Ranking Every NXT TakeOver Special - From Worst To Best

What has been the best NXT live special to date?

bayley sasha banks
WWE.com

Similar to last year, WWE WrestleMania 33 had its work cut out for it with NXT hosting its latest live special the night prior. From Bobby Roode successfully defending his NXT Championship against Shinsuke Nakamura to the stacked Triple Threat tag team title match, it was a solid show that met the lofty expectations of fans.

Then again, have any of the installments of TakeOver to date disappointed? That would be resounding no. Granted, some have been better than others, but by and large, every TakeOver has had something special to offer, which is incredible when you consider that there have been 15 of them since February 2014.

Even when the buzz surrounding the black-and-yellow brand isn't quite so fervent, TakeOver events never fail to deliver. Ranking each of the live specials is a tough task given that all of them ranged from good to great to extraordinary, but it's only appropriate we attempt to do so as TakeOver: Chicago looms large. Where will the latest live special rank among its predecessors?

15. TakeOver: Fatal 4-Way

NXT TakeOver 4 Way
WWE

The Highlights: To call NXT TakeOver: Fatal 4-Way the worst live special to date isn't necessarily saying it was atrocious, because again, every TakeOver has been good at the very least. Rather, this installment had the weakest card of any TakeOver thus far, yet it was still an enjoyable show on the whole.

Of course, the eponymous Fatal 4-Way between then-NXT champion Neville, Sami Zayn, Tyler Breeze, and Tyson Kidd was absolutely exceptional and one of the best bouts of 2014. Hideo Itami also arrived that night and made a major statement by fending off The Ascension.

The Low Points: The rest of this TakeOver left a lot to be desired. Baron Corbin's debut and The Lucha Dragons winning the NXT Tag Team Championship were cool moments, but Bull Dempsey's squash of Mojo Rawley was a waste of time.

Enzo Amore vs. Sylvestor Lefort was a forgettable affair, and Charlotte vs. Bayley for the NXT Women's Championship paled in comparison to their future matchups against each other.


14. TakeOver: The End

Joe Balor 2
wwe.com

The Highlights: There was plenty of speculation from fans in the weeks preceding NXT TakeOver: The End as to what "The End" was actually in reference to. Thankfully, it wasn't the end of NXT as a brand but rather the end of the long-running rivalry between Samoa Joe and Finn Bálor for the NXT Championship.

The real match of the night, however, was the remarkable Revival vs. American Alpha NXT Tag Team Championship match. Shinsuke Nakamura and Austin Aries came close with an excellent match as well - perhaps Aries' best bout during his NXT tenure.

The Low Points: The Joe vs. Bálor rivalry seemed to peak at TakeOver: Dallas, and although their Steel Cage match on this show was very good, it wasn't their greatest outing. In the opener, Andrade 'Cien' Almas debuted in a fun match with Tye Dillinger, but 'The Perfect 10' outshined Almas his first night in.

Meanwhile, Asuka brought the best out of Nia Jax, but it was far from the greatest women's match in the history of TakeOver specials. Per usual, it was a very entertaining evening on the show but lacked historical significance.


13. TakeOver

NXT Takeover Zayn Breeze
WWE

The Highlights: The inaugural NXT TakeOver event had its fair share of memorable moments, including the breathtaking bout between Natalya and Charlotte for the NXT Women's Championship that exceeded all expectations. Neville and Tyson Kidd contested a great match in the main event, but the women truly stole the show that night.

Elsewhere on the card, Tyler Breeze had a breakout performance versus Sami Zayn and scored his sole victory on a live special, simultaneously earning himself a future NXT Championship match.

The Low Points: Adam Rose and Camacho was fine in the opening slot, though largely uninspiring. The Ascension vs. Kalisto and El Local might have been a better fit in that position, but even that match was underwhelming due to the two teams lacking in-ring chemistry.

Again, Neville and Kidd provided fans with a quality main event, but it was a pretty basic bout compared to other main event matches we would receive in the future. If nothing else, this installment proved Arrival was no fluke, not to mention that it overshadowed that Sunday's WWE Payback pay-per-view.


12. TakeOver: London

Finn Balor Samoa Joe
WWE Network

The Highlights: Of course, English audiences are always energetic and rowdy in wrestling, so they provided NXT TakeOver: London with an electric atmosphere. Without them, the show might not have been as strong, though the overall card was solid and featured a handful of above-average matchups.

The initial encounter between Finn Bálor and Samoa Joe did not disappoint, and the NXT Tag Team Championship match between The Revival and Enzo Amore and Big Cass also exceeded expectations.

The Low Points: Truth be told, there wasn't a bad match on the entire card, and essentially everything was enjoyable in its own right. Again, though, it felt more like a filler TakeOver than a true culmination of compelling storylines.

The Bálor and Joe rivalry resumed through the following summer, Bayley's reign as NXT Women's champion was just getting underway, Enzo and Cass fell short in their quest to become champions, and Apollo Crews vs. Baron Corbin was the weakest match of the night. It was more of a fun pit stop than it was a real historical landmark.


11. TakeOver: Orlando

bobby roode shinsuke nakamura
WWE.com

The Good: Having been in a bit of a lull since the summer, the pressure was on for NXT to deliver big at TakeOver: Orlando, and they didn't disappoint in putting forth an excellent effort. Shinsuke Nakamura and Bobby Roode met in a rematch for the NXT Championship, and they had an arguably better match this time around than they did in San Antonio.

However, the match of the night was undoubtedly Authors of Pain vs. #DIY vs. The Revival for the NXT Tag Team Championship. All three teams had spectacular showings and never gave the fans in attendance the chance to take their seats. It was tag team wrestling at its finest.

The Bad: For the first time since 2014, NXT was not the talk of WrestleMania weekend. Granted, the brand held its TakeOver: Orlando event the night before the 'Show of Shows', but WrestleMania 33 simply provided more thrills and was a better show overall.

That said, TakeOver: Orlando was still an entertaining event from start to finish, albeit uneventful outside of Drew McIntyre's shocking appearance at ringside. That was due to no titles changing hands, and while there wasn't a bad bout on the entire show, it didn't have that same "must-see" aura of past installments.


10. TakeOver: San Antonio

NXT Takeover SanAntonio Show Roode
WWE

The Highlights: Paradoxically, TakeOver: San Antonio benefited from having very little buzz heading into it. By and large, NXT has been a relatively hot brand in some form or fashion over the last the three years, but the build to the San Antonio special was almost nonexistent.

As such, it was an enjoyable evening that exceeded everyone's expectations. Although there were only five matches, each of them had something special to offer, including the NXT Championship main event between Shinsuke Nakamura and Bobby Roode. Andrade 'Cien' Almas and Roderick Strong also surprised a lot of people with their hard-hitting affair on the undercard.

The Low Points: For all intents and purpose, the NXT Women's Championship Fatal 4-Way was a ton of fun, but it paled in comparison to the standard that had been set by past women's matches in NXT. At only 10 minutes long, it was nothing to write home about.

Meanwhile, Tye Dillinger and Eric Young didn't open the event on the hottest note. They picked up the pace down the stretch, but Dillinger losing yet again when it mattered most was a bit of a downer.


9. TakeOver: Unstoppable

NXT TakeOver Arrival
WWE

The Highlights: By May 2015, NXT's TakeOver specials had become some of the most anticipated events of the year, and TakeOver: Unstoppable wasn't about to break that strong streak. Even with Hideo Itami out injured, Finn Bálor and Tyler Breeze still contested a nice match in the opening slot, but it was the women that stole the show when Becky Lynch and Sasha Banks contested a classic.

For the second straight special, Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn failed to produce the thrilling main event fans knew they could have, but the storytelling was spectacular. Besides, the unannounced debut of Samoa Joe more than made up for it.

The Low Points: Alexa Bliss turning heel and costing Enzo Amore and Colin Cassady their NXT Tag Team Championship match against Blake and Murphy was cool, but the match itself left a lot to be desired. Baron Corbin vs. Rhyno wasn't much better, and although it was a competent contest which didn't last long, it was largely a snore-fest.

Including the second women's match, which saw Charlotte and Bayley team up against Emma and Dana Brooke, is merely nitpicking, but it didn't serve much of a purpose other than to get them on the card.


8. TakeOver: Arrival

NXT Takeover Zayn Breeze
WWE

The Highlights: No one knew what to expect from NXT's inaugural live special on the WWE Network, especially those who hadn't watched the product since its days as a crappy competition show. This event was intended to wipe away that previous perception of the program and instead introduce the audience to what would be the future of WWE.

Sure enough, the event accomplished that goal. Cesaro and Sami Zayn opened Arrival with an absolute thriller that came close to topping their 2-out-of-3 Falls match from the prior summer, while Paige and Emma kicked off the real women's revolution in WWE with their phenomenal outing. Additionally, the Ladder match in the main event saw Adrian Neville end Bo Dallas' then-record-setting reign as NXT champion.

The Low Points: The marquee matches surely delivered, but fans tend to forget about the awful undercard for Arrival. The Ascension vs. Too Cool (no, seriously) for the NXT Tag Team Championship was fine yet forgettable, Mojo Rawley vs. CJ Parker was a bout that belonged on NXT TV, and Tyler Breeze vs. Xavier Woods never even got underway.

Nevertheless, the main matches are what made this show a success.


7. TakeOver: Respect

Samoa Joe Finn Balor Rhodes NXT TakeOver Respect
WWE

The Highlights: After the major milestone that was TakeOver: Brooklyn, the subsequent special was designed to be a bit of a "cool-down" show before they went overseas for TakeOver: London. However, it turned out to be much more than that and virtually every match held its own, resulting in an exceptional event on the whole.

The main focus of TakeOver: Respect was the Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic, meant to honor the late, great Dusty Rhodes. All three tag team matches were solid, but Respect will forever be remembered as the night Bayley and Sasha Banks took center stage and made history with their 30-minute Iron Man main event match.

The Low Points: It's hard to nitpick anything individually from Respect, but it did lack a few memorable moments outside of the women's main event. The NXT Women's Championship was the only title defended with then-NXT champion Finn Bálor already pulling double duty and then-NXT Tag Team champions The Vaudevillians not making the card.

It would have been helpful if the tournament launched a new tag team and had not been won by two established stars in Bálor and Samoa Joe, but the post-match celebration was worth it.


6. TakeOver: Toronto

gargano dawson toronto takeover
WWE.com

The Highlights: After conquering several major cities in the United States and even England, it was time for NXT to travel to The Great White North. The audience was electric all night long at TakeOver: Toronto and made Bobby Roode vs. Tye Dillinger a better bout than it likely should have been, due to both men having Canadian roots.

In addition to Shinsuke Nakamura and Samoa Joe producing yet another above-average main event match, #DIY and The Revival contested arguably the greatest match of 2016. Their masterpiece of a matchup over the NXT Tag Team Championship was a thing of beauty and culminated in an emotional title victory for Johnny Gargano and Tomasso Ciampa.

The Low Points: Fans don't currently look back at TakeOver: Toronto as being among the most epic installments ever, but why? Sure, the build-up heading into the event was underwhelming, but everything on the card was either good, great or amazing. If anything, Authors of Pain vs. TM-61 was merely decent but only because the rest of the event was so stellar in comparison.


5. TakeOver: Brooklyn 2

Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE.com

The Highlights: Although it's tough to top the original, TakeOver: Brooklyn 2 certainly came close to capturing the same magic from the first installment emanating from Brooklyn one year earlier. The main matches from TakeOver: Brooklyn were more monumental, but the sequel had a better card overall.

The Revival contested yet another incredible outing when they defended their NXT Tag Team Championship against #DIY, while Asuka and Bayley had the exhilarating match they should have had in Dallas. Finally, Shinsuke Nakamura's epic entrance was one for the ages, and his grand NXT Championship victory was only icing on the cake.

The Low Points: As we enter the top five, the low points will mostly consist of nitpicking. For example, Bobby Roode came off like a total star following his first entrance as an NXT Superstar, but his subsequent match with Andrade 'Cien' Almas was nothing special. Additionally, Ember Moon had a memorable debut, but the crowd sat on their hands for the match itself between her and Billie Kay until the finish.


4. TakeOver: Rival

NXT TakeOver Rival
WWE

The Highlights: As NXT prepared to celebrate one year on the WWE Network, the black-and-yellow brand commemorated the occasion with a tremendous TakeOver: Rival special in February 2015. Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn quickly became one of the most anticipated main events in years, and after Owens' ruthless annihilation of his former friend, he was declared the new NXT champion.

Elsewhere on the card, The Four Horsewomen clashed in a fantastic Fatal 4-Way that saw Sasha Banks clinch her first NXT Women's Championship. Finn Bálor and Neville followed close behind with a brutal battle of their own, serving as a fitting swan song for Neville from NXT.

The Low Points: With three such sensational matches taking place toward the top of the card, it's hard to complain about anything else. That said, Baron Corbin and Bull Dempsey stunk up the joint in a below-average No Disqualification match that was best kept short and sweet.

Furthermore, Blake and Murphy vs. The Lucha Dragons for the NXT Tag Team Championship was fine, but the former pair were still trying to find their footing as champs and the match suffered as a result.


3. TakeOver: R Evolution

Sami Zayn Neville NXT
WWE.com

The Highlights: As remarkable as Rival was, it just wasn't quite as magical as TakeOver: R Evolution, which took place two months earlier. Not only did the event see several storylines reach their climax, this show set the stage for the future of the brand with a number of up-and-comers officially solidifying their spot in NXT.

Kevin Owens' long awaited arrival kicked off the night on a newsworthy note, Finn Bálor debuted his "Demon" persona in his thrilling tag team match against The Ascension, and Charlotte and Sasha Banks took their rivalry to new heights with one of the best women's matches all year.

In a battle of best friends, Sami Zayn toppled Neville in a captivating contest to capture the NXT Championship, only to be betrayed by Owens immediately afterward. That compelling cliffhanger gave viewers something to look forward to in the months to come.

The Low Points: Baron Corbin's quick squash against Tye Dillinger (pre-Perfect 10) was uneventful, but it furthered Corbin's feud with Bull Dempsey. Likewise, the NXT Tag Team Championship match between The Lucha Dragons and The Vaudevillians was adequate, but most fans couldn't have cared less.


2. TakeOver: Brooklyn

sasha banks bayley
WWE.com

The Highlights: The first five NXT live specials were all incredible, but TakeOver had yet to travel outside of Florida. Thus, with SummerSlam emanating from the Barclays Center in Brooklyn, the timing could not have been better for the black-and-yellow brand to emerge as the hottest commodity in all of wrestling.

From the NXT Tag Team Championship changing hands to Jushin 'Thunder' Liger wrestling his first WWE match to Apollo Crews arriving on the scene, the undercard was filled with incredible moments.

The NXT Championship Ladder match between Kevin Owens and Finn Bálor definitely delivered in being a complete war from bell to bell, but the true main event was Bayley vs. Sasha Banks. Their five star mat classic featured some of the best storytelling WWE has done in years and saw Bayley finally reach the mountaintop by becoming the new NXT Women's champion.

The Low Points: As much of a treat as Liger vs. Tyler Breeze was, it didn't do anything to elevate Breeze, nor was the match as good as it could have been. The Vaudevillians winning the tag titles was cool as well, but only the final few minutes made it memorable.


1. TakeOver: Dallas

nakamura zayn
WWE.com

The Highlights: With such a stacked card, sometimes it's difficult to live up to the hype, but NXT managed to do just that with TakeOver: Dallas 48 hours ahead of WrestleMania 32. While WrestleMania ultimately left fans disappointed, TakeOver proved to be the best part about WrestleMania weekend in 2016.

To open the event, American Alpha beat The Revival in an awesome affair to win the NXT Tag Team Championship, Austin Aries arrived on the scene by beating Baron Corbin in impressive fashion, and Asuka continued her dominance over the women's division by knocking off Bayley for the NXT Women's Championship.

The sequel isn't always as great as the original, but Finn Bálor and Samoa Joe's bloody battle was an improvement over their encounter in London. Of course, TakeOver: Dallas should be considered the best installment of all-time for the instant classic between Shinsuke Nakamura vs. Sami Zayn alone.

The Low Points: Other than Aries vs. Corbin not being a barn-burner of a bout and Asuka and Bayley having a better match in Brooklyn, this was as flawless of a show as NXT might ever have.


Contributor
Contributor

Since 2008, Graham has been a diehard pro wrestling fan and, in 2010, he combined his passions for WWE and writing when he joined Bleacher Report. Equipped with a master's in journalism, Graham has contributed to WhatCulture, FanSided's Daily DDT, Sports Betting Dime, and GateHouse Media. Along the way, he has conducted interviews with wrestling superstars like Chris Jericho, Edge, Goldberg, Christian, Diamond Dallas Page, Jim Ross, Adam Cole, Tessa Blanchard, Ryback, and Nick Aldis among others.