Silly Little Guys Who Didn't Belong In WWE ?

Turning funny into money - the most unlikely and WEIRD Superstars in WWE history.

Ronnie Garvin
WWE

There's a big movement building around wrestling not being serious enough at present.

The tide has turned on MJF and Adam Cole's extended bromance, and the thinkpieces are coming armed with ticket statistics that might - might - reveal some home truths. After All In and Grand Slam ended with handshakes and hugs and the 'Salt Of The Earth' moved deeper into comedy with his injured tag partner (and his "injured" partner Roderick Strong), the knives and the jury were out on the AEW Champion's entire title run.

There's no easy or objective answer to any of this, but part of the debate completely discounts how fun some of wrestling's stranger characters and storylines have been in the past. It's an odd industry; so odd that even the market leader in all of its insanity doesn't feel like the perfect fit for some of the talent that travel through it.

Buried within the bowels of WWE's history sit a selection of silly and/or little guys who couldn't have matched their surroundings any less. About as far away from the polymath Maxwell Jacob Friedman as it was possible to get, these weren't better than you...and you knew it.

10. Johnny Saint

Johnny Saint
WWE.com

Perhaps it's cruel to single out the elder statesmen of the already-forgotten NXT UK brand rather than highlighting the silliest of the silly little guys on that roster, but Johnny Saint was perhaps most representative of how silly and little the whole project was.

Any wrestlers and/or gimmicks that didn't feel particularly TV-ready - and there were plenty of them - were like that because they weren't TV-ready.

The entire idea was hurried into existence when World Of Sport dared to get a few hours on ITV in the UK, and the brand itself only existed to make good on a doomed promise about further elevating a then-booming scene. It was all a facade, broadly serving the purpose of creaming a little bit off the top of a diluted market before the pandemic and SpeakingOut were the two biggest of several final nails.

WWE trying to make a WWE-adjacent show out of all these decidedly non-WWE properties was silly. Making Johnny Saint the "tonight in this very ring" authority figure (because god forbid a show not have one of those) was silliest of all.


9. Rob Gronkowski

Rob Gronkowski Gronk WWE
WWE

Rob Gronkowski was a supremely successful NFL star, with achievements and awards including four Super Bowls, four first-team All-Pros, five Pro Bowls, and a host of other awards and acknowledgements that all sound very good but don't mean an awful lot if you don't know your football.

If you know your wrestling - and you're here, so good start - Gronk's contributions to the industry before 2020 started and ended with being Mojo Rawley's friend and helping him win the Andre The Giant Battle Royal at WrestleMania 33. Not exactly glittering, but any athletic background can be enough if you've got charisma, and he appeared to have plenty of that.

Until, bizarrely, he didn't. An entire WWE "special attraction" run spent working under pandemic conditions didn't help, but when you're brought in for your mainstream appeal as much as your wrestling skill, that shouldn't really matter. Gronk's wooden displays as the WrestleMania 36 host and 24/7 Champion were roundly critiqued as well.

Only an incredibly silly debut sticks out from an all-around torrid time.


8. Seth Green

Seth Green John Cena triple H
WWE.com

Is there anything that could be more "silly little guy" than the image above?

Seth Green was such a silly little guy in a world of hyper-inflated pro wrestlers that he was in some ways perfect for his role as John Cena and Triple H's tag team partner back in 2009, but the contrast in size between the actor and his wrestler friends wasn't enough to justify yet another television main event fed to the machine that was the Guest Host Era.

Between cute sight gags, fake-feeling promo battles and the countless other reasons thought up in order to make space for random celebrities on a weekly basis, Green was far from the worst offender in that dreaded era between June 2009 and 2010. In fact, he might have been the very best literal manifestation of silly and little and was merely part of the problem rather than the problem itself. But - like all the rest knocking around every Monday - he simply didn't belong.


7. Top Dolla

LA Knight Top Dolla
WWE.com

It is not funny when somebody makes a big and public mistake in their job.

It is not funny when somebody is needlessly abused within their job.

It is not funny when somebody loses their job.

These things are not funny, and those who pile in to laugh at AJ "Top Dolla" Francis are as bad as the ones who mapped out that specific path for the former Hit Row man in WWE in the first place. Francis, with all his (at times, slightly misplaced) confidence, was sometimes somebody it felt quite funny to watch wrestle.

A charming all-mouth-no-trousers mic-worker, he was the sort that never got great enough to back up the moxie of his raps, making them all the sillier and funnier when he lost in short order. A guy who spoke like him needed to back it up or know somebody who could, and the win/loss records highlighted that he couldn't really do either. Fame is fickle but it's rarely forgotten - somewhere he'll crop up, and probably be warmly regarded for it.


6. Adnan Virk

Adnan Virk
WWE

Adnan Virk tried his best.

Between April 12th and May 25th 2021, the sports and movie broadcaster took his place at one of the most legendary (and legendarily difficult) desks in all of pro wrestling, ostensibly landing the Monday Night Raw commentary gig out of nowhere. Virk was an affable enough guy, but when has that ever been associated with anything World Wrestling Entertainment? Not least one still operating within the confines of The ThunderDome.

Virk was passable enough thanks to his prior broadcast training, but didn't seem to connect fully with the deranged activities suddenly in front of him, and wasn't given the easiest of rides by viewers online in the time it must have taken to wrap his head around it all.

Outside of being the man to call the infamous WrestleMania: Backlash Zombie Lumberjack match (complete with charmingly naff Twitter photo), Virk left no other impression, with fellow non-wrestling replacement Jimmy Smith becoming a welcome presence in the spot.


5. The Road Warrior

Road Warrior Animal 2007
WWE.com

There’s a strange phenomenon pro wrestling creates where how over the character is in the context of their career at the time can have an impact on how they look physically.

Jon Moxley was a man reborn in AEW and NJPW after Dean Ambrose found his impressive frame ground down and down and down again by WWE. Zack Ryder had that jacked body in WWE, but it’s not just because he’s literally a foot taller than most of the GCW roster than Matt Cardona looks so much bigger on the indies. Cody Rhodes’ final days in AEW are so stark in their differences to his following ones in WWE that you can scarcely believe he was an architect of the former.

Animal from The Road Warriors was one of the most dangerous men to ever paint the canvas with his opponents’ blood. Solid Gold Homer Simpson and Arnie’s Terminator meshed into one. 2006’s The Road Warrior, singles bully two decades past his prime was a silly little guy who didn’t belong in WWE. That’s just the way it works sometimes.


4. Tatanka (2016)

WWE Tatanka
WWE.com

Tatanka's 1992-1996 run, while not the stuff of legend, left a mark amongst a generation of fans thanks to the lack of content overexposure at the time. WWE was the Number One wrestling company in the world for the entirety of his run, and for what little that represented at the time, it gave him a certain cache for life.

But it was tested beyond breaking point when he randomly appeared in the WrestleMania 32 Andre The Giant Battle Royal.

Vince McMahon will have it that the Dallas 'Show Of Shows' was the biggest crowd of all time, which means the biggest crowd of all time saw Tatanka as a silly little guy on the company's "Grandest Stage". No reason was given, nor was the contest rife with retro wrestlers, but the former undefeated star was there all the same. He couldn't even grab the headlines - WWE finally delivered a version of the long-awaited Shaq Vs Big Show face-off that stole focus from just about everything else until Baron Corbin's surprising win.


3. Eli Cottonwood

Eli Cottonwood
WWE.com

Eli Cottonwood's infamous "moustache" promo was the defining moment from a short and otherwise-uneventful WWE television career, but time is rightfully kinder to the wrestlers themselves from the game show era of NXT.

A needlessly cruel and potentially damaging process, early-2010s NXT was less of a developmental than Triple H's 2019 super-indie version of the show, dragging hopefuls through a host of increasingly irrelevant tasks and trials that made a mockery of the promotion, the performers, and anybody that saw it as a viable way to make it big. It was a self-own, too - if making it in WWE really did require such a hare-brained and scattershot skillset, maybe it wasn't that great place to make it along?

Eli Cottonwood was a textbook silly little guy because he was actually a very serious big one, but trapped in a time where the company seemed more intent on doing damage to prospects rather than helping any to maximise their minutes and fulfil any dormant potential.


2. Lance Cassidy

Lance Cassidy
WWE

There was perhaps no worse a time for Steve Armstrong (he of the famous and once-considered "cursed" Armstrong wrestling family) to debut in WWE than October 1992.

The company was about to enter its leanest years, and not just because the headliners were suddenly looking a little smaller. Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels were given the Survivor Series main event following a wildly successful SummerSlam 1992 show at Wembley Stadium, but these were obscuring a cold reality brought into focus by Hulk Hogan's rash return in the spring - the bubble had burst.

Business was trending downwards and getting worse, Vince McMahon was all out of genuine creative solutions, and he had no choice but to lean on his elite tier wrestlers (Hart, Michaels, Mr Perfect, Scott Hall), long-tenured favourites (Randy Savage, temporarily Hogan and a soon-to-depart Ric Flair), and non-muscular monsters (Undertaker, Yokozuna, Giant Gonzalez) to try and pull him out of the hole.

If you couldn't slot yourself into one of those three, you weren't likely to see it through to the summer and lithe laughing cowboy Lance Cassidy sadly slipped through some harsh cracks. He was gone in four months.


1. Ronnie Garvin

Ronnie Garvin
WWE

For younger fans or those that grew up exclusively on WWE, Rugged Ronnie Garvin is little more than a footnote wrestler from a bygone time. He was, for a while, substantially more controversial than that.

After a serviceable career for Jim Crocket Promotions without ever really troubling the top of the card, Garvin won the NWA World Heavyweight Championship out of nowhere in a move of mutual convenience for both promotion and performer. With WWE running their inaugural Survivor Series in opposition to Starrcade 1987, JCP wanted a Flair title win to headline. As 'The Nature Boy's rival at the time, and sensing that this was probably a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity, Garvin agreed to take the gold just to be the fall guy.

Belts and titles simply aren't comparable over the generations, but this marriage of convenience could perhaps be likened to WWE's Jinder Mahal experiment in 2017. Unlike that abomination, this was short and had good matches, and Garvin was on WWE's radar in the aftermath.

The man with "hands of stone" gamely attempting some Sports Entertainment brought about some wonky results. Across his 1988-1990 run he feuded almost exclusively with Greg Valentine, serving an enforced retirement, spending time as a babyface referee that broke the rules, and eventually pulling wacky faces in the payoff match that etched his place wrestling meme lore. And actually, why not celebrate that? There are far worse WWE legacies to have than a silly little one such as this.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.