Ranking Every WWE To AEW Move From Worst To Best
Which WWE to AEW moves have gone on to be epic hits? And how many will go down as misses?
The landscape may have somewhat shifted again over the last few weeks, with AEW's biggest competitor thoroughly shaking up their creative team on the back of Vince McMahon's sudden resignation, but that still doesn't entirely change the fact that the Land of All Elite still sits as arguably the most desirable workplace in the industry at this current moment.
This is evidenced largely by the fact a great many one-time WWE faces have quickly opted to jump ship over to TK's innovative company on the back of sitting out their various 30-to-90-day non-compete clauses post-exit from the biggest promotion in the game.
But not every WWE turncoat has found themselves going from strength-to-strength in the wake of being dumped into the signature "...is All Elite" social media graphic, with many struggling to make a splash on a roster seemingly growing more bloated by the week.
So, looking at the numerous former WWE stars to have signed on the All Elite line as a full-time player after kissing goodbye to the world of Sports Entertainment - not counting various announcers or other backstage talent - let's dive into which wrestlers have been all-out hits or unfortunate misses since becoming All Elite.
33. Jake Atlas
After feeling like a bit of a missed opportunity throughout his time on the black and gold brand, mixing innovative gymnastics with a compelling natural babyface magnetism, Jake Atlas' AEW career never really got started.
Hot on the heels of coming out of retirement post-August 2021 WWE release, a win over Serpentico on Dark in December paved the way for a contract and Rampage debut against Adam Cole.
It's here when Atlas suffered a serious knee injury and was sidelined almost out of the gates before eventually winding up in the headlines for all the wrong reasons due to a domestic violence arrest in May.
And with AEW reportedly terminating his deal not long after, Atlas' brief All Elite run is one that has already been largely forgotten about.
32. Mercedes Martinez
What initially appeared to be a shrewd piece of business for TK in the midst of WWE's 2021 spell of mass releases, the acquisition of veteran talent Mercedes Martinez provided his often overlooked women's division with both a bit of name value and some near unrivalled experience.
However, in the time since returning to AEW in December 2021, the one-time RETRIBUTION member hasn't exactly set the world on fire, with arguably her most notable All Elite actions to date being the fact she was responsible for a rare DQ finish within the promotion out of the gates and an admittedly fun but quickly forgotten about ROH Women's World Championship main event with Deonna Purrazzo in May.
Here's hoping Martinez is rewarded with a bit more time in the spotlight on the back of another decent, but again largely ignored, title skirmish with Serena Deeb at Death Before Dishonor.
31. Samoa Joe
Another star who appears to have been recruited in a bid to add some more unequalled experience and wisdom to a cutting edge roster, Samoa Joe has also found himself being lost in the shuffled somewhat largely due to the muddled nature of Tony Khan's Ring of Honor purchase.
Outside of a strong but unremarkable showing in the first-ever Owen Hart Foundation Tournament, reaching the final against Adam Cole but never looking a likely winner, Joe's time in the All Elite sun has largely been spent butting heads with fellow ROH all-star Jay Lethal over that promotion's TV title.
Said feud has done little to nothing to remind folks why The Samoan Submission Machine being booted from the Sports Entertainment sphere was seen as such a monumental mistake in the first place, with Joe himself already feeling like a bit of an All Elite afterthought and often appearing as though he's struggling to keep up with the next generation of super worker.
30. Paul Wight
Acting as one of the most successful giants ever to maraud around a wrestling ring throughout his near-thirty-year run in the business, that still couldn't change the fact that AEW's signing of Paul Wight back in February 2021 after leaving his long-time home of WWE was seen as a rather bizarre development by most.
For the most part, it was pretty tough to imagine how the former Big Show would fit into a landscape not exactly known for accommodating slow-moving monsters. And with the former WCW man not exactly being a proven commodity on the mic, his role as one of Dark: Elevation's new commentators didn't exactly fill fans with optimism either.
And in the time since his on-screen debut, it's hard to class Wight's few showings in-between the ropes and stints at the announce desk as anything but disappointing. But perhaps a reported return to "Captain Insano" territory can at least give him an interesting reason for existing in the AEW landscape in the coming months...
29. Matt Hardy
While evidently not aided by the fact the return of his most-cherished gimmick and All Elite debut in general was unfortunately brought into being within an empty arena due to the pandemic's grip on the planet, each and every other attempt to seize hold of some relevancy in the wake of that lacklustre arrival has produced equally disappointing results for Matt Hardy.
Whether he's BROKEN, Big Money, or simply dipping into the Hardy Boyz nostalgia well, the one-time WWE player has routinely found a way to wiggle onto Dynamite and Rampage since making a quick switch over to AEW after his deal expired in March 2020. But his presence has often resulted in more eye rolls than enthusiastic "DELETE" slices.
The aforementioned Hardy Boyz reunion did at least hint at a long-awaited effective use of Matt in a creative arena he still holds the potential to excel in, but Jeff's real-life troubles have all but killed off any of the momentum the veteran brothers had conjured up in the lead-up to a reported title run. And Hardy once again now looks destined to become OBSOLETE.
28. Tay Conti
Firstly, the fact Tay Conti has barely taken a bump on AEW TV in 2022 since aligning with real-life partner Sammy Guevara is a stat Tony Khan needs to put right sooner rather than later.
And while the Brazilian star is still honing her craft and growing as a performer after a rather forgettable run as part of WWE's NXT corner of the company, the potential is clearly there for the judoka to become a feature player within AEW's women's division.
A savage street fight alongside long-time ally Anna Jay against Penelope Ford and The Bunny showing that Conti can bring the violence, her real-life combat legitimacy, and undeniable charisma all point to a star who needs to be doing more than assisting the chaos often surrounding the Jericho Appreciation Society.
But competing in barely any singles contests or matches in general on AEW programming in recent times has no doubt hindered her steady progress.
27. Athena
Another talent you can throw into the no-brainer column, from the second she arrived on the free agency market you knew it would only ever be a matter of time before the AEW President slammed a contract down in front of the one-time Ember Moon.
Easily one of the most engaging and supremely gifted workers plying her trade within the business today, the now-Athena offered an inventive and highly athletic way of getting the job done that ensured she instantly stood out from the rest of the pack upon touching down on AEW TV.
And while she hasn't been showcased as much as fans who witnessed her electric rise on the black and gold show would prefer, the few glimpses of Athena the AEW faithful have been treated to in the form of her various multi-woman battles with The Baddies hint at a truly mouth-watering showdown when she finally locks up with TBS Champion Jade Cargill in singles action.
26. Dustin Rhodes
Kicking things off with one of arguably the most celebrated matches in the company's short history, Dustin Rhodes gave himself a tough act to follow in the form of his brotherly war with Cody Rhodes at the first-ever Double of Nothing PPV.
In the time since that bloody and highly acclaimed battle, however, the one-time Goldust has still proven he can remarkably go whenever the moment demands it, with his fights against CM Punk and Bryan Danielson over the last year alone both showcasing how the ever-green performer is still better than he has any right to be at the age of 53.
But with the older Rhodes brother spending much of his time focusing on coaching the next generation lately, his on-screen All Elite appearances are becoming increasingly fleeting.
You wouldn't put it past this Nightmare Family star truly fighting forever, though, in all honesty.
25. Toni Storm
How anyone can take one look at the supremely talented Toni Storm and think "yep, throw her in a pie skit. That'll get her over," is one of life's true mysteries.
But WWE's loss on the back of the one-time NXT UK Champion deciding enough was enough in December was clearly AEW's gain, with the explosive Mae Young Classic 2018 winner smashing many a skull into the turnbuckles from the get-go.
It wasn't too long before Storm was gifted an opportunity to compete for the top women's strap in the company, either, putting on an exciting back-and-forth with Thunder Rosa at Forbidden Door. And while she's only been a part of TK's gang for a matter of months, the already wise-beyond-her-years 26-year-old has almost instantly marked herself out as one of the most exciting talents on the roster.
Simply put, it feels like Toni's Time may not be that far away, at all.
24. Jeff Hardy
Joining many of the other one-time WWE names on this list that likely looked like a better idea on paper, Jeff Hardy's inevitable arrival on All Elite TV, while gripping, had bad news written all over it pretty early on.
Throwing caution to the wind like only he can, the freedom to put his body through whatever hell he pleased whilst strutting his stuff within Tony Khan's template seemed to catch up to The Charismatic Enigma fairly quickly.
It must be noted that Hardy's sickening bumps from up high in everything from a barmy eight-person tag against the AFO in March, to his hellacious war with Darby Allin in May, all left the crowd needing a serious lie down. But by the time Double or Nothing came around, Jeff was evidently battered.
An alarming latest DUI arrest would later result in Hardy being suspended without pay, with only a successful completion of treatment and the maintaining of his sobriety paving the way for an All Elite return down the road.