Ranking All 30 WWE SummerSlam Main Events
The summer classic has seen wide range of closing matches.
WWE’s summer classic is almost upon us, and as usual, the company is pulling out all the stops. SummerSlam has become the promotion’s summer WrestleMania, a major show where major angles culminate and big-money matches take place.
This year is no exception on paper, as you have Brock Lesnar facing Roman Reigns in what should be the end of their epic(?) feud, Ronda Rousey challenging for the Raw Women’s Championship, AJ Styles and Samoa Joe tangling for the WWE Championship, and Daniel Bryan finally getting his hands on The Miz in a rivalry that is long overdue for a match.
Of course, that doesn’t guarantee a blockbuster of a show, but it’s clear WWE views SummerSlam as a big deal. SummerSlam has produced some truly amazing matches throughout the years, and it’s given us some turkeys – and that range of match quality applies to the main events of each of the previous 30 summer PPVs. Some main events have bored fans to tears, while others have brought them to their feet.
Sometimes the strength of the PPV is measured by how good the main event is. A truly memorable last match can elevate fans’ and critics’ opinions of the event, while a forgettable bout can damage the PPV’s reputation.
With that said, let’s take a subjective look at the SummerSlam main events through the years and see how they stack up.
30. 1994 – Undertaker Vs. Underfaker
As a match, as a storyline and as a main event, this flopped – completely.
The backstory is that at the Royal Rumble that year, Yokozuna (and about 10 other wrestlers) beat Undertaker in a casket match. The casket started smoking, then 'Taker levitated into the heavens to be reborn. (No, seriously.) In the interim, Ted DiBiase debuted his Undertaker, who very clearly was not the Undertaker. At SummerSlam, the two collided.
The match was doomed from the start because it followed the excellent WWF title cage match between Bret and Owen Hart. Throw in that the two Undertakers spent a lot of the 10-minute match no-selling moves and you have a recipe to suck the oxygen out of the arena.
You know it’s a bad match when it’s never referenced again, except by fans when assembling “Worst of…” compilations.
29. 1995 – Diesel (C) Vs. Mabel
You almost have to feel bad for Kevin Nash here. He
has proven through the years that he is capable of having a good match with the
right opponent.
Unfortunately, Mabel is not one of them. Besides that, was anyone in 1995 buying Mabel as King of the Ring, much less a threat to Diesel’s championship?
Like the previous year’s main event, Diesel vs. Mabel suffered from having an awesome match precede it, this time Shawn Michaels vs. Razor Ramon in an Intercontinental Championship ladder match (no, not that ladder match).
Diesel and Mabel plodded through the bout, finally
ending with Diesel winning the “epic” battle. Mabel would go on to legit injure
Undertaker, which would lead to his being sent into exile for two years.
28. 1989 – Hogan/Beefcake Vs. Savage/Zeus
This match is the blueprint for how not to do a movie crossover.
The release of Hulk Hogan’s movie “No Holds Barred” led WWF to look for ways to increase the movie’s visibility. And the braintrust decided that the best course would be to have the movie character Zeus, who lost to Hogan’s character Rip in the movie, challenge Hogan in the real world, with actor Tom Lister still portraying Zeus. Confused? You’re not alone.
Nevermind that Lister was an actor, not a trained wrestler. Nevermind the confusing backstory. This was a license to print money! Or not.
The match itself was brutal. Thankfully, Randy Savage was Zeus’ partner, keeping things from falling apart. But after a rematch in a steel cage, Zeus was gone from WWF, and this entire storyline faded away and became the butt of many jokes.
27. 1991 – Hogan/Warrior Vs. Slaughter/Adnan/Mustafa
If we counted the “wedding” of Randy Savage and Miss
Elizabeth as the main event, 1991 SummerSlam’s entry would rank much higher.
But alas, this was the wrestling main event, pitting WWF champ Hulk Hogan and former champ Ultimate Warrior against former champ Sgt. Slaughter and his two managers, General Adnan and Col. Mustafa (better known as the Iron Sheik).
Considering the heel side consisted of 52-year-old Adnan, 49-year-old Mustafa and a “spry” 42-year-old Slaughter, was anyone giving them a chance? Who thought this was going to be a good match? Hogan had already dispatched of Slaughter and his Iraqi flag-waving buddies at WrestleMania VII.
Needless to say, this one goes on the scrap heap.
26. 2010 – Team WWE Vs. The Nexus
For one fleeting moment, it looked like WWE had figured out a clever way to redo the nWo invasion storyline in a fresh way, using rookies from its farm system to “take over” the company. Then John Cena went and killed it dead in an instant.
The seven Nexus rookies squared off against seven WWE superstars in an elimination match that had the potential to boost the rookies (or at least some of them) to new heights in one evening. While the match itself was fine, the ending – Cena overcoming the odds to defeat the final two Nexus members – effectively killed the entire angle. Edge and Chris Jericho, who were both on Team WWE, have discussed how Cena changed the ending from a Nexus win to a Cena victory (and how Cena later admitted he was wrong), so there’s no sense in reliving it all.
But for the poor booking decision alone, this deserves to be in the bottom third of SummerSlam main events, match quality be damned.
25. 1990 – Warrior (C) Vs. Rude
This would be Ultimate Warrior’s first PPV match after winning the WWF Championship at WrestleMania VI.
The poor guy had to contend with Hulk Hogan still wrestling on the card against Earthquake, so Warrior remained in the Hulkster’s red and yellow shadow. At least he was in the ring with a capable opponent in Rick Rude.
Rude had defeated Warrior for the Intercontinental Championship a year earlier, so not only was there backstory, it was plausible that the Ravishing One could beat Warrior in the cage match. Of course, that wasn’t to happen, and Warrior would continue on as champ until Royal Rumble, when Sgt. Slaughter would derail his reign.
24. 2003 – Elimination Chamber: HHH (C) Vs. Orton Vs. Jericho Vs. Goldberg Vs. Nash Vs. Michaels
Now we get into matches that were by all accounts pretty decent, and rankings come down to things such as historical context and personal preference.
In mid-2003, Goldberg was on a roll. Amazingly, he had managed to capture lightning in a bottle a second time, getting his WCW act over in WWE. At SummerSlam, he faced off in an Elimination Chamber match against World Heavyweight Champion HHH and four others.
After running through Randy Orton, Chris Jericho and Shawn Michaels, Goldberg finally got his hands on HHH. Logic said that the red-hot Goldberg should have won the title here from an already-injured Game.
But logic be damned. Instead, HHH used his trusty sledgehammer to prolong his reign for another month – and damage Goldberg’s momentum in the process.
23. 1993 – Yokozuna (C) Vs. Luger
With the departure of Hulk Hogan in 1993, Vince
McMahon needed a new all-American hero to combat the evil forces in the WWF.
He decided to flip Lex Luger from a self-absorbed heel to a Made in the USA babyface. Luger turned and kicked off his feud with then-champ Yokozuna by boarding the USS Intrepid on Independence Day and bodyslamming the behemoth. After campaigning cross-country on the Lex Express, Luger got his title shot at SummerSlam.
The two carried on a perfectly serviceable match, except for one notable problem: it lacked a finish. After slamming Yokozuna and knocking him out of the ring with a forearm smash, Luger won the match – by count-out. Per the match stipulation, Luger would not get a rematch, thus having to wait until the Royal Rumble to earn another shot, which wouldn’t go so well for him.
For WWE, it was a lost opportunity to turn Luger
into a “made man,” and his next world title reign would come four years later
in WCW.
22. 2016 – Lesnar Vs. Orton
What a weird match this turned out to be.
While a match between Brock Lesnar and Randy Orton sounded like a good one on paper that had some history (Lesnar defeated Orton in all their dark and televised matches during their debut year in 2002), this one came out of nowhere. Orton was simply announced as Lesnar’s SummerSlam opponent, and then they backfilled the rivalry.
The match didn’t really click, but it would take a bigger nosedive with how it ended. Lesnar mounted Orton and began pummeling him, busting him wide open. Randy gushed blood – a sight very rarely seen on WWE TV these days – and the match was basically ended right there. It apparently was ruled a TKO, with Orton unable to continue.
SmackDown GM Shane McMahon came out to complain, and he was given an F-5 for his troubles. And then, there was no real follow-up to the match. Orton and Lesnar had a house show match a month later, but that was it. There was no televised bout showing the Viper trying to avenge the brutal loss.
Just a complete downer of a PPV main event.
21. 2005 – Hogan Vs. Michaels
Yep, it’s that match.
Although it was billed as Icon vs. Icon, it ended up being Ego vs. Ego. Hulk Hogan and Shawn Michaels finally met in singles action, fueled by an awesome heel turn by HBK (which disappeared as quickly as it came about). Originally envisioned as multiple matches, Hogan balked at losing, which led Michaels to stage his own version of a protest: overselling nearly every power move in the match.
Michaels bounced around like the proverbial pinball for Hogan, to comical effect. He somersaulted backward out of the ring off a shoulderblock and proceeded to sell Hogan’s '80s offense like he was being shot. The highlight (or is it lowlight?) was Michaels popping up after Hogan’s big boot, flailing around in a circle before collapsing in position for the legdrop. Bad match, tremendous trainwreck.
The next night, Hogan was gone, Michaels turned back to face, and everyone just moved on. Given that it basically has become an ignored part of WWE history, this match gets bonus points for the sheer spectacle of it all.