Ranking EVERY WWE Elimination Chamber Match From Worst To Best

Ranking nearly 20 years of brutality and occasional brilliance inside WWE's big mesh monster.

Edge Elimination Chamber
WWE

An expensive undertaking eventually done-good for WWE, the Elimination Chamber has persistently promised more than it's been able to deliver over the years, but the company's insertion of it into WrestleMania season in the late 2000s added value to a stipulation sometimes too grandiose for its own good.

The stakes - a title or title shot, depending on post-Rumble permutations - have routinely advanced the outing beyond its structural and creative limitations. Since the gimmick's inception at November 2002's Survivor Series, the ginormous steel structure has been carted out over 25 times over nearly two decades, hosting countless WWE/World Heavyweight Title matches, WrestleMania opportunities, the launch of the Women's Tag Team Champions titles and two more cases of duos squeezing into pods.

But more is always more in WWE - the gimmick hasn't remained as protected as it probably should have been. Several matches have taken place merely because they had to, rather than because a conflict or storyline truly warranted the entrapment. The same complaint that has diluted Hell In A Cell and Tables, Ladders and Chairs can be applied to this post-Royal Rumble skirmish too, but its record isn't half bad. Literally so - just over half of them are worth a rewatch.

And as for some of the rest?

26. 2015 (Intercontinental Title)

Dolph Ziggler Wade Barrett Elimination Chamber
WWE.com

Competing for the vacant Intercontinental Title after the secondary belt was vacated by the injured Daniel Bryan, Ryback, King Barrett, Dolph Ziggler, R-Truth, Mark Henry and Sheamus entered in a spirited display that aimed to restore balance back to the underwhelming midcard at the time.

Only when stability was so desperately needed could a contest fall apart so horrifically.

Midway through the clash, Dolph Ziggler was thrown into Mark Henry's pod breaking the plexiglass and allowing 'The World's Strongest Man' an early start in the contest. This drew distracting questions from commentators as to if Henry was yet a legal participant which (like Henry's involvement in the match in general) were eventually forgotten along whatever else had been pencilled in.

Further to that, an attempt to ape an old Chamber spot with a broken door fell flat - Sheamus let himself into he match as the last entrant, which was the draw he'd received anyway.

The final sections were similarly devoid of drama, with Ryback pinning 'The Celtic Warrior' in an anaemic ending played out to a largely bored crowd. Only 'The Big Guy's crowning by former champion Bryan generated any sort of reaction Chamber matches usually generate.


25. 2006 (December To Dismember)

Test Elimination Chamber
WWE.com

December To December 2006 as an event was able to offer the worst incarnation of everything wrestling's capable of, and it's contribution to the history of the Elimination Chamber is no different.

Adding weapons to the gimmick to give it an 'Extreme' edge in Vince McMahon's disgracefully mishandled vision of what a modern day ECW product should be, the match was a catastrophe through to the bitter end, when Bobby Lashley would topple an injured and overweight Big Show to capture the brand's Heavyweight Title much to the chagrin of the capacity crowd.

Going into the match, sentimental favourites were the unbeaten newcomer CM Punk, and perennial ECW favourites Rob Van Dam and Sabu, starkly contrasting stereotypical WWE monsters Show, Lashley and Test. In another spectacular troll job on his audience, Vince then booked Sabu to get decked before even entering, allowing Hardcore Holly into the chamber in his place.

As if to drive the knife in further, CM Punk was next eliminated, by last remaining babyface RVD no less.

Van Dam himself was despatched minutes later by Test, who was yet another pariah that represented absolutely nothing the live crowd had paid to see.


24. 2015 (Tag Team)

New Day Elimination Chamber
WWE.com

An interesting idea in theory, the Tag Team Elimination Chamber WWE experimented with on their 2015 Network Special ended up as a muddled, clunky affair.

Despite their position as sly heels at the time, The New Day entered in the most advantageous position, and were further allowed to outsmart their opponents with a numerical advantage over each of the remaining duos in an easy defence of their Tag Team Titles.

With The Ascension and The Lucha Dragons already defeated before the Champions even entered, their task was not particularly challenging, other than trying to bring the crowd back into it after a high spot-gone-bad.

The convoluted stunt was the the low point of the entire match. Kalisto aimed to steal the show with a dive from the centre of the Chamber - something never previously attempted in the match. However, it took 'The King of Flight' so long to ascend the cage that his opponents were made to look foolish waiting around in the middle of the ring to simply be fallen upon. It looked totally contrived, and JBL's candour on commentary referring to it as 'dumb' was unusually welcome.


23. 2010 (Raw)

Elimination Chamber
WWE.com

Outside of the stirring conclusion in which Triple H tapped out to eventual winner John Cena, Raw's contribution to the February Pay-Per-View served only to provide an inferior tribute to a famous Chamber moment.

Sacrificing the rare clean submission from 'The Game', Sheamus' maiden WWE Title reign, and big match opportunities for Ted Dibiase Jr and Kofi Kingston, the entire brawl was instantly forgotten when Vince McMahon announced an immediate title defence for Cena against Dave Batista.

Serving the shattered Cena on a platter to 'The Animal' as he had done four years earlier to Edge (more on that later), McMahon repaid a favour to Batista for helping him in his feud with Bret Hart, and in doing so, ended Cena's title reign after less than a minute.

Though Batista had been excellent in his run as an obnoxious, arrogant heel at that point, it seemed a spurious way to build to their WrestleMania 26 rematch, and frustratingly rendered the preceding thirty minutes in the Chamber completely pointless.


22. 2013

Jack Swagger Randy Orton Elimination Chamber
WWE.com

The aggressive 2013 megapush for the 'All American American' steamrolled its way through an entire Chamber match and WrestleMania buildup, as the Tea Party rhetoric-spewing Zeb Colter joined forces with Jack Swagger to take down struggling babyface World Heavyweight Champion Alberto Del Rio.

Swagger's run on television and Colter's emotive verbiage telegraphed the finish of the Elimination Chamber, which seemed even more ludicrous in light of the fact he was sharing the ring with Randy Orton, Daniel Bryan, Kane and Chris Jericho.

In an effort to elevate Swagger well beyond his status, those particular stars were thoughtlessly sacrificed, with then-tag team champions Bryan and Kane dismantled by Mark Henry, who himself would suffer an RKO alongside Chris Jericho, as Randy Orton looked set for victory.

Rolling up the dominant 'Viper' in an intentionally fortuitous conclusion immediately after he'd despatched 'Y2J', Swagger looked every bit the chancer audiences already thought he was.

Regrettably, Swagger was stung with an ill-timed DUI just weeks before his huge WrestleMania match.

With a black mark against his name and audience apathy for his act on the rise, he was rapidly de-pushed, rendering much of the belligerent bluster around the show utterly useless.


21. 2009 (Smackdown)

Triple H No Way Out 2009
WWE

Despite a star-studded line-up including The Undertaker, Triple H and The Big Show, the WWE Title match at the 'No Way Out' pay-per-view peaked in the first few minutes with an innovative twist on the concept, and struggled to recover from the initial shocker.

Entering as defending champion, Edge had to start the match against former titleholder Jeff Hardy, but in a legitimate surprise, got caught with an inside cradle from a spear attempt less than three minutes into the match. The pinfall turned the match upside down, guaranteeing a new WWE Champion and robbing 'The Rated-R Superstar' of his precious prize.

It also added tremendous suspense to the second Chamber match on the card, as Edge desperately attempted to get back into a WrestleMania main event (more on that later). However, despite the certainty of a new champion, the match simply had nowhere to go afterwards.

Vladimir Kozlov and The Big Show were comfortably dispatched, and the anticlimactic departure of sentimental favourite Jeff Hardy left the crowd apathetic to the final stand-off between Triple H and The Undertaker.

A victory for Triple H would ultimately see the title itself leave Smackdown, as the dying embers of the original Brand Extension were extinguished further to promote tepid WrestleMania 25 title feuds on both shows.


20. 2020 (SmackDown Tag Team Championship)

Otis Elimination Chamber
WWE.com

As stewards of modern day tag wrestling in WWE, The New Day and The Usos anchored a better second attempt at the doubles chamber, even if the resultant contest didn't exactly sell the concept as must-see.

Too many mad high spots missed, diluting the decent ones that hit. The generous "This Is Awesome" chant after a Gran Metalik hurricanrana on John Morrison felt like a case of the crowd fighting for the wrestlers, and they were rewarded somewhat when when Tucker wiped out the entire field with a dive from a pod and Otis ploughed through another all the way to the floor.

Big E and Kofi Kingston bit the dust when retaining Champions Miz and Morison piled on Kofi after a missed dive. They trapped The Usos to reclaim in a noble conclusion to a noble festival of banter that spoke more to Vince McMahon's wider disinterest in tag wrestling that the performers' collected efforts.


19. 2011 (Smackdown)

edge rey mysterio elimination chamber
wwe.com

Showing dominance in the Chamber in his penultimate Pay-Per-View match ever, Edge's victory in the World Title clash would mark the first time in five years a World Champion had retained their title in the structure.

Despite a fabulous closing spot in which 'The Rated-R Superstar' caught Rey Mysterio in mid-air with a spear, the match struggled to get out of the blocks with an indifferent cast and little doubt of who would be facing Royal Rumble winner Alberto Del Rio at WrestleMania 27.

Making up the numbers, The Big Show, Wade Barrett, Kane & Drew McIntyre used all the usual high-volume Chamber shortcuts, but the booking was ultimately unable to work around the predictability, with fans mainly sitting on their hands until the tantalising final stretch.

Furthermore, the post-match action dominated discussion, with Christian making a surprise return from injury to save Edge from a Del Rio beatdown and help build the clash at the 'Show of Shows' that would see the former 'brothers' unite against Del Rio and his new heavy Brodus Clay.


18. 2006 (New Year's Revolution)

Elimination Chamber
WWE.com

A match remembered more for the post-match drama than any antics within the Chamber, the 'New Year's Revolution' main event marked the final successful defence of John Cena's inaugural run with the WWE Title, and played into his immediate surrender of that very prize.

The Chamber match itself actually proved rather experimental, with experienced hands Kurt Angle, Kane and Shawn Michaels anchoring the title contest with relative newcomers John Cena, Carlito and Chris Masters.

The booking of the match played to the disparity, with Carlito and Masters working in tandem to surprisingly make it down to the final three with the defending champion. To be fair to 'The Doctor of Thuganomics', he'd go the distance too, working from the very beginnning and taking an admirable beating from every opponent, including a brutal DDT on the steel grating from Chris Masters that left him battered and bloodied.

This only played into the immediate aftermath further, as Vince McMahon emerged to confirm that the first ever 'Money In The Bank' cash-in was taking place right there.

Edge would famously take full advantage of the Cena's altered state, winning the WWE title and setting the template for nearly every briefcase cash-in since.


17. 2012 (Raw)

Chris Jericho Elimination Chamber
WWE.com

Working the entire Chamber match, defending titleholder CM Punk was the highlight of the 2012 match exactly as he had been the previous year.

Mugging with his title right in the face of each of his opponents, Punk defied the odds as he remained determined to make it to WrestleMania as WWE Champion.

Further building to his feud with Chris Jericho at the 'Show of Shows', Punk eliminated R-Truth with his sloppy elbow drop leaping from the post right in front of 'Y2J's pod, then added insult to injury by literally booting him out of the Chamber and knocking him cold shortly after Jericho had eliminated Kofi Kingston.

With Punk, the announcers and ringside referees treating the situation as seriously as possible, the match was left to the 'Voice of the Voiceless' and the previous year's WrestleMania main eventer The Miz, who nearly stole the title with a fabulous 'Skull Crushing Finale' from a Punk springboard attack.

With his eventual victory, CM Punk looked like a true WWE headliner for the first time since scooping the title in November, and Jericho was able to argue his way into a title shot due to never suffering formal elimination from the Chamber.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.