The Disturbing Truth Behind WWE's FOX TV Deal
$1 billion in the contract doesn't necessarily mean $1 billion in the bank...
26 June 2018 saw WWE and FOX announced a five-year partnership that would see Vince McMahon's promotion bring SmackDown to the network for a cool $205 million per year, making it worth at least $1.25 billion in total.
Per Dave Meltzer in the 2 July 2018 issue of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, 2020 would see WWE's new FOX and USA Network TV deals combine to generate $435 million of revenue, which would be an increase of roughly 85% on 2018. Total company-wide revenue should exceed $1 billion in 2020. By 2019's end, WWE expect to reach $200 million OIBDA, doubling their all-time profit number. This figure would then be "blown away" the following year, all as a result of these insane television contracts.
These are just phenomenal numbers. There's no better way of saying it.
The FOX deal is already reaping benefits beyond the balance sheet as well, with WWE advertisements all over the last few weeks of NFL games. They're going all-on promoting SmackDown's big move with three shows dedicated to hyping the big debut. If this deal fails, and it shouldn't, then it won't be down to ineffective marketing or a lack of effort.
That's fortunate. For WWE, the cost of failure would be severe...
CONT'd...
Before we dive in fully, let's note that this editorial isn't a prediction of failure. Things will likely work out for WWE and FOX. The momentum generated from this deal (real momentum, not the kind Michael Cole babbles on about) is already propelling WWE forward at an impressive rate. WWE's financial position was already close to failure-proof; now, with this extra billion, Vince McMahon's coffers are so flush they'd make Scrooge McDuck blush.
But success isn't guaranteed. It never is. While WWE going out of business anytime in the next decade is a ludicrous prediction, there's still the slightest of slight chances that disaster could befall the promotion. The chances of the FOX deal falling apart aren't so slight.
FOX have given SmackDown every chance of success. In their own words, the network are "rolling out the blue carpet." That their platform has greater reach than SD's current USA home (where Raw remains) makes the old B-show WWE's de facto flagship. The show is being treated as an important part of FOX's weekend sports run, with the 11 October Draft episode getting a particularly strong push in recent weeks. It's all very encouraging so far.
Here's the thing, though: remember those December 2018 reports stating FOX would expect SmackDown to draw an average of 3.3 million viewers each week? Well, the most recent episode did 2.06 million on USA. The network is essentially asking for a 60% jump.
Are these expectations realistic?
CONT'd...
With thanks to Matt McEwan for compiling the data, SmackDown is currently watched by approximately 2% of the 90.4 million households that USA Network is available to in the United States. Achieving a similar percentage on FOX would mean roughly 2.5 million weekly viewers. That's considerably less than the 3.3 million quoted in those December 2018 reports, but still a jump of approximately 25% on the current viewership.
SmackDown's first few episodes should, theoretically, attract considerably more than that. The Friday night broadcast will not only have that shiny new toy appeal, but 4 October is an anniversary special that'll likely call on all kinds of big names, the 11 October is the Draft. From there, WWE and FOX can expect another few weeks of stronger ratings before SmackDown settles on an average figure.
Would 2.5 million be enough? Probably not. Per McEwan's research, this would make SmackDown the 150th most-watched show in the country. Last year's 150 show was a FOX-produced sitcom called Rel. It attracted the same average viewership and was cancelled for low numbers after just 12 episodes. Next on the FOX ratings rankings was The Gifted, which was also scrapped at 3.32 million - a shade more than what FOX apparently want SD to hit.
That's... not good. At all.
CONT'd...
It's too straightforward to say that SmackDown will be in trouble if the show ends up drawing similar numbers to Rel or The Gifted, though. WWE's FOX content will be presented as a sports event, and sports events are attractive to networks as there as the advertising revenue is usually way more lucrative. This means that Vince McMahon's promotion will almost certainly be granted more leeway by their new home. Networks tend to be a tad more forgiving with Friday numbers as well, per "Friday night death slot" theory.
Regardless, it's clear that WWE need to step their game up. They're going to have to start delivering at a higher level if they want to see the FOX deal out, as it's hard to see the network sticking to their wrestling commitments if the blue brand is only serving up 2 million viewers this time next year.
WWE's viewership has been in chronic decline for the best part of two decades. On 16 September 1999, the show scored a 4.5 Nielsen Rating (approximately 5.19 million people); 20 years later, SmackDown has dropped to less than half that. Suddenly, even though the company has never been so profitable, McMahon must find a cure.
Fortunately, recent weeks suggest this Herculean task might not be impossible...
CONT'd...
Brock Lesnar showed up to challenge Kofi Kingston on this week's SmackDown. He'll be WWE Champion by the end of the 4 October FOX debut show.
Say what you will about 'The Beast Incarnate' as a performer, but he's one of the few guaranteed draws left in the company. Expect more to follow. WWE will likely load SmackDown with as much star power as possible in the upcoming Draft because coasting on declining ratings is no longer an option, meaning the Becky Lynchs and Ronda Rouseys of the world could soon become blue brand exclusives.
TV's recent upturn in quality is encouraging, too. While SmackDown hasn't improved to Raw's extent, the appointment of Eric Bischoff and Paul Heyman as Executive Directors has coincided with a noticeable increase in positive reviews. If a good product is the key to a stronger viewership, it's safe to say both shows are on the right track, though this will need to continue.
Let's hope it all falls into place, as SmackDown has largely been a strong, well-booked show for the past few years. This hasn't yet translated to improved ratings, but WWE have the FOX machine behind them now. Their position has strengthened. Now, it's time to build a sturdier structure on these stable foundations: their entire business strategy depends on it.
CONT'd...
WWE has evolved into a lean, mean, money-making machine that has never been so efficient at squeezing every last cent out of its shrinking audience. Still, their projections for the next few years depend largely on the FOX money coming through. That's why it's so vital that they make this work.
A 60% increase to 3.3 million viewers could literally happen overnight come 4 October, though the first week's numbers probably won't be sustainable. Settling in at that level will be much, much harder, and if they don't do it, there's every chance FOX executives could step in to guide the product down routes Vince McMahon and co. might not necessarily want to take. We've already seen this with USA and Raw (the Wild Card Rule was supposedly a compromise between Chairman and network).
This situation means that although 2019 has been one of wrestling's most newsworthy years since WCW died, 2020 could be even crazier. TV viewership figures will be at the centre of it. Following SmackDown's FOX fortunes could be every bit as gripping as the so-called Wednesday Night Wars, so let's hope, for the good of the sport, that McMahon, Paul Heyman, Eric Bischoff, and co. finally have the solution to this decades-old problem.