Ranking Every 2017 WWE Pay-Per-View From Worst To Best
Super Serve Me
What even is a WWE pay-per-view anymore?
It doesn't pay the wrestlers like it used to - several have explored options elsewhere thanks to a financial imbalance on their payslip WWE have kept tight-lipped about disclosing since launching the Network in 2014.
It's categorically not the direct money-making mechanism it used to be. Their streaming service's subscriber numbers broadly trend upwards every year, but typically only the Royal Rumble-to-WrestleMania quarter reflects growth worthy of significant boasts. Vince McMahon has played the long game and will likely win in the end, but his company's insistence on clinging to a dated monthly model without the incoming revenues to justify it has diluted a television output he now relies upon for significant funds.
Since the 2016 Brand Split, the shark-infested waters have gotten only muddier. Peddling two supercards a month on numerous occasions, the apparent need to establish Raw and Smackdown as re-partitioned entities resulted in a seismic overload of sup-par product, forcing even the most ardent fans to take a breather from the sheer amount of content they'd been expected to endure on a bi-monthly basis.
2017 was subject to the burden, though lessons have apparently been learned with the binning of at least two shows next year. It was very easy to get lost or look away as another Sunday show crept up, but the sheer diversity of the modern era ensured almost every show had something noteworthy, even if it wasn't always for the right reasons.
16. Battleground
The Good: The New Day and The Usos stole the show with a spellbinding battle over the SmackDown Live! Tag Team Titles. Long before it was quite apparent how incredible the chemistry was between the squads, Jimmy, Jey, Kofi Kingston and Xavier Woods let it all hang out in a festival of high spots and high drama. A frenzied fightback by Woods in particular after Kingston was floored with a powerbomb outside the ring kicked off a year in which he'd confound critiques that considered him little more than a third man.
The Bad: The Punjabi Prison (and The Great Khali's one-night return) at least added something to Jinder Mahal's dull defence of his newly-won WWE Championship, as did some more suicidal Singh bumps to mask the inadequacies of the man charged with holding the top title. Mike Kanellis' prospect looked suitably doomed following a moribund defeat against Sami Zayn, whilst Kevin Owens and AJ Styles again struggled to rise above the convoluted finish needed to facilitate Shane McMahon's placement as referee in a SummerSlam rematch.
The Ugly: Rusev had already gone back on his word to abandon SmackDown Live! after Daniel Bryan and Shane McMahon failed to bow to the pressure he'd put on for a title shot, and looked weaker still when John Cena flattened him in a jingoistic flag match. In an emerging pattern for 2017, 'The Bulgarian Brute' ended his one-month rivaly with John Cena in far worse shape than he started it. The less said about Shinsuke Nakamura's disqualification victory over Baron Corbin, the better.
15. Payback
The Good: A night where reliable pairings did what reliable pairings do, Payback was unspectacularly pulled back from the brink by safe bet retreads of matches that had already happened and would happen again as per life in modern day WWE. Contests featuring Chris Jericho, Kevin Owens, Neville, Austin Aries, The Hardy Boyz, Sheamus and Cesaro, Roman Reigns and Braun Strowman were all broadly enjoyable without being any one man's best night.
The Bad: Bayley losing the WWE Women's Title in her hometown was dispiriting, but not as bad as the card would eventually get. 'The Hugger' hasn't won the belt back since, and quite honestly hasn't even looked close to it. Seth Rollins and Samoa Joe went too long and did too little in their 16-minute snoozer, but were perhaps hamstrung by an audience completely bewildered at the shower of sh*te they'd just had to endure...
The Ugly: Barely a match until the closing stretch, the 'House Of Horrors'...thing between Randy Orton and Bray Wyatt was the worst version of whatever it was supposed to be. Bad wrestling often dates well, but this overblown and overwrought am-dram may take decades before becoming palatable.
14. Backlash
The Good: Baron Corbin and Sami Zayn put in a decent shift even if the result was yet more parity booking that harmed 'The Lone Wolf' in 2017 almost as much as his failed Money In The Bank cash-in. The Welcoming Committee looked as strong in their match against babyface defenders Becky Lynch, Charlotte Flair and Naomi as they had done on television. The match and angle in general would mark the peak of the blue brand's female league this year.
The Bad: Jinder Mahal winning the WWE Title had novelty appeal, but like almost all of his run with the strap, the match was the drizzling sh*ts. 'The Modern Day Maharaja' never remotely grew into the role. Kevin Owens and AJ Styles had their first of many disappointing outings this year, with the pair already slipping gradually into the Owens/Shane conflict that overwhelmed their chemistry up to and including the last SmackDown Live! main event of 2017.
The Ugly: Shinsuke Nakamura's main roster debut against Dolph Ziggler was a catastrophe. The polar opposite of his NXT TakeOver bow against Sami Zayn, 'The King Of Strong Style' was reduced to little more than a limp babyface threat within minutes of the bell, and left to flail and sell until a comeback sequence that drew underwhelmed applause from the crowd. Elsewhere, Luke Harper and Erick Rowan were doomed to failure yet again, made painfully apparent by their appalling match here against one another shortly after the complete post-WrestleMania decimation of The Wyatt Family. The Bludgeon Brothers gimmick was a sideways step, at very least.
13. Clash Of Champions
The Good: Baron Corbin, Bobby Roode and Dolph Ziggler assembled an electric three-way opener few saw coming after separate singles clashes between the three completely failed to sparkle. In what had to have been Jinder Mahal's final WWE main event, AJ Styles carried the former Champion to something substantially more watchable than anything else he'd achieved during his own spell with the strap. Closing out the year by permanently shutting Mahal out of the top bracket was a fitting end to a year that did untold damage to the once-prestigious title.
The Bad: WWE grasped defeat from the jaws of victory by booking a Fatal Four-way Tag Team Title match as a constant rotational four-way dance instead of the traditional two-in-the-ring formula. Popular, over and talented, the four units still managed a hot closing sequence despite the shackles of the booking, but the inexplicable rule shift tarnished what should have been an end-of-year classic. Charlotte Flair and Natalya's lumberjack match was a f**king mess, and exposed a dearth in talent on the blue brand beyond the treadmill at the top.
The Ugly: Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn were apparently fighting for their jobs against Randy Orton and Shinsuke Nakamura, but they may have had a brighter future just taking the defeat rather than actually trying to win. Warring referees Daniel Bryan and Shane McMahon dominated proceedings as the accoutrement overwhelmed the main course, including a farcical and protracted closing stretch that saw 'The King Of Strong Style' hurled through a table in contrast to 'The Apex Predator' getting beat with a roll-up.
12. WrestleMania 33
The Good: Though the Ladder Match stunt show that followed was instantly forgotten, The Hardy Boyz' WWE return was absolutely not - it was a genuine 'WrestleMania Moment' in an era of manufactured ones. Apparently not even worthy of inclusion on the original DVD release, Neville and Austin Aries' Cruiserweight Title match was as glorious as the sunshine it was set to. Brock Lesnar and Bill Goldberg exorcised their WrestleMania 20 demons with a flawlessly planned and executed destruction derby. Triple H and Seth Rollins had one of the better versions of 'The Game's long WrestleMania formula outings, though a later rewatch suggested it required the timeliness of the tale to really amp up the drama. Stephanie McMahon going through a table was visually satisfying, if misplaced and mishandled on the night.
The Bad: The match pitting The Miz and Maryse against John Cena and Nikki Bella was destined to close with 'The Champ's marriage proposal to his longtime partner, but the quality contest didn't have to be needlessly sacrificed to get there. AJ Styles made the best of ludicrous circumstances in his show-opener with Shane McMahon. Whomever laid out the match to position 'The Money' as 'The Phenomenal One's in-ring equal wants sacking...but probably got a raise.
The Ugly: If his contest with Roman Reigns really was The Undertaker's retirement clash, he went out one match too late. The two couldn't remotely conjure up a believable scenario in which the decrepit 'Deadman' could down 'The Big Dog'. The botched Tombstone reversal sequence really didn't help either. Randy Orton's WWE Title victory over Bray Wyatt was catastrophically bad for both men, and permanently 'The Eater Of Worlds' to cartoonish bullsh*t for the remainder of his career.
11. No Mercy
The Good: Cesaro cemented his long-held status as 'hardest man in the world' by not only working through an ungodly injury but also throwing himself into yet another incredible pay-per-view doubles dance with Dean Ambrose and Seth Rollins. Smashing his face against the post on a routine catapult spot, Cesaro's teeth were forced up into his gums and blood gushed from the sudden gap in the middle of his mouth. The false finishes in the contest were as effective as the false dentures he may one day require. A Five-way match for Alexa Bliss' Women's Title overachieved at just the right time - No Mercy began the build to Asuka's main roster arrival and 'The Empress Of Tomorrow' needed credible opposition to help her make a mark.
The Bad: John Cena's match with Roman Reigns forced through more artificial 'moments' than a modern day WrestleMania. A cliched cover version of Cena's epic wars with CM Punk, AJ Styles and others, the finisher-fest lacked craft and didn't remotely elevate Roman Reigns' already-sky high stock half as much as the post-match arm-raising implied.
The Ugly: Brock Lesnar's Universal Title defence against Braun Strowman was categorically the biggest disappointment of the year. The contest was bereft of the chaos and carnage now inexorably linked to the 'Monster Among Men's major matches, whilst 'The Beast's creative contempt towards the megastar-in-waiting mirrored his reckless WrestleMania 31 mistreatment of Dean Ambrose.
10. Extreme Rules
The Good: Samoa Joe claimed victory in an excellently-booked and worked fatal five way main event alongside Seth Rollins, Roman Reigns, Bray Wyatt and Finn Bálor. All five were permitted to look like top stars, as much thanks to the selflessness of 'The Big Dog' as anything else. He was ready, willing and able to make everybody else out there with him look as good as they possibly could. Sheamus and Cesaro continued to show that outstanding matches were the rule rather than the exception in an absorbing cage match with The Hardy Boyz.
The Bad: Neville and Austin Aries had the weakest match of their series in what proved to be 'The Greatest Man That Ever Lived's final televised contest for the company. Rich Swann and Sasha Banks' mixed tag team match win over Noam Dar and Alicia Fox was destined to be drab, and didn't over-deliver.
The Ugly: The 'Kendo Stick On A Pole' match between Alexa Bliss and Bayley continued an utterly wretched post-WrestleMania slump for the booking of 'The Hugger'. Weeks of build-up (including 'This Is Your Life', the worst segment of the entire year) pushed the idea that Bayley wasn't emotionally tough enough to wallop the Champion with the weapon...and she didn't, and she lost. Another nailed-on transcendent top babyface was flushed away in that very moment.
9. SummerSlam
The Good: A Vince McMahon fever dream brought to life, SummerSlam's chaotic fatal four-way main event was f**king great fun. Brock Lesnar, Braun Strowman, Roman Reigns and Samoa Joe all beat the absolute sh*t out of each other in a nonstop action movie of a match that holds up to multiple rewatches. Cesaro ripping a beach ball in half mid way through The Bar's Tag Team Title match with Dean Ambrose and Seth Rollins stole the headlines, but the match would have stolen the entire night had it not been for their SmackDown Live! compatriots on the pre-show. The Usos/New Day clash was the best of their epic series and the best WWE tag team match of 2017.
The Bad: Bray Wyatt's provided the sauce for his own sh*t sandwich when he tipped it on Finn's head just before their SummerSlam showdown. He triggered 'The Demon', got 'The Demon', and lost to 'The Demon'. What a berk. An unnecessarily lengthy pre-show resulted in The Hardy Boy, Jason Jordan, The Miz and The Miztourage all working in front of an almost empty arena. They all deserved a better night than that.
The Ugly: The continued on-screen punishment of Enzo Amore scoured new depths by raising him to uncomfortable new heights. Acrophobic Enzo was plonked in a shark cage for the closest view of one of the year's worst matches as Big Cass lumbered home against The Big Show. Elsewhere, John Cena's treatment of Baron Corbin was abhorrent. It's been some time since 'The Champ' sh*t so joyously on a midcarder's hopes and dreams that this return to old habits represented a jaggedly unwelcome surprise.
8. Fastlane
The Good: Neville's Cruiserweight Title defence against Jack Gallagher was the match of the night by a country mile, and retained the faint hope the 'King Of The Cruiserweights' had fostered that there might be life in 205 Live yet. Neville's forced return to using the Red Arrow to defeat the challenger was a sensational moment for anybody closely following his refined style at the time. Roman Reigns' selection as the man to hand Braun Strowman his first loss was typically divisive, but their match was typically sensational.
The Bad: Goldberg's predictable 20-second Universal Title win over Kevin Owens felt like an unfair way to dethrone the hard-working champion, even if it played into his epic rivalry with Chris Jericho. Samoa Joe took nearly ten minutes to defeat Sami Zayn in his WWE pay-per-view debut, despite the match itself never looking remotely competitive. A reminder of their gripping NXT feud, this was not.
The Ugly: Foreshadowing some dark times ahead for the Raw Women's Division, both singles matches on the card were hugely problematic. Sasha Banks' fluke win over Nia Jax favoured neither, with Jax in particular failing to inspire the fire required to deliver such a ragdolling to 'The Boss'. Elsewhere, Bayley's second less-than-clean victory over Charlotte Flair further dampened enthusiasm for her first (and only) Women's Title reign. Putting a bullet in Flair's pay-per-view undefeated streak a month before WrestleMania was then as it still is now, inexplicable.
7. Survivor Series
The Good: The star power in the main event was legitimately exciting as a spectacle...before the bell rang. Fortunately, the company had already delivered another match of the year contender just minutes earlier. Brock Lesnar Vs AJ Styles represented a total reinvention for 'The Beast' as a monster that actually had to work at flattening his foe for a change. 'The Phenomenal One' was at his peerless best in this one. Intra-brand Champion clashes between The Usos and The Bar and Charlotte and Alexa Bliss were very enjoyable indeed, and a subtle reminder of how beneficial the brand extension can be when the roster rules are actually adhered to.
The Bad: Whilst not actively awful, The Shield and The New Day's show-opener may have been somewhat overwhelmed by the expectations placed upon it. The trios were outworked by their respective brand opponents later in the show, and the contest lacked a spark most assumed would be in-built. Baron Corbin's match with The Miz was desperately dull, but had little chance of being much else.
The Ugly: The Raw Vs SmackDown Live! main event was one of the most diabolically-booked outings in recent memory. Protecting all the wrong people at the expense of those that desperately need propping up in a star-laden environment, the egos of Shane McMahon, John Cena and particularly Triple H were prioritised in the place of anything else. Braun Strowman himself seemingly only survived to set up a programme down the line with 'The Game'.
6. Great Balls Of Fire
The Good: Samoa Joe's pre-bell beatdown of Brock Lesnar babyfaced 'The Beast' in an innovative manner, despite the match itself ultimately following the same pattern as most of Universal Champion's traditional squashes. Alexa Bliss and Sasha Banks had a fabulous brawl over the Women's Championship in a much-needed refresher for the division. The 30-minute iron man match that concluded The Hardy Boyz' feud with Sheamus and Cesaro was one of the year's under-appreciated triumphs.
The Bad: Big Cass inadvertently made himself look a Big *ss when he covered the letter C in his name on the TitanTron. His pathetic match with Enzo Amore made them both look like sh*t. Having feuded for much of 2017 on both brands, The Miz and Dean Ambrose had ran out of steam long before a tepid decider conclusively awarded the spoils to 'The A-Lister'.
The Ugly: Roman Reigns and Braun Strowman were largely incapable of having crap contests with one another in 2017, but the farcical aftermath of their Ambulance Match was the sort of tripe that already seems of another world just six months removed. Having lost the match, 'The Big Dog' burst out of the ambulance almost immediately as if to render the result moot. Everybody then put on their 'Owen Hart' voices as Roman "went too far" by trapping 'The Monster Among Men' in the vehicle and reversing it into a stationery production truck. Attempted murder charges are still to follow, presumably.
5. Hell In A Cell
The Good: The quality main event between Shane McMahon and Kevin Owens almost justified the months of matches between 'KO' and AJ Styles it inadvertently sabotaged. Their brawl atop the structure had to be watched through fingers, whilst the big bumps and twist ending had far more context than the usual Shane stuntfest. It differed enough too from the red hot opener between The Usos and The New Day. A final battle for the time being at least, the teams assembled another bonafide classic, typically rich in inventiveness and innovation.
The Bad: For the second time in a year, Dolph Ziggler failed to help kickstart an NXT graduate's WWE pay-per-view career. His match with Bobby Roode was boring, as matchmakers seemingly knew it would be - the pair were lumbered between the WWE Title match and the Hell In A Cell main event. Natalya and Charlotte shouldn't have taken anywhere near 12 minutes to arrive at their cheap count-out finish.
The Ugly: Jinder Mahal's pathetic encounter with Shinsuke Nakamura had most condemning 'The King Of Strong Style's entire WWE career as a profound failure. Incapable of working up to his opponent's standard nor raising his own game to meet a foe in need, Mahal was worthless in the spot he'd been unjustifiably gifted. This result was widely predicted yet still somehow completely infuriating.
4. Money In The Bank
The Good: AJ Styles and Shinsuke Nakamura's brief face-off during the eponymous ladder match drew electrifying cheers as the two genuinely looked and felt like real-life video game characters set to do battle. The company smartly left plenty behind for another day though, breaking things up quickly in order to get back to Baron Corbin's big win. The New Day and The Usos had a great 12:00 match that would in hindsight serve as a curtain-raiser for one of the best feuds of the year. Ordinarily preserved as dark match performers on Tuesdays to keep butts in seats for 205 Live tapings, it was a pleasure to see Breezango bask in their newfound support as wrestlers following a streak of side-splitting vignettes.
The Bad: Lana always looks to be trying her very best, but she'll never be as competent between the ropes as she is on a microphone. Her title shot against Naomi was laughably poor, especially by the raised standards and stakes of today. Jinder Mahal's title defence against Randy Orton was brutally boring because of course it was.
The Ugly: Lost to the booking, the first ever Women's Money In The Bank Ladder Match will only ever be remembered for James Ellsworth dropping the case down to Carmella. It mattered not what WWE were aiming to achieve from the stunt, nor how good the televised rematch was a fortnight later - the history-making moment deserved less controversy and contrivance than it received.
3. Elimination Chamber
The Good: The Chamber itself was fabulously redesigned in a way that protected the talent and made for a substantially more satisfying viewing experience. Bray Wyatt's 2017 was a complete disaster save for one tiny moment of glory experienced here where it looked for a split second like his maiden WWE Title win could salvage years of horrendous booking and lethargic character work. Nikki Bella and Natalya's feud was a Tuesday Night highlight between 2016 and early-2017. Their bombastic brawl complemented the hard-hitting rivalry that came before it.
The Bad: From planning through to execution, everything was wrong with the handicap match pitting babyfaces Kalisto and Apollo Crews against newly-minted heel Dolph Ziggler. 'The Show Off' soaked up sardonic cheers from the crowd as a preposterously positioned underdog destined for defeat. Even the winners looked like losers.
The Ugly: A rotten night at the commentary desk foreshadowed some pretty major upheaval soon to occur on blue brand broadcasts. Mauro Ranallo had a bad night, persistently referring to the main event cage as 'Hell In A Cell' and earning hefty abuse from JBL in the process. David Otunga gave as good as he got, mocking the Texan for slipping when he'd made his entrance earlier in the night but neglecting most of the action throughout the night as a result. By September 2017, all three were removed from main roster announce duties, with JBL exiting the company outright amidst a slew of fresh bullying allegations.
2. Royal Rumble
The Good: WWE at long last figured a way out of the Royal Rumble curse - booking Roman Reigns as an out-and-out heel. As the unannounced #30 entrant, his p*ssed off tear through the knackered field was a highlight of the battle royal, particularly when he callously dumped sentimental favourites The Undertaker and Chris Jericho. That the match wasn't a complete and utter disaster alone was a huge step back in the right direction for the gimmick. John Cena's WWE Title win over AJ Styles has already aged badly against competition elsewhere in 2017 alone, but was still an outstanding feat by any regular standards. Neville defeating Rich Swann for the Cruiserweight Title foreshadowed a run of incredible - yet utterly meaningless - outings for the Geordie.
The Bad: Kofi Kingston's contrived comedy was a literally too close to the bone - he absolutely pulverised his own ribcage on the LED post dodging a Baron Corbin leg sweep. Chris Jericho did little of note as WWE again failed to actually think about how the year's 'Iron Man' would spend 60+ minutes in the Battle Royal. He was used far more effectively from the confines of a shark cage during Kevin Owens' Universal Title match against Roman Reigns.
The Ugly: The Club dethroned Sheamus and Cesaro on the lifeless pre-show. It foreshadowed the torrid year Gallows and Anderson would have, and recklessly misused the future 'Bar' having deigned them worthy of breaking The New Day's 483-day reign just a month earlier.
1. Tables, Ladders & Chairs
The Good: Kurt Angle finding Intensity to match his Intelligence and Integrity for the first time since returning to WWE was spine-tingling. Captured beautifully by the cameras, he was presumably asked to act as if he was shooting laser-beams from his eyeballs, because it felt like ones were striking you in the heart on the other side of the screen. Absolutely blasting Cesaro through a table then dramatically kicking out of the Skull Crushing Finale was an iconic conclusion to his - and The Shield's - pay-per-view return. Elsewhere, selecting AJ Styles from an entire roster as a last minute opponent for Finn Bálor was an inspired decision. Loaded with drama, intrigue and enough nudges and winks to leave you bruised and bemused, it restored Finn's wounded superstar aura in one night. There's no such thing as 'too' sweet.
The Bad: Enzo Amore defeating Kalisto for the Cruiserweight Title was the right call creatively, but their match was predictably the pits. As too was a limp showdown between Alexa Bliss and Mickie James. The Champion spent weeks deriding James for being too old to cut it at just 38, then was booked as being correct all along.
The Ugly: Very little, though in the alternate universe where Sister Abigail actually debuts, this is probably the worst show of all time. Back in this timeline, it just could have done without Jason Jordan lobbing vegetables at Elias.