Ranking Every NXT Call-Up From Worst To Best

6. Charlotte

Charlotte Flair
WWE.com

WWE's most accomplished female superstar is also their finest. Though Charlotte's main roster matches haven't quite reached the quality of her NXT barnstormers, her very presence instantly imbued a desperate division with a much needed dose of prestige.

In recent times, the booking team have came perilously close to Roman Reignsing (it's a verb) Flair. They'll keep trying until they do.


5. Big E

Big E The New Day
WWE.com

Big E has - eventually - became the big success everybody expected on the main roster. When his original singles run fizzled out, E, né Langston, was shited into the DOA New Day team, which believe it or not, wasn't supposed to be complete tripe.

The infectious personalities of the trio ultimately overcame the tragedy of the concept, and they've been stars ever since. The pick of the bunch, Big E clearly has more to offer on the singles scene. Here's hoping he gets another chance.


4. Braun Strowman

braun strowman
WWE.com

To call Braun an NXT graduate is pushing it a bit. A quick glance at the 6'8" former strongman instantly reveals why he was fast-tracked through developmental, and after a patchy start, he's dominated the main event scene ever since.

Gold has so far eluded Braun - discounting the tag title he won alongside an 10-year old - a fact made all the more perplexing given the difficult circumstances surrounding Roman's abdication. WWE had best give him a run with the belt before his knees no longer let him.


3. Dean Ambrose

Dean Ambrose
WWE.com

There are no surprises with the top three NXT graduates, and it's absolutely telling that they were amongst the first - almost as if the man running the shop actually cared at the time. The Shield made one of the all-time great debuts at Survivor Series 2012, soon establishing themselves as the company's most popular act in forever.

Dean Ambrose fared worst out of their 2014 split, his 'wacky' character frequently failing to hit the mark - along with the general quality of his output. A sudden WWE Title win did nothing for him; it was only when he returned from action after a lengthy spell out, jacked and having shaved off his literal lunatic fringe, that Dean felt like a big player again. He's a heel now, because if anything's worth capitalising on, it's cancer.


2. Seth Rollins

Seth Rollins WrestleMania 31
WWE.com

The Shield's split, though ostensibly orchestrated to shift Roman Reigns to singles superstardom, ended up doing wonders for stablemate Seth Rollins. 'The Architect' stood tall after one of the all-time great WrestleMania smash 'n' grabs, and despite his Cyril Sneer schtick, enjoyed a stellar year as champ.

A serious knee injury arsed that up, and after struggling to re-find his form, Seth has emerged in 2018 as one of the company's most consistent performers. He also became the latest man to claim WWE's Grand Slam. You can't get much more successful than that.


1. Roman Reigns

Roman Reigns WWE Title
WWE.com

Except you can, by one. Just how do you measure Roman Reigns' success? Until the sobering realities of his leukaemia recurrence intervened to put everything into context, Reigns was arguably the least popular WWE superstar since John Cena at his pomp.

The victim of Dave Meltzer outing him as Vince McMahon's chosen one, absolutely nothing the company has tried has succeeded in getting the majority of fans on board the Roman Express. Headlining four consecutive WrestleManias only engendered resentment, not respect.

Fact is, no NXT graduate can be more 'successful' than Roman; if WWE has learned anything from the fiasco, they'll think twice about pushing his successor quite so hard, and quite so uncompromisingly. Maybe.


Editorial Team
Editorial Team

Benjamin was born in 1987, and is still not dead. He variously enjoys classical music, old-school adventure games (they're not dead), and walks on the beach (albeit short - asthma, you know). He's currently trying to compile a comprehensive history of video game music, yet denies accusations that he purposefully targets niche audiences. He's often wrong about these things.