Ranking Every Major Monday Night Wars Jump From WORST To BEST

But whose side is he on?

X Pac WWE Debut
WWE

It’s wartime once again, but sadly, even if the threat of competition is driving the WWE product into more interesting territory, one thing just won’t be the same: talent jumps.

In this online-all-the-time world, everybody is too connected to experience that shocking disconnect when a talent trades sides. Back in that fabled day, you had to pay for a Wrestling Observer Newsletter subscription or the Power Slam hotline to get the scoop on which talent was pissed off, which talent was angling for a move—which talent Eric Bischoff didn’t have a clue what to do with because they hadn’t arrived, at his lap, like a pole dancer on his wife’s.

And, even then, the contracts were different in a world that was far from corporate.

Some acts were able to “work the dirts” because they worked on the sort of handshake deals nobody works under anymore. Most every WWE performer is tied to a long-term deal, and if they’re close to running it down, there are exponentially more insiders plying their trade ready to break the news. That is, if they don’t break it themselves with a thinking-face emoji and a #10months hashtag.

But, if you can’t look forward to the future, you can make like Johnny Swinger and get stuck in the glorious past…

15. Bret Hart

WCW Bret Hart
WWE

Bret Hart: the best wrestler on the planet, who exited the WWF in the most wild of circumstances as the most controversial and talked-about star in the game, was introduced to WCW fans as…

…a referee!

Immediately absorbed as a tertiary player into the nWo drama fans thought would come to an enthralling, euphoric end at the pay-per-view promoted as expressly that, Hart guest refereed a dire comedy match between Eric Bischoff and Larry Zbysko. He also restarted the main event, in a finish informed by the Montreal Screwjob, in which Hogan legit screwed Sting as a result of his political gamesmanship. WCW WCW’d its biggest event ever, and WCW WCW’d Bret Hart.

The question isn’t Did Hart’s no-compete clause scupper plans?

The question is Why the f*ck did WCW debut him as a referee?

WCW and Bret Hart was an unhappy marriage without the honeymoon.


14. Haku

haku 2001
WWE.com

An hilariously unnecessary shot aimed at WCW—the company was, if not officially dead, very much an incinerated car in the WWF’s rearview mirror—Haku re-debuted at the WWF Royal Rumble as WCW Hardcore Champion.

In the sort of quintessential LOLWCW moment that filled two books, the former Meng wasn’t under contract, and yet the company strapped him up regardless. Haku didn’t do much in the Rumble match itself, beyond lacerating the chest of the Undertaker, but it was a pretty funny flex, all the same, and it’s not as if WCW hadn’t repeatedly asked for it. Vince McMahon, impeccably, unconscionably cruel, responded to the gamesmanship when the game was over.

WCW, in response, meekly deactivated the title. As for the physical belt, Meng awarded it to his old tag team partner the Barbarian, before it was handed over to WWE as part of the sale agreement.

WCW didn’t acknowledge the switch, even though it recognises that Kevin Nash once gave away the Heavyweight Title to Ric Flair.


13. Dustin Rhodes

Seven WCW
WWE Network

One of the most hilarious moments in the history of professional wrestling, [Rainier Wolfcastle voice] it wasn’t a comedy.

Dustin Rhodes played a character even more problematic than the gay panic predator that was Goldust. ‘Seven’ was a child molester, and it can only be inferred that this was classic LOLWCW stuff akin to naming a heel act after a plan for the mass genocide of the worldwide Jewish population. In a vignette, Seven hovered outside of a young boy’s window. “Awake, my son,” he said. “Come with me and live forever,” he followed up, before inviting the child to join him “in complete bliss, mmmm, that’s right”.

“Mmmm, that’s right” is what male pornographic actors say when satisfied at the fellatio prowess of their co-stars, for f*ck’s sake.

Rhodes played this character for about three minutes, before swiftly burying it on his debut. “My new name’s Seven, by the way,” he said with glorious deadpan, before rubbishing his ‘Uncle Fester’ look.

An incredibly dangerous waste of precious time: WCW, everybody.


12. Madusa

Madusa Nitro
WWE.com

Remembered as iconic more for the fallout than the moment itself, Madusa’s transgression has developed a weird mythology in the years since.

Presented as evidence that Vince McMahon couldn’t allow Bret Hart to leave the WWF as Heavyweight Champion in fear of a repeat humiliation, that is bullsh*t: a legal impossibility, WCW would have been f*cked faster than it f*cked itself, had Eric Bischoff dared. But this baseless speculation—“this is why Vince screwed Bret” has 271 likes on the pirated YouTube video—has informed the legacy of the angle, which is in itself…not great.

Madusa’s promo was shaky and repetitive when it badly needed to be confident, and really, it didn’t resonate beyond gossipy insider circles. The WWF had binned the title before Madusa did. It wasn’t a sacrosanct piece of Titan iconography. The stint helped build WCW’s perception as the cool, contrarian promotion, if nothing else.

Mildly humiliating, audacious, a nice checkpoint in the Monday Night Wars saga—but not much else.


11. Jeff Jarrett

Buff Bagwell La Parka
WWE Network

A two-parter with the same finale, Jeff Jarrett jumped twice under the belief that his new home represented a chance of upward mobility.

He was right and wrong: the WWF was free of Hulk Hogan’s creative control, but he flourished only as a very entertaining midcard act. He thought more of himself, and so left his second red-hot promotion (!) under the ambitious idea of elevating WCW as a main event talent.

On the October 20, 1997 RAW, Jeff Jarrett went the shoot route by accusing Eric Bischoff of nepotism—with significantly less of the fury and comedy—but far more racism!—Steve Austin had unleashed two years prior in ECW. Jarrett made sure to bury Austin, incidentally, which ultimately scuppered a pitched main event programme.

And so it was off to WCW, in which the Chosen One chose the worst possible time to debut. On the October 18, 1999 Nitro, he smashed Buff Bagwell with his guitar seconds after the ‘Stuff’ “went along” apathetically with the “script”. Vince Russo had unspooled the guts of pro wrestling, leading to drastically unpopular confusion—and Jarrett slipped on them.

Remove the delusions of grandeur, and Jarrett was great—but he ain’t no headliner.


10. Rick Rude

Rick Rude Nitro
WWE Network

Possibly the cutest jump of the Monday Night Wars—and leave it to Rick Rude, one of wrestling’s most f*ckable ever men, to pull that off—the moustachioed Ravishing one, in defiance of the Montreal Screwjob, left the WWF to debut on WCW on the November 17, 1997 Nitro—a night on which he also appeared on the taped RAW broadcast…

…with a full beard.

Firmly aware of the continuity that would expose RAW as literal old hat, Rude, bowing out of his pay-per-appearance deal, changed his look to depict Nitro as the more vital show—the show with the scoop. With Eric Bischoff in the background looking perfectly smug—for the last time—Rude raged against the WWF for screwing Bret Hart. Cuter still, Roode referred to his old employer as the “Titanic”.

It was a sensational story—or it would have been, were the WWF really the Titanic. In reality, as literally cheeky a transgression as this was, the real intrigue of controversy was unfolding in the WWF.

If anything, ironically, WCW was hurtling towards the iceberg that was Starrcade.


9. The Big Show

Big Show Debut
WWE

The Big Show’s WWF debut was as confusing as his subsequent presentation.

Heel, babyface, ‘overgrown 500 pound bag of monkey crap’, WWF Champion: Vince’s love of the mass and his loathing of the performer’s motivation were locked in constant battle in 1999, and the first shot of this internal war was fired on the very first night: the St. Valentine’s Day Massacre, February 14, 1999.

In the sort of wrestling visual that is awesome, provided you don’t think about it at all, Paul Wight/No Gimmicks Needed/Big Nasty/The Big Show burst through the ring canvas and smashed Steve Austin into the black bars of the steel cage.

And then he smashed him through it, handing Austin the match at the expense of his new master. He has superhuman strength, you see, but Wight is also as dumb as a brick.

A dance as old as time itself.

Typically dumbsh*t late-Russo booking that didn’t much matter, because the stars were so hot, this was also insufferable on account of Michael Cole’s pipsqueak ’99 voice.


8. Vader

Vader Yokozuna Wrestlemania Xii
WWE

Vader looked like a monster precisely three times in his hugely disappointing two year WWF run. His killer first two nights in marked the arrival of a deadly new force—before he succumbed to injury and politics.

He stiffed Savio Vega in the face with clubbing blows before, in an awesome spot, staring a hole through the 1-2-3 Kid while in the process of casually wiping the sh*t that was Doug Gilbert from his shoe. He eliminated a ‘Squat Teamer’ but not before d*mn near lifting his head off by way of his trademark gruesome upward strike to the ear. Eliminated by Shawn Michaels before returning to the ring in a rage, the following scene resembled a dangerous shift for the Animal Control Service.

The next night on RAW, in an angle of seminal, transgressive violence, Vader brutalised the beloved Gorilla Monsoon from behind. The Mastodon looked dangerous and ugly enough putting his claws on his fellow competitors: this was so disturbing as to be harrowing, called perfectly by Vince McMahon and his histrionic, repeated pleas of “That’s Gorilla Monsoon!”

The WWF tranquillised the animal upon his return from suspension (surgery), but what a tremendous debut this was.

Inimitable, sadly.


7. Ted DiBiase

Ted DiBiase nWo
WWE

A rare, mutually beneficial Monday Night Wars jump, Ted DiBiase left the WWF in the summer of 1996, and in doing so, left Steve Austin to his own devices. Austin used that freedom to get over, ultimately, as the biggest star in the business.

DiBiase left to join WCW in an inspired role that subverted his old role so beautifully. As the informal ‘Trillionaire Ted’, DiBiase was revealed as the financier of the New World Order, which helped to fill a plot gap using canny continuity: WCW weren’t exactly paying them to disrupt programming and pummel the babyfaces. This was the work of DiBiase, established in pro wrestling canon as a man of obscene wealth.

By the time of his arrival, any notion of this being a shoot had long since vanished—but this marvellous attention to detail allowed fans to suspend their disbelief.

DiBiase was replaced in the role by the more iconic Eric Bischoff—which some note as the very beginning of the end—and though he lacked that sheer detestable quality, he shone in the early, glory days of wrestling’s most effective faction ever.


6. Roddy Piper

Piper Hogan
WWE

Roddy Piper made his last in-ring appearance for the WWF at WrestleMania XII in a very creative but very ugly Hollywood Backlot Brawl opposite Goldust.

His pay-per-view debut with WCW was a different sort of ugly, but far more euphoric: he defeated the enormously unpopular Hulk Hogan in a dire but over main event at the smash-success Starrcade ’96, but this time, true to form, Piper changed the question: here, he was the babyface, drawing at his legendary history with the Hulkster by claiming that he knew he was a snake all along.

Yet more effective, subversive prime WCW storytelling, the result and indeed the jump suited all parties: Hogan didn’t lose his Heavyweight Championship under the non-title stipulation (the believable animosity sold and excused this), WCW generated considerable revenue, and Piper earned a bumper twilight payday.


5. X-Pac

X Pac WWE Debut
WWE

An awesome (and unheralded) illustration of how white-hot the WWF was at the time, on the surface, this was an underwhelming and ambitious pitch. Syxx was a midcard act, Shawn Michaels a super-worker of a main event talent. The fact that Sean Waltman was a tremendous pro wrestler under any guise didn’t matter: he wasn’t Shawn Michaels. Nobody was.

On the surface.

But the timing was so perfect. WWF had on the night prior presented the monster that was WrestleMania XIV. The event that made formal Steve Austin’s coronation as the man, and the WWF as the cool company, re-debuting X-Pac 24 hours later was a masterstroke. His jump from WCW was yet more evidence of the shift in atmosphere. The WWF was where it was at: that’s why he was there.

X-Pac’s rant at Hulk Hogan wasn’t close to the most fire of Attitude Era promos—“Hulk Hogan, you suck pal!”—but for the first time, the weapons lobbed down south didn’t resonate as defensive.

The WWF was on the offensive, in every definition of the wor


4. The Radicalz

The Radicalz
WWE

In which the WWF stripped WCW of its last semblance of identity.

WCW—and its antecedent, Jim Crockett Promotions—was always considered by its ardent fanbase the purer, grittier, technically advanced pro wrestling league. In one shocking rebellion-cum-coup, the WWF, in capturing the men that made up the Radicalz faction, formalised WCW’s descent into chaos and confusion: what even was WCW anymore? Following this defection, which lit up the WWF’s midcard, it was an even more inferior version of sports entertainment.

On the January 31, 2000 RAW, Chris Benoit, Eddie Guerrero, Perry Saturn and Dean Malenko arrived at ringside to take in the New Age Outlaws Vs. Head Cheese—before establishing themselves as faces with a blitzkrieg of the aerial offence that defined them as hardcore darlings with the buzz of controversy.

Subsequent appearances were mixed—the Radicalz starred in superb individual showcases in a legendary RAW 10-man tag after a weird, very WWF failure of a mettle-test on the February 1 SmackDown—but the net result was a total kill-shot.


3. Chris Jericho

Chris Jericho WWF Debut
WWE.com

A sensational moment, a monster pop, and an ultimate success, Chris Jericho’s debut WWF promo—whisper it, or you’ll get called a “c*nt”—was far from his best.

Jericho played it with too much emphasis on comedy and attempted to get one or five too many catchphrases over, all at once—but he held his own against the most over verbal genius in the company, with such confidence and personality, that many bemoaned the lack of a pay-per-view follow-up.

A genius collaboration of promotion, production, and performance, nonetheless, this promo displeased the wrong people. The Undertaker was deeply pissed off at being labelled boring, but then, he shouldn’t have cut one of the most aimless promos of all time the next week. Still, Jericho captured the imagination of his new people, which was precisely the point.

The jump itself brought into focus the disparity between the two companies. The WWF was unassailable, WCW unrecoverable.

Jericho represented the ideal intersection of workrate and showmanship; in 1999, he was the next big thing, and there was only one place for him.


2. Lex Luger

lex luger wcw
WWE.com

Lex Luger re-debuted in WCW on the launch of its new prime-time flagship.

Contractually well within his rights to do just that, this had an air of infraction about it at a time of captivating ignorance, something Luger put over, albeit unintentionally, by wearing Jerry Seinfeld’s puffy pirate shirt.

Luger observed the match between Sting and Ric Flair, arms folded, in an iconic visual that put over WCW—immediately—as the place to be. The endearingly naff mall setting was fitting, nonetheless: it put in mind the idea that fans could now shop around for the best pro wrestling product.

Luger returned during the main event, ostensibly to save Hogan from a beat-down, before a miscommunication nearly erupted in violence.

An early flirtation with blurred character dynamics, this set the tone of early Nitro’s must-see shock factor and, indeed, the storytelling approach that added the crucial substance to it.


1. The Outsiders

The Outsiders Debut Wcw
WWE.com

The jump, the arrival of Kevin Nash and Scott Hall illustrated—and defined—the shift in the North American landscape.

The WWF was the cartoonish, over-gimmicked, unfashionable company; WCW in contrast was the more realistic, dangerous, unmissable promotion. Re-debuting under their real names, as part of an irresistible and mysterious storyline, Nash and Hall were the hottest properties in wrestling. Hall, a vastly underrated promo man, both acknowledged the in-the-know crowd and left them hanging: “You people know who I am, but you don’t know why I’m here,” he said. It was a killer line that made changing the channel impossible. Referencing the Billionaire Ted skits without speaking in the pejorative, Hall framed himself as an interloper and spoke of a “We”. Again: changing the channel was impossible.

Nash didn’t know what an adjective was, but he knew how to win a war, unlike Adolf Hitler, whom he referenced quite bizarrely. Nitro took the lead the next week, and didn’t look back for 83 weeks.

And, in response, the WWF somehow contrived to reinforce its perception as the fake, uncool company by introducing New Razor Ramon and Diesel characters.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!