Ranking Who Was REALLY The Worst Wrestler Every Year 1990-2021

WWE is no longer going to recruit from the independent scene. This, as you'll learn, is a bad idea.

Giant Gonzalez Eva Marie
WWE

Ordinarily, this series is a celebration of the highs of millennial pro wrestling fandom.

AEW's impeccable viral marketing campaign that heralded CM Punk's arrival inspired a look back at modern pro wrestling's best ever debuts, including the meta mind-melt of Scott Hall's first WCW Nitro appearance and WWE actually, thrillingly acknowledging itself as pro wrestling upon introducing Kevin Owens to NXT audiences in 2014. The return of the booming crowd pop in 2021 also inspired a revisit of some life-affirming all-timers, like the unreal spectacle of Akira Hokuto descending on Big Egg Wrestling Universe. That was a 10 hour card. Even writing about it in passing and putting it back out in the universe might compel Nick Khan to increase the duration of RAW. Sorry about that.

It's a fun and easy thing to write, a fond recollection of awesome memories viewed through the kaleidoscope of this great sport; the technicolour of the early '90s, the dark edge of the late decade. At least until the f*cking thing starts to lag by the time one reaches the 2000s. The colours stop on deep, dulled red and blue as WWE's monopoly takes hold. But this is a caustic capsule rant about the worst of the worst.

John Laurinaitis finally becomes useful!

32. 1990 - Mike Rotunda

captain mike rotunda
WWE.com

Mike Rotunda charged into the ropes like Del Boy falling through the bar, and while that was actually impressive, since he made his way back up, it also made for a very awkward and clumsy sight.

When he rebounded back, he did so in a way that was physical and looked like it hurt, but it looked like sh*t. When he wasn't gracelessly smashing into his opponents, he was effective, in the parameters of the match, at grounding his opponents.

Unfortunately, wrestling is meant to be entertaining, and Rotunda's amateur-inspired grappling while legitimate-looking was just so punishingly dull.


31. 1991 - Oz

19910519 Oz  0147a19e127a1a9581b279c7717d62f2
WWE

It wasn't just a stupid idea to present a handsome and agile seven-footer under such a drastically silly gimmick. The Wizard of Oz was an elderly, diminutive conman. Kevin Nash was f*cking massive.

He was also good, eventually, but in 1991 he was as green as his bastard hat; in a match against Sting, in one of few that didn't get the minus-star treatment from the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, he couldn't even clothesline his opponent over the top rope. It was a move that relied on Sting doing the bulk of the work, and he still couldn't do it.

His wide-eyed attempts at intimidation were as risible as whatever the hell the gimmick was.


30. 1992 - Nailz

Big Boss Man Nailz
WWE.com

Backstory was quite nifty, his debut almost harrowing by WWF standards.

*Extremely Bruce Prichard voice*

"Anything you say, boss! Hey, look over there - Paul just lost a war with tiny soldiers! Demote him!"

"Oh, I said the quiet part loud. And then the bell rang!"

Once the kiddies stopped being scared of Nailz's modulated voice, they became bored sh*tless by his work. Nailz threw jobbers against the turnbuckle, and when they crumpled to the floor, he joined them with an assortment of chokes. Then, when he finally picked them up and fired them into the ropes, he caught them with a sleeper.

Nailz throttled. That was his thing.

The easiest WWF payday ever, and the cheeky f*cker thought he was worth more!


29. 1993 - Giant Gonzalez

Undertaker Giant Gonzalez
WWE.com

Physically incapable of doing anything beyond glacial nerve holds and moving around like a giraffe on an ice rink, Giant Gonzalez was atrocious because he didn't even have an aura going for him. He projected zero intimidation. During his heat spots, he raised his arms in the air as if pretending to terrify an infant in a game even the infant knew was bullsh*t.

When he had to sell, Jesus Christ; Gonzalez wore such a bulging, inadvertently hilarious expression of shock and fright that he looked like a twee pop bedroom miserabilist had double-dropped on a gabba night.


28. 1994 - Bastion Booger

Bastion Booger
WWE.com

Bastion Booger could barely move, which was a problem. Wrestling requires movement, for starters, and fans by the early-to-mid '90s had come to expect a big man who could actually get about a bit.

He managed to lift his foot an inch before dropping the leg, which was the limit of his athletic endeavour. He was also capable of dropping to his knees, albeit very gently, to land his Batcave finish. This was as rubbish as it was inaccurate. He didn't hit his opponents with his nose. He hit them with his c*ck and balls.

He was called Bastion Booger, not Bastion Smegma.


27. 1995 - Bertha Faye

Alundra Blayze Bertha Faye SummerSlam 1995
WWE.com

More than serviceable as the Monster Ripper, as Bertha Faye, she was the Bastion Booger but a lass. It didn't work the first time, but what was Vince McMahon supposed to do?

Not book her as a repugnant object of disgust?

The work couldn't possibly be good, because it was built around comedy spots. You see, she was so large that you'd have a horrid time if she simply landed on you with no athletic precision. She was not skilled, in the parameters of the storyline. She was simply massive. It was fine for Mabel to be a big lad. But Bertha?

She fell over! She fell over! She fell over!

Faye was barely an effective base either, sadly. She took crossbody blocks to the knees at times, and struggled through the most basic spots.


26. 1996 - Loch Ness

Loch Ness WCW
WWE Network

Not even 'The Loch Ness Monster'.

In WCW, the former Giant Haystacks, a rather too literal version of the "immovable object," was simply 'Loch Ness'. The connotation was obvious, but the monster is the scary part, not the still expanse of the body of water. Then again, surveying his "work," 'Loch Ness' was exponentially more accurate. This wasn't a "LOLWCW" or "WCW, everybody" moment. Comparing this man to a massive thing that barely moved was as fitting a pro wrestling moniker as 'The Excellence of Execution'.

He had one job - stand there, no-sell attacks, and catch a diving babyface - and he couldn't even do that. He almost killed Scotty Riggs on Nitro.

Lanny Poffo put in a harder shift in Atlanta.


25. 1997 - Crush

Crush Jailbird
WWE.com

There's an argument to be made that Hunter Hearst Helmsley belongs in the spot, and it wouldn't even scan as a gimmick entry.

Helmsley worked profoundly tedious slogs - genuine nothing duds amongst the most boring matches ever held in a WWE ring - against Flash Funk and Sgt. Slaughter. They were longer and more oppressive than the work of Crush, but Crush's work was such total drab crap.

All the man did was walk about, very slowly, and punch people with no expression on his face. When he had to fire people into the ropes, he just stood there, head down, and left it up to his opponent as he saved his energy for the bump. The colourful look and goofy mannerisms of his New Gen years was absent as he played a butt rock biker in '97.

He therefore had nowt going for him other than the Undertaker's friendship.


24. 1998 - Kurrgan

Kurrgan WWE
WWE.com

Another barely mobile and awkward fellow signed on the "Is he bad enough to literally kill somebody with his clumsiness? No? OK. Good" principle, Kurrgan was an atrocious early '90s hangover.

He practically originated the "Monster hoss becomes comedic foil" trope, on account of being entirely useless. A grunting big man heel, he became an oddity who just likes to have fun, Maggle, within months of his woefully unremarkable barely-push. He couldn't even do the basics; after awkwardly putting his opponents on the canvas with a slow back body drop with no snap on it whatsoever, he turned around, checked he hadn't hurt them (!), and then growled with a cartoonish roar - not unlike T-BAR! - to the hard camera.


23. 1999 - Mideon

Mideon Godfather
WWE.com

Mideon was the drizzling sh*ts. Never has a wrestler simply moved so bizarrely.

He was almost an anti-athlete in shape and footwork. He ran the ropes armpit-first to take the resulting big boot and somehow ended up bumping on his knees. It was the strangest bloody thing. Mideon was a nominally professional wrestler who made it to the mainstream - during its most popular period, no less! - having somehow failed to grasp that a professional wrestler is meant to land on their back. It was as if he'd missed the first few weeks of wrestling training, and learned to walk before he learned how to run.

And then never learned how to run.

He just happened to be so rubbish it became phenomenally awkward, but he sensed it too, and by all accounts became quite the chef in a far more successful second career.


In this post: 
Nia Jax
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!