angle with Kaitlyn, whose Secret Admirer turned out to be a set up by heel rival AJ Lee. Perhaps if Paige ever receives anonymous flowers, she should definitely watch her back.
4. Bo Dallas Babyface Push
684080Bo Dallas eventually found his stride with the Bo-lieve gimmick - not that it's doing him much good on the main roster. But during the early days of NXT he was presented as one of it's top babyface stars. Fans did not like it.
Similar to Mojo Rawley, Bo was expected to get over, working alongside indy darlings like Seth Rollins, Kassius Ohno and Neville. Fans barely registered the smiley faced superstar.NXT had evolved. It was becoming a third brand with it's diverse roster of international superstars and blended styles.
Bo was a remnant of FCW, regarded by many as WWE's robot factory. His unremarkable style, generic look and dumb name, all reeked of something McMahon-ufactured on an assembly line. He never stood a chance as a babyface.
Yet unlike Mojo Rawley, Bo was pushed relentlessly. Maybe Triple H really believed he was the guy, maybe it was his family connections (for the five people who don't know, his father is Irwin R Shyster and his brother is Bray Wyatt). Bo was chosen to dethrone Big E and held the NXT Championship for nearly a year until he was mercifully defeated by Neville at the first ever TakeOver event Arrival.
During his reign he turned heel by playing the exact same generic smiling babyface he had always been, admittedly a stroke of genius. Still, it's hard to believe that this guy was the face of NXT for nearly a year.
3. Leo Kruger Becomes Adam Rose
706111There's an old expression about wheels and whether or not they should be fixed if they aint broke.
Such is the case of the South African Kraven the Hunter-esque Leo Kruger who terrorized NXT for two years. A dangerous heel, this man stalked his prey like a beast and delivered crippling offense that could shorten careers. Well one day someone decided the character had grown stale and decided to reboot him as something else entirely.
In January 2014 Adam Rose was born.
An eccentric, flamboyant, party animal with his own entourage of costumed ... Rosebuds, this character was a polar opposite of Leo Kruger (it's a credit to the man that he can play both convincingly). Rose made his entrance with the aid of his Rosebuds and a song that you will never get out of your head once you start thinking about it (too late!) He was immediately over with the Full Sail crowd on his first night.
Unfortunately no one waited to see how the character would survive long term and he was rushed onto the main roster. The Full Sail crowd are usually more open minded than a Raw crowd when it comes to ridiculous gimmicks and one positive reaction on his first night was not enough to promise success on Monday nights.
People soon became tired of Rose (mostly due to the refusal of the writers to give him any character development beyond hating lemons) and he was soon demoted to back to Superstars and then forced into a never ending feud with his own Bunny.
No wonder fans have been chanting "Leo Kruger" at him for nearly a year now.
2. Feeding Hideo Itami To The Ascension
Hideo Itami, formerly known as KENTA is one of the very finest wrestlers in the world. He is also small, skinny, speaks limited English and made his name in another promotion. We all should have known WWE would screw this up.
For the first two months of Itamis career he was targeted by the hulking Ascension, Konnor and Victor. The two juggernauts attacked and dominated the Japanese star week after week. Itami was permitted to fight back and get a few shots in, but the two men would always overpower him.
His continuous efforts to fight back should have been heralded as brave and resilient. But instead he was blasted on commentary by Alex Riley (renewing his membership in Vince McMahon's Kiss My A** Club) who claimed Itami didn't belong in the big leagues.
Way to endorse a new star, A-Ry!
Itami would even the score by bringing in the debuting Finn Balor as his tag team partner, but unfortunately Balor stole all of his thunder. This wasn't just because of his incredible demon entrance or his Bullet Club popularity, but because he could speak English and fans just subconsciously related to him more. Plus Balor defeated the Ascension after one match. Hideo got beat up continuously for two months!
Getting injured earlier this year may have been a blessing in disguise. It's been long enough now that Itami can return fresh and rejuvenated, without having to share the spotlight with any other debuting stars. Let's hope they get it right this time.
1. Bullfit
This is actually worse than anything that happened on NXT before 2012.
Ten years ago Bull's size and look would have made him an imposing monster heel, but it seems NXT already have enough big men running around. So we get Bull being shamed on TV for being out of shape and being made to embarrass himself in ridiculous 90s style exercise montages.
Sure maybe Bull is on board with it, or maybe he, like all NXT superstars has been conditioned to agree with what comes his way. If he had refused to do the storyline, it's likely someone else would be getting his TV time every week. Even in this improved developmental system, wrestlers are still having to just accept what they're given and be grateful for the opportunity.
And sure maybe this is more playful than WWE's previous attempts at shaming their wrestlers to lose weight (Piggy James) but everything about this angle feels cheesy, cartoonish and about twenty years out of date.
Maybe there will be a satisfying payoff to this storyline as it's still admittedly ongoing. But until that day comes, the fans are going to have to wade through a ton of Bullfit.