Ranking Every NXT Call-Up From Worst To Best

26. Carmella

Carmella Smackdown Women's Champion
WWE.com

Carmella has surpassed the legacy of her jobber father Paul van Dale, but not by much. An absolute terror in the ring, she was handpicked to kill Asuka dead earlier this year, and any burgeoning credibility the SmackDown Women's title had with it.

Sense eventually prevailed, and she's now largely restricted to dancing with R-Truth. Thank God.


25. Bayley

Can Bayley make the best use of this situation?
WWE

You have to give WWE credit where it's due: how they managed to take the phenomenally popular Bayley and turn fans against her through sheer indifference is almost majestic.

At this stage, she really could use a hug.


24. Paige

Paige Main Roster Debut
WWE

Made an immediate impact winning AJ Lee's Divas title on night one, and became the fulcrum of the nascent 'women's revolution'. Injuries and personal issues curtailed Paige's promise, and she was soon overtook by a crop of newer - and admittedly, better - stars.

Retired from the ring, she now has a cushy role as SmackDown's GM - at least until her movie comes out.


23. Sasha Banks

Sasha Banks crutch
WWE

Hankies at the ready. Sasha shared the company's finest ever women's match at TakeOver: Brooklyn opposite Bayley, and followed it up with a similarly stellar sequel at Respect.

Should have been the standout star of the 'Women's Revolution' after headlining Hell in a Cell 2016, but has subsequently been mis-ued worse than the word 'nonplussed' - which pretty much describes everybody's reaction to her booking. The corner seems a long way off.


22. Bobby Roode

Bobby Roode Raw
WWE.com

Bobby Roode was, dare we say it, (sigh) glorious in NXT as the cocky heel totally oblivious to his own pomposity (you could call him vainglorious).

On the main roster, he became a tabula revelare with a catchy theme song. He's now paired with fellow lost soul Chad Gable.


21. Asuka

Asuka MITB
WWE

Oh blimey. Asuka entered the main roster a ready made star, and things looked suspiciously promising when she won the first ever women's Royal Rumble. Then she lost her streak to Charlotte.

It was still salvageable, but the company insisted on making their best female wrestler look absolutely thick as f*ck at the expense of Carmella, of all people. It's over, folks.


20. Becky Lynch

Becky Lynch
WWE.com

To everybody's bewilderment, Becky didn't debut on the main roster as a leprechaun, and eventually broke out of the pack to become the first SmackDown Women's champion. Super talented and super popular, WWE tried their damnedest to sabotage Lynch's momentum with a nonsensical heel turn earlier this year.

It didn't work: she continues to be cheered, and is arguably the most popular woman on the roster besides Ronda Rousey.


19. Sami Zayn

Sami Zayn
WWE

Made a memorable Raw debut in Montreal as part of John Cena's open challenge, but suffered a shoulder injury in his enthusiasm.

Has since wrestled Kevin Owens for the last time about nine million times, before finding a new lease of life as his s**t-eating buddy. Then he was banned from Saudi Arabia on account of being Syrian, and is now basically f*cked.


18. Nia Jax

Nia Jax
WWE.com

Nia Jax is not like other girls. Which is to say, her character alignment is determined at random by Yarrow sticks.

Despite trying to set a world record for injuring as many people as possible in a calendar year, Jax continues to be pushed because it's a PR friendly anti-bullying story. Except when she's a bully the very next week. Psyche!


17. Luke Harper

Luke Harper
WWE

Mostly known for being underrated, to the extent that he's possibly overrated. Impressed as part of The Wyatt Family, so the team was promptly split.

A main-event run for Harper was mooted around WrestleMania 33. In reality, he was tossed from the Andre Battle Royal by Titus O'Neil, and is now a Bludgeon Brother. Yup.


Editorial Team
Editorial Team

Benjamin was born in 1987, and is still not dead. He variously enjoys classical music, old-school adventure games (they're not dead), and walks on the beach (albeit short - asthma, you know). He's currently trying to compile a comprehensive history of video game music, yet denies accusations that he purposefully targets niche audiences. He's often wrong about these things.