Ranking EVERY Undertaker Vs Kane Match From Worst To Best

Every episode of WWE's original Horror Show.

Undertaker, Kane, WrestleMania XIV
WWE.com

The Undertaker and Kane like a spot where they both go for the chokeslam at the same time.

It's a simple but effective visual that reminds the audience of their familial parity as well as their remarkable size and reach. The two storyline brothers always looked enough like they could be related based on how much they towered over their opponents, and often relied on the mirror image bit to buy them time or audience participation if a match went off the rails.

And a few of these did just that, if they were ever on them.

If you're an Undertaker and/or Kane superfan, please consider that ahead of reading this list and flying into a blind fury. Neither man would likely posit the other as their best in-ring opponent, yet both stand as monuments to WWE's occasionally great gimmick factory, fully deserving of the celebration their careers will receive long after they've left this mortal coil. Actually left it, as opposed to all the times they pretended to.

Anyway, the bad outweighs the good here, but the magic of revisiting this series compared to something like the John Cena/Randy Orton feuds is the manner in which WWE went about protecting their investments when the two faced off. Several are gimmicked to f*ck, whilst others have so much going on around them that it was as if the company knew the work itself needed to play second fiddle.

Not a bad gig, especially when your first is 'The Rattlesnake' himself....

15. Judgment Day (October 18th, 1998)

undertaker kane judgment day
WWE.com

The above image captures Undertaker and Kane working some sort of leg grapevine thing in a not-unfamiliar rendering of a Diesel/British Bulldog pay-per-view main event precisely three years prior.

Why does this matter? Not because both shows took place in October, nor because both sought to determine the undisputed WWE Champion, but because both matches were - in Vince McMahon's own 1995 words - "f*cking horrible".

The Chairman stormed backstage after the Big Daddy Cool/Davey Boy Smith debacle, but was probably in slightly better fettle as he waited in his supervillain's lair behind the TitanTron to fire Stone Cold Steve Austin for not counting a pinfall to end this wretched display.

To quickly summarise the story - and f*cking hell if only they had - the Brothers Of Destruction plodded on for 17 laborious minutes with guest referee Stone Cold Steve Austin adding flashes of colour before 'The Rattlesnake' counted them both down and out for three so not to award either new WWE Champion. He was kayfabe fired to close the show, but McMahon should have turned his ire on whomever pitched this stinker.


14. SummerSlam 2000 (August 27th, 2000)

Kane Undertaker
WWE

A unfinished non-match wasn't exactly the return to an old feud fans were expecting when WWE presented the first version of an Undertaker/Kane contest with 'The Deadman' cast as 'The American Bad Ass', but the entire presentation got away with being part of a pay-per-view too fantastic for anybody to really give a sh*t.

Elsewhere on SummerSlam 2000, The Rock and Triple H improvise a quality main event until a concussed Kurt Angle miraculously remembers his vital role, Shane McMahon fell a hundred million feet or so thanks to a kendo stick attack from Steve Blackman, and the entire tag team division changed the game again with a TLC upgrade to a WrestleMania show stealer.

Here, Undertaker punched and punched and punched and stole obsessed over Kane's mask until he...got it. Understandably rattled, 'The Big Red Machine' bailed to the back. Match over, storyline not. But more on that later, when the work got marginally better.


13. Hell In A Cell (October 3rd, 2010)

Undertaker Kane
WWE

The worst of an unexpected 2010 trilogy between the two, Undertaker's loss to Kane at Hell In A Cell was supposed to feel loaded with all sorts of pathos and story and craft and the various other synonyms for Actually Good Pro Wrestling the Sports Entertainment company had largely done away with at the turn of the decade.

Instead, the pair had yet another big bruiser bore, undermining the structure surrounding them even more than the fact that the equally boring Randy Orton/Sheamus scrap in there an hour earlier.

Leaning on the past when the match realistically had no place in the present, the company brought back Paul Bearer to side with The Undertaker against his own son, before revealing the set-up all along (etc) on the night itself.

The finish called for Bearer to shine a spotlight from the Urn in Undertaker's face during a Tombstone attempt, then hand it to Kane for him to complete the devilish deed. That this called for 'The Deadman' to kill the lights for no reason was stupid enough without the entire thing playing out in perplexing slow motion. As far as wrestling actors go, Undertaker, Kane and Bearer aren't the worst, but three industry icons were being made to look like hacks, and they knew it.


12. Survivor Series 1998 (November 15th, 1998)

Kane Undertaker
WWE.com

The first of their matches to openly reflect a change in heel/face dynamics between the two after The Undertaker reunited with Paul Bearer at Judgment Day a month prior, this Survivor Series tournament clash was kept lean by comparison - but that's about the kindest sentiment it warrants.

The 1998 Autumn extravaganza was famously dedicated to the layered and intricate Deadly Game tournament ultimately won by The Rock thanks to the careful plot construction of the McMahon family on-screen and Vince Russo off. The thread throughout the night successfully sought to thrill, but even with all matches taking a back seat to the story, this one still ranked quite low.

The confines of pay-per-view and the bracket concept for the show only afforded them seven minutes. And though it was nice to see most of the hits without ten extra minutes of the sh*ts, there was clearly still a problem capturing the majesty of their WrestleMania match or the energy of a surprising TV belter (more on that later) on a more consistent basis. More's the pity - they fought a lot.


11. Raw (November 27th, 2000)

At least it was short.

Four minutes on a 2000 edition of Monday Night Raw isn't enough to get hot over, but luckily for the wrestlers nobody ever told Attitude Era crowds.

Kane and his bike-riding brother have another lumbering f*ckabout here before Edge, Christian and Kurt Angle rush the ring at the end to lay a beating on 'The Deadman' that 'The Big Red Machine' simply joins in on just for the craic and to park their hostilities for another three years or so.

The pair had been on the periphery of the World Title picture in a post-SummerSlam period for the company that retrospectively hid the gentle creative decline, but neither looked in the same league as Champion Kurt Angle, a rejuvenated Steve Austin or Triple H and The Rock working an in-ring levels they'd never reach after 2001. Naturally, The Brothers Of Destruction were slotted in for two more months at the top coming out of WrestleMania X-Seven.


10. Raw (February 22nd, 1999)

Kane Undertaker
WWE

An inferior sequel to the original, but not a bad time all told thanks to the audacity of WWE giving it away on television with minimal promotion and a literal ring of fire being used to feed into a story that would eventually make no sense at all between The Undertaker and Vince McMahon.

Strap in because it's more Russo stuff that takes more unpacking than the equipment required to set this batsh*t match up.

Kane was the Corporation's trapped goon, kept either medicated or sectioned depending on the dialogue that week. Undertaker had returned a month and a bit earlier with no moustache and his own Ministry, with a view to take control of the entire company. Decking his brother was icing atop his layer cake - 'The Deadman' reduced The Chairman to his knees by setting Stephanie McMahon's childhood teddy on fire and Kane's boot ablaze. 1999 looked the same as 1998, but things were getting weird.


9. Raw (June 1st, 1998)

It's inadvertently amusing watching Kane do the "I want the belt gesture" to Stone Cold Steve Austin after his first victory over his storyline brother just before another red hot 1998 edition of Monday Night Raw went off the air.

Ahead of 'The Big Red Machine' saying he'd setting himself on fire (fire fire fire every f*cking angle with this guy...) if he lost to Austin at the King Of The Ring, it spoke to Kane's progression beyond the monster-of-the-week spot he'd secured that he'd managed to secure a title match at all.

Not to drag down every single one of their matches, but 'The Rattlesnake' and Vince McMahon stole the show from ringside on commentary. A buzzing audience enjoyed The Undertaker decking Paul Bearer, Mankind's run-in at the conclusion and every time the TitanTron flashed up scenes of McMahon and Austin at the desk, but could only summon mild enthusiasm for Kane's Tombstone victory.


8. Night Of Champions (September 19th, 2010)

Kane Undertaker
WWE

And so to the second of a 2010 trilogy between one man that had quietly passed his in-ring peak and another that never truly found one outside of dearly beloved tag team unites with smaller guys.

For context, consider that this match came four months after 'The Deadman's epic sending off of Shawn Michaels at WrestleMania XXVI and another six or so before he'd assemble another 'Show Of Shows' success with Triple H. He was starting to feel like a once-a-year guy before he actually became one, but feuds like this and the other programmes he bothered with in between are sometimes better left forgotten.

Fought under No Holds Barred rules after Kane had supposedly left his sibling in a "vegetative state" earlier in the year, the freedom of movement helped move an ordinary layout into something approaching decent. Considering the stipulations they had in store for the rematches, this environment exploration was relatively milquetoast.


7. Mayhem In Manchester (April 4th, 1998)

Somehow, this worked.

Looking now as if the crack WWE production crew were using jersey royals instead of their top-of-the-range kit, the pair barely took breaths between battering each other thanks to a litany of production issues that Undertaker himself literally had to wear for the duration of the match.

'The Deadman' was a victim of lost luggage before a show that had once been pitched as a pay-per-view before the company changed course and reverted to standard house show rules instead. Some partial promotion resulted in the recording the company ultimately released, giving the entire thing a certain calamitous air.

To their credit, WWE tried to make it appear as if D-Generation X had attacked Undertaker before he could get all costumed up, resulting in the brothers having a frenzied brawl before a babyface win sent the fans home happy. It couldn't match the grandiosity of their brawl a week earlier, but as a snakebitten house show main event, it could have been substantially worse.

And about their prior match...


6. Raw (October 19th, 1998)

Undertaker Kane
WWE

This completely forgotten casket match is frankly too fun for it's own good.

With their unholy union fractured by a shared thirst for the vacant WWE Championship, the pair hold nothing back in a match that sees the coffin take as big a beating as the men themselves.

A fist fight in a double deep double wide box that looks Yokozuna-ready spills out of countrol when 'The Deadman' drills his brother with a DDT inside of it. The lid closes on both, but the casket comically rattles and shakes as if it were a cartoon prop. But then wait, it is a cartoon - the thing gets ripped to f*cking pieces as the pair fight around the broken wood and felt, with Undertaker flying from the ring with a crap aerial assault beford smashing the sh*t out of his storyline sibling with a chair shot to the back.

And that's the whole stupid bloody thing. It was a different but eerily familiar time.


5. WrestleMania XIV (March 29th, 1998)

Wrestlemania 14 Kane The Undertaker
WWE.com

Still hard to determine if this was supremely well-worked or a touch on the cocky side, but The Undertaker and Kane's first bout against one another felt every bit as big as the near-one year story that fed into it.

1997's summer introduction of the character to canon before his formal arrival in October was twisted yet elegant stuff from a company starting to find a new creative voice thanks to the brash New Yorker lending his to the top table. Elaborate and potentially very silly, the tales told by Paul Bearer of Kane's tortured past and The Undertaker's grim future were only going to be as good as the eventual reveal.

Kane's role was destroy, but when setting fire to The Undertaker at the Royal Rumble (!) didn't put him away for good, 'The Big Red Machine' had to rely on his own supernatural strength in a decent hoss battle enhanced by Undertaker taking an announce table to the face from his big match dive.

It's remembered more for Pete Rose than the 17 minutes that followed, but don't hold that against it.


4. Bragging Rights (October 24th, 2010)

Undertaker Kane Buried Alive
WWE.com

Go big on bullsh*t, or go home.

Here, WWE went huge. Digging out the Buried Alive stipulation for the first time in seven years, the company had the perfect pair for it in The Undertaker and Kane, not least with a World Title to decide and an actual feud to end all at once.

In a year that saw the latest sibling squabble by the two undercooked due to The Nexus angle being talk of the entire company, it was perhaps fitting that 'The Deadman' and his demonic brother would have such an entertaining scrap right at the time Wade Barrett and his cronies decided to get involved.

Winning all three of their battles but saving this one for last, Kane enlisted the crew to ensure he got the victory, and such had become the way things worked in WWE by then, got away with it! Their relationship didn't exist beyond the pay-per-view, and Undertaker returned in the Spring only to be immediately challenged by Triple H due to his deeming that absolutely nobody else backstage deserved the spot.


3. WrestleMania XX (March 14th, 2004)

Kane The Undertaker WrestleMania XX
WWE.com

All sizzle and minimal steak, this, but on a show with so much stuff going on it was actually quite nice that an Undertaker/Kane match focussed on the stuff people almost universally enjoy about these specific characters.

'The Big Red Machine' had buried his brother alive at the prior Survivor Series to reincarnate the American Bad A*s as his original self, but the inclusion of Paul Bearer, a host of druids and the spectre of Madison Square Garden itself did much to cultivate the atmosphere WWE had hoped to cultivate in bringing a beloved creation back from the Sports Entertainment dead.

Much like Kane's character itself (for the first ten years at least), this didn't outstay its welcome and did just enough to ensure Kane got the comeuppance he deserved for being a unprovoked sh*thead a few months earlier. Good for The Undertaker and the company for providing that catharsis, and for the fans that paid a pretty penny to see it in person.


2. Unforgiven: In Your House (April 26th, 1998)

Kane The Undertaker Inferno Match
WWE.com

In WWE canon, the Inferno Match came from the twisted dreams of Paul Bearer, smarting after Kane's WrestleMania defeat at the hands of The Undertaker. A contest designed to give 'The Deadman' a grimmer fate than a mere pinfall loss, the entire pay-per-view was sold on just want on earth this hellscape might look like.

In execution, never was the literal fire and figurative fury of this inherently stupid stipulation captured better than in its original incarnation.

That it was on Earth was perhaps the only issue. There was something rather mechanical about the original aesthetic, but fans sharp lost interest in all that boring stuff when the flames magically responded to high spots! Reaching for the rafters every time one of them got any air time, this unique addition made an already-incredible aesthetic even better.

The highlights came late - 'The Deadman' did his iconic dive over the tips of rising flames, before Kane's arm brushed against the blaze. He ran off to the back, before we all saw him burned alive, frustrating the most disturbed of WWE's predominantely male 18-30 demographic at the time.


1. SmackDown (April 4th, 2008)

Kane Undertaker
WWE

And to the best of the bunch, with the two somehow assembling a minor workrate classic despite having just nine minutes and a no-contest to work with.

As World and ECW Champions respectively, The Undertaker and Kane were coming off hugely successful WrestleManias whilst both enjoying second lives between the ropes. 'The Big Red Machine' secured the ECW Championship in just 11 seconds, giving plenty of time for Edge and 'The Deadman' to contest one of the stronger 'Show Of Show' main events in the show's history.

Subsequently on fertile ground with impending rematches against the defeated champions as well as the other technical rivals on the horizon, the Brothers Of Destruction levelled up here and in general as working babyfaces as part of their relatively fresh directions. Ever the total b*stards, the former titleholders played spoilers here - their 'La Familia' group ran in to deck the pair of them, robbing a surprisingly enjoyable television tussle of the finish it deserved.


Watch Next


The Undertaker Returns WWE Quiz: How Well Do You Remember His Comebacks?

The Undertaker 2006 return
WWE.com

1. Who Had Kane Just Defeated When The Undertaker Returned At SummerSlam 2010?

Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.