The ONE WWE Superstar Who Never Lost Clean
OR, how to make it in pro wrestling,
A loss always haunts the spot-obsessed professional wrestling megastar in the rearview.
Whether as a result of encroaching age, political sabotage, or maybe, just maybe, the wild notion that said wrestling megastar might get over it and give back with no compunction, everybody loses.
Bret Hart put his own brother Owen over, clean in the middle, in his top drawing years. On the same night he won back the WWF Championship, in fact, booking his reign before it even started because he was the absolute best.
Hulk Hogan lost "cleanly" to the Ultimate Warrior at WrestleMania VI years earlier, but revisiting that finish with the glare of an ultraviolet light reveals the stain of bullsh*t, for Hogan accentuated the classic c*nt's trick of the 3.01 kick-out by gesturing desperately to the heavens above. It was as if a divine entity had won the match for the Warrior, not Warrior himself. Hogan slammed his hands to the mat in a fury afterwards - the divine entity was black, presumably - but, hero that he was, he pulled himself together to congratulate the winner. This was so magnanimous, in fact, that he left the hero, and not the WWF Champion.
This isn't a cynical reading of the post-match, but Hogan's publicised intent. It was one of few truths revealed in his autobiography. In the years afterwards, he escaped the job by flashbulbs and other assorted chicanery, but Vince McMahon, ruthless, had him lay down under the crushing force of Brock Lesnar's bearhug in August of 2002. It's by the by, but what a perfect finish that was - a symbolic means of showing that even the fans couldn't get Hogan out of that one.
CONT'D...(1 of 5)
Shawn Michaels broke his record of refusing to drop a title via traditional means, at WrestleMania XIV, when the Undertaker threatened to wipe the smile from his face before it suspiciously disappeared.
Steve Austin was allowed to do this - he actually drew money - but he did his most famous clean job to the departing Rock in what was more a gesture of profound mutual respect than a forward-thinking business move - not that you'd ever criticise Austin for how much he grew the business, and how much physical pain he endured to do it. He put the Rock over, who put Brock Lesnar over, who has now put Drew McIntyre over. There is a chain.
Mostly.
Batista did the honours for the Undertaker when he was on top, but by then, the culture had mostly changed. Agency had deteriorated as the power balance swung firmly into the direction of Vince McMahon, then the autocrat of the entire U.S. wrestling business. Self-preservation was out, do what you're f*cking told was in, but McMahon replicated the hulk Hogan push with John Cena, who was protected to an extent so absurd that preadolescent children in Higher Power gowns shook him more than gigantic men capable of pounding his d*ck into the dirt.
But, as his run began to slow, he started to do clean jobs, which are invariably more effective than exercises in withholding carny bullsh*t. Daniel Bryan resonated as a true headlining superstar by defeating Cena clean in the middle at SummerSlam 2013; Kevin Owens remains the most effective NXT-to-main roster call-up by virtue of the brave and audacious decision to have him go over Cena at Elimination Chamber two years later.
CONT'D...(2 of 5)
Still, the clean and decisive win isn't really a thing in WWE, because they like to protect their babyface stars via f*ck finishes that double as transparent pretext for rematches. That verb has taken on an extreme irony in recent years, of course - they if anything require a gigantic f*cking shield to protect them from the writing staff - but that is the mentality, nonetheless, whether it's applied effectively or not. WWE's method of protection is a double rubber job, and it's no wonder the thrill of drama is often lacking.
Few were as protected as the Ultimate Warrior, and with sound reasoning. He was a megastar, megastars become megastars by winning a great deal, and he was so fundamentally abysmal as a pro wrestler that it's not as if he could (or should, from the perspective of his character) have gotten over in spirited defeat. He was an energetic lummox who radiated a rampant insanity the young 'uns conflated with charisma, and that look was something else. A balloon-muscled colour wheel, the Warrior looked like a living superhero designed by a focus group of giddy children.
An exceptionally ruthless and singleminded human being with no great love for his chosen profession, Warrior was an overnight sensation, pretty much, and this sparked a sense of entitlement within him. He didn't lose; he was paid very handsomely; he worked when he felt like it. Bret Hart, after watching Warrior tell a young, terminally ill fan to give him a "f*ckin' minute" - how many minutes did that child have? - described him as the worst role model he had ever seen. It was one of the nicer things said or written about this man.
CONT'D...(3 of 5)
Once it was established that the WWF was going with the Warrior, he never lost cleanly in canon. He literally sprinted to the Intercontinental Title, and while there were losses engineered unfairly by Bobby Heenan along the way, these were mere diversions to his ascent; Warrior never lost that Intercontinental Title for a second time. He vacated it after winning the big one, the winged eagle, becoming in effect the most powerful force in Federation history, looking at the literal worth of his accomplishments.
His WWF Title reign was a huge disappointment. He worked familiar opponents from his very recent past, which didn't help, nor did the imminent end of wrestling's popularity cycle. Warrior's work didn't have the same storytelling or emotive substance to it as Hogan's. A fad within a dying fad, McMahon took the strap off him at Royal Rumble 1991, and it's ironic; his selling of that infamous sceptre shot was superb, as was his performance at WrestleMania VII in the semi-main slot. Maybe the big man he always claimed to be dealt better without the pressure of assuming Hogan's spot, though he did not agree with that interpretation.
Ahead of SummerSlam 1991, Warrior requested vastly improved terms, out of nowhere, claiming he meant as much "or more" to the man he had statistically failed to replace in Hulk Hogan. McMahon acquiesced, to preserve the appeal of the upcoming SummerSlam show, before out-carnying Warrior. He suspended him indefinitely immediately after the show. Warrior couldn't do business on his way out because he was told to f*ck off.
CONT'D...(4 of 5)
He returned at WrestleMania VIII, worked a dire programme with Papa Shango, and left a few months later for reasons that are disputed, but have everything to do with how juiced to the gills he was. He returned in 1996, crushed a lot of midcard talent, but didn't get a run in the main event because he played his extortion games again, and after more acrimony surrounding comic books and the suspicion of dying fathers and how much they were loved - Jesus Christ, what a pair of lunatics - Warrior left, never to wrestle for WWE again.
There is a record and footage of Warrior losing cleanly to André The Giant, on a 1988 Italy house show, but house shows don't count. They happened, yes, but in general, house shows never factor in to WWE canon outside of the odd title change. And that's less "You can't miss a second of WWE!" and more "MSG is on its a*se again - arbitrarily switch a midcard title because we still love the old bugger we're too cheap to run on TV".
Maybe the Warrior thought losing in a predetermined pseudo-sport was gay or something, the awful homophobe, because he never did when he was all the way over. To avoid defeat, a wrestler might work hard on their conditioning to endure longer than the rest. They might study the pure art of technical wrestling to reverse any manner of pinning combination. They might draw on the roar of the crowd for support.
Warrior however was simply a gigantic temperamental prick who just spat his dummy out on the regular. It wasn't too removed, athletically, from what he did in the ring. And so the formula for never losing cleanly is: being a megastar and either knowing your worth or being an unprofessional, flake sh*theel. The truth lies somewhere in the middle.
In summation, if there's a lesson to be learned, we were cruelly reminded of it this week: to make it pro wrestling, it helps enormously if you are terrible human being!