Ranking Every NXT TakeOver From Worst To Best

8. Respect

NXT TakeOver Respect Sasha Banks Izzy
WWE.com

Though TakeOver: Respect was all about one match, it was far from just a one-match show.

Returning to Full Sail University after the historic Brooklyn supershow could have undermined the importance of the TakeOver label, but Bayley and Sasha Banks' noble sequel to their era-defining classic ensured that Respect would always be considered amongst the elite for the brand.

Their 30-minute Iron Woman main event was a story-driven classic underpinned by their lengthy programme and the history they were making going on last. Underneath Izzy's tears and Bayley's cathartic cheers, Finn Bálor and Samoa Joe won the first ever Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic with two strong wins as their impending rivalry rumbled under the surface and Asuka arrived in style by joyously battering f*ck out of a stupidly over-matched Dana Brooke.

When this wasn't building talent it was blowing minds. It was a show representative of the three letters acting as both developmental proving ground and sh*thot brand in perfect synchronicity.


7. Philadelphia

Almas Gargano Wwe Nxt Takeover Philadelphia
wwe.com

Andrade 'Cien' Almas and Johnny Gargano came of age as characters in a TakeOver main event that completely reimagined the quality bar of an event that had teased breaking the scale for years. Dave Meltzer's star ratings to matter loads to many but they matter a lot to some, and the pair earning the first perfect score for the company in a decade a half helped enhance what had already been an evocative and exceptional main event.

Reborn under the guidance of Zelina Vega, every slick and sick assault from Andrade landed on the crowd with the same force they appeared to strike ultra-sympathetic Challenger Gargano. The man that had lost just about everything was about to win the show's top prize until he fell marginally short. Tommaso Ciampa's post-match attack was somehow crueler than the actual defeat.

Elsewhere, Adam Cole announced himself as the future steward of the whole brand in a brutal Extreme Rules match loss against Aleister Black, Ember Moon squeaked past Shayna Baszler while expertly marking her own cards for a future loss, and Velveteen Dream continued his inexorable rise with another strong showing against Kassius Ohno.

NXT had raised the bar, and it wouldn't ever be lowered again.


6. Phoenix

NXT TakeOver Phoenix War Raiders Undispute Era
WWE.com

'Johnny Wrestling' reframed his 'Johnny TakeOver' persona during a temporary turn right around TakeOver: Phoenix, but an unbelievable North American Title switch sprung from the wreckage of an ineffective and inelegant heel switch.

Flipping the formula of his supercard epic, Gargano became a cutoff merchant in the face of Ricochet's incredible physical feats, using his torturous teases for evil rather than good. It anchored a robust card that took chances in concept rewarded by a near-immaculate execution.

The Undisputed Era surrendered their Tag Team Championships to the rock hard War Raiders, but kept their position as NXT MVPs with another scintillating show-opener. Elsewhere, Bianca Belair pushed back the challenge of Shayna Baszler's MMA Horsewomen but panicked and paid for it in a thrilling Women's Championship clash and Matt Riddle did in nine minutes what he'd done in about as many seconds a few months earlier with a worthy win over Kassius Ohno.

The card could have relegated Tommaso Ciampa's gritty NXT Championship win over Aleister Black to a secondary concern, but the pair assembled a thrilling WWE-style main event in what ended up as a closing montage of Champion Ciampa's best bits before a neck injury sidelined him for the summer.


5. Brooklyn

Bayley Sasha Reverse Hurricanrana TakeOver Brooklyn
WWE

Sasha Banks' NXT Women's Championship loss to Bayley was probably the most important moment of the decade for WWE.

It concluding a beautiful match highlighted a Brooklyn card that signalled NXT's move away from Full Sail supercards to main roster-adjacent epics. It stole the f*cking show and year by returning evocative physicality to the company's burgeoning women's division and pure, throat-draining emotion to WWE's output full-stop. It wasn't even the first to do so, but it was fitting that the payoff to a road paved by several clashes elsewhere in this list shone a spotlight on two of the performers most responsible for it.

A card greater than the sum of its parts, Brooklyn offered this and a bruising ladder main event as excellent epics but saw potentially passable matches made truly, earnestly great by a crowd falling head over heels for the brand. Blue Pants got the pop of her life as The Vaudevillains' antidote to Alexa Bliss' interference during a Tag Title switch with Blake and Murphy, whilst Jushin Liger's one and only appearance under WWE's auspices came as part of an awesome alternate universe opener against NXT favourite Tyler Breeze.

Part celebration part inauguration, NXT grew beyond this relatively humble card, but rarely felt quite as epic.


4. Portland

Dakota Kai Tegan Nox
WWE.com

NXT faced a rather unique type of pressure during the build to the first TakeOver of 2020 and the first to be entirely consumed by the USA Network era for the show.

It was to be the longest ever based on matches and the reasonable expectations for all of them, with a build fraught with complications thanks to a Worlds Collide show against NXT UK the prior month and main roster interjections into the Women's Championship match. These proved not to be caveats for its failings but measures of just how massive a success the event was.

No single match threatened the ludicrously luxurious top tier of TakeOver tussles, but all of them were excellent and illustrative of the how high the bar had been permanently set. Finn Bálor and Johnny Gargano lived up to sky high expectations with an elegant exercise in elevation, whilst The Broserweights combo of Matt Riddle and Pete Dunne continued their tag division saviour mission with an exhilarating victory over perpetual stewards The Undisputed Era.

Elsewhere, Adam Cole and Tommaso Ciampa were recipients of some glorious overbooking in a thrilling take on the somewhat overdone headline formula, and Rhea Ripley, Bianca Belair, Tegan Nox and Dakota Kai celebrated the women's division's status as the best in wrestling with two rippers over belts and broken friendships respectively.

A white hot crowd and a Poppy double-header opening the event only increased the heat - this was a total triumph.


3. New Orleans

Adam Cole NXT TakeOver New Orleans
WWE

In which Tommaso Ciampa and Johnny Gargano asked old weathered WWE fans if they'd finally seen their favourite ever match topped.

New Orleans was the setting for the first match between the pair following a turn that had taken place the prior summer and an edgy tag partners story crafted from the embers of a Cruiserweight Classic...classic a year earlier. And it was every bit as f*cking fantastic as it needed to be.

Fought at pace but with fittingly violent interludes, it should have been the end of their feud in how apocalyptic it felt, not least with the two Marvel fans playing the biggest hero and final boss villains of their own story. Ciampa was a wonderful, magnificent heel too - the synchronicity between his character and the audience's loathing of his actions was as pure as the starry-eyed expression on Gargano's face at his lowest ebb while fighting for his life.

Away from a once-great team, the newest group on the NXT block gained a fresh member as Roderick Strong joined the Undisputed Era in a shocking conclusion to a wicked triple threat tag match for both the Tag Team Titles and that year's Dusty cup. The turn concluded an amazing night for Adam Cole after he became the first North American Champion in a blistering and multi-man ladder opener.


2. Dallas

Nakamura kick Zayn Turnbuckle DDT NXT TakeOver Dallas
WWE.com

Dusty Rhodes famously spoke fondly of emotion being pro wrestling’s key driver, and ‘The American Dream’ would know - a decent wrestler but incredible worker, Rhodes was so sublime at what he was good at that it didn’t matter a jot what he couldn’t quite do as well.

As was TakeOver: Dallas, the first WrestleMania weekend for his beloved brand since his passing. A season finale of sorts for the NXT that became the hottest promotion in the world without even being a promotion, Dallas was a card that contradicted one of his all time legendary promos - from the developmental brand lurking behind the main roster, the view was changing.

Shinsuke Nakamura’s debut was a Moment (TM) WWE couldn’t come close to conjuring up one night later in front of a pretend 100,000 people. His debut already confirmed the brand as a destination wrestling location, but his infectious charisma and immaculately tweaked (and ONLY tweaked) promotion was confirmation of exactly what this proving ground had become - as if the work itself wasn’t doing the talking already.

‘The King Of Strong Style’ had an instant epic with Sami Zayn, made all the more impressive by what they’d been surrounded by. The Revival and American Alpha meshed styles with mesmerising mechanics and grace. Bayley and Asuka battered each other whilst breaking the hearts of every attendee in reminding them of life’s cruel natural order. Finn Bálor and Samoa Joe ingeniously worked around a worrisome blood stoppage to craft an entirely unique main event. Baron Corbin and Austin Aries were also there.

More of a cultural checkpoint for wrestling than just a supershow, this was all things to all eras of NXT in a manner that surely would have made the ‘Son Of A Plumber’ proud of all his “NXT kids”.


1. New York

Johnny Gargano NXT TakeOver New York
WWE.com

An exhilarating show that didn’t leave breathing space for a crowd that didn’t request it, TakeOver: New York was perhaps the peak of a genre NXT had perfected as the darling promotion for just about every subsection of the wrestling fanbase. It is, crack-to-cl*t, a near-perfect event and comfortably one of the greatest shows in company (and possibly industry) history.

An opening Tag Team match featuring The War Raiders and the makeshift Aleister Black/Ricochet pairing was an attritional assault in keeping with the Champions’ old moniker. Matt Riddle turned himself heel for the body of a dynamic (Velveteen) Dream match in a fine exhibition of a midcard title elevated by the men wrestling for it. Pete Dunne surrendered a legendary UK Championship reign to the seemingly indestructible Walter Shayna Baszler saw off all her immediate competition in an immaculately paced four way sprint that didn’t allow a tired crowd to snooze nor exhaust themselves for a main event set to be something potentially very special.

Very VERY f*cking special.

Again reflecting perhaps the peak of a genre they’d help craft and curate, Johnny Gargano and Adam Cole brought a sold out crowd to their knees over a vacant title in a fight with no other angle than the prize itself. A triumph beyond even the highest expectations, this was fought as if the end of the world were set to occur the very next day. For many in the audience unable to imagine a time where a show could be this good again, that’s exactly how it felt.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.