Ranking Every WWE To AEW Move From Worst To Best

23. Ruby Soho

Ruby Soho
AEW

The sheer sound that met the one-time Ruby Riott upon making her AEW debut at All Out 2021 told the story of a talent who was grossly under-utilised during her limp spell within WWE's borders.

Settling into the role of dependable babyface from minute one, the newly christened Soho got things off to winning start in a Casino Battle Royale before competing for the AEW Women's World and TBS Championships later down the road.

And while she may not have come out on top in either of those scenarios, Soho's ability to extract every ounce of drama and excitement out of a sequence and match-up in general have made her one of the devision's clear MVPs.

The perennial bridesmaid's time is coming. But similarly to the likes of pal Eddie Kingston, she'll likely have to nurse a few more soul-crushing defeats before triumphantly reaching the top of the mountain.


22. Buddy Matthews

Buddy Matthews Malakai Black
AEW

On the back of an often hilariously awkward presentation towards the latter stages of his hit-and-miss WWE run, anything other than the sight of Buddy Matthews getting involved with a 19-year-old daughter of a wrestling veteran on national television was always going to be classed as an improvement.

Sure enough, despite his All Elite debut also sitting as a signing few were genuinely clamouring for back in February, the House of Black member has quietly gone about doing his business in some of the most enthralling trios encounters the company have committed to television in recent times.

His rather enjoyable clash with PAC in June also served as a reminder of the gifted singles performer still housed within the one-time Murphy as well.

So, if Matthews finds a way to effectively transfer the sort of captivating energy found within his faction's edge-of-your-seat wars with Death Triangle into his one-on-one AEW showings in the coming years, Tony Khan may have just played a blinder in landing this Aussie menace.


21. Stokely Hathaway

Jade Cargill Stokely Hathaway
AEW

Regularly finding a way to make an impression on a product often devoid of genuine creativity during his spell appearing on it, Stokely Hathaway's routinely brilliant NXT exploits on the mic under the Malcolm Bivens moniker made his departure from WWE in April seem like another monumental c*ck-up on the part of his now-former employers.

And while his assigning to TBS Champion Jade Cargill as the mesmerising mouth-piece for a performer who wasn't in any real need of support in that part of her game has divided some, there's little arguing with the fact that his presence and effortless stream of quotable one-liners on AEW television and Twitter act as the gift that keeps on giving.

Now that the master of words is seemingly adding some more clients to his ever-growing list of allies/Baddies, too, it certainly feels as though the best is yet to come from arguably the most entertaining manager in the game.


20. Andrade El Idolo

Andrade El Idolo
AEW

He may not have instantly seized his place at the top of the card or regularly been the name on fans' lips throughout his first year under the AEW banner, but Andrade El Idolo can still lay claim to a string of high-calibre showings in-between the ropes and an all-round presentation that feels a world away from his limp execution on WWE's main roster.

Scintillating showdowns with everyone from Rey Fenix to Cody Rhodes have all proven the former NXT Champion can hang with the very best of them at this current moment in time. And it's a testament to his undeniable talent that failed alliances with the likes of Vickie and Chavo Guerrero didn't do irreparable damage to his All Elite reputation.

The arrival of La Facción Ingobernables teammate Rush on the AEW scene could finally provide Andrade with the final piece of the jigsaw when it comes to taking his highly competitive workplace by storm, too.


19. Bobby Fish

Bobby Fish AEW
AEW

Brushing off a limp closing stretch of his once-eye-catching run within the WWE bubble alongside his fellow Undisputed Era cronies, Bobby Fish looked like a performer reborn upon making his AEW debut in October against Sammy Guevara during a TNT Championship contest.

Following up that unexpectedly effective encounter, Fish would then again remind fans what made him such a combustible element on NXT programming with gruelling battles against CM Punk and Bryan Danielson not long after officially becoming All Elite.

His reuniting with aforementioned Undisputed pals Kyle O'Reilly and Adam Cole may not have instantly clicked in the way it once had, admittedly. But before succumbing to injury, Fish still managed to play an important role in a number of critically acclaimed duos and trios battles against the likes of Jurassic Express and The Young Bucks.


18. Kyle O'Reilly

Kyle O'Reilly Jon Moxley
AEW

Just edging out his reDRagon teammate thanks to his run of highly impressive singles showings before also falling victim to AEW's recent injury curse, Kyle O'Reilly looked destined for the NXT main event spotlight this time last year.

But with the black and gold show being entirely revamped and skewed more towards amateur athletes and muscular "Superstars" not long after signing off his dramatic feud with Adam Cole, the writing was on the wall for the one-time Undisputed Era wrestler.

Sure enough, O'Reilly soon jumped at the chance to link back up with Cole and Fish in AEW, attacking Orange Cassidy in his bout with the former just a few weeks on from his last 2.0 appearance.

And AEW's pushing of O'Reilly as another serious singles contender in the lead-up to his untimely injury recently was quickly rewarded with a string of excellent bouts against everyone from Jon Moxley to Darby Allin. Combine that with the aforementioned reDRagon tag clinics and the sky appears to be the limit for Kool Kyle.


17. 2Point0

2.0 2point0 Daniel Garcia
AEW

Who would have honestly predicted the one-time Ever-Rise establishing themselves as one of the most entertaining and rewarding units AEW have to offer when Angelo Parker and Matt Menard joined the ever-growing list of sudden WWE departures in June 2021?

Yet, from the moment 2point0 rocked up on the scene in August 2021, it became clear these long-time jobbers were hellbent on capturing the attention of the masses in whatever way they could.

Instead of being quickly ploughed through by the likes of Jon Moxley, Sting, and Darby Allin before being thrown on the scrap heap, the relentlessly energetic duo refused to be denied and were rewarded with a spot in The Jericho Appreciation Society later down the road; a development that resulted in them becoming key players in the eventual classics that were Anarchy in the Arena and the most recent Blood & Guts war.

Daddy Magic and Cool Hand Ange wanted a taste. And boy, did they earn it.


16. Serena Deeb

Serena Deeb
AEW

The second Serena Deeb turned up on AEW television and started transforming her adversaries into human pretzels with the sort of prowess rarely associated with a largely hit-and-miss women's division, fans were found understandably wondering what in the hell WWE were thinking in keeping her contributions strictly within the Performance Center for much of her latest spell in Sports Entertainment.

Time and time again, The Professor has crafted great to excellent displays during her simply stellar stint with AEW so far, putting on triumphant series with Thunder Rosa and Hikaru Shida whilst also offering her unmatched wisdom to the locker room backstage in her roles as both a coach and producer.

Whatever way you slice it, Deeb has cemented herself as one of AEW's most important cogs in next to no time, and WWE will probably rue the day they let this highly influential figure slip through their grasps.


15. PAC

PAC Forbidden Door
AEW

Had this list been written even just a few weeks ago, it's likely the freakishly gifted super-worker that is Newcastle's own PAC would've found himself a little further down the rankings.

It's not that he's let his ridiculous standards slip or been any less other-worldly in-between the ropes. It would've mostly been down to the fact that The Bastard has often found himself getting a bit lost in the mid-card shuffle over the last few years or unfortunately sidelined due to the pandemic grounding him in the UK.

However, the recent decision to strap him up with the All-Atlantic Championship, while initially seen as little more than yet another worthless title thrown into the mix, has paved the way for the former NXT Champion to rediscover his spark a touch, with high-class bouts against the likes of Shota Umino and Conor Mills giving fans a serious reason to tune into Dark for a change.

And perhaps the arrival of the Trios Championships could see his Death Triangle add another layer of gold to their trophy cabinet, too. Either way, PAC is once again highlighting why leaving 205 Live in the rear-view mirror was clearly the right call back in 2018.


14. Keith Lee

Keith Lee
AEW

Though there was a justifiable level of fear that came with Keith Lee's initial few weeks as part of the All Elite machine, what with the Limitless star appearing to quickly become just another guy despite his one-of-a-kind ability to soar and drop jaws, said worries were eventually eased somewhat thanks to his eventual AEW World Tag Team Championship victory alongside Shane "Swerve" Strickland.

Looking at the way Lee was lazily booked and handled in his final days under the stewardship of a WWE management team that should've been licking their lips at the mere thought of this supernatural babyface letting rip on the competition, few could've imagined just how quickly the one-time Bearcat would recover from such a soul-crushing waste of his time.

But with the former NXT Champion now finally looking as though he's rediscovering his mojo and love for the business alongside his fellow released ball of charisma, fans can no doubt expect to be basking in Keith's inevitable glory for the foreseeable.


In this post: 
WWE AEW FTR
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Gareth has 6 years experience writing and presenting articles/videos covering all things professional wrestling within the fantastic WhatCulture team. Gareth is also a life long wrestling fan, so is clearly living the dream!