Ranking Who Was REALLY The Worst Wrestler Every Year 1990-2021

22. 2000 - The Wall

The Wall WCW
WWE.com

Christ, what an indictment: The Wall was the worst wrestler of LOLWCW's worst-ever year.

He was useless, bless him. As a heel, he was such a nondescript brawler. But he was tall, so he got a spot.

As the babyface Sgt. A-Wall, his fire-up spot was almost funny. He barely landed any punches, but wore an expression as if he was fighting for his life in there. The gulf between what was he doing and what he thought he was doing was enormous, pitiful, hilarious.

He was as far away from getting pro wrestling as he was from Hulk Hogan on top of a friggin' building.


21. 2001 - Kronik

Kane Vs Kronik
WWE.com

The Undertaker put the Mark in Mark Calaway in 2001, during which time he sabotaged several WCW invaders - most notoriously Diamond Dallas Page - because he didn't take too kindly to a bit of mutually beneficial predetermined storytelling, you hear?

You wanted an invasion? Blame 'Taker for your crushed dreams, because he was more interested in getting his mates a job than making anything of a business that was heading towards the sh*tter.

In a lovely karmic retaliation, his mates entered an all-time hilariously bad performance at Unforgiven. How do you get blown up working f*cking Kane? It's a lark in a meadow.

The Two Brians did precisely that, and got so lost that Paul Heyman had to scream directions from the commentary booth.

"Turn around!" Heyman screamed.

"Step forward with your left foot!" William Regal added.


20. 2002 - The Undertaker

The Undertaker 2002 Big Evil SummerSlam
WWE.com

Big Evil sucked, and since there wasn't that much wrestling to suck in 2002, the first full year of the post-monopoly era, he gets the nod.

'Taker at his best was a phenomenal pro wrestler. He wasn't at his best here, and the WWF needed him to be. Viewership tanked with his boring, sludgy work dominating the main event scene. It was unacceptable, really; he reduced crowds to silence during overlong walk-and-brawls with Triple H and Steve Austin a year removed from Standing Up For WWE at the expense of a fun inter-promotional war that people rather liked the idea of.

He did f*ck all to get Test over, either, and while he did the business for Brock Lesnar, his dire half-year output wasn't just tiresome - it was actively damaging to interest.


19. 2003 - Nathan Jones

Nathan Jones
WWE.com

Nathan Jones was so piss-poor that Vince McMahon unceremoniously dumped him from the WrestleMania XIX card. Omos doesn't have a clue where he is almost all of the time, and he was spared that indignity. Shane McMahon has worked multiple WrestleMania shows, and Jones couldn't even make one!

He couldn't make one because all he did was grunt and perform the most basic power moves in between selling comebacks as if he were mid-sneeze.

He became the NXT Champion years later, but in 2003, he was peak "This business is f*cked".


18. 2004 - Mordecai

Mordecai Hardcore Holly Great American Bash 2004
WWE.com

Pitched as the grand nemesis to a WWE legend, it did not work. The Undertaker was white enough.

It also didn't work because Mordecai, religious zealot, probably should have applied his passion to his craft, at which he sucked. His debut was dismal. He was built with such lofty conviction that most were expecting a frightening powerhouse with something approaching an aura.

Instead, against Scotty 2 Hotty at Judgment Day, he got pummelled early. He avoided the worm by spiking Scotty against the ropes, but was so shoddy that he couldn't even get out of the way quick enough. He bumped his head on Scotty's arse and then just stamped on him a bit.

Useless.


17. 2005 - Heidenreich

Heidenreich WWE
WWE.com

You might as well get reacquainted with Heidenreich, because this is where WWE is headed: recruiting failed American football players on the strength of their size, and hastily promoting them to the main roster because Vince McMahon simply cannot wait to look at them.

If you aren't acquainted with the man, here's a quick primer: he moved around the ring as if coded by an LJN-tier hack of a programmer, looked hilariously intense, and, brilliantly, he took the idea of selling pain more literally than any wrestler ever. Heidenreich actually said "Ow!" out loud as he screamed in pain, and he wasn't selective about it, either. If a man half his size aimed a forearm at his back, he'd scream "Ow!"

He wasn't not wrong. He was like one of those kids in the smart-ass test answers memes.

Only less intimidating.


16. 2006 - The Boogeyman

The Boogeyman
WWE.com

A creepy presence with a great physique, the Boogeyman only worked his glamour muscles.

As with everybody who had no clue what they were doing - so 99 out of every 100 John Laurinaitis hires - the Boogeyman oversold everything. Every punch between the shoulder blades caused him to double over in pain, every punch to the stomach compelled him to flail wildly. He had a shocking lack of flexibility and mobility. and even more egregious grasp of character. He was a spooky monster fella, and he sold everything like he was Barry Horowitz.

It was funny, not that that was ideal for his character, but it was perversely entertaining at least. When he bumped for a Booker T superkick at WrestleMania, he jumped in the air before falling because he was literally unable to take a flat-back.


15. 2007 - Deuce

Deuce Sim Snuka
WWE

Well, they did effectively call him 'Sh*t'.

Sh*t and Domino were a pair of '50s greasers that nobody on the face of the planet took seriously as '50s greasers because the tag team was not even anachronistic. They weren't merely out of time; they were a pastiche of a time nobody in the 2000s gave a sh*t about.

The poor timing also extended to Sh*t's in-ring work. He couldn't even execute a hip toss without his own legs getting in the way. He was fairly athletic, with a vertical leap that separates him from the dirt-worst big men on this list, but his work was painful-looking in the most clumsy of ways. He worked like IRS.

Oh!

Nothing he did looked good, but countless peers moaned about how much it sucked to take.


14. 2008 - Manu

Manu WWE
WWE.com

How does one describe bland without just stating the word?

There was nothing to Manu beyond a basic power game. His physique was neither ripped nor imposing in its bulk, which hardly helped his total lack of aura. He was too small to be big and too big to be small. He was OK, fundamentally - but that was the problem. He could drop fairly quickly into a flat-back, but mostly walked through the imposed routine of flying headbutts and Samoan drops without the same frightening explosions.

Generic in the extreme, he was too generic for the most generic era in WWE history.


13. 2009 - The Great Khali

The Great Khali
WWE.com

The mid-2000s version of Great Khali was a fun and absorbing spectacle, and you've probably missed the entire point of WWE to complain about or deny it. He was better than Giant Gonzalez, and his presence added something undeniable to WWE's oeuvre. It helped that the wrestling was broadly good underneath his daft b*llocks, and he actually worked a super-dramatic match with John Cena.

The novelty had worn off by 2009, exposing the inflexible, thrashed husk underneath. The man couldn't even reverse an Irish whip without desperately holding onto the rope and dreading the prospect of moving.

Useless, immobile, clumsy, boring, and, by the end of the run, really quite depressing.


In this post: 
Nia Jax
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!