Ranking The 28 Greatest Hell In A Cell Matches In WWE History

18. DX Vs. The McMahons And Big Show (Unforgiven 2006)

This is where the line in the sand can be drawn and the separation between the clearly worst versions of Hell in a Cell and the middle of the pack begins. DX vs. The McMahons was entertaining, simply put. The booking back then was clearly trying to find a balance between yesteryear and modern times, so if you could appreciate that for what it was, then you likely enjoyed watching the €œnew€ DX in 2006. The matches carried that theme forward into in-ring competition. They certainly were not designed to blow the roof of an arena, but they accomplished what they intended to accomplish in the entertainment department. It brought something different to the table and opened up creative€™s happy-go-lucky side a bit. HBK and HHH were a legitimately funny duo even in a watered down environment. Adding Big Show to the mix made sense at the time. He had come on strong in the summer as the ECW World Champion and it was smart to use him as an agent of destruction. There have certainly been better Hell in a Cell matches, but those five guys offered up an enjoyable effort that stands up well against its peers outside of the top ten.

17. Randy Orton Vs. Sheamus (Hell In A Cell 2010)

The PG versions of Hell in a Cell have featured one particular wrestler more than any other: Randy Orton. His sadistic character and methodical style seemed a good fit for the gimmick€™s transition from one era to the next. Reviews have been mixed as to how effectively he has pulled off the switch from a blood and guts-laden brawl to less organic, forced, decidedly less violent matches, perhaps best exemplified by his work with Sheamus in 2010. Blood would certainly look fascinating on the pasty white skin of the Celtic Warrior, would it not? In much the same way that it worked so aesthetically well in Ric Flair€™s blonde hair, crimson would massively accentuate any personal story that Sheamus tried to tell. Alas, blood is not allowed. To some critics, Sheamus sold them on his ability to be a top WWE star in his Hell in a Cell match with Orton. To others, it was just another PG Cell match. Orton and Sheamus are both very good at the little quirks and psychological ploys that can be used to better the drama in a modern match. The Celtic Warrior works a stiff style that meshes well with Orton€™s. They had to heavily rely on the details to make their Cell match standout. Only its mixed critical reviews prevented it from being higher up the list.

16. DX Vs. The Legacy (Hell In A Cell 2009)

When DX resurfaced in 2006 and then again in 2009, it had to adapt its characteristic style to fit both modern standards and HBK€™s personal views. In contrast to their feud with the McMahons in €™06 that had been strongly comedic and €œfun€, their €™09 storyline with Randy Orton€™s new stable, The Legacy €“ featuring Cody Rhodes and Ted Dibiase, Jr. €“ was far more intense. It featured many of the antics that we had come to know and expect of the once rebellious faction, but it was decidedly more focused on the fact that HBK and HHH were legends who had become the targets of two up-and-coming thoroughbreds. Rhodes and Dibiase rightly viewed it as an opportunity to break out. In hindsight, it is actually surprising that they did not ascend higher up the proverbial ladder because their work against DX was fantastic. They had a three-PPV rivalry that concluded with Hell in a Cell. As with their other matches, the Hell in a Cell bout was quite good. Legacy€™s approach to each match was to divide and conquer, a strategy that elevated Rhodes and Dibiase and made them both look like future stars. That style led to one of the more creatively booked of the Cell matches that have come since the 2008 Edge-Taker bout laid the blueprint for the gimmick€™s post-Foley existence.

15. Alberto Del Rio Vs. CM Punk Vs. John Cena (Hell In A Cell 2011)

This is a good opportunity to praise the recently-departed Alberto Del Rio, who was never the most charismatic WWE Superstar, but who could undeniably work. In the old days, guys like him were referred to as mechanics. Del Rio was one of the best mechanics WWE has had in the last decade. He was the star of the 2011 Hell in a Cell main-event. He really stepped up his game in that environment and dominated for long stretches. His credibility needed the boost back then and it got it thanks to his performance. The not-too-recently-departed, downright legendary CM Punk made his case for MVP of the match, too, for bumping like he did and making it feel like more than just a regular match surrounded by a roofed fence. The finish was thrilling. You always think Cena is going to overcome the odds, so it added great drama to see him struggle to re-enter the Cell after having been locked out. Del Rio winning back the title for the 7th title change in 2.5 months was a justifiably questionable decision, but the match itself sits firmly in the middle of the pack as, perhaps, the most forgotten of all Cell matches.

14. Randy Orton Vs. Undertaker (Armageddon 2005)

Many had hoped that, perhaps, a classic distinction could be reserved for a match between Randy Orton and Undertaker in 2005. They had a nice series of matches that year, particularly the bouts at WrestleMania 21 and Summerslam, but none of them were great. Their Hell in a Cell at Armageddon gave them a chance in the blow off match to their lengthy rivalry. Unfortunately, they did not deliver much more than they had previously despite an added ten-plus minutes of bell-to-bell time. That is not to say that they did not deliver a very good half hour of wrestling, stripping away the pre-match expectations. It featured several swings in momentum over the course of 30-minutes and Orton certainly came away from both the match and the feud with his career back on track after that disastrous face turn in the fall of 2004. This was during the time when the WWE was transitioning the Cell to its current format, though. As such, one could say that it was lacking something to push it over the top into the best ten. On a rainy day, you could bring this up to view and have plenty of historical subplots (Orton€™s resurgence, Taker€™s role in it, both of their respective places in WWE lore) to sink your teeth into along with their half year of on-screen feuding.

13. Daniel Bryan Vs. Randy Orton (Hell In A Cell 2013)

There was simply too much talent between them for Bryan and Orton not to have a great match at some point. It was not a classic, their Hell in a Cell match, but it was one of the best versions of the gimmick in the last half decade. The climax was clearly setting up something foul, as it became apparent that evil Authoritarian, Triple H, expected special guest referee, HBK, to do dirty work on his behalf. That dirty deed ended up being a superkick to Bryan when the "Yes!" man had the momentum in his favor. The previous two PPVs had done a poor job of delivering Bryan vs. Orton matches that seemed fitting for those who purchased the show, while also fanning the flames of the top feud so that it could continue to be built on television. It had that familiar aura that did the Cell bouts of old. The Miami crowd responded, doing their part to add a much-needed backdrop. Orton and Bryan delivered unique variations of moves, a pace befitting of a presumed end, and clear cut motivation to steal the show for the first 3/4 of the match. Then, Triple H came to the ring and prompted more story-driven action reminiscent of the previous two PPVs. The camera shifted back and forth, creating necessary confusion that well told the tale of corporate collusion.

12. Batista Vs. Undertaker (Survivor Series 2007)

Taker and Batista had a fantastic series of matches in 2007 that surprised many critics. Batista stepped up his game that year and elevated his position in wrestling history through his title matches with the Deadman. Their Hell in a Cell was the final one-on-one PPV encounter of their saga. Rather than definitively end their storyline, however, the match was used to begin Taker€™s next WrestleMania rivalry (with Edge). Disappointing as that may have been given the desire to see Batista and Taker take each other to the limit one more time, the match was still quite good. It was similar to Taker€™s match with Orton, though, in that expectations were €œMatch of the Year€ candidate and we ended up getting something less. Unlike some of the other €œmiddle of the pack€ choices on this list, Batista vs. Taker drew mixed opinions, often finding itself just inside the top 10 of Hell in a Cell rankings and just as often finding itself much further down than you see here. It has been steadily rated at the 4-star mark, but did not have the novelty or intangibles to overcome the interference-laden climax considering that the Cell has traditionally been used to clearly identify who the better man is.

11. John Cena Vs. Randy Orton (Hell In A Cell 2009)

2009 ushered in a new era for the Cell. It became its own PPV, but the style also changed dramatically. No more blood meant the loss of an important intangible in putting over the finality of a rivalry once reserved for matches. The star since that change has been Randy Orton, who has excelled despite the handcuffs. He had a very good match with John Cena at the inaugural Hell in a Cell PPV, showing off some of the best character work that he had ever done. His heel character was hitting its stride in early €™09 when he main-evented WrestleMania and it was in full gear when he wrestled four PPV matches against Cena later that year. The requisite near falls were there and they told a story that drew in the crowd and kept their feud alive for another month. Of all the Hell in a Cell matches, this might be the most underrated. Much of the credit goes to Orton for his psychology and selling. John Cena more than held up his end of the bargain, though. He has proven to be one of modern wrestling history€™s top big match performers and his Hell in a Cell with Orton was an adequate example.

10. Shawn Michaels Vs. Triple H (Bad Blood 2004)

HBK vs. HHH inside Hell in a Cell was, by far, the longest match in the storied gimmick€™s 17 years. Upon first viewing, the marathon was praised by some for its attention to rivalry-specific detail, its storytelling, and psychology (HBK playing up his past back problems was particularly noteworthy), while many a comment was made about its rather slow pace. It being an unprecedented length for a WWE main-event combined with the unpredictability of the match as it wore on helped it become a performance that was highly praised, though not universally. However, as time wore on, second and third viewings did not hold up to the standard of the first, many would come to say. It became more difficult to sit through, as glaring weaknesses such as the fact that the crowd was completely dead for much of it began to stick out like a sore thumb. Its pacing, noted originally for being slow, almost negated the psychology and the selling simply because it was not entertaining enough to hold your attention when re-watching it. All in all, it was a memorable match; epic even. Unfortunately, it has become like watching Avatar of film lore, in that it is worth a watch, but more than once a decade might be pushing its entertainment limits.

9. Chris Jericho Vs. Triple H (Judgment Day 2002)

When Hell in a Cell first came into existence, it was Undertaker€™s yard. By 2002, Triple H had firmly laid claim to it being €œhis€ gimmick. To wrap up his lackluster feud with Chris Jericho, Trips dusted off the Cell for the first time in 18 months €“ the longest period ever between Cell matches. It needed the break, frankly. Thanks to Mick Foley and, to a lesser extent, Shawn Michaels, people expected utter carnage when they saw €œSatan€™s Structure.€ Triple H and Jericho did their best to add a wrinkle to the match that had not been used before, spending the climactic portion of their match at the top of the Cell without anyone falling off. The carnage, unfortunately, extended to the referees, as long-time official and former Andre the Giant behind-the-scenes assistant, Tim White, suffered a career-ending injury. Innovative as the finish may have been, HHH vs. Y2J suffers from a similar problem as many of the middle of the pack Cell matches, in that it arguably struggles to stand up to the test of time. Its position at #9 is somewhat deceiving, as there is no suitable separation criteria to make it definitively better than the last 5-10 matches listed. Nevertheless, when compared to today€™s versions, its final scenes are almost breathtaking.

Contributor
Contributor

"The Doc" Chad Matthews has written wrestling columns for over a decade. A physician by trade, Matthews began writing about wrestling as a hobby, but it became a passion. After 30 years as a wrestling fan, "The Doc" gives an unmatched analytical perspective on pro wrestling in the modern era. He is a long-time columnist for Lordsofpain.net and hosts a weekly podcast on the LOP Radio Network called "The Doc Says." His first book - The WrestleMania Era: The Book of Sports Entertainment - ranks the Top 90 wrestlers from 1983 to present day, was originally published in December 2013, and is now in its third edition. Matthews lives in North Carolina with his wife, two kids, and two dogs.