Ranking Every AEW Wrestler's 2019 From Worst To Best
From Le Champion to the Librarians...
AEW haven't even put their name to 30 different shows yet, but the promotion has already demonstrated an aptitude for getting the most out of many performers at once.
The roster isn't perfect, and AEW already have a handful of rebuilding jobs on their hand, though it's hard to be too cynical at this early stage. The promotion are in the process of building a tiered roster with a clearly-defined hierarchy. That's very, very difficult to do with just two months of television, though those above this list's lower reaches are already in a great place.
Only wrestlers listed on AEW's official roster page were considered here, as incorporating freelancers, part-timers, and moonlighters like Aja Kong, Jamie Hayter, and T-Hawk would have made things messy. Tag teams were only taken as separate entities when necessary.
The factors determining these rankings included (but wasn't restricted to) quality of performances, overness, presentation, positioning, quality of pushes and programmes, and effectiveness as televised wrestlers and personalities. Remember that this is almost entirely subjective. There is no objective way to measure most of these factors, so your own list may be completely different. Please share it in the comments section below!
Let's get into it...
56. Leva Bates
The Librarian gimmick remains a misfire despite Leva Bates and Peter Avalon's repositioning as complete jobbers, and performances are what separates them.
The former Blue Pants looks in over her head in even the most rudimentary of squash matches. Though she isn't entirely without merit, Leva was hopeless in bouts with Allie and Nyla Rose, suggesting she may be better suited to a full-time managerial role going forward.
55. QT Marshall
It was hard to not get behind QT Marshall after his spot on Cody's From Undesirable to Undeniable series on Dark a few weeks ago, though the full-time producer/part-time wrestler rarely appears onscreen. His only bouts so far have been tag losses on Dark's fourth and Dynamite's fifth episodes. Neither brought enough ring time to fairly assess his credentials, though it's hard to imagine he'll ever be more than a moonlighting enhancement guy.
54. Peter Avalon
A better wrestler than partner Leva Bates, 'Pretty Peter' is a decent jobber with a slappable face and decent charisma, though the abysmal pre-match promos in which he rips basic town/sports team jokes from Heel Verbiage For Dummies need to go.
These things suck by design, but "deliberately bad" still means "bad."
53. Michael Nakazawa
AEW's resident oily boy has appeared as a background character in a couple of Kenny Omega segments so far, but wrestled only three singles matches.
Fyter Fest's fanny-on with the event's co-organiser, Alex Jebailey, was abysmal and his Dark defeat to Shawn Spears was entirely too long, though he was effective squash fodder for Jon Moxley a few weeks ago.
Nakazawa is a comedy goober. That's his role, but it means he can't really place higher than this.
52. Penelope Ford
A talented athlete with plenty to offer AEW going forward, what holds Ford back is that the promotion hasn't done a whole lot with her since signing. She'd likely still be serving as Joey Janela's valet had their real-life relationship not ended and though her new alliance with Kip Sabian looks promising, we've seen next to nothing from it so far, with only a single promo on record.
51. Brandi Rhodes
A very good/great manager but a subpar wrestler, Brandi hasn't competed since All Out's Buy In Casino Battle Royal. A smart move, as he skills are far better suited to a non-wrestling role, and her alliance with Awesome Kong could go places if AEW's Chief Brand Officer resists the urge to step through the ropes too often.
50. Angelico
The Hybrid 2's least exciting wrestler hasn't been bad... he just sort of exists. Jack Evans and his snotty personality have stood out a lot more, while Angelico treads water in a tandem hired to play jobbers to the stars.
A stronger push may never be forthcoming for these fellas. That's fine, but it hinders Angelico's position on lists like this.
49. Brandon Cutler
Brandon Cutler's is a hard-warming story, with The Young Bucks reaching out to gift their buddy the stability of two AEW contracts as the promotion was assembling its roster.
Regardless, Cutler is an enhancement talent. He has gone 0-4 in AEW so far, putting the likes of Joey Janela, MJF, and Shawn Spears over, and will likely keep treading this path going forward. Backstage duties aside, that's primarily what he's here for.
48. Allie
Few AEW wrestlers have performed before their skill level with such regularity as Allie, who has gone from a standout in Impact's Knockouts division to a struggler in her new home in under a year. Granted, she hasn't always faced elite competition, but it looks very much like the former Cherry Bomb has regressed as a wrestler.
Her repackaging as 'The Bunny' alongside newcomers The Butcher and The Blade offers hope, though. Let's hope she shines in that role.
47. Sadie Gibbs
An athletic standout full of potential, Sadie Gibbs still has a few rough edges to iron out, having wrestled only 49 matches (per Cagematch) in her young career so far.
This has been reflected in her AEW presentation. Gibbs has appeared only in tags and multi-person bouts, showing flashes of her athletic brilliance but little else. She needs the opportunity to show what she can do in a singles match.