The One Thing WWE & AEW MUST Learn From NJPW

"When you don't have talent, you don't have storylines."

Will Ospreay
NJPW

Professional wrestling will never not be a star-driven business.

WWE have attempted to alter consensus by touting their brand as the draw, not the wrestlers, but keep going back on themselves. Vince McMahon blamed injuries to key performers for WWE's disappointing Q1 financials back in April. "When you don't have talent, you don't have storylines," he told the press, "and when you don't have storylines, you're not going to do that well in terms of live events and television ratings." Regardless of whether Vince's statement is right or wrong, it can be taken as an acknowledgement that stars do still matter to him.

McMahon's star-making procedures have come under intense scrutiny over the past few years. Every metric that matters shows his audience is shrinking. His performers aren't as over as they used to be either, and the WWE machine crafting another Rock or John Cena looks unlikely at the moment. Brock Lesnar is the rule-proving exception. The likes of Becky Lynch, Seth Rollins, and Roman Reigns are big for this era, but not previous eras, and Ronda Rousey's drawing power was created in the UFC.

So if Vince's old methods are failing him, what about the competition?

It's too early to tell how AEW's star-creation efforts will go. The Young Bucks, Cody, Kenny Omega, and co. used graft and ingenuity to get themselves over with smaller crowds, though each is objectively less famous than WWE's headliners (owing, primarily, to their platform). It remains to be seen if these wrestlers can transcend their current level when Dynamite hits the airwaves, or how AEW will build new stars beneath them.

Both American promotions would do well to follow NJPW's example.

CONT'd...


Gedo NJPW
NJPW

Gedo isn't a perfect booker. His neglection of NJPW's tag divisions has left them feeling as unimportant as Raw and SmackDown's. Constant rematches and 50/50 booking have become increasingly common in 2019 in as well, though caveats sometimes apply. Contextually, Kazuchika Okada's upcoming successful IWGP Heavyweight Championship defence over SANADA after losing to 'Cold Skull' in the G1 Climax isn't the same as EC3 and Dean Ambrose trading arbitrary Raw victories one week after each other. On the flipside, extreme repetition rendered Destruction in Beppu's Hiroshi Tanahashi vs. Zack Sabre Jr. main event skippable, and they're two of the best wrestlers in the world.

But despite all this, and despite subjective, taste-based complaints on who he is or isn't pushing, no modern booker is as adept at nailing the things that matter. When it comes to creating and sustaining drawing, engaging main event stars for his product, Gedo is the master. He is peerless in this regard.

It's all relative, but Tanahashi, Okada, and Tetsuya Naito are more over with NJPW crowds than Seth Rollins, Roman Reigns, and Becky Lynch are with WWE's. New Japan's attendances are growing with those guys on top; WWE's are shrinking.

CONT'd...


NJPW

Hiroshi Tanahashi was already a four-time IWGP Heavyweight Champion by the time Gedo took the pencil in late 2011 but not yet the company's era-defining ace. Under Gedo and Jado (the 'Complete Fighter's' co-booker until 2015), Tanahashi ascended, growing as the charismatic, gifted franchise player New Japan needed to help carry the promotion towards a new era prosperity.

Even today, with the ace title his only in name, Tanahashi remains a huge, crowd-popping draw. He is immortal.

Kazuchika Okada was built alongside the 'High-Flying Star.' Returning from an excursion in 2012, the 'Rainmaker' challenged Tana to an IWGP Heavyweight Championship match on his first night back. Thus began one of the most acclaimed (and important) rivalries in Japanese wrestling history, peaking, after four masterful years, with Okada fighting off Tanahashi's title challenge to effectively claim his ace role at Wrestle Kingdom 10. Gedo took everything he'd built with Tana and mirrored it with Okada, his new centrepiece. The story is still going on today.

Tetsuya Naito is another success story, though he's very much the 1B to Okada's 1A at the moment. In him, Gedo has built a wrestler so over he's effectively bulletproof, hence his middling win/loss records in 2018 and 2019. The booker knows Naito's popularity and drawing power are too strong to be harmed in defeat. His crowning moment will come, though. It always does.

But great wrestling booking is about more than having a core group of strong headliners. Establishing the next guy up is just as vital, which is part of why Vince McMahon's Q1 statement iwa such a self-own.

CONT'd...


Katsuyori Shibata
New Japan Pro Wrestling

The efficiency with which Gedo mitigates the damage done by talent losses by ensuring he always has somebody ready to step up is unparalleled in modern wrestling. While McMahon bemoans injuries and blames poor ratings and attendances for Superstar absences, New Japan don't have that problem. They've been quietly building the wrestlers below for years, so when a spot opens up (whether foreseen or not), there's a readymade replacement.

The 2016 WWE talent raid would have stifled lesser promotions. AJ Styles and Shinsuke Nakamura were scooped up and suddenly, NJPW were deprived of two top-tier main-eventers. No problem, because up stepped Katsuyori Shibata, Kenny Omega, and Tetsuya Naito, all of whom had already been groomed and prepared for their new spots. They were ready.

Naito was IWGP Heavyweight Champion within three months of Styles and Nakamura's departure. In Omega, Gedo had taken an erratic, inconsistent genius and turned him into a drawing headline-grabber and NJPW's most important foreign wrestler in forever. Shibata didn't work out, but would have if not for his health.

Omega's case is particularly interesting as he was the most successful wrestler to elevated post-Styles/Nakamura, but left a similar hole himself upon leaving NJPW three years later.

CONT'd...


Kenny Omega Young Bucks Kota Ibushi
NJPW

January 2019 saw Gedo once again tasked with replacing a host of departing stars as All Elite Wrestling's eventual formation saw him lose not only Omega, but The Young Bucks, Hangman Page, and Cody, with former junior heavyweight standout jumping to WWE at roughly the same time.

Again, Gedo had prepared for this. His team's bench had been restocked long ago.

'Switchblade' Jay White stepped up shortly after pinning Okada at Wrestle Kingdom 13, capping a year of rapid improvement by wresting away the IWGP Heavyweight Championship Tanahashi had taken from Omega in the Tokyo Dome. His was a short reign, but it worked. In putting Tana out to pasture, White gained credibility to compliment his outstanding sh*theel act, and now, as the year draws to a close, he stands as Intercontinental Champion.

Finally tied to a full-time New Japan deal after years of freelancer work, Kota Ibushi may leave Wrestle Kingdom 14 as IWGP Champion. His has been a stunning year rife with blow-away matches and an overdue G1 Climax victory. Elsewhere, Will Ospreay has emerged as NJPW's likeliest Omega replacement by gliding between the junior and heavyweight divisions, while former Dragon Gate bruiser Shingo Takagi has begun a crawl through the ranks sure to conclude at the top of the card.

Gedo played a huge part in building these men. In making a concentrated effort to slowly build them up beneath the main event scene, he made NJPW disaster-proof. His blueprintis one that could easily be applied by the AEW and WWE booking teams, too.

CONT'd...


Smug Vince McMahon
WWE.com

Roman Reigns, Kevin Owens, Sami Zayn, and Triple H were among the list of absentees referenced by Vince McMahon during the G1 2019 earnings call. Each left WWE in a bind, but where were the substitutes? Where were the next guys up? Where were the rising stars McMahon had groomed for ascension?

If WWE's star-making machine wasn't damaged, those absences wouldn't have been a problem. Like NJPW, the company could've had 3-5 performers waiting in the ring, primed and ready to go, but they didn't. They had nobody. They had nothing but excuses.

For AEW, losing Kenny Omega, Jon Moxley, and Chris Jericho to injury tomorrow would be a disaster. This need not be the case a year from now. If they follow the Gedo blueprint and prime the likes of MJF, Hangman Page, and Jungle Boy for the spotlight, they'll be well-equipped to survive any talent raids or injury crises. Tony Khan won't need to complain about declining live attendances, because his new stars will have him covered.

Gedo, meanwhile, will continue as the best booker in wrestling by ensuring that the next time an Okada or Naito departs, a SANADA will leap seamlessly into their spot. A Juice Robinson, SHO, or Zack Sabre Jr. will then climb to the level just below, patiently waiting for their own headlining tilt.

Imagine if Vince McMahon had the next Brock Lesnar lying in wait. It's almost as if he shouldn't have burned Braun Strowman on 'The Beast.'


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.