Ranking Every Night One WWE 2024 Draft Pick From Worst To Best

13. LA Knight

LA Knight
WWE.com

Draft Position: #5 for SmackDown. #9 overall.

Brand Switch: N/A.

LA Knight is one breakout star who needed a change of scenery.

He won't threaten Cody Rhodes as top baby on SmackDown, and he's had his title crack against old champ Roman Reigns anyway. On paper, the only reason to keep Knight around on Fridays is so he can wrestle Logan Paul. All will be forgiven if that happens over the summer.

Even that won't alter the fact that LA Knight didn't go anywhere in the 2024 Draft. He was included for a cheap pop from the live crowd and that was it. Apologies in advance, but we're not quite finished with the 'Wrestler A is staying on Show B' stuff yet.


12. Randy Orton

Randy Orton WWE
WWE.com

Draft Position: #3 for SmackDown. #5 overall.

Brand Switch: N/A.

Legacy star (bit of a double-edged meaning to that given his old stable!) Randy Orton is an asset to whichever show he finds himself on. He's versatile, and doesn't really need to be involved in top programs to be useful in 2024. That said, Orton didn't need to be announced as one of the picks in this year's Draft.

WWE could've got away with putting a finger to their lips and booking Randy as a SmackDown star without anyone batting an eyelid. They didn't need to make a big deal out of his standing on the roster, so this goes down as another wasted pick.

Randy Orton went SmackDown > SmackDown.


11. Seth Rollins

Seth Rollins
WWE

Draft Position: #2 for Raw. #4 overall.

Brand Switch: N/A.

The only reason this guy can think of for keeping Seth Rollins on Raw is that Hunter wants to book him vs. Drew McIntyre again, and wait around on CM Punk's comeback so WWE can reignite that rivalry. Ex-World Champ Rollins has done almost everything there is to do on Mondays though, so a jump to SmackDown seemed plausible.

It didn't happen.

During night one of the Draft, WWE chose to cement Seth's status as a Raw man. He was the brand's second pick (fourth overall), and will surely now just keep on doing what he's been doing. Rollins has some injuries of his own to heal up first. Don't forget about that.


10. AJ Styles

AJ Styles
WWE.com

Draft Position: #7 for SmackDown. #13 overall.

Brand Switch: N/A.

You'd be forgiven for wondering when all the positivity starts gushing in. Sorry, but it won't be for another few entries. On the plus side, and to toss everyone a bone, it is cool that AJ Styles' immediate future has been thrashed out right before he challenges Cody Rhodes for the WWE Title at Backlash.

The difference between AJ and Jey Uso (who's in a similar boat) there is that Styles seemed destined to be heading back to Raw or maybe for a stint helping out on NXT so he could interact with Shawn Michaels. Ahem. Selfish reasons coming to the fore for that last bit!

Not apologising for that.


9. The Bloodline

Solo Sikoa Tama Tonga Paul Heyman Bloodline
WWE

Draft Position: #6 for SmackDown. #11 overall.

Brand Switch: N/A.

Paul Heyman revealed that Roman Reigns pulled himself of the Draft ahead of time, which means The Bloodline's only draftees include Heyman, Solo Sikoa and new boy Tama Tonga. Looking on the bright side, this does push the mutiny story that's starting to emerge with Solo.

Roman won't be chuffed that Sikoa is making crucial family decisions without his permission. Heyman knows that, which is why he's horrified about being drafted alongside Solo and Tonga. If nothing else, at least WWE had the foresight to further those cracks in The Bloodline during this year's Draft.

It also suggests Reigns and possibly The Rock will eventually be SmackDown-bound themselves.


8. Baron Corbin

Baron Corbin
WWE

Draft Position: #9 for SmackDown. #18 overall.

Brand Switch: NXT > SmackDown.

This just in: Baron Corbin won't be continuing his War Dogs tag on WWE's main roster. His NXT partner Bron Breakker is on a different show to him, and that was confirmed when Baron was drafted as part of the supplemental picks. He's one of only two from the supplementals to rank this high on the list.

Corbin has a chance to contribute on the main roster again. Anyone who watched his work on the third brand will know that - don't be totally shocked if Baron forms another tag and tries to repeat the success he experienced with Breakker.

Anything but 'King' Corbin is fine. Oh God. King Of The Ring is coming up...


7. Alba Fyre & Isla Dawn

Alba Fyre Isla Dawn
WWE.com

Draft Position: #9 for Raw. #17 overall.

Brand Switch: SmackDown > Raw.

Fingers crossed going to the flagship pays dividends for talented duo Alba Fyre and Isla Dawn. Both Scots put their hearts and souls into a witchy possession gimmick that WWE's writers failed to meet halfway, and it's pretty clear they were screwed for life on SmackDown.

Change will be good for them.

Keep faith that Alba and Isla will show what they're capable of on Raw. The division is light on excellent tag-teams, after all, and they've got a better shot at shining over there than trumping Bianca Belair and Jade Cargill on SmackDown.


6. Andrade

Andrade WWE 2024
WWE.com

Draft Position: #8 for SmackDown. #15 overall.

Brand Switch: Raw > SmackDown.

Behold one of the most logical decisions in the 2024 Draft.

Andrade has been involved in the ongoing LWO vs. Legado del Fantasma stuff since arriving back in WWE at Royal Rumble, but it would've been challenging to continue that post-Draft unless he came over to SmackDown from Raw. Good job there, Nick Aldis. That makes up for the Cedric Alexander and Ashante Adonis silliness examined earlier.

Matches vs. Santos Escobar, Humberto, Angel, Carlito and more await Andrade on Fridays. That is, of course, unless WWE flips the script by taking Legado to Raw during the second half of the Draft this coming Monday. They wouldn't, would they?


5. Kiana James

Kiana James WWE Draft 2024
WWE.com

Draft Position: #8 for Raw. #16 overall.

Brand Switch: NXT > Raw.

Eyebrows were raised once it became clear Roxanne Perez wouldn't be involved in this year's Draft. She seemed like a dead cert to get promoted, but brand champs are locked. That must be why WWE went with Kiana James instead. Even she looked taken aback when a Raw cap was placed on her head during SmackDown.

To the future!

James was the last name announced on TV during opening night, and that's a pretty big deal for her. She still has an entire career ahead of her, and can easily make a splash on Raw if given a fair shake. It's nice to see promising workers get rewarded.


4. Bron Breakker

Bron Breakker
WWE.com

Draft Position: #3 for Raw. #6 overall.

Brand Switch: SmackDown > Raw.

Right, there's no denying they botched this, but let's give WWE the benefit of the doubt.

Bron Breakker was recently signed to SmackDown before the Draft, so it didn't look like he'd be eligible for a rapid trade. So much for that. Bron was Raw's third overall choice, thus rendering Nick Aldis' chase pre-WrestleMania totally worthless. Good job, creative team. You made the GM look like a right clown again.

What was that about the benefit of the doubt? Oh yeah, back to Breakker. He's a star in the making, and will make a fine rival for guys like Bronson Reed and Ivar over on the flagship. Put it this way: WWE's meaty meat division could use him.


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.