Ranking Every AEW Championship Reign Of 2023
Grading the best and the most blah of AEW's many title reigns this past year.
AEW's statement of intent seems to be "a little bit of everything, for everyone".
No matter what you like about wrestling, you should be able to find something across their programming that appeals to your tastes. In 2023 fans have witnessed brutal hoss fights, insane death matches, deeply exciting tag team wrestling and long-term character-driven storylines.
The only problem with such variation is a potentially missable mark for quality and simple consistency. This extends to their championship cabinet, too.
It's tough to imagine a successful pro wrestling company without championships because they give something to frame the entire show around. Wrestlers want to prove they're the best by toppling those at the top and taking their gold. In AEW's case, you can try and fail, and then move onto a different belt quite happily because the company seems to reveal a new one every four weeks.
Several titles in AEW are forgettable in and of themselves, let alone some of the champions that have held them. There are also, by comparison, several examples of belts that are debatably some of the most respected titles in American wrestling and reigns that will be etched into history.
26. Wardlow - AEW TNT Championship
Not to put the cart before the horse, but Orange Cassidy's International title reign is going to be pretty close to the top of this list. It's worth mentioning now just for the benefit of this incredible stat:
During Cassidy's first reign with that title, Wardlow lost the TNT Championship three times.
This particular instance is the second. Wardlow beat Samoa Joe for the title at Revolution and then dropped it to Powerhouse Hobbs 3 days later. If you thought AEW didn't do what WWE was so guilty of during the 2010s, proceedings must be kicked off with the most blatant use of a transitional champion ever.
25. Rey Fenix & Jon Moxley - AEW International Championship
This low ranking is a total victim of circumstance. And, with 37 days between them, these unfortunate champs may as well be paired together.
Moxley's reign-ending victory over Cassidy was all part of a longer play to set the two up for a clash at Full Gear a few months later. However, during the AEW Grand Slam International title defence against challenger Rey Fenix, Mox sustained a concussion and called an audible. Fenix securing his first solo title win in AEW could've been exciting if the finish wasn't confusing and, as good ol' JR would put it, "bowling shoe ugly".
But unknown to Moxley and his quick-thinking in the face of his injury, Fenix was also banged up. As such, the refreshing potential of a cruiserweight with the title was squashed by elements out of AEW's control. Fenix dropped the belt 20 days later to Cassidy so that, by the time Moxley was ready, the match would still go ahead just with a different man coming in as champion.
24. Darby Allin - AEW TNT Championship
There's nothing inherently wrong with moving a title around a lot, especially if it's being defended frequently (which is largely the point of the AEW's equivalent to WCW's TV title), but the key is interesting booking.
The TNT championship was passed around so much in 2023, and typically between the same group of guys. For example, Samoa Joe lost the belt to Darby Allin in January, but got it back less than a month later. There's a lot of "what was the point of that" to be asked about the TNT title this year, but this was perhaps the most glaring.
Darby and the TNT belt go together great but, in retrospect, it was a needless diversion from Joe's reign, which would wind up being short-lived itself as it was.
23. Wardlow - AEW TNT Championship
When looking at up-and-coming stars fumbled to painful degrees in 2023, Wardlow is in the running for the top-spot. Not that he couldn't heat back up - the guy is great fun to watch - but his booking has been such a shambles that it feels like a tough ask.
His third TNT Championship win occurred in April, reclaiming the belt from Powerhouse Hobbes after losing it previously in March. By this point, the title felt absolutely pointless as it was and so too did putting it back on a star that - once considered a future major player of the company - needed something fresh after floundering for so long.
Two months and three defences later, the belt was on the move again, and it felt like AEW had completely given up on what remained of the Wardlow push.
22. Julia Hart - AEW TBS Championship & Toni Storm - AEW World Women's Championship
For the sake of expediency, these two can easily be packaged together.
They're both titles that, at the time of writing, just changed at hands and so the reigns haven't even started. They're also held by two great women who have really come into their own recently. Julia Hart could easily be described as one of AEW's most improved performers in 2023. Toni Storm's "Timeless" gimmick is massively over.
In short, putting the belt on the hottest act is always a good move, and both decisions make absolute sense. Let's just hope there's some longevity to both.
21. Death Triangle - AEW World Trios Championship
Again, this is another ranking that is low purely down to the fact that Death Triangle dropped the titles just 11 days into the year.
In what is becoming more obvious was quite a cursed period for AEW in 2022 and 2023, the Trios Championship were basically invented to be put around the waists of The Elite. However, this was done at All Out, the show where the EVPs were all temporarily suspended following backstage drama. As such, these new belts were already off to a bad start. Thankfully, Death Triangle's 127-day run was quite an exciting one.
And, as far as at least spectacles go, the Best of Seven Series with the Elite felt like a big deal by the time it wrapped up in January 2023.
20. Hikaru Shida - AEW World Women's Championship
Hikaru Shida brings a certain prestige to the AEW Women's World Championship, as well as international flair. Her second title win felt like a big deal because many fans remembered her 372-day prior run, and it was a wonderful moment to reward her by having her win it in front of a crowd when she had previously held it through the company's empty arena days in 2020.
However, eyes narrowed with suspicion as Shida's second title win felt a little bit insincere. She captured the gold on Dynamite's 200th episode, perhaps just a way to make the card a bit more memorable, and it seemed as though she was being set up to drop it again a few weeks later when the company flew to England.
Of course, all of this proved to be true. It was great that she was able to perform at Wembley Stadium, but the belt moving around felt so needlessly arbitrary.
19. Saraya - AEW Women's World Championship
This entry is sure to get some flack. Saraya coming back to wrestling after a devastating early retirement and winning a championship in her home country is certainly a feel-good moment - but it just continued to harm the already reduced prestige of the women's title.
AEW have been under constant (deserved) criticism for their inability to build many interesting women's storylines, with the best they've got largely just centring around "I want the belt". This is all well and good, but the women's championship means very little as it stands, as it's been passed around far too much this year. Putting it on the local hero for a cheap pop is just another example of doing the bare minimum...and even then it didn't make sense.
Saraya was a heel and the Outcasts stable wasn't over one way or the other by this point. The pop was nice but it felt like an empty platitude when they needed to instead fix their systemic issues with booking their women's division.
18. Hikaru Shida - AEW World Women's Championship
Hikaru Shida winning the Women's title a third time! On a special episode of Dynamite! This is feeling awfully familiar...
Shida getting the belt back from Saraya on Title Tuesday felt like a moment of potential course-correction after the belt was used to get a pop at All In. Finally, the longest reigning AEW Women's champion might get a proper follow-up run with the belt. Unfortunately, that's not really what happened.
Shida defended the title three times across an eight-day period and then proceeded to lose the belt to Toni Storm, who had captured the fans with her "timeless" meltdown gimmick. On the one hand, it allowed Shida to set a record as the first woman to hold the gold three times. On the other, it's took yet more shine off the championship she once held dominion over for more than a year.
17. Orange Cassidy - AEW International Championship
As previously stated, the International Championship has had a cursed few months near the end of 2023. Putting the belt back on its most faithful champion in Orange Cassidy at least made sense. With OC besting his biggest challenge in Jon Moxley at Full Gear though, the question now is what next?
Does Cassidy continue to dominate the mid-card by defending the title every week? Does he enter another major feud with the belt as a centerpiece? Or is it perhaps time for him to move onto something else entirely? The main event scene is not really in a place that has space for OC, considering it's already occupied by MJF, Cole, Samoa Joe, Roddy Strong and the mystery Devil storyline, but how long before he feels much bigger than the spot he's in?
There's a lot of intrigue regarding the future of the International Championship, and the chance to really put someone over when Cassidy drops it for the second - and a perhaps more defintive - time.