The Lesson WWE BADLY Needs To Learn From The NJPW G1 Climax

The best pro wrestling on the planet. Period.

Kazuchika Okada KENTA
NJPW

We are over the halfway line of this year’s G1 Climax tournament—and nobody has a godd*mn clue who’s going to win.

IWGP Heavyweight Champion Kazuchika Okada leads the A block with 10 points accrued through his undefeated five match run. This is unusual, which is where the intrigue lies. The mere inclusion of the Champion in the G1 frames it as an achievement in itself—and not merely the vehicle with which to headline the Tokyo Dome. The tournament also doubles as a means of setting up the challengers throughout the remaining calendar year. It’s such a neat narrative device that it has become a trope. But not this year: the unprecedented idea of Kazuchika Okada selecting his challenger is far from remote.

The debuting KENTA was instantly presented as a serious proposition. He didn’t merely destroy Kota Ibushi and Ace Hiroshi Tanahashi; he did so with a real !*$% disposition. This version of KENTA is a complete !*$% who revels in his perception as persona non grata; the idea of him winning is as viable as it is concerning for the New Japan diehards. New Japan builds stars as a matter of course; with KENTA, the company has replaced the black sheep heel sh*t-kicker that was Katsuyori Shibata.

Kota Ibushi has racked up enough points (six) to embark on a late surge. Fellow A block standouts Lance Archer and Will Ospreay, meanwhile, have enhanced their reputations by securing major wins and losing classics with painstaking endeavour, respectively.

Over in B Block, Jon Moxley has also racked up the perfect 10, getting over as a cool, charming, totally badass shooter—both expert strategist and incredible showman. He is everything a pro wrestling megastar should be in 2019. He debuted in June; in under two months, the character has significantly more of an aura than he ever had in WWE. That he hasn’t yet been defeated is no coincidence.

Gedo has built a headline act overnight.

CONT'D...(1 of 5)


Zack Sabre Jr Hiroshi Tanahashi
NJPW

Tomohiro Ishii, the Ace of the G1, has fused his awesome performances with a very good record. Always the sentimental favourite, the word “sentimental” need no longer apply. Tetsuya Naito is approaching sudden death territory following a subdued start. This arc has accomplished two goals: protected as a megastar for years, his aura is bulletproof. A win over Naito means something. Moreover, his remaining matches will now take on an absurd strain of drama.

This mentality also applies to Jay White. Most expected the former IWGP Champion to have fared better thus far. That he hasn’t does not affect his standing in the ranks, because he has already amassed several major wins in 2019. The booking instead adds layers of intrigue to the complexion of the tournament.

Pro wrestling is a strange, incalculable thing because it is an art form. Much of what gets over cannot be designed, which seems counterintuitive, since it’s all predetermined. But that’s wrestling. Gedo’s genius approach to it is that he is both mathematician and architect. Gedo builds talent, carefully, constantly, precisely, and the effect creates a world in which so many of its inhabitants are over. The G1 is his masterpiece. An epic series of electric matches, it is also a framework in which wins and losses don’t merely “matter”; they are everything. The hopes of entire fandoms often live, die and live again within the last, scintillating five minutes of exhilarating, tortuous drama.

At time of writing, there are no fewer than seven viable winners still alive across each block. This number does not include Tanahashi, who at this period in his legendary career is forever over. Nor does it include Zack Sabre, Jr., whose audacious 2018 New Japan Cup win was booked with such conviction that it established him as a formidable player in storylines. Viewed strictly, Zack’s subsequent win/loss record probably veers close to 50/50.

This formula exists within the New Japan universe, but it just feels different.

CONT'D...(2 of 5)


Tomohiro Ishii chops Juice Robinson at G1 29
njpw1972.com

Rematches are spaced out, generally. There’s no sense of numbing repetition, of guys resonating as just “guys” through the most arbitrary of quickly-traded wins. Nobody wins one week and loses to the very same opponent one week later, resulting in confusion and any semblance of a tier. A win is always built towards; a loss is rarely framed as a humiliation. It’s impossible to look upon the fallen, drenched in sweat with an icepack stuck to their battered neck, as a loser.

The number doesn’t even include Will Ospreay—the pick of many as this year’s MVP. He has lost more than he was won, but has brought the fight of his life every night. Trickier to accomplish within the WWE schedule, that still does not excuse the baffling “He stole one!” trope.

Nothing is stolen in New Japan. Even losses are earned; to level up to Tomohiro Ishii, Juice Robinson wrestled his brutal match, knowing the danger inherent to it. He lost, bravely, in a minor classic. He lost an ass-kicking contest to the warrior of the G1, and there was no shame in it. He could be proud just for bringing the fight. The approach is devoid, totally, of bullsh*t. Every decision is clean; nothing is muddied. Most every wrestler emerges from a loss with their integrity intact.

With plate-spinning concentration, Gedo judges who can lose, and when, without suffering. Hirooki Goto, crucial to the early years of this boom period, is approaching geek territory now. But he is the rule-proving exception.

At time of writing, there are no fewer than seven viable winners still alive across each block. When was the last time this could be written of WWE’s G1 analogue—the Royal Rumble?

CONT'D...(3 of 5)


Finn Balor Andrade
WWE.com

WWE drops several clues in the weeks leading up to it, unhelpfully, by positioning just one star at the forefront of TV. This year, it was Seth Rollins. 2018 was the outlier. In 2016, WWE gracelessly gave away the main event of WrestleMania 32. A year earlier, it was so searingly obvious that Roman Reigns was winning that WWE adapted the “Anyone but you” sentiment into his programme with Bray Wyatt. Becky Lynch was nailed on to win this year’s Women’s Rumble. To entertain themselves ahead of it, fans had to debate the how, not the who. In the end, WWE opted for an unimaginative injury angle, which Becky got over through sheer force of will and her connection with the people.

This problem isn’t limited to the Rumble.

WWE has struggled badly to build talent this year through carefully plotted midcard programmes. Paul Heyman didn’t really need to put over his “spoiler” shtick ahead of Extreme Rules—which other heel was remotely ready for the SummerSlam main event, if not Brock Lesnar? Sami Zayn lit up the post-WrestleMania RAW, indicating to fans that he was to be heavily featured in the coming months. As the months rolled by, he did jobs to Tucker on SmackDown. Andrade went 50/50 with Finn Bálor, and then Apollo Crews. Baron Corbin was an unpopular choice to challenge the Universal Champion, but he at least had an in-built reason to challenge, by virtue of retiring Kurt Angle at WrestleMania. Drew McIntyre played lackey to Shane McMahon. Daniel Bryan was relegated to the tag team division.

With no heels built for Kofi Kingston, either, WWE simply fast-tracked Samoa Joe, relying on his excellent character work. The careless plotting was contagious; their Extreme Rules encounter died a death.

CONT'D...(4 of 5)


Randy Orton Kofi Kingston
WWE.com

Kofi’s SummerSlam match with Randy Orton is more intriguing, but we are essentially through the looking glass. The premise of the feud is based on how badly WWE bungled Kofi’s first singles push. This is the exact opposite of the Gedo approach: WWE has essentially lucked out on a WWE Title programme through happenstance. This informs a not inconsiderable drama, but it’s a deeply fortunate meta byproduct of a broken system.

Nobody knows who is going to win the G1 Climax. WWE’s system is so broken that fans can barely guess who is going to contend a title programme, post-SummerSlam. WWE often talks of “roads”, but there are too many cars on it, stuck in an infinite traffic jam.

WWE badly needs to build talent by identifying which talent the company is actually behind, and implementing measures to protect them. Frame wins as wins, not flukes. Don’t immediately negate those wins with a loss. Don’t conflate winners and losers by entering both into All Star Battle Royals, retconning a five-hour PPV in less than 24.

The G1 Climax is a masterpiece of storytelling. WWE, without characters, can barely tell stories.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!