That Time Vince Russo’s Ideas Were TOO GOOD For WWE

Who’s swervin’ who?

stone cold steve austin stephanie mcmahon
WWE.com

“I was always raised to tell the truth, that’s just the way my parents brought me up.”

- Vince Russo, complete with run-on sentence, writing on his website ‘Pyro and Ballyhoo’.

2002 marked the end of WWE’s mainstream boom.

Steve Austin was close to retirement, and had at this point “taken his ball and gone home”. The Rock was bound for Hollywood. The company had f*cked the Invasion angle with robotic, half-hearted thrusts, pushing the rope with which it hung itself. Ratings were tumbling. A combination of the industry’s cyclical nature—and WWE’s dimwitted acceleration of it—meant that the magic, simply, had gone. In a premonition of the desperation to come, to reverse the trend, Vince sent for the man:

Vince Russo.

And this was desperation, for Russo’s one-hit-wonder booking style had accelerated the demise of WCW. The hire—if it qualifies as that—was a real indictment of the existing creative team. Vince believed the man who killed WCW’s creative was a better fit that than the team that had, in spite of everything, maintained a profitable enterprise. The news sent shockwaves through the entire company, and came as a surprise to even his own daughter, Stephanie, who was in charge at the time. That is wild.

Russo had allegedly met with Vince McMahon in June of that year to discuss his grand plan to arrest the slide. “Satisfied”, McMahon had Russo outline it to the creative team, the most influential members of which were Michael Hayes, Paul Heyman, Brian Gewirtz, and (an absent) Bruce Prichard.

There are two sides to this infamous meeting.

CONT'D...(1 of 5)


Batista Thumbs Down
WWE

Per a report from Wade Keller of Pro Wrestling Torch, Russo pitched another invasion angle, in which Goldberg, Bret Hart, Mick Foley, Eric Bischoff and Shawn Michaels were to take over one of the two programmes as a united, disrupting force. The famously forgiving Bret Hart and the man who retired him. The famously forgiving Bret Hart just up and going back to WWE, years and years before tensions had eased.

Anyway.

Russo, for his part, claims that this one-year plan was so groundbreaking, so meticulous, so guaranteed to be brilliant that his new colleagues were reduced to a reverent, awed silence. “Their jaws hit the ground,” Russo said on his Truth With Consequences podcast earlier this year. “It became pretty evident to everybody in that room, “‘Well, if Vince McMahon hires this guy, there’s no need for us’.”

Man, that sounds like an awesome idea!

The idea was so good that Heyman et al. just had to sabotage Russo. And they did, by all accounts; per the July 1, 2002 Wrestling Observer Newsletter, Russo was either buried by Stephanie, or his ideas were so bad that he buried himself. In any event, he was repackaged more quickly than Mike Awesome was two years prior: he walked into that room as a writer, and left it a “consultant”.

But if this idea was so out-of-this-world, why was Vince Russo’s subsequent TNA run a risible parody of WCW’s own astonishingly stupid and unpopular parody of sports entertainment?

Vince Russo is so obsessed with the swerve that it’s a wonder has hasn’t yet said “sis”, instead of “bro”. Gauging by that TNA run, Evolution wouldn’t have worked quite as well as it did. An excellent premise for a faction that spawned Batista’s mega-run with a perfect baked-in narrative, this wasn’t the way Russo did things. He’d have booked Ric Flair and Triple H as the gatekeeping main event stars, only to reinforce that perception by booking the up-and-coming Batista and Randy Orton as secondary to Rhyno, which isn’t satire, because that is precisely what became of AJ Styles’ and Samoa Joe’s Frontline.

Is Vince Russo telling the truth?

CONT'D...(2 of 5)


Vince Russo WCW
WWE.com

The guy defined by the swerve and the lie reckons he was raised to always tell the truth. Now, of course Russo isn’t going to use the truth in his capacity as a writer of predetermined professional wrestling—but here are just two examples of verifiable lies spewed from a mouth he simply cannot keep track of.

Vince Russo outed himself as a secret TNA consultant in 2014 by cc’ing Mike Johnson of PWInsider into an email instead of TNA employee Mike Tenay. Johnson broke the story, which Russo initially denied. “WOW—just amazing to see that anybody will print anything as TRUTH without checking into it. Nice to see the SWERVE still works!!!” he tweeted. Russo was lying. He admitted as much when Johnson threatened to publish the aforementioned email—i.e., proof.

That point, about Russo being unable to keep track of his own bullsh*t? The following quote, from a Kayfabe Commentaries shoot recorded in 2015, encapsulates it neatly. He contradicts both the lead-in quote and, in fact, the same sentence.

“I’m gonna be honest with you here. This I can probably say, without a shadow of a doubt (!), this will be my last wrestling interview. Every time I do a wrestling interview, my own kids get on me because they know I’m not telling the truth.”

Narrator: this wasn’t Vince Russo’s last wrestling interview.

But Bruce Prichard is also a prize bullsh*tter. You have to admire the sheer gall of the man—“You weren’t there!” he repeatedly tells Dave Meltzer, while also believing second-hand information disseminated to him by the same exact source in Heyman. That information was thus:

CONT'D...(3 of 5)


Goldberg Invasion
WWE.com

Russo entered the room, with no knowledge of existing storylines, and decided to strip every reigning Champion and set up several tournaments to crown new ones. This is a quintessentially Russo idea—so much so that it’s at least a plausible lie—but to enact it, WWE would have to acknowledge that the product was so poor it demanded a reset. WWE does this as a matter of course in 2019, but things weren’t quite so desperate in 2002.

Russo has admitted this, only, with an hilarious defence: “Bro, I did not watch the product leading up to 2002 because the product sucked! I’m not gonna sit there and watch a sh*tty wrestling show!”

He sure as sh*t can write ‘em, but he won’t watch ‘em.

So, to recap: Vince Russo, who thought booking Goldberg to refuse to “go up” for Kevin Nash’s powerbomb was a good idea, marched into a WWE creative meeting and said “I don’t even know what you’re doing, but I already know it sucks, because it’s drawing better ratings than I managed in WCW. Here’s a regurgitated idea that died in WCW, which itself died!”

Of course they were going to bury him. This mass burial, to the detriment of something that might be quite good, does sound consistent with that super-weird WWE management culture. But Russo asked for it with full knowledge of the warped political landscape. If he isn’t a liar, he is, for sure, a moron. And if his big idea was another invasion angle, WWE loathed the idea of running the first one.

CONT'D...(4 of 5)


Samoa Joe
Impact Wrestling

“If you hated this, what about this?”

“It’s the same thing, Mr. Russo.”

“Yes, but Steve Aww-stin turns even more, bro!”

This bizarre tale is like the pro wrestling version of ‘Burn After Reading’—a farce in which all parties were total nimrods. We won’t ever learn the truth. This is a podcast game played between carnies inflating the balloons with significantly less of the hot air that usually comes out of their mouths.

In that same edition of the Observer, Meltzer wrote the following of the meeting and the fallout:

“Quite frankly, nobody knows what McMahon truly thinks on this one, other than the answer will become obvious in a few months.”

Russo swerves the dirt sheets, again…!

…because it was made clear WWE couldn’t wait to get shot of him within two weeks, not months. Russo “joined” TNA just two weeks later—he was already there, swerve!—in, yes, an accelerated development hilariously consistent with his own warp-speed bullsh*t narratives.

And, since Russo on his podcast last pitched a Fatal 5-Way power struggle for control of WWE—Shane McMahon Vs. Bruce Prichard Vs. Paul Heyman Vs. Eric Bischoff Vs. Triple H & Stephanie McMahon—maybe it’s OK that Aleister Black talks in that voice, or that Sami Zayn gets buried all the time.

At least they don’t have d*cks drawn on their faces.


In this post: 
Vince Russo
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!