Ranking Every Halloween Havoc From Worst To Best

Monster trucks, electric chairs, cages aplenty and...Yetis?

NXT Halloween Havoc
WWE.com

WWE have a lot to live up to at NXT: Halloween Havoc on 28 October.

Match quality is one thing, and that's almost automatic when it comes to NXT anyway, but Havoc always had this unique charm about it. Actual wrestling often took a backseat to WCW's lunacy - the sets, the gimmicks and the big names were typically more important than matches. Truthfully, that's why some of the pay-per-views were downright horrible.

The first two Halloween spectaculars were technically produced as NWA events in 1989 and 1990. Then, the WCW name took over and the promotion continued using Havoc as a tent pole occasion on its annual calendar. Eric Bischoff has even said before that the pay-per-view was a bigger deal to him personally than Starrcade, if only because it regularly took place in Las Vegas.

Why was the quality so erratic then? It was WCW for a start, but there was always an attempt to do something meaningful at Havoc that'd get wrestling fans talking. That, as you'll find out during this ranking, typically meant ridiculousness.

Time to revisit some old scares...


12. 2000

goldberg kronik
WWE.com

WCW was a total mess by October 2000, and there was no way the quick quarterly one-two punch of Halloween Havoc and Starrcade was going to change that. The company was on life support creatively, and that led to one of the worst cards you'll see.

The undercard was a jumbled mix of unwanted noise like Reno vs. Sgt. AWOL for the Hardcore Title, Buff Bagwell vs. David Flair in a 'First Blood DNA' own goal and Mike Sanders vs. Ernest Miller in a 'Kickboxing' exhibition.

Then, a Goldberg vs. Kronik handicap match nonsensically headlined the same show Booker T vs. Scott Steiner for the WCW Title was on. Never watch this unless you're a masochist.

Best Moment: N/A.

Worst Moment: The Goldberg vs. Kronik main event.


11. 1999

Sting WCW Halloween Havoc
WWE.com

1999 comes a close second to the worst Havoc.

Perhaps the only saving grace here is that DDP and Ric Flair tried their best to stir some emotion from a bored Las Vegas crowd by way of their 'Strap Match'. Elsewhere, there was more 'is he/isn't he' guff with Sting as a heel, and the WCW Title was made to look like the least important belt in all of wrestling yet again.

Nobody, including super workers like Chris Benoit and Eddie Guerrero, looked motivated to do anything other than phone their matches in. Apologists who say things like, '...at least it was better than the prior month's Fall Brawl' are either lying to themselves or are called Vince Russo.

Best Moment: N/A.

Worst Moment: Sting's continued heelish-ness.


10. 1995

Hulk Hogan The Giant Sumo
WWE Network

Havoc '95 had some buzz around it because of Nitro's recent launch and the arrival of Lex Luger. Typically though (this was WCW, remember?), Luger's first singles match on pay-per-view since returning to the company was a short loss to Randy Savage in a bout hardly anyone remembers.

There's almost nothing worth seeing here aside from Ric Flair teaming with Sting to take on Arn Anderson and Brian Pillman; Flair's turn, which everybody could see coming, was admittedly well-done and the match was solid. The less said about monster truck battles on top of the arena or The Giant falling from atop the building though, the better.

Peak mid-90s mediocrity right here.

Best Moment: Ric Flair turning on Sting.

Worst Moment: The monster truck battle and Giant's fall.


9. 1998

Hogan Warrior
WWE.com

Somehow, despite looking like a largely dreadful pay-per-view going in, Halloween Havoc 1998 had serious intrigue. Warrior and Hulk Hogan would be working together for the first time since WrestleMania VI eight years prior. Not only that, but Bret Hart vs. Sting, Kevin Nash vs. Scott Hall and Goldberg vs. DDP were also scheduled.

The latter match saved the entire show.

This might be higher on the list had WCW not conspired to screw everything up - many fans who'd bought the show on pay-per-view missed DDP vs. Goldberg when feeds went dark. Havoc '98 ran over its allotted time, because of course it did.

Best Moment: The main event (one most viewers missed).

Worst Moment: Hogan vs. Warrior II.


8. 1991

Chamber Of Horrors
WWE.com

In fairness, the sight of Abdullah The Butcher being kayfabe electrocuted at Halloween Havoc 1991 is no more or less ridiculous than some of the cinematic stuff WWE has been doing in 2020. Even so, it's pretty embarrassing to look back on now - that 'Chamber Of Horrors' is classic crap.

On the plus side, Steve Austin and Dustin Rhodes (who were both four-five years away from landing on successful gimmicks in the WWF) put on a cracker of TV Title match on the undercard. If that isn't enough to lure you in, then seeing big Abby fry might do the trick.

Or, if you're a Ron Simmons mark, then you might enjoy seeing him in the WCW Title frame too.

Best Moment: Steve Austin vs. Dustin Rhodes.

Worst Moment: The infamous 'Chamber Of Horrors' electrocution.


7. 1992

Sting Jake Roberts
WWE Network

A 'Coal Miner's Glove' match.

Of all the gimmick bouts WCW could've picked for Jake Roberts' company bow, they chose that one. He and Sting struggled mightily with the 'On-A-Pole' rubbish they'd been fed, and the Snake's debut felt like a complete letdown as a result.

If you must check out Havoc '92, then stop off at Ricky Steamboat vs. Brian Pillman to see some decent exchanges. Also, Barry Windham and Dustin Rhodes vs. Steve Austin and Steve Williams is worth watching if you don't mind the time limit gimmick.

Christ knows why The Barbarian was pushed as a viable challenger to Ron Simmons though.

Best Moment: Ricky Steamboat vs. Brian Pillman.

Worst Moment: The 'Coal Miner's Glove' gimmick.


6. 1989

WCW Halloween Havoc 1989 ThunderDome
WWE

Yes, the original 'ThunderDome'.

Halloween Havoc 1989 is where things start to pick up on this list. Doom vs. The Steiner Brothers was classic big dudes throwing one another around stuff, Brian Pillman did his best to pry a good match out of defending United States Champ (and all-round muscle head) Lex Luger, and the main event has gimmicky appeal.

It's definitely weird to see Bruno Sammartino guest-reffing a main event tag match inside a cage reminiscent of WWE's later Hell In A Cell - brace yourselves for that strange visual. However, the headliner's action was solid and the talent sufficient enough that it never dragged.

Best Moment: That 'ThunderDome' cage.

Worst Moment: The Dynamic Dudes. Generally.


5. 1994

ric flair hulk hogan halloween havoc
WWE.com

WCW changed a lot in 1994. Hulk Hogan arrived, old faves like Cactus Jack and Steve Austin moved closer to the exit door (only to be replaced by all of Hulk's mates) and Ric Flair retired "forever". OK, obviously not, but that's what the company wanted fans to believe at Havoc following a cage bout between he and Hogan.

Credit where credit's due - the main event was drama, drama, drama.

The biggest regret of the night came via Jim Duggan's tired routine opposite Austin. Other than that, this was a fun show, albeit a different one than NWA traditionalists and hardcore WCW fans were used to. It's difficult to look past the chemistry Hulk and Flair had, or other fine outings like Dustin Rhodes vs. Arn Anderson.

Best Moment: More Hulk Hogan magic.

Worst Moment: Jim Duggan's routine.


4. 1990

WCW Halloween Havoc 1990 Sting Sid Vicious
WWE

Go out of your way to see The Steiner Brothers vs. The Nasty Boys from this pay-per-view, and then follow that up with a quick watch of matches like Stan Hansen vs. Lex Luger and Doom vs. Ric Flair and Arn Anderson. All three are good, old-fashioned NWA-style action, and there's something lovable about that.

Unfortunately, the Sting vs. Sid Vicious main event lets the side down a little; that's more a surprise than you might think, because the Stinger seemed like the ideal man to bounce around for Sid and make him look like a million bucks (think Bret Hart or Shawn Michaels). It's not awful, but hardly great stuff.

The 'Black Scorpion' angle midway through the show is also tantamount to torture. It was a rotten gimmick, and the 'fake' Sting trope always felt bogus.

Best Moment: The Steiners and Nasty Boys beating the sh*t out of one another.

Worst Moment: The Black Scorpion.


3. 1993

Cactus Jack Vader
WWE.com

Never underestimate how much fun one can get from seeing Mick Foley take a kicking.

At Havoc '93, he took an almighty beating from Big Van Vader in a 'Texas Death' headliner that made fine use of WCW's 'Spin The Wheel, Make The Deal' idea. Watch this one and you'll see Vader in his element as he throws bombs at Cactus and generally tries to turn his bones into dust.

Other choice bouts you should probably check out include a rare battle of the Brits between Steven Regal and Davey Boy Smith, Dustin Rhodes vs. Steve Austin (again), The Nasty Boys vs. Marcus Alexander Bagwell and 2 Cold Scorpio and Ric Flair vs. Rick Rude.

Best Moment: A thumping Cactus Jack vs. Big Van Vader main event.

Worst Moment: Seeing The Shockmaster open.


2. 1997

Rey Mysterio Eddie Guerrero WCW Halloween Havoc 1997
WWE.com

Eric Bischoff points to 1997 as his favourite WCW year, and events like Halloween Havoc show why. The roster was so stacked - there's barely a match that goes by without some sort of involvement from a future Hall Of Famer. Also, some of the matches are must-see.

Rey Mysterio vs. Eddie Guerrero, for example, blew everyone away in '97. The fluidity of both men here would never be topped in follow-up efforts they had in WWE, and this is rightly heralded as one of the best WCW matches ever. You need to see it, especially to relive Rey's stunning speed and precision.

Star power is at a premium in matches like Curt Hennig vs. Ric Flair, Randy Savage vs. DDP and Hollywood Hogan vs. Roddy Piper (another cage bout) in the main event too.

Best Moment: Rey Mysterio and Eddie Guerrero producing a classic.

Worst Moment: Alex Wright vs. Steve McMichael or Disco Inferno vs. Jacqueline.


1. 1996

WCW Halloween Havoc 1996 Hulk Hogan Randy Savage
WWE

It's 1996 that takes the prize.

Listen to this for a line up: Dean Malenko vs. Rey Mysterio, DDP vs. Eddie Guerrero, Syxx vs. Chris Jericho, The Outsiders vs. Harlem Heat and Hollywood Hogan vs. Randy Savage. All of those matches are worth booting up the WWE Network for; Arn Anderson fans may get some giggles out of his match with Lex Luger as well.

The nWo angle was still red hot around this time, and WCW was starting to gain some serious momentum as a genuine WWF beater. Malenko vs. Mysterio was a flawless opener, the likes of Guerrero, Syxx and Jericho were on their game and the occasionally-combustible combination of Hogan and Savage seemed inspired to do good business here.

Great pay-per-view, and the best Havoc ever.

Best Moment: Almost the entire card.

Worst Moment: N/A.

What were your favourite Halloween Havoc moments? For more wrestling, check out 10 Things You Learn Binge Watching Every WWE Raw From 1997 and 10 Things We Learned From WWE 24: Drew McIntyre!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.