Ranking 10 Most Successful Wrestling Defections

Who was the biggest jump from WWE to WCW, and vice versa?

Radicalz Debut
WWE.com

While basketball fans buzz over trade rumors during the NBA’s off-season, especially Kyrie Irving reportedly wanting to jump from the Cleveland Cavaliers and LeBron James, wrestling fans are left to reminisce about one of their favorite pastimes. Before WWE conquered the wrestling world, becoming the only mainstream organization in North America, fans could speculate and fantasize over which WWE Superstars would jump to WCW or ECW, and vice versa. It was an era of unpredictability as fans never knew who would show up next on Raw or Nitro during the Monday Night War.

That period was great for viewers as well as industry players – the wrestlers had unprecedented leverage against promoters.

While performers could relocate to different territories back in the day, the territories were still controlled by the National Wrestling Alliance, a self-governing union of promoters who usually stuck together and could blackball wrestlers if need be.

During the 1990s, WWE and WCW were in competition, and either company was all too willing to scoop up a disgruntled performer from the opposition. This gave wrestlers the opportunity to negotiate higher-paying contracts or change their scenery, perhaps for the long-term benefit of their career.

10. Bret Hart To WCW

Bret Hart WCW
WWE.com

On paper, WCW acquiring Bret Hart should have been the company’s biggest coup since signing Hulk Hogan. The Hitman was fresh off a hot anti-American heel run, and had lost the WWE Championship in controversial fashion at Survivor Series 1997. In theory, WCW had taken WWE’s main star, a performer regarded as a legend but who could still go in the ring.

However, as McMahon would reportedly tell Hart, “they won’t know what to do with you.”

Although he won the U.S. and World Titles, and regularly hovered around the main event scene, Hart went from a major fixture of WWE TV to just another name in WCW. Ironically, his departure from WWE actually boosted the company to its creative and financial zenith, as McMahon capitalized on the real-life animosity stemming from the Montreal Screwjob and let it play out storyline-wise between Stone Cold and him.


9. The Hardy Boyz To WWE

WrestleMania 33 Hardy Boyz
WWE.com

While WWE maintains its position as the only mainstream pro wrestling entity, there are minor league operations still in existence that can provide for intriguing defections. TNA, for example, has had its roster cherry-picked by Vince McMahon, with several of WWE’s current top stars having paid their dues in the struggling promotion. Although the Hardy Boyz built their reputation in McMahonland, they reinvented themselves in TNA, becoming the most popular act in the industry last year.

A dispute (still ongoing) with TNA’s new management led to Broken Matt and Brother Nero leaving the company earlier this year, inciting rumors that the Hardyz would finish out their careers in the company where they began. Sure enough, at WrestleMania 33, the Hardyz shocked the WWE Universe when they entered a ladder match for the Raw Tag Team Championship, and won. Although they’ve yet to revert to their “broken” characters, they’ve rejuvenated the tag team division and done maximum damage to TNA.


8. Radicalz To WWE

The Radicalz Mick Foley
WWE.com

Dave Meltzer recently described the Radicalz jump to WWE as the final blow to WCW, which was acquired by WWE a year or so later. Chris Benoit, Eddie Guerrero, Perry Saturn, and Dean Malenko were four extremely talented midcarders discouraged by WCW management’s reluctance to give them a main event chance. So when management offered to grant anyone’s release that wanted out, those four friends left for McMahonland.

It was a mixed bag for WWE: Benoit and Guerrero would go on to become world champions while Saturn and Malenko were relegated to C-shows and comedy status. Nearly 18 months after joining WWE, Malenko retired from active competition and became a road agent. In hindsight, McMahon probably regrets having Benoit ever associated with WWE, as his tragic and heinous end on this earth nearly destroyed the empire.


7. AJ Styles To WWE

Aj styles
WWE.com

It seems unfathomable for any company to let AJ Styles go, but after nearly a dozen years in TNA, he had nothing left to accomplish. Styles won every title, performed every role and competed in several five-star matches. He weathered the turbulence of rotating management and television homes, building his legendary reputation among diehards. With few healthy years left to compete at his highest level, it was time for the Phenomenal One to cash in on that WWE exposure.

Since debuting at the 2016 Royal Rumble, Styles has been a main event player. He’s won the WWE Championship, carried SmackDown in the brand extension and shined as both hero and villain. While WWE experiments with Jinder Mahal on top, fans know they can rely on Styles to deliver on the undercard.


6. Kurt Angle To TNA

Kurt Angle TNA Debut
ImpactWrestling.com

Christian was the first WWE guy to willingly jump to TNA, an indication that performers frustrated with WWE’s glass ceiling could go elsewhere to realize their potential. But when Kurt Angle jumped ship a year later, it meant McMahon had competition once again.

As drug addiction deteriorated his relationship with WWE officials, Angle declined rehab in favor of a release. McMahon granted his wish, and a month later, TNA President Dixie Carter announced that Angle had joined the company. Signing one of WWE’s biggest stars lent TNA newfound credibility, and provided a known name for the company to build around. Angle would spend the rest of his active career having great matches with a slew of up and coming talent like AJ Styles, Desmond Wolfe, Christopher Daniels, Bobby Roode, and EC3. His battles with Samoa Joe drew TNA’s highest-purchased pay-per-views, fueling momentum that the troubled company struggled to capitalize on.


5. Chris Jericho To WWE

Chris Jericho Debut
WWE.com

The personification of WCW’s blind eye toward talent: Chris Jericho.

After years of competing in the cruiserweight division, Y2J had broken out from the pack, establishing himself as an arrogant, perpetually whiny villain. Through hilarious antics like reading a list of his 1,004 holds and hiring a fat slob bodyguard (Ralphus deserves a comeback), Jericho illustrated his knack for entertaining. Unfortunately, WCW didn’t peg him as main event caliber, and allowed him to try his luck in WWE.

You know how that went. Since 1999, Jericho has become WWE’s most reliable force: He has helped young guys like Fandango and Kevin Owens, reignited fan interest in established players like Big Show and acted as traffic controller during celebrity segments. Jericho’s dabbles in outside projects, whether in music, reality TV, film or podcasting, have also made him an ambassador for WWE.


4. Ric Flair To WWE

Ric Flair Real Worlds Champion
WWE

In the summer of 1991, Bobby Heenan joined Gorilla Monsoon and Jim Neidhart on WWF Wrestling Challenge, holding the NWA World Heavyweight Championship. Affectionately referred to as the “big, gold belt,” it was last seen around the waist of Ric Flair, who was fired by WCW President Jim Herd just weeks prior to Heenan’s appearance. It was unprecedented for WWE to acknowledge competing organizations, let alone broadcast their championship.

Fans weren’t sure what to expect, but knew that the 'Nature Boy' was on his way.

Flair’s defection to WWE caused mass panic at WCW – fans hijacked the Great American Bash that year, chanting "We Want Flair". In WWE, Flair was regarded as the "real world’s champion", and was instantly seen on par with arch rival Hulk Hogan. Although McMahon never pulled the trigger on a seemingly surefire WrestleMania main event between the two, Flair did achieve great success in foreign territory, winning the WWE Championship twice and stealing the show at Royal Rumble 1992.


3. Lex Luger To WCW

lex luger nitro
WWE.com

Eric Bischoff fired the first shot in the Monday Night War with a bullet named Lex Luger.

The Total Package shocked the world by walking out before Ric Flair locked up with Sting during the first Nitro. He was recognized as a WWE guy, having spent the past two years as an American hero and competing at a house show just one night before. Apparently, Luger’s contract had expired and he expressed interest with best friend Sting about coming back to WCW. Bischoff signed him in secrecy to maximize the shock factor of his appearance and immediately create a sense of unpredictability surrounding the new show.

Luger would go on to have a very successful run, winning the World Heavyweight Championship and leading WCW in the never-ending fight against the nWo.


2. Hulk Hogan To WCW

Hulk Hogan Wcw
WWE.com

Hell froze over in the summer of 1994 as the face of WWE joined WCW amid a ticker tape parade in Disney World. After leaving WWE in 1993 for the promise of Hollywood, Hulk Hogan would soon receive an offer from Eric Bischoff that he just couldn’t refuse. Hogan signed a massive contract that included creative control and a huge cut of pay-per-view revenue, among other incentives, and WCW signed the biggest star in pro wrestling history.

Immediately, Hogan was scheduled to face arch rival Ric Flair for the World Heavyweight Championship in a dream match that fans had been dying for since both men were in WWE two years earlier. They competed at Bash at the Beach, drawing an estimated 1.02 buyrate and grossing $2.58 million, compared to a .5/$1.18 million for Beach Blast the year prior. Of course, Hogan’s importance to WCW would grow even more two summers later…


1. Outsiders To WCW

The Outsiders Debut Wcw
WWE.com

There was no defection more significant in pro wrestling history than that of Kevin Nash and Scott Hall. Competing as Diesel and Razor Ramon, they were major players in WWE for the first half of the 1990s, representing the company’s New Generation. Disappointed in the lack of financial mobility, Hall reached out to WCW first, followed by his best friend Nash. They left WWE in May of 1996 after the infamous Curtain Call incident.

Two weeks later, Scott Hall appeared out of the crowd on Nitro, insinuating that he was sent by WWE to invade WCW. A couple weeks later, he was joined by Nash, and they promised a third member to complete the takeover of WCW. Nitro ratings skyrocketed as fans wondered what would happen next as the Outsiders attacked WCW’s roster on a weekly basis. Then Hogan revealed himself to be the third man at Bash at the Beach 1996, and the New World Order was born.

The super trio pushed not only WCW but also pro wrestling to its highest levels of popularity and revenue. Unfortunately, the nWo expanded beyond the trio, watering down its power and rarely receiving its comeuppance, ultimately being one of the factors that led to WCW going out of business.


 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Formerly the assistant editor of Wrestledelphia, John has joined the Muthaship at WhatCulture.