Ranking The 16 Greatest WWE TLC Matches Ever

Tables, Ladders, and Chairs...Oh my!

Tables, Ladders, and Chairs...Oh my! It has been nearly fifteen years since three tag teams got together at WrestleMania and redefined the concept previously known as the Ladder match. Unofficially, Mania 2000 became the site of the first TLC match. The specialties of three dynamic duos - the Dudley Boyz and their use of the table, the Hardy Boyz and their mastery of death defying leaps off of ladders, Edge/Christian and their steel sandwich otherwise known as the "conchairto" - combined into a format once made famous by Shawn Michaels and Razor Ramon. It was an exercise in hardcore visual artistry. What a legacy it has left... On the eve of the sixth annual TLC pay-per-view, it is almost hard to believe that such a popular gimmick had such decidedly mid-card origins. Somewhere, its forefathers should be grinning through gritted teeth, likely still dealing with the pain on a daily basis from the wounds inflicted by their invention of an instrument for bodily destruction. Good thing Mick Foley was not around for the TLC Era. The stipulation has seen many changes since the "old" days. Edge made it a main-event happening. You may note that half of the upcoming list features TLC matches for the World Championship. Though violence has been kicked to the curb in the last half decade in favor of a creative flavor, TLC still remains a must-see affair. There have been 16 TLC matches in WWE history with the 17th involving Dean Ambrose and Bray Wyatt coming up next Sunday. In preparation for the future, let us celebrate the past.

16. John Cena vs. Randy Orton (TLC 2013)

There's something about an Undisputed Championship that elicits goosebumps. The WWE and WCW Championships merging together was an epic moment of the early 2000s. For all intents and purposes, expecting something of reasonable epicness was not asking very much when the World titles once exclusive to respective WWE brands, Raw and Smackdown, were merged together a year ago. The stage was set for perhaps the two most recognizable stars of the Brand Split Era, Randy Orton and John Cena, to offer an incredibly memorable match for the ages. Unfortunately, the Tables, Ladders, and Chairs hindered the ultra-methodical Orton; and the ever-adaptable Cena merely went along for the ride. It's not that the TLC match between Orton and Cena was bad, but it was completely underwhelming when you consider the importance of what they were fighting for. Title unification matches should be outstanding spectacles or, at the very least, leave a lasting impression. The only impression left on that night was that the WWE fanbase was sick and tired of seeing Cena and Orton be put in such positions. The crowd was lukewarm, the spots were largely unimaginative, and the wrestlers seemed out of their element.

15. El Torito vs. Hornswoggle (Extreme Rules Pre-Show 2014)

Is the WeeLC famous or infamous or both? One thing is for certain: El Torito and Hornswoggle far exceeded the expectations for their match. Unlike Cena and Orton, who were given a golden opportunity for critical acclaim and squandered it, their smaller counterparts were thought to be "throwaway nonsense" and personified the old saying about turning chicken you-know-what into chicken salad. The fact that the feud that led to the match was comedy mid-card filler is irrelevant in the context of expectation. On the night of their match, they delivered well beyond what even the smartest of smart fans could have predicted. Beyond that, there is not much else to say about the match. Perhaps the biggest statement that they made was unspoken: that WWE desperately needs a new generation of top talents to take TLC and make it their own. Maybe Ambrose and Wyatt can do that. The telling note to take away from the first two entries of this list is that they both took place within the last 12 months.

14. The Miz vs. Jerry Lawler (Monday Night Raw November 29, 2010)

It would be a shame if the fact that The Miz hit it big during an era where fans are so intent on "what have you done for me lately" that they forget just how good Mike Mizanin's alter ego was from 2009-2011. No heel in modern history was able to get under your skin quite like him. Nobody wanted to see him succeed, fans and many peers alike, and he let that work to his advantage, crafting a character that was equal parts snobby and annoying. The concept of the Money in the Bank cash-in was perfect for him. If WWE wanted a cheap, smarmy heel to win the title to groan-inducing jeers from the fans, then they found it in Miz. He was like the rich guy's son who got the starring spot on youth sports teams because of who his daddy was. His promos perfectly reflected his persona. Miz really was awesome in that role. Why did they ever turn him babyface? Some questioned the decision to put him against Jerry Lawler for an extended feud, but could there have been a better way to accentuate the mindset that Miz was an opportunistic little punk than to have him barely be able to defeat an old codger with a crown?

13. CM Punk vs. Alberto Del Rio vs. The Miz (TLC 2011)

There is a secondary class of TLC matches that do not quite live up to the standard of the top editions of the gimmick, but were certainly fun to witness on the night that they occurred. You could interchange Punk-Del Rio-Miz with any of the next few entries and be perfectly justified in your argument. Del Rio was a heck of a mechanic, so he brought a different element that had been missing from the stipulation's recent past. Miz has never been a particularly inventive performer, so it was up to ADR and Punk to create something outside the parameters of the typical, "let's just destroy ourselves" mold for TLC. They succeeded. Creativity reigned supreme that night en route to one of those types of matches that you could label as "4-stars" and apply such adjectives as "great" but not "classic." Overall, TLC has been a match type that WWE could book in its sleep. There have not been many that failed to achieve at least some level of critical acclaim and Punk's first major title defense of his second reign as WWE Champion was no exception.

12. D-Generation X vs. Jeri-Show (TLC 2009)

This one got the nod over the previous simply because it has aged well. On the night of, this particular critic was not blown away. 2009 was a Ladder match-heavy year that had followed several other Ladder match-heavy years, which did not allow the WWE Tag Team Championship match from HBK's hometown to stand out immediately. In the past half decade, DX vs. Jeri-Show has become a much more engaging viewing experience. Let's face it: Big Show climbing a ladder has always been a fascinating sight. Combine that with the fact that three of the four participants are in a master class of storytellers in the WrestleMania Era and it should come as no surprise that they produced a Ladder match that concentrated on drama and selling more than stunt brawling. It did not lack for innovative spots, granted, but there was no way that four guys at their age were going to be able to do a TLC Era type TLC bout. What we got was thoroughly enjoyable; another of the ilk described in the previous entry that is worth a watch without any illusions of deeming it outstanding.

11. Edge vs. Kane vs. Alberto Del Rio vs. Rey Mysterio (TLC 2010)

Expectations were not incredibly high for the second annual TLC PPV's signature gimmick. Edge and Kane had a dud of a feud in late 2010 that partially eased the blow of the Rated R Superstar's abrupt retirement in early 2011. By then, he was getting quite stale, though a legend, indeed. Del Rio and Mysterio had long since reached the peak in their own respective rivalry, so the TLC match that put the four of them at odds was clearly thrown together. Fortunately, all four men are consummate professionals and delivered a match full of twists and turns. Unpredictability helped. Some thought that Kane had earned the right to carry the World Heavyweight Championship into WrestleMania. Others felt that Edge was the best option with the biggest name. Del Rio was thought to be a lock as a future World Champ, so some also felt that the future was now. Any of the three could have walked away with the strap and it would not have been surprising. Alas, it was Edge who emerged victorious in a thrilling match that lived up to the gimmick's sterling reputation.

10. Kane vs. The Dudley Boyz vs. Jeff Hardy & Rob Van Dam vs. Christian & Chris Jericho (Monday Night Raw October 7, 2002)

"Greatest match in Raw history," as it had been hilariously named just a month after it happened on a hokey Raw 10th Anniversary TV special, TLC IV was not. However, TLC IV was a very entertaining spectacle that gave its predecessors a quiet run for their money despite carrying very little of the historical significance or relevance. It depends on what you like, comparing this match to the previously mentioned bouts. It, too, is a TLC match that falls outside the category of the truly greatest ones, but it is great in its own right. Once upon a time, TLC was used to pop a TV rating. That was long before it had a PPV registering its namesake far more important than the product of a "Raw Roulette," spin of the wheel type deal, as had been the case when TLC was featured on Raw in 2002. Credit goes to all of the participants for just how well they pulled off something so seemingly random. It was a nice mixture of smart workers and glorified stuntmen. Subsequently, it is hard to argue the quality of the match.

9. Edge vs. Ric Flair (Monday Night Raw January 16, 2006)

We have Edge to thank for making Tables, Ladders, and Chairs a main-event gimmick, pulling each of the pieces of TLC out of their long-term place in the mid-card and moving them up the card. Of course, it was Edge who helped pioneer the stunt brawl in WWE, combining with Christian to form the duo that may not have gotten all the glory from the fans during the TLC tag team era, but did receive the majority of the kayfabe victories in the matches. Edge and Flair had been feuding for awhile when the Rated R Superstar won the WWE Championship at New Year's Revolution, pioneering the Money in the Bank concept, as well. Flair was a natural first title defense for him, but the TLC stipulation was a surprise from a Raleigh (Flair Country) edition of Raw. Many wondered if Flair could do a Ladder-style match given his age. They had an amazing match. Flair's age was part of the reason why it was so memorable. An old man had no business being in that sort of match. To see him excel in that environment - with a big assist from Edge - was thrilling to watch, particularly for fans that had seen him do it all before (with the exception of the Ladder match). If you watch it back, notice a young Charlotte sitting ringside during her senior year at North Carolina State (in Raleigh).

8. Edge vs. Undertaker (One Night Stand 2008)

Here's Edge again. Get used to it... The Rated R Superstar was once referred to as "the Einstein of the business." He was very adept at taking the pieces of the puzzle that shape a wrestling match and putting them together in intricately creative ways. That skill set applied particularly well to the finishes of his matches. He was one of the best closers in history, capable of capping off matches in thrilling fashion. He would need it against Taker, who is perhaps the most methodical worker to have ever appeared in a TLC match. Part of the allure of the match in 2008 was the added stipulation that Taker would have to retire if he lost the match. The World Championship and a legendary career hung in the balance. What the Deadman lacked in TLC experience he more than made up for thanks to his chemistry with Edge. This was the second in a trio of classics between the two. The high spots were very well done and the finish was an incredible visual.

7. The Shield vs. Team Hell No & Ryback (TLC 2012)

Next Sunday's TLC match will be the second in history to hang nothing above the ring. The first to merely feature an excuse to beat up an opponent with tables, ladders, and chairs was two years ago. And it was awesome... Recently, Seth Rollins was a guest on Chris Jericho's podcast, during which he recounted the early days of his time as the architect of the Shield. At TLC 2012, none of the three had ever wrestled an official WWE match, having made their debut just a month prior at Survivor Series. Team Hell No and Ryback were the popular talents chosen to be the first official bone thrown to the Hounds of Justice. Think of the Attitude Era main-event style when trying to picture this type of TLC. They battled all over the place, Rollins showed his propensity for bumping, Reigns was impressive as an intensely-driven force of nature, and Ambrose displayed the early signs of his strangely endearing wild man self. As Rollins mentioned on Talk is Jericho, they all clicked with Daniel Bryan, who largely carried the match amidst the inexperienced and the Ryback. All in all, it was a unique take on the concept; a breath of fresh air, frankly. Watching 2012 veteran, Ambrose, and Bray Wyatt attempt to best the original will be quite interesting.

6. Edge & Christian vs. The Hardy Boyz vs. The Dudley Boyz (WrestleMania X-Seven)

As we venture into the top 6, it gets a little bit more difficult to separate the various matches from the pack. To some, TLC 2 was the greatest of them all. To others, it was a Jeff Hardy tight rope act away from being one of the greatest matches of all-time, period. The Triangle Ladder match that unofficially birthed the TLC concept was over 20-minutes and had some downtime, whereas the first and second official versions were shorter and non-stop action. History remembers Edge giving Jeff a Spear, Jeff hanging on the hook and Edge launching himself off a ladder. It does not as often recall that Hardy stumbled and fumbled what would have been a brilliant spot - a be all, end all for a stunt brawl. The original plan had been for Jeff to go from one ladder to another and then grab the hook. It didn't work. Alas, it was the missed spot that allowed the matches ahead to stand out above TLC 2. Take nothing away from these six guys, though, plus Lita, Rhyno, and Spike Dudley. It was a borderline masterpiece in many ways.

5. Edge & Christian vs. The Hardy Boyz vs. The Dudley Boyz vs. Chris Benoit & Chris Jericho (Smackdown! May 24, 2001)

Wrestling fans have the choice to evoke the kayfabe clause in their own minds when it comes to grapplers that were amazing contributors to WWE world but detractors from the real world. In the kayfabe world, Chris Benoit had so many classic matches that WWE has, understandably, swept under the rug because of his actions in leaving the real world. In regards to TLC 3, being cast into the depths of WWE's storage closet is nothing new. It was already known for years as "the forgotten TLC." Edge once called it that in his book and later acted on it during a promo in 2006, claiming to have never lost a TLC match. Well, he had. TLC 3, in fact. To Benoit and Chris Jericho, the newly minted Tag Team Champions whose classic Raw match against Triple H and Steve Austin has also been filed away in the "Do Not Mention" folder. The real reason for TLC 3 being forgotten is that it took place without hype on Smackdown. It just happened. Matches like TLC should always be built up and this one was not. Nevertheless, it was an incredible match. Visually, the additions of two other men (especially the caliber of Benoit and Y2J) was just what the gimmick needed to freshen up after three separate takes on the death-defying stunt brawl. Benoit and Jericho, themselves, had torn the house down with a story-driven Ladder match at the 2001 Royal Rumble four months prior, so they contributed something different. The taped nature of the match certainly did not hurt, as any missteps could be edited (though botches were, shockingly, very uncommon among them - amazing given the degree of difficulty).

4. CM Punk vs. Jeff Hardy (SummerSlam 2009)

What are your tastes in a TLC match? Your palate should have been exposed to enough varieties, by now, to have allowed you to develop a preference. If what has drawn you to the TLC concept has been violence and innovation, then CM Punk vs. Jeff Hardy might not be the right match for you. Again, we go back to the earlier discussion of there being a more diverse set of criterion to evaluate gimmick matches. A quick history lesson to accentuate the point: HBK and Razor, followed by Rock and HHH, introduced us to a Ladder match as a stipulation that made a ladder an interesting prop to use in telling a story, while Edge, Christian, and the Hardys proceeded to add a new wrinkle by delving into a display of wrestling's hardcore visual artistry. In the combat arts, HBK-Razor was a Pacino flick, while the tag team bout was one of Van Damme's action movies. Punk vs. Hardy was the most psychologically sound of all TLC matches, with its focus not on creating mayhem through its stunts, but on creating drama through its interactions between rivals. Of course, it featured Jeff Hardy throwing caution to the wind, so it also had a balance. Take out the ending with Taker returning and you've got a borderline masterpiece.

3. Edge & Christian vs. The Hardy Boyz vs. The Dudley Boyz (SummerSlam 2000)

Speaking of masterpieces... The official first TLC match at Summerslam 2000 was similar in its non-stop, spot exercise format as the Hardys vs. Edge and Christian at No Mercy 1999 - the Ladder match that had, essentially, laid the foundation for the tag team renaissance that TLC is well-known for pioneering during the Attitude Era. For less than a quarter hour, three teams intricately weaved a series of near death-defying stunts together, creating an outstanding aesthetic experience for viewers that can easily be argued has never been matched. Unlike its lengthier predecessor from Mania 2000, TLC 1 did not leave much time for such things as selling, so that has typically been the knock against it and why some have favored the unofficial original. Not to offer the literary version of the broken record, but it is - again - a matter of preference. Yet, if you favor the type of TLC that bombarded you with sights of incredibly high risks and life-altering bumps, then it would be difficult to argue against TLC 1 being the best of the lot.

2. John Cena vs. Edge (Unforgiven 2006)

The WWE main-event style has, even at its Attitude Era peak, been heavy on the in-ring psychology. TLC is not a particularly ready-made gimmick for lengthy doses of selling, expression, and taunting. So, in 2006, it was up to TLC veteran, Edge, to find a way to blend a stipulation that had previously been a decidedly mid-card affair with a main-event style that had pre-dated the start of his lengthy career. Sans for one mistimed spot, he actually made it look quite easy. Edge and John Cena had the 2006 Match of the Year in the very first attempt at bringing TLC to the PPV main-event scene. Admittedly, what allowed the Edge-Cena match to climb the ranks ahead of its peers was the intangible of the Toronto crowd, who adored the Rated R Superstar (hometown Toronto) and gave Cena a large dose of the verbal medicine that he still takes today. A great crowd can boost a match. Since creating these lists inherently carries the challenge of separation, a great crowd can be the factor that jumps one match over another. The crowd merely responded, though, to an amazing match. Edge and Cena held nothing back. They both bumped like mid-carders trying to make an impression on management instead of two established top tier performers who had already made it. This one is worth as many repeat viewings as any of its peers.

1. Edge & Christian vs. The Hardy Boyz vs. The Dudley Boyz (WrestleMania 2000)

There really is something to be said for the original, however unofficial it might be in the grand scheme of all things TLC. The Triangle Ladder match at WrestleMania 2000 was, let's face it, a TLC match simply missing the name "TLC." In every respect, it was the first actual TLC, with tables, ladders, and chairs galore. It can be somewhat confusing, especially for younger fans, when WWE history reflects back to the year 2000 and calls the Summerslam match "TLC 1" and zooms to Mania 17 for "TLC 2." Technically, they may as well be called "TLC 2 and 3," respectively, given what went down at Mania 2000. They look very much the same, with the exception being that the Triangle Ladder match was near epic length for a Ladder match at well over twenty minutes. No matter the official order, Edge, Christian, the Dudleys, and the Hardys made themselves legends that night. They stole the show from megastars like Rock, Triple H, Foley, and the McMahons. They were young and hungry and they allowed their desire to rise to the top of the business to fuel an undeniably brilliant performance. Even though it was smack dab in the mid-card of the year's biggest show, it was somewhat oddly not treated as anything less than a main-event. What arguably separates it from everything that followed it these last 15 years is that they wrestled it like a main-event. They paused in between some of the eye-popping action, allowing a proper response beyond just "Wow." Even if you had seen Michaels vs. Ramon in 1994, it mattered not. The three teams completely re-wrote the expectation for Ladder matches - of all varieties. Initial reaction reigns supreme, here. Maybe you could argue that the original has been topped. Yet, if you think back to the first time you ever saw this match, then everything that has come since has merely been competing for second place.

Contributor
Contributor

"The Doc" Chad Matthews has written wrestling columns for over a decade. A physician by trade, Matthews began writing about wrestling as a hobby, but it became a passion. After 30 years as a wrestling fan, "The Doc" gives an unmatched analytical perspective on pro wrestling in the modern era. He is a long-time columnist for Lordsofpain.net and hosts a weekly podcast on the LOP Radio Network called "The Doc Says." His first book - The WrestleMania Era: The Book of Sports Entertainment - ranks the Top 90 wrestlers from 1983 to present day, was originally published in December 2013, and is now in its third edition. Matthews lives in North Carolina with his wife, two kids, and two dogs.