The Misunderstood Genius Of AEW's Kenny Omega

The problem with Kenny Omega's approach to storytelling is that he's too good at it...

Kenny Omega Will Ospreay
AEW

The most believable story told in wrestling all year was Will Ospreay Vs. Kenny Omega.

A real long-term story years in the making - the saga extends back to 2019 - it began when Omega departed New Japan Pro Wrestling and tasked Ospreay with succeeding him. The conflict developed a meta quality when, seemingly out of nowhere, Omega took to burying Ospreay on social media and in press interviews last year.

On February 4, 2022, Ospreay tweeted "The chase begins," a reference to a record - the most five star and above match ratings awarded by Dave Meltzer - he was set to break. Omega quote tweeted Ospreay in response: "Keep sending your fan cam footage of your 0 pressure indies and you might just pull it off. I’d do the same for some EZ 5’s but I understand the difference between what an Arena/Dome/Budokan main event means compared to when you play with your mates a few blocks over at York Hall."

Omega was "shook".

A divisive blurred lines approach, in which wrestling was portrayed as something to excel at in its predetermined form, and not something real, it was nonetheless a great tactic. Omega and Ospreay later tweaked the narrative to immerse fans in the fiction of it, but the establishing premise was credible in a form defined by its lack of credibility. Two elite, massively acclaimed wrestlers with inflated egos would naturally resent one another. Consider the way Michael Jordan talks about LeBron James.

He can't sanction the idea that James might be a better basketball player, because he himself was driven to be the very best, but he knows he can't say James isn't great. He'd look foolish, desperate, sad. In 2020, during a press conference held ahead of the NBA Paris Game, Jordan was asked to give his thoughts on James. Choosing his words carefully, Jordan said James was "one of the best players in the world, if not the best". This was clever. He reframed the conversation, slyly, to suggest that, if there was a player from this generation that could compare to Jordan, it might not even be LeBron. "He's a heck of a basketball player without a doubt," he followed up. This verged on patronising. Cristiano Ronaldo was very quick to praise Pele as the greatest football ever weeks after his rival in that conversation, Leo Messi, had achieved victory in the World Cup final with Argentina - the one major honour that eluded Cristiano throughout his career.

This is what top athletes do.

They are egomaniacs. What drives them to succeed also drives them to play these pissy games. They cannot abide the fact that somebody is better than they are. They are simply not wired to accept it.

Omega, utilising the media to tell a unique story, was similarly defensive throughout 2022 with NJPW Wrestle Kingdom 17 in mind.

CONT'D...(1 of 5)


Kenny Omega
AEW

He was clever. He didn't rubbish Ospreay as a glorified gymnast or anything quite so cliched. Modern elite athletes, bluntly, are more c*nty than that. Speaking to Fightful ahead of AEW x NJPW Forbidden Door - but with a long-term goal in mind, promoting a different show - Omega said the following:

"Ospreay, he's doing great in his role, not my thing so much. Will, the first thing he does is goes online and brags about his next five-star match. It's five to one guy, it's maybe three and a half to me, but it doesn't matter."

Omega constantly talks up what it means to be an all-time great or best-in-class pro wrestler. Across several interviews in 2022, he insisted that a great wrestler is great at everything: comedy, hardcore, main event epic, tags, week-to-week episodic TV.

Pore over these words carefully, words that aren't screamed in your face via mid-match monologue, and the subtext reveals itself. While he believes these words - this is a man who embraced the range of wrestling before he even crossed paths with his WK17 opponent - Omega, indirectly, is talking about Ospreay. Ospreay stays in one lane, the big epic match, and some believe he has surpassed Omega in that field. Omega, the character, is defensive over the critical acclaim that Ospreay generates.

Who is the "everyone" referred to in this (pinned) tweet?

Omega is moving the goalposts of what it means to be a pro wrestler because Ospreay is constantly smashing it into the postage stamp with his in-ring output.

The irony here is that, yet again, the video gamer Kenny Omega - the man who once worked a match with a nine year-old girl, whose facial expressions are exaggerated - is telling a fantastic and thoughtful sports-oriented story.

CONT'D...(2 of 5)


Kenny Omega
AEW

It is also a story rooted in a classic pro wrestling philosophy espoused by the late, great Jerry Jarrett: if you can get the people to believe in the first beat of the story, they will be more inclined to invest in what follows. With a believable hook dropped, and the animosity between both men established, Omega worked on incorporating a fictional element to the programme.

Omega accused Ospreay of being unintelligent, mentally unstable, and unable to withstand the pressure of being the top foreign star in New Japan. This too was believable - Ospreay is very candid about his mental health struggles - and Omega pecked at his psyche. To remind Ospreay of the old Omega, who presided over the company in more lucrative times, he added extensions to his hair and reverted to Sephiroth imagery during his entrance at Wrestle Kingdom 17.

In the press conference that preceded it, Don Callis negged Ospreay and embellished Omega's success in Japan to further cast him as the Final Boss. Callis, in tremendous form, borrowed the old Pele line: it was raining in Japan when Omega departed in 2019 because God was crying. Ospreay was beaten before the bell rang; in a superb promo all the better for its near-total lack of composure, he called Omega a "c*nt" as he boiled. The first thing Ospreay did in the match was charge at Omega with a furious sprint. He was beaten before he went down for the three.

The detail in their seminal January 4 match was incredible. Forensic. Omega, unable to keep pace, needed to shatter the superior athlete and ruin him mentally. Early in the match, after smacking him repeatedly in the back of the head, Omega struck Ospreay between the shoulder blades with a series of open-palm strikes. This was Omega literally getting Ospreay's back up, inflicting a sharp, irritating pain and lulling him into impulsive errors. Ospreay fought with too much unrestrained emotion, but was able to use the agility, over which Omega was so defensive, to cartwheel out of a hurricanrana attempt. Omega, though, was able to guide Ospreay around the ring. The puppet master had him on strings.

CONT'D...(3 of 5)


Kenny Omega
AEW

When he lulled Ospreay by the exposed top turnbuckle and dropped him head first onto it, the match turned. Ospreay was busted open, following which Omega controlled the pace and annihilated Ospreay, playing the Final Boss with an energy bar that could not be drained.

A lesser wrestler might have said, over and over again, that he was living rent free in Ospreay's head. Omega does not rely on exposition to tell his stories.

Instead, mirroring the effect he had on Ospreay's mind throughout the build, he smashed his head through the remnants of a table. An instantly iconic, violent image, it told the story through imagery and adhered to the old promoter's principle. The tone of brutality had been set so expertly that it was easy to overlook that, in reality, he was only hitting Ospreay's head against compressed sawdust. It can't have been particularly pleasant to receive, obviously, but he was hardly bashing Ospreay's brains in - although, lost in the magic, that's what it felt like.

Omega toyed with Ospreay in the gruesome, unsettling final third.

Omega's presence towered over Ospreay like a Dark Souls boss occupying the entire frame as he lunged into the foreground with multiple V-Triggers and a Terminator dive captured to perfection by NJPW's best-in-class production. In an unreal spot, Omega hoisted a barely conscious Ospreay onto the top turnbuckle, and, exerting total control, folded him in half with a spectacular, terrifying avalanche Croyt's Wrath. The core strength required to pull this off was astounding, the execution of an insanely risky spot impeccably timed, and it was inserted into the match to convey that Omega had used the elite sporting mentality to put away his opponent. Ospreay, mentally broken, was at his mercy.

CONT'D...(4 of 5)


Kenny Omega The Young Bucks The Elite
AEW

In the end, after an incredible sell-job and a comeback with no real hope, in an exquisite chaining of offence, Omega blasted Ospreay with a straightjacket German suplex. This allowed him to transition seamlessly into the Kamigoye: the last "f*ck you" to Ospreay in retaliation for shelving Kota Ibushi four years prior. A story four years in the making was rooted in a love story that has spanned a decade and a half.

And this four-year story is not over; the idea is to run at least one more match, at the end of which Ospreay successfully takes Omega's spot.

The problem is that Omega and Ospreay didn't interact with a microphone in hand or an invisible camera pointing at their faces, which appears to be a prerequisite to tell a "story" these days. The problem, again, is that Omega didn't repeatedly say "I'm in your head rent-free" on national television.

It is far from the only long-term story that Omega has told. The Kota Ibushi saga remains unfinished. His seven-year association with the Young Bucks is also unfinished. Omega treats his wrestling career as one long arc with an unparalleled focus on continuity. His work is almost too densely packed with subtext, if, at least, he wants a mass audience to anoint him one of the best storytellers in the industry. Take for example his long programme with Hangman Page. Just as they seemed to reunite, after the first Stadium Stampede match, a "throwaway" line on a Road To AEW Dynamite show on YouTube created more conflict. "I can count the number of drinking buddies you have on one hand" made Page feel worthless, and allowed FTR to creep in and manipulate him.

The problem with Kenny Omega's approach to storytelling is that he actually adheres to its most important rule - he shows and doesn't tell - but wrestling on the whole still hasn't grasped that.

The word "storytelling" in online wrestling circles is relentlessly misunderstood - and so is Kenny Omega's genius.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!