The One Thing Everybody Gets Wrong About Wrestling

Be born earlier.

WWE Super ShowDown 2020 Brock Lesnar Ricochet
WWE.com

Wrestling fans smashed through the looking glass decades ago, beyond the surface of the story and into an exposed backstage area with its lurid, fascinating politics. Years later, under monopoly rule, this knowledge came to dominate a discourse itself dominated almost entirely by in-the-know fans.

We were the only ones left, and we had a fair understanding of why.

The fiction, more often than not, became lost in the plot: a secondary concern to the manner in which it was told. And, since WWE has become more and more inept at telling stories in recent years, fans discussed pro wrestling exclusively using insider terms and with a tone of dread. Who is getting pushed? Why isn't the guy I like getting the push? Why isn't the guy generating audibly huge reactions getting the push? And, most pressingly:

Is Wrestler X getting buried?

Buried in this context meaning a talent relegated to a position not consistent with their reaction - or left to rot as an afterthought the booker is bored of - as opposed to an onscreen punishment.

This conversation has erupted in recent years because, and much qualitative data bears this out, Wrestlers A, B, C, D, E, F and f*ckin' G were all buried by WWE for one of two reasons, primarily: either getting over when it wasn't in the plans, or failing to get over within three weeks, creating a grim paradox from which a sense of nihilism festered amongst the fanbase.

CONT'D...(1 of 6)


Cody Lance Archer
AEW/Lee South

Daniel Bryan and Zack Ryder are definitive examples of the former, Cedric Alexander and Humberto Carrillo the most prominent recent examples of the latter.

Sometimes the burial isn't even a spiteful, conscious decision. This can happen through neglect and incompetence. Take, for example, Rhea Ripley, who was an early standout of the Wednesday Night War. Her rise was booked with total conviction and received in much the same way, until her character was reframed as a humanised dream-chaser - after the dream was realised (!) - and she lost to Charlotte Flair at WrestleMania 36. The way the character was booked subsequently didn't reverse the discourse. She didn't win, was screwed, and at TakeOver: In Your House, the leading light of NXT's Women's division was positioned a distant third to the victorious Io Shirai and the protected Flair. If she wasn't overtly buried, the soil still conspired to fall over her head. The level of star we were told she was is crucial here: she was meant to be the Ace of that division. This is key.

WWE's monopoly has heavily informed the way pro wrestling is discussed, and this has inevitably - but unfairly - migrated over to AEW.

When Lance Archer was defeated by AEW Executive Vice President Cody at Double Or Nothing 2020, fans feared this was a burial; after all, Archer arrived as a big, big deal, pushes 7', and you don't beat a guy that major that quickly. But consider the story: Archer in league with Jake Roberts invaded his turf, left his bloodied brother for dead, and terrorised his wife. The story demanded the babyface win. The fans wouldn't believe in Cody after that, because if he couldn't overcome the size difference with that babyface motivation, when would he?

CONT'D...(2 of 6)


Brian Cage
Lee South/AEW

AEW didn't have to tell that specific story, but it was a great one, one that helped sell an improbable smash success of a pay-per-view. Cody emerged as the winner because the story demanded it and he, alongside Jon Moxley and Hangman Page, is the top, most over babyface in an industry driven by and starved of them.

In a similar vein, you might feel anxious about the upcoming prospect of Jon Moxley Vs. Brian Cage at Fyter Fest. Cage has just debuted in imposing, eye-catching fashion. He is a massive brick sh*thouse who can kick your face off at warp speed and drive what's left of it into the canvas with one of the most beautiful and deadly '90s finishers. He can't lose. It would bury him.

Except he can, because Jon Moxley is the Ace of AEW and historically, fans have gravitated towards dominant, believable babyfaces. Dominant, believable babyfaces get over by vanquishing well-built threats. If they beat somebody who's barely worth a damn, it won't mean a damn thing. Besides which, AEW set up Cage's second programme before his first. He was introduced by Tazz who, spurned by Darby Allin, brought Cage in to AEW to prove that his expertise is precisely that. The well thought-out, intricate post-plan will get Cage over as an established upper midcard heel, in theory.

If that reads as predictable, it won't feel like that on the night, with Moxley positioned for the Drill Claw and prone to an unbearable near-fall. That's what committed booking achieves, and long-term booking will ensure that he isn't perceived as a bust not worth caring about in the aftermath.

CONT'D...(3 of 6)


Jon Moxley
AEW/Lee South

Years and years of anxiety orchestrated by WWE has obscured the very way that professional wrestling is meant to function. Professional wrestling is high-stakes drama. It was never meant to be this meaningless volley of sh*t patter spliced between several matches, the stakes of which are diluted, the sporting, competitive purpose behind which lost in a haze of talk show segments.

This sh*t is meant to make your heart race. It's meant to feel like all or nothing. Everything to win, and everything to lose. One shot, no comfort of the mandated rematch. Wrestling shouldn't be comfortable. Stakes should be driven onto that apron. There should be a gravity to this. When you worry about whether or not a wrestler is getting buried, that's what wins and losses are meant to feel like when wins and losses matter.

You are meant to feel like the loser has nothing left afterwards. This is a good thing. This informs every move. This informs the searing drama of every near-fall. But they of course do have something left afterwards. It's fiction. We should remember that.

CONT'D...(4 of 6)


Hangman Page Kenny Omega the Young Bucks
AEW

Remember Kenny Omega and Hangman Page post-Full Gear. Omega had just lost to Jon Moxley, decisively, while PAC negated Hangman's win by settling their trilogy on the following Dynamite. Kenny Omega was the guy who wasn't the same star he was in NJPW, while Page was the bland loser babyface failure. But together - just about - they were driven by the consequence of failure to take a run at the tag team division. They reached the pinnacle through their respective brilliance and maintained it through a refined chemistry and renewed bond, which itself has created tension within the Elite stable. The gravity of a loss is embraced, not hidden through carny mechanisms like the f*ck finish. This is what separates the loss from the burial.

AEW has proven itself adept at rehabilitating talent after a major loss. So much of the discourse ahead of Full Gear centred on the Cody Vs. Chris Jericho AEW World Title match: had AEW booked themselves into a corner?

Cody couldn't lose; he was the on-fire top babyface who cried in his go-home promo and afforded himself just one shot. It would bury him. Chris Jericho couldn't lose in his first defence; he was there to legitimise the title and use his star power to make the midcard in the crucial formative stages of the TNT run. AEW had steadfastly - and loudly - proclaimed that they weren't going to f*ck the fans with carny f*ck finishes.

And, when Cody lost, it was done so very deftly.

CONT'D...(5 of 6)


MJF Cody
AEW

Chris Jericho looked like such a sadist with his demented, skull-scraping application of the Liontamer that Cody surely would have passed out - but MJF throwing in the towel spared Cody a definitive, stigmatising loss. It was the perfectly balanced finish, one that informed his subsequent blood feud with MJF. He wasn't buried. Omega wasn't buried. Page wasn't buried.

AEW gets a kicking (by bad faith actors looking to gotcha Dave Meltzer on Twitter, truly, a pathetic calling) for an apparent failure to present an alternative product with the marketed sports-oriented feel. This isn't untrue at all; even before AEW created the much-needed levity of Stadium Stampede and embraced a sort of heightened quasi-canon in the wake of the unfolding global health crisis, the early promises of "statistics" and the like never materialised. The win/loss rankings are a helpful visual cue as to who is on form, but they didn't drive the booking, at least exclusively.

But AEW has emulated the most important part of sport: the agony and the ecstasy of the failure and the triumph. To borrow an analogy from that sports-oriented messaging, if AEW is a new "league," there's very little in the way of a mid-table. So don't worry.

Or do worry.

That's the point.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!