Ranking Every 2019 WWE PPV From Worst To Best

The Best In The World At What They Do (...most of the time)

The Undertaker
WWE

A quick set of caveats before we get to the meat of what used to be WWE's main revenue stream, and - confusingly - is still booked as such. Television are currently where the billions can be found, but it hasn't (yet) changed the company's approach to the big monthly special.

"Pay-per-view" in this context at least, will exclude:

- Abbreviated Network-only specials. Your (sigh) Starrcades and your (hard sigh) Shield's Final Chapters and your (hardest f*cking sigh of the year) SmackVille were house shows with cameras rolling for small portions and can't be fairly graded amongst the usuals.

- Anything NXT, discounting their Survivor Series involvement. In TakeOver, NXT has established the most consistent and beloved regular brand of anything in North American wrestling, to the point where even August's deeply disappointing Toronto edition would still breeze past over half of WWE's annual offering. The similarly well-recieved NXT UK TakeOvers also won't feature here.

- Saudi Arab-nah, just kidding. WWE, in spite of what might appear to be better judgement, deeply embed these events within the fabric of their regular weekly and monthly offerings. They're getting judged like every other show, and predictably, one of them is the only place to start this year's particular list...

14. Super ShowDown

WWE Super Showdown 2019 Battle Royal
WWE.com

The Good: 'Money' in name and nature, Shane McMahon remains the clown prince of these f*cking things. His victory (!) over Roman Reigns set up their feud decider a few months later, and though he dominated too much of their 9:15 encounter, he brought a certain charm when working at his most cowardly.

The Bad: A 51-man Battle Royal was another gift to local hero Mansoor but sucked otherwise. Randy Orton and Triple H insultingly went 25 minutes when that wasn't even welcome a decade ago, whilst Finn Bálor's least effective Demon match with Andrade served as a genuine disappointment considering what could have been.

The Ugly: Eeesh, the ugliest, perhaps. The poster of Undertaker's match with Goldberg reeked of the Saudi wealth that drew them there before the real thing stunk up the joint even worse. A concussed and exhausted Goldberg and a stressed and sweating 'Deadman' botched their big moves, including Tombstones and Jackhammers so dangerous-looking it was as though they were receipts for one another. Undertaker took home all the tragic awards in 2018 for the moment he couldn't summon the breath to move the hair from his face during a Saudi superclash with D-Generation X. This catastrophe represented his real rock bottom.


13. Hell In A Cell

Seth Rollins Bray Wyatt
WWE.com

The Good: Becky Lynch and Sasha Banks had an absolute ripper of an opener inside Hell In A Cell for 'The Man's Raw Women's Champion. Banks bettered her performance from her last Cell clash with Charlotte Flair, whilst Lynch at long last got the gritty, believably violent title defence she'd been trying to muster since WrestleMania.

The Bad: Charlotte Flair's victory over Bayley triggered the latter's image-altering heel turn, but the match was one of their worst together. Chad Gable was "Chad" for the last time, and had his victory over Baron Corbin nullified by a brutal backstage assault. Whatever fire Ali had left was doused by a routine defeat to Randy Orton.

The Ugly: In only the second match for the character, The Fiend was mishandled and abused beyond all comprehension because the company didn't have the guts to put the Universal Title straight on him or have Seth Rollins somehow defeat him. A chronically awful match saw Rollins booed mercilessly by a crowd that could barely even see all the action because of a debuting stupid red spotlight. The second Hell In A Cell non-finish in as many years was the worst case scenario and a fatalistic bottle job by the company. Already on the ropes, Seth's babyface persona was blown to pieces by it. So soon into an intriguing repackaging, Bray Wyatt lost invaluable support too.


12. Stomping Grounds

WWE Stomping Grounds Seth Rollins Baron Corbin
WWE.com

The Good: Long-forgotten by the end of a troubling show, Ricochet's United States Championship win looked to be the start of something major for 'The One & Only'. Daniel Bryan and Rowan assembled a surprise triumph against Heavy Machinery that played into the limited strengths of the popular babyfaces. Removed from the WWE Title picture, Bryan had lost none of his early-year spark in a doubles role.

The Bad: Bayley and her fans had waited two years for a sense of redemption against Alexa Bliss, but it wasn't to be found in a dry and dull time-filler on this show. Tacoma (the town that infamously hosted the WCW Raw Booker T/Buff Bagwell main event in 2001) weren't buying what Stomping Grounds was selling. The event was almost entirely three-sided in the venue and shot as such to protect blushes.

The Ugly: Kofi Kingston and Dolph Ziggler had a steel cage match that could be classified as offensively boring, so much so that it knocked any remaining bloom clean off the Kofi rose. A passable opener between Becky Lynch and Lacey Evans was downgraded by their joint involvement in a woeful main event between Seth Rollins and Baron Corbin. It was all to set up a month mixed tag cr*p between the four that mostly sucked too.


11. TLC: Tables, Ladders & Chairs

bray wyatt the miz
WWE.com

The Good: Buddy Murphy and Aleister Black made the most of a rare opportunity to shut up and wrestle, easily stealing the main portion of the pay-per-view without the help of any of the titular weapons and props. Some of the work in a New Day/Revival ladder match was outstanding, even if the rank meaningless of it all put a damper on the devilish bumps.

The Bad: The Kabuki Warriors' main event Tag Title victory over Becky Lynch and Charlotte Flair was marred by an injury to Kairi Sane which itself appeared to marr several of the planned spots. The contest felt clunky and disjointed in spite of its moving parts on a show that needed a banger of a main event to transform an otherwise-ungainly evening.

The Ugly: Bray Wyatt and The Miz went six minutes in a confused calamity of a half-baked idea poorly fleshed out that played to silence. Immediately following that, Rusev lost in a revenge mission match against Bobby Lashley. Falling at first hurdles is death for a babyface, as WWE have persistently found at their peril with 'The Bulgarian Brute'. The Raw Tag Team Title match being reduced to a KFC advert wasn't the crime of the century, but it robbed a show in desperate need of a great match of something that might have approached it.


10. Clash Of Champions

Braun Strowman Seth Rollins
WWE.com

The Good: "Good" was sort of the problem here, as much of the card found itself made up of those types of matches impossible to be thrilled by despite how functional they may have been. Becky Lynch and Sasha Banks turned the volume up in their brawl, but an inconclusive finish soured the hard work up to that point. AJ Styles and Cedric Alexander bordered on great, whilst the angle between Braun Strowman and Seth Rollins made for some intrigue ahead of the main event. Rollins - in spite of a dying push - always shines when he works double duty.

The Bad: Bayley's quickie win over Charlotte Flair was unconvincing and misjudged. Hindsight reflects it as a false start for her heel turn, but it was simply closer to WWE 2019 trolling at the time. Harper returning for one last short run alongside Rowan was well-shot, but not enough to carry a middling battle with Roman Reigns over the line.

The Ugly: Kofi Kingston's WWE Championship run didn't deserve to end the way it did, but it didn't argue for itself at any point either. A second scrap with Randy Orton here was the inarguable nadir - these were the ones that were supposed to find some excitement where there'd been none. They failed twice to generate a reaction outside of their finisher exchanges.


9. Crown Jewel

Braun Strowman Tyson Fury
WWE.com

The Good: Cesaro pulled off the carry-job of the year for Saudi star Mansoor as his on-these-shows-only push continued. Ignoring the reasons behind why their match was so problematically historic, it was clear to see how impacted Lacey Evans and Natalya were by becoming the first two to wrestle there. Girls and women in the crowd seemed earnestly moved too, not least because this appeared the most fan-heavy attendance thus far. Monied punters - if there were any there - were shunted out of sight. Team Hogan Vs Team Flair was a riot of a good guys/bad guys 10-man tag and deserved a spot on an entirely different pay-per-view.

The Bad: Brock Lesnar Vs Cain Velasquez and Braun Strowman Vs Tyson Fury were used in place of weird returning legends, but both were equally unsuccessful. One sucked because it was too short, the other blew because it was too long.

The Ugly: The Fiend and Seth Rollins sucked all over again, and even though the result was right, the drab spots only brought into focus that all of this is still as ethically ugly as one of those red lights looks.


8. Money In The Bank

Lesnar Money in the Bank
WWE.com

The Good: Seth Rollins Vs AJ Styles was a total banger. Though they're both beloved, they're often short a present-day WWE ripper to argue the toss for themselves. this was decisively it. Bayley's unexpected Money In The Bank win and SmackDown Women's Championship cash-in later that night went down a storm with her browbeaten fanbase after partner Sasha Banks' real life post-WrestleMania exit. It was a relatively elegant way of getting one of the belts back from Becky Lynch too - she was made to work twice and cheated out the blue brand's belt thanks to interference from the already-beaten Lacey Evans.

The Bad: Kofi Kingston's semi-main event against Kevin Owens was a huge letdown after a big post-WrestleMania angle between the two. Tony Nese's Cruiserweight Championship defence against Ariya Daivari was the first to get pay-per-view backing of this nature in an age. The pair threw it away, assembling a totally forgettable tussle despite the extra eyes.

The Ugly: Brock Lesnar's end-of-the-match insertion into the men's Money In The Bank encountered bordered on the intolerably gross for some, but the truth behind it was duller. WWE didn't have star heels for Seth Rollins to beat, so they went to the last programme they'd tried that had worked and just rehashed it over the summer.


7. Fastlane

WWE Fastlane 2019 The Shield
WWE.com

The Good: Fastlane's main event was one of the best examples of one of WWE's best modern tropes. The company have become deft with a multi-man match over the last decade, and fewer acts have benefitted from this as much as The Shield. The group's last major pay-per-view stand before Dean Ambrose's April exit, this thrilling and emotional war against proper heel d*ckeheads Baron Corbin, Bobby Lashley and Drew McIntyre was one of the most satisfying and cathartic contests of the year. There's been lots of silly sh*t in the 2010s, but it's always been easy to Believe In The Shield. Elsewhere, some wicked tags and triple threats matches shored up the undercard and Shane McMahon's heel turn on The Miz went down a treat.

The Bad: Becky Lynch was gifted back her spot n the WrestleMania main event thanks to a Ronda Rousey run-in during her all-or-nothing match with Charlotte. This was meddling in the extreme, and not entirely different to the issues being experienced over on SmackDown.

The Ugly: The Bar Vs Kofi Kingston was an infuriating bore. A naked and uncreative delaying tactic for Kofi Kingston's WrestleMania push having rejigged his spot with Kevin Owens', the company took his white hot built and almost extinguished in crushing fashion.


6. Elimination Chamber

Elimination Chamber 2019
WWE.com

The Good: The closing stretch of the eponymous headliner topped Daniel Bryan's previous best-of-all-time Chamber finale against Santino Marella. Bryan and Kofi Kingston engaged in a 12-minute one-on-one thriller after already enduring nearly 25 of them in the main Chamber clash itself. Going up the gears, the two chased and captured the heat around Kofi's unlikely victory with magnificent ease - a Trouble In Paradise counter highlighted the gripping final third. The structure played host to tear-soaked history elsewhere on the show - Sasha Banks and Bayley's capturing of the brand new Women's Tag Team Championships felt as satisfying to watch and it clearly felt to be living through. They looked joyous at the prospect of a long maiden run. But more on that later.

The Bad: Limping Becky Lynch was becoming a bit of an irritant around this point as WWE tried desperately to make it seem as if anybody but her stood a chance at WrestleMania, but a heated standoff with both Ronda Rousey and Charlotte Flair dragged something from Rousey's humbling squash victory over Ruby Riott at least.

The Ugly: Baron Corbin had been called worse than sh*t for being ratings poison just months earlier, but intentions were far clearer in the booking than the promos - the 'Lone Wolf' was getting his push. Leading Bobby Lashley and Drew McIntyre in a three-on-one beardown of Braun Strowman, the future king actually got to win his programme over the 'Monster Among Men' despite being a disposable d*ckhead the whole time.


5. Survivor Series

Roman Reigns Keith Lee
WWE.com

The Good: The last of 2019's Big Four creeps into the top five thanks to a blistering five-on-five-on-five men's main event between the hosses and bosses of Raw, SmackDown and NXT. Keith Lee was made in action against Roman Reigns and Seth Rollins, whilst earnest in-ring work between the different components genuinely inspired some of that oh-so-silly brand loyalty that always gets trotted out at the same time of year. Title defences from Adam Cole and Brock Lesnar against Pete Dunne and Rey Mysterio respectively were both wildly enjoyable in their own ways.

The Bad: The Raw Vs SmackDown Vs NXT women's match couldn't touch the male equivalent for quality and was let down by a big mid-match angle that failed to satisfy much of the crowd.

The Ugly: The Women's Champion triple threat main event was dull on its own terms but disastrous from a wider perspective. It undermined the cause of women headlining shows to d*ckheads that think they shouldn't by being too boring to function as one.


4. Royal Rumble

Ronda Rousey Sasha Banks Royal Rumble 2019
WWE.com

The Good: Virtually the whole card. Ronda Rousey had yet another banger, giving Sasha Banks her best singles match in forever. Brock Lesnar and Finn Bálor had another 'Beast Vs Little Guy' firecracker, Asuka's opening victory over Becky Lynch was bravely booked under challenging circumstances and Seth Rollins Royal Rumble win was the right result in a better-than-average battle royal. The baseball ground setting looked magnificent too.

The Bad: The women's Royal Rumble match ran too long, had a few too many botches and made an unnecessary meal of Becky Lynch's eventual victory. The result did much to mask the reality of its failings at the time, but it doesn't hold up to scrutiny on rewatch.

The Ugly: AJ Styles and Daniel Bryan got their match all wrong. Technical to a fault and unable to follow the aforementioned excitement for Becky Lynch, this lacked everything the crowd were looking for and thus had to objectively be judged as an outlying dud for the pair of them.


3. WrestleMania 35

20190405 WM35 Show Kofi  B27677f7fb8245447fb2a9673879be5a
WWE

The Good: The best of its kind so far, WrestleMania 35 was still ungodly in length but delivered legitimate history twice and three babyface outcomes in its blockbuster Championship encounters. What Becky Lynch, Ronda Rousey and Charlotte Flair lacked in in-ring fluidity they made up for in star power, whilst Seth Rollins and Kofi Kingston's snagging of Brock Lesnar and Daniel Bryan's Championships were wildly different but no less absolutely thrilling. Kingston's moment transcended even that - a beautiful celebration, it moved many to tears and with good, organic reason.

The Bad: It was still long as f*ck, and thus not immune to drag. Roman Reigns took 10 minutes to defeat Drew McIntyre when five would have done, Shane McMahon and The Miz shouldn't have gone 15 just to get to their one big stunt, whilst AJ Styles and Randy Orton shouldn't have gone 16 to lead to even less.

The Ugly: Batista and Triple H's ponderous brawl didn't really support the story they'd crafted beforehand, nor the chances of keeping the crowd awake. Two or three token spots generated pops, but the rest was indulgent fluff for two men having the match for them more than thr 82,000+ in attendance. Though the match itself was fine, the choice to have The IIconics become Women's Tag Team Champions nearly did irreparable harm to the titles and the women's roster. Billie Kay and Peyton Royce were comedy wrestlers rather than the fighting titleholders originally pitched, whilst Banks herself took months away from WWE just to try and reconnect to it.


2. SummerSlam

The Fiend Finn Ba Lor
WWE.com

The Good: An amazing Fiend debut stole the show and the headlines thanks to Finn Bálor's gracious put-over and the company's sensational production bringing this terrifying manifestation to life. It wouldn't last, sadly. Trish Stratus bid WWE a tearful farewell after a fantastic retirement battle with Charlotte Flair, whilst Seth Rollins finally appeared to smash his pre-Summer blues with yet another emphatic and gutsy victory over Brock Lesnar. A Goldberg/Dolph Ziggler squash was inch-perfect too, whilst Kevin Owens' win over Shane McMahon was so strong that it should have been the end of their series.

The Bad: AJ Styles and Ricochet somehow both looked ordinary in a match that should have allowed them to express themselves in a more satisfying manner. Working WWE's house style instead of their own, the contest struggled to come alive despite the obvious grace and ability of the pair.

The Ugly: Kofi Kingston's draw with Randy Orton was a bit of a disaster, in truth. Failing to entertain was trouble for the wrestlers, but failing to deliver a winner was the main issue for fans in the arena and watching at home.


1. Extreme Rules

The Undertaker Roman Reigns Shane McMahon Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

The Good: 'The Graveyard Dogs' pairing of Roman Reigns and The Undertaker contested one of the best main roster matches of the year against Shane McMahon and Drew McIntyre. A No Holds Barred Sports Entertainment spectacle for the ages, it took every shortcut but did so at 100mph, resulting in a showcase so thrilling that it rehabilitated The Undertaker's legacy after several wonky years. Seth Rollins and Becky Lynch were at long last good together - their tag main event against Baron Corbin and Lacey Evans was the best moment from an otherwise-tepid feud. AJ Styles and Ricochet had the best match of their own mini-run, a Kevin Owens squash win over Dolph Ziggler was morbidly hilarious, whilst The New Day's Triple Threat Tag Team Championship win over Daniel Bryan/Rowan and Heavy Machinery was a flashback to the SmackDown doubles division operating at its 2017 peak. As was a Revival/Usos scorcher that had the task of following the aforementioned Undertaker opener.

The Bad: Kofi Kingston had another disappointing WWE Championship match, but his battle with Samoa Joe was at least functional, even if it proved to be one of the only drab things on the whole show.

The Ugly: A mini-arc to reset for SummerSlam had started at Money In The Bank when Brock Lesnar won the briefcase, and his inevitable cash-in here still made for a tough watch.


In this post: 
Undertaker
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.