Ranking Every Night One WWE 2024 Draft Pick From Worst To Best
Opening night could've been bigger, but WWE still did some moving and shaking in the 2024 Draft!
Triple H and Cody Rhodes led the way by announcing the first round of 2024's WWE Draft picks on Friday's episode of SmackDown. They were joined by legends like The Dudley Boyz, Torrie Wilson, Michelle McCool, Teddy Long and JBL throughout the show. The whole thing felt paint by numbers, but there were still some tasty jumps across four rounds on TV.
Later, WWE announced a collection of supplemental picks to beef things out further. On Monday's Raw, the company will deep dive into another six rounds of announcements on the flagship, and then tack on even more stragglers via social media after the fact. This year's Draft is a busy one in terms of numbers, but...are fans right to be slightly disappointed/underwhelmed by the whole affair?
Trips himself made sure to note that brand GMs could lock in wrestlers already on their shows, but that explanation was fairly weak. It came across as an excuse for why some of WWE's heaviest hitters stayed put instead of leaping from brand to brand, and that'll be viewed as a cop out by many.
Regardless, there are 23 picks to rank here from worst to best. So, who's going where?!
23. Cedric Alexander & Ashante Adonis
Draft Position: #10 for SmackDown. #19 overall.
Brand Switch: N/A.
What was the point of this?
Cedric Alexander and Ashante 'Thee' Adonis have barely shown up on TV as a tag-team, and yet everyone's supposed to believe SmackDown GM Nick Aldis said: 'Yes, those are my guys'? It's totally unbelievable, but this under-developed unit isn't the only Draft pick one could say that about.
Keep in mind that the GMs, in theory, could choose any non-champion they liked. Sure, Cedric and Ashante were in the supplemental bracket, but that still doesn't explain why Aldis would go for them when WWE has other tags who, y'know, actually appear on television frequently.
22. The O.C
Draft Position: #11 for SmackDown. #22 overall.
Brand Switch: N/A.
Apparently, Nick believes keeping Luke Gallows, Karl Anderson and Michin around on Fridays is important too. People have pointed out that effectively drafting three wrestlers with one pick isn't exactly fair, but the rules are skewed in WWE's Draft. There's nothing particularly new to report there.
Again though, The O.C without AJ Styles isn't very valuable. This is the kind of pick aspiring brand managers would make in MyGM on WWE 2K24 if rivals had scooped the best remaining options. At least Trips had the decency to plop this trio in the supplemental field, eh?
Yawn.
21. Zoey Stark
Draft Position: #12 for Raw. #23 overall.
Brand Switch: N/A.
You'll already be clocking a pattern with the earlier rankings here - an awful lot of the workers hitting the skids in the bottom half are those staying put on a brand they already wrestled for. Zoey Stark, who has been totally directionless since her alliance with Trish Stratus ended, is definitely deserving of a lower spot.
Learning that she...won't be jumping at all is hardly a thrilling use of Draft reveals.
WWE elected to keep Zoey's regular tag-team partner on the same show too. Fair enough, but why were these ladies drafted separately when other duos got lumped together? That doesn't make much (if any) sense, and tramples all over the company's own rules.
20. Shayna Baszler
Draft Position: #11 for Raw. #21 overall.
Brand Switch: N/A.
Shayna Baszler is sticking around on Raw. Yay for Shayna.
Seriously, what in the name of MMA happened to Baszler's pro wrestling career? She once seemed set to dominate the division on WWE's main roster after a sparkling spell on NXT, but hasn't come close. Instead, Shayna is best known for crapping her drawers over spooky dolls, teaming with Nia Jax and winning an awful match vs. Ronda Rousey.
Things are not going well for Baszler, to say the least. Oh well, at least she's still knocking around and included in the Draft somewhere. It's really hard to get buzzed for news that she and Zoey are still on Raw though. WWE's bigwigs are surely taking the p*ss by announcing that.
19. Ricochet
Draft Position: #5 for Raw. #10 overall.
Brand Switch: N/A.
Ditto.
The Dudley Boyz had to pretend they were excited to announce that Ricochet is still tied to Monday Night Raw. Surely putting him back in the hunt on SmackDown would've been preferable. Hell, even sticking Rico on NXT's books as the sole main roster star going 'back to developmental' might've breathed new life into his run.
Ricochet hasn't been given much since excelling opposite Logan Paul at SummerSlam 2023. He works good matches, sure, but how many of them are truly memorable? If anyone needed a fresh start (and a proper feud or two), it was this high-flyer.
18. Ivar
Draft Position: #10 for Raw. #20 overall.
Brand Switch: N/A.
Get used to seeing "N/A" next to brand switch in this article, sadly. WWE didn't do a lot of moving and shaking. What they did do was fun, but then there are reveals like this one. Ivar of Viking Raiders fame is still a Raw star. In fairness, he was one of the bigger names included in the supplemental round.
It doesn't look like Erik or Valhalla will be coming along for the ride with him. Is this the quiet end of The Raiders? Could be. Of course, creative will probably just stick Erik on Mondays without explaining why whenever he's able to return from injury.
Hands up who else fancied seeing Ivar go elsewhere?
17. Alpha Academy
Draft Position: #7 for Raw. #14 overall.
Brand Switch: N/A.
This could be awkward in a few weeks.
A lot of fans complain about WWE neutering their own Draft almost as soon as it's over. Chad Gable staying with the rest of Alpha Academy is indicative of the format's current woes. Perhaps it would've been smart to move Otis, Akira Tozawa and Maxxine Dupri to SmackDown or NXT and let Chad get on with his push.
Gable will almost-defo link up with The Creed Brothers as a homage to Team Angle, which will render this collective pick pointless. The goofier side of this Academy needs to be swept aside so Chad can continue growing under Triple H's watch.
16. Liv Morgan
Draft Position: #4 for Raw. #8 overall.
Brand Switch: N/A.
Liv Morgan has a date with destiny whenever Rhea Ripley returns from injury. Creative has a natural feud in their back pockets there, but they could've done something interesting with Liv vs. Bayley in the interim over on SmackDown. Nope, Morgan was the latest to be announced as...going nowhere.
She's still team red.
WWE is blatantly keeping some powder dry for Monday's Draft blowoff, but the fact Liv was Adam Pearce's fourth overall pick is rather baffling. Injured stars can't have been eligible, otherwise someone like Ripley would've made way more sense. Also, what about red hot newcomer Jade Cargill?!
15. Bianca Belair
Draft Position: #1 for SmackDown. #1 overall.
Brand Switch: N/A.
Listen, Bianca Belair is fab, but she's cooled off as a character in 2024. Therefore, placing her as the top overall pick and most desirable draftee on the books feels strange. It's worth saying that Bianca and partner Jade should've come as a package deal like other tags too.
The inconsistencies here are ever-so-slightly annoying.
Fans did pop when Cody Rhodes announced Belair, but the moment lacked oomph once everyone realised that Bianca wasn't actually leaving SmackDown for pastures new. No, she's still on FOX for now. In other words, her reveal in the Draft didn't merit top billing.
It changed nothing.
14. Jey Uso
Draft Position: #1 for Raw. #2 overall.
Brand Switch: N/A.
Pre-Draft, this writer worried that the upcoming Backlash PLE would either have an impact on things or get spoiled by WWE booking workers to hop brands. Jey Uso, for example, could have gone back to SmackDown but still had his World Title match against Raw champ Damian Priest over in France.
Perhaps wisely, WWE decided against moving Jey again. The downside is that he represented yet another pick in the Draft that changed sod all on the top two rosters. If only Triple H would return to picks that exclusively mix things up between Raw and SmackDown.
There was a lot of wasted air during opening night.