The Four Worst Wrestling Debuts Ever
“Six months might seem like forever to a fan who doesn’t know what the plan is.” - Triple H.
On the December 17, 2018 RAW, WWE promised huge, sweeping changes to a product that had grown so stale, and so fetid, that the company felt it had no choice but to hang a lampshade over the darkness.
Usually, this practise of “lampshade hanging” in television is a necessary measure to cutely acknowledge that which cannot be ignored. It’s a reassurance of sorts; the writers know that the points plotting A to B are absurd, but bear with them: Z is worth the contrivance. Or perhaps a recast is so glaring, confusing even, that the writers script some sort of self-deprecating joke—“You know Miss Banks, since you had that baby, there’s something different about you…”
In WWE’s hands, this manifested thusly: “We are intimately aware that you are bored sh*tless with the current cast, and so here are some new faces.”
The problem is that these weren’t new faces, not really. Technically, yes, they were. None had previously appeared on Monday Night RAW nor SmackDown, beyond a single cameo—but they each represented age-old archetypes beloved by a man who had promised change, but is fundamentally incapable of it.
They were faces, that much is true. That is the crux of the issue. They weren’t performers, they weren’t talents, they possessed no backstories, there were no plans in place. They were faces, nothing more; Vince McMahon, who very clearly has not watched a single episode of NXT, had not watched them.
CONT'D...(1 of 5)
Upon calling up EC3 (MUSCLES), Nikki Cross (ZANY), Heavy Machinery (FUNNY) and Lacey Evans (BLONDE), Vince watched no charisma-drenched promos, unhinged and violent Last Man Standing bouts, absurdly funny backstage segments, nor any of the straight singles matches that proved Evans, an apparent member of high society, was nowhere near ready for her debutante ball.
Vince had instead scanned the NXT roster page on WWE.com, and gauged their potential purely on an aesthetic basis.
First, the face of EC3. And the body, most pressingly: EC3 is a shredded, handsome specimen of a man, one who looks so consummately “sports entertainment”, that he felt out of place on the more traditional pro wrestling brand. This was a no-brainer of a decision to which WWE took a very brainless approach. EC3, to date, has not once referred to himself as the “top one percent” of sports entertainment. EC3, one of the best promos in the company, hasn’t uttered a single word.
Vince likely pissed himself laughing at the mere sight of Otis Dozovic, and called him up immediately. It was a shame he arrived lumbered with a dreaded tag team partner in Tucker Knight, but no matter: Heavy Machinery existed purely as a desperate promise. They have not existed in the past week. Of these four faces, Nikki Cross has fared best—and Nikki Cross has wrestled three times on RAW, winning once, and losing twice. WWE hasn’t even 50/50 booked her.
“Do you want to play with Nikki?” she asks. Already a broken old toy, the answer to that is a stern ‘No’ from Vince. Cross hit a McMahon button—“She’s crazy, I love it!”—but she is as normal as can be now.
CONT'D...(2 of 5)
Lacey Evans has lost each of her main roster matches thus far: a Main Event showing against Natalya, and the Women’s Royal Rumble Match. She was never going to win that, but really, and this is an indictment of the regime, not the performer, she should not have entered it. Evans backflipped out of a hip-toss attempt, and stumbled on her feet. She then mistimed a stereo kip-up spot, and fell over again. This all happened within 30 seconds. She cut a pitiable figure in Phoenix. A tall, glamorous blonde, given what we know of McMahon and Kevin Dunn, sadly, everything about her debut was—sorry—premature.
FOX Sports interviewed Triple H in March 2017, in which he effectively patronised the fandom.
“People [are] being impatient that there’s somebody they want to see. “Oh, this guy would be great on RAW or this girl would be great here, I want to see them there.” I understand that feeling, but if we have a plan that six months from now we have an idea to do this that’s going to debut this person in a bigger way…that six months might seem like forever to a fan who doesn’t know what the plan is.”
We know what those plans are now.
The plan for EC3 saw him debut as a mute babyface before turning heel after three f*cking weeks. Stellar plan, one definitely mapped out six months in advance. The nicest thing we can write about the entire development is that EC3 hasn’t yet subjected us to a rotten cliché of an “Each and every one of you…” promo—but it’s coming, and it might be mere hours away. The plan for Heavy Machinery? Do the Worm, pal, and f*ck off. Nikki Cross? Win, lose, whatever. It is literally a laugh. Lacey Evans? Make an entrance at Elimination Chamber, unannounced, and then leave immediately.
Now, I have followed wrestling for approximately 28 years. I don’t think I’m meant to react to a performer by saying “What the f*ck is she doing here?”, as she leaves before I even complete the thought, but I am just a fan. I do not know what the plan is.
CONT'D...(3 of 5)
All four of these performers are indistinguishable on RAW, and none are even exclusive to it yet. We are two months and one day removed from the first teaser trailer, and already, the ensemble feature has bombed at the box office.
The title of this article, while combative, is not clickbait. It’s the truth: these are the worst four debuts in the history of professional wrestling because, individually and collectively, WWE has achieved the opposite of the desired effect. It’s almost impressive satire, or it would be, if this were Reddit or something. EC3 does the opposite of what might yet get him over; he doesn’t talk. Heavy Machinery are losers. Nikki Cross is a loser, and she lost to a major pay-per-view loser in Ruby Riott to set up a bullsh*t squash match. Lacey Evans is a loser.
That they debuted en masse ruined them all, too: not only was this a very optimistic and arrogant gesture on WWE’s part, but it was just “Here are some guys.” That was it. A debuting pro wrestler should catch our attention. This performer is special, we should think, because they pose a threat to the existing roster. The debuting star once threatened to skin the existing roster alive. The debuting star was once the Perfect athlete. The debuting star once wanted the world, chico, and everything in it. The promise of the debuting star isn’t compromised by competition. They are a new, singular attraction.
These four absolute nonentities literally hung around backstage under the faint hope that management might graciously allow them the privilege of performing. It is a catastrophe of promotion, because why, why would we react to them as stars? They are the opposite of stars. EC3 and Evans in particular were literally backstage extras.
It’s pointless, it’s nihilistic, but think about it for a second. Think about this in dreaded kayfabe, as impossible as that is, now we are so far through the looking-glass. A promoter should only bring in a new act, in theory, if they stand even a chance of winning, of increasing the level of competition, of changing the landscape, of making them money. To put this premise over, they should win. But they do not, because so few do.
CONT'D...(4 of 5)
Contrast EC3 with MJF, and his introduction on Being The Elite. It really is legitimately funny stuff. Working an hilarious “secret d*ckhead” gimmick, which he plays with a marvellous insincerity and turns on a dime with perfect comedic timing, we’re already anticipating the moment Cody discovers the ruse, and doles out the comeuppance. MJF is over as a charismatic über-a**hole, and the payoff shall be glorious. He has the facials to put it over huge when it happens. That, if we are not mistaken, is a plan.
AEW doesn’t even exist yet, and it is already drastically superior than WWE at debuting new talent.
Give it time, you may think, but no. WWE hasn’t done anything to earn our trust—that’s precisely why these four faces were rushed to the main roster in the first instance: to win us back as part of an overarching, harebrained charm offensive.
To us, these four faces are redeemable. They’re not, but they could be. EC3 can talk, Cross can war, Heavy Machinery can and have enjoyed cult success. Evans meanwhile needs to go back to developmental. That she was even selected to debut proves in itself how backwards all of this is.
These four, symbolic faces serve as a damning and morbidly hilarious indictment of WWE’s modern malaise. To management, these four faces are, essentially, turds—turds flung across a wall to see which may stick.
And, since WWE creative is the drizzling sh*ts, none have.