Ranking Every NXT Call-Up From Worst To Best

16. Shinsuke Nakamura

Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE.com

Mithering over the 'waste' of Shinsuke Nakamura on the main roster would be much easier had his series of 'dream' matches with AJ Styles not been so monumentally disappointing.

The clock seems to have run down on Shinsuke's time at the top, but hey, he won the Royal Rumble, and is US Champ at least.


15. Drew McIntyre

Drew McIntyre absolute piece
WWE.com

This lad'll do well, and as he should.

A considerable Scottish upgrade on Big Cass and Baron Corbin, the one-time 'Chosen One' has every chance of becoming 'The One' - if he can break his injury curse. Has wetter hair than an otter.


14. Rusev

Rusev Lana
WWE.com

Went on a lengthy unbeaten run after his call-up, with the whole streak ultimately designed to feed the John Cena machine. A truly lamentable lovers' square involving Dolph Ziggler threatened to completely derail the Bulgarian's career - as programmes with Dolph tend to - as did the terrible League of Nations faction.

But Rusev kept his chin up, and became one of 2017's breakout stars with his 'Rusev Day' catchphrase. Not that that has helped his career prospects any; he's lost every PPV match he's had in two years, but hey ho, that isn't to say he couldn't be WWE champ next week.


13. Xavier Woods

Xavier Woods
WWE.com

A totally nondescript Xavier Woods was set to follow the dregs down the post-development drain until his natural charisma worked miracles on a gimmick almost custom-built to end three careers.

WWE officials toot his horn now - but he may have already hit his highest note.


12. Elias

Elias WWE Raw
WWE.com

It's no coincidence whatsoever that the call-ups clamoured for the least are pushed the most.

To be fair to Elias, he's been absolutely magical on the mic since he drifted onto Raw, and some of his unplugged schtick has been electric. That said, he is sort of awful when he wrestles. It won't stop him.


11. Bray Wyatt

Bray Wyatt
WWE.com

Bray Wyatt promised a grand return to gimmicks of a bygone era after his post-Nexus repackaging. Things started well, then he lost each and every feud, and quickly descended into rambling like a teenager on LiveJournal circa 2004.

An unexpected WWE Title run last year had the potential to revitalise the broken Bray. It didn't. He's now in desperate need of reinvention, preferably, as IRS.


10. Samoa Joe

samoa joe mic
WWE.com

Was presented as a main-eventer upon his call up, and has looked like one ever since. Injury stalled his early momentum, but Joe has stayed fit for much of his SmackDown headlining run in 2018.

Where does WWE's most accomplished character go from decisively losing his programme opposite AJ Styles?


9. Kevin Owens

kevin owens universal
WWE.com

Enjoyed perhaps the best main roster debut of anyone, smashing John Cena and then beating him cleanly at Elimination Chamber 2015 - all whilst still holding the NXT belt.

Has never looked quite as convincing since, despite a stint as Universal champion and a high-profile programme opposite Shane McMahon. Management seems to have lost interest, because - and this is (probably) a direct quote - it's "only fat Kevin Owens."


8. Finn Bálor

Finn Balor Money In The Bank Briefcase
WWE.com

You can't ask for much better than a major title victory just a month after debuting on the main roster. Unfortunately for grinning Finn, a spiteful Seth Rollins buggered up his shoulder, and he was forced to spend the next five months on the treatment table.

It seems he's been punished for his dodgy rotator cuff ever since; Vince McMahon deemed him 'not over enough' to face Brock Lesnar at Royal Rumble, and he's now permanently rooted in the mid-card.


7. Alexa Bliss

Alexa Bliss
WWE.com

You'd have got pretty long odds on Alexa Bliss becoming one of the breakout stars of the Women's Evolution when she made the step up from NXT in 2016. One of WWE's most endearing babyfaces behind the cameras, Bliss' veritable virago character is one of the finest heels in front of it.

She became the first woman to claim both the SmackDown and Raw women's titles, adding a Money in the Bank briefcase to her trophy cabinet earlier this year. There are worrying suggestions that a series of concussions might stop her reign of terror dead.


Editorial Team
Editorial Team

Benjamin was born in 1987, and is still not dead. He variously enjoys classical music, old-school adventure games (they're not dead), and walks on the beach (albeit short - asthma, you know). He's currently trying to compile a comprehensive history of video game music, yet denies accusations that he purposefully targets niche audiences. He's often wrong about these things.