The Problem With Andrade That No One Wants To Talk About
This isn't an Andrade problem, but a Vince McMahon and WWE problem...
Andrade is on his way out of WWE.
Or at least, Andrade wants to be on his way out of WWE.
Last week's news that the former NXT and United States Champion had requested his WWE release was quickly followed, predictably, by confirmation that the promotion had turned this down. Like many before him, it looks like the 31-year-old will be left to rot for the time being.
This is common practice. If WWE deems a wantaway wrestler to be a potential asset to a rival company, they'll hold onto them rather than clearing their way to waltz into an AEW or New Japan and help boost their business. FTR were made to wait 15 months for their release after initially asking, while Brodie Lee was retained for eight, and PAC 10. Depending on when his contract expires, Andrade faces a similar ordeal.
It's a ghoulish custom, particularly when the wrestler's only alternative is to subserviently accept their lot in an environment they aren't happy in, as is the case with Andrade. Dated 12 March, his latest Instagram post was accompanied by a telling caption:-
Si no te gusta donde estás muévete no eres un árbol! Feliz fin de semana! If you don't like where you are, move you are not a tree. Great weekend! #andrade #elidolo #outfit #style #estilo #salud #weekend
But what brought us to this point?
How does a wrestler earmarked for long-term success as recently as last June end up trying to engineer an exit from the world's biggest wrestling promotion nine months later?
CONT'd...
Andrade and Zelina Vega's success shouldn't have had a ceiling.
Vega arrived in November 2017, two years into an NXT run that had seen the former La Sombra veering dangerously close to becoming the first big-name black and gold bust. He had floundered in his fedora and suspenders, forced into an ill-fitting babyface act he was visibly uncomfortably in, floundering while Finn Balor and Samoa Joe soared and those signed after him (Bobby Roode, Shinsuke Nakamura, et al.) lapped him on the racetrack.
This was an immediately transformative pairing, as Vega counteracted Andrade's biggest roadblock to long-term WWE success. For better or worse, the ability to cut lengthy English promos is a prerequisite for being pushed in Stamford and Orlando. Andrade attended language classes, improved, and embarked on a process that would take years to complete without Zelina. Together, the wrestler who helped bring five-star matches back to WWE for the first time in seven years and an elite talker with similar charisma and confidence should have climbed main roster mountains.
Should have.
In 2020, things fell apart. Andrade was United States Champion for 151 days but accomplished little of note in a lengthy reign by modern standards. A promising stable with Angel Garza lost credibility before it could build anyway, as they were immediately booked into losing positions. By October, Andrade had no belt, no stable, no manager, and no brand, having gone undrafted in WWE's latest roster reshuffle, while Vega went to SmackDown. One month later, Zelina was out of the company.
A can't-miss act had missed. As is often the case, it was neither Andrade nor Vega's fault...
CONT'd...
Andrade took time off after losing to Garza on Raw's 12 October 2020 episode, reportedly to undergo a minor surgical procedure. Reports of an NXT return swirled. Two months later, El Idolo was linked with an onscreen role alongside real-life fiancée Charlotte Flair, a company favourite.
Neither happened. Five months have passed since Andrade's last televised appearance. With the release request, we have likely seen the last of him in WWE.
Objectively, Andrade failed to reach the heights his act warranted. He didn't even come close. A guy that should have become a megastar will go down as another midcard should-have-been - and it isn't his fault.
Though some may point to Andrade's inability to cut lengthy English promos that fit Vince McMahon's erratic, ever-changing tastes as a reason for his failure, this was nullified by Vega. Managers exist to cover such flaws and Zelina was one of the best. This shouldn't have been an issue.
Charisma? Even when wearing a mask as La Sombra, Andrade oozed it. Look at the coolness seeping from the Instagram image posted above. The guy has it.
In-ring ability? Please.
Unquestionably, this isn't an Andrade problem, but a WWE problem, and a systemic issue rather than an individual issue.
WWE's quest to find a new megastar for its Spanish-speaking audience failed again.
CONT'd...
Creating stars intended to pop his humungous but underrepresented television demographic is something WWE has been trying to do for years, with countless wrestlers of Latino and Hispanic backgrounds trialled near the top.
The success of Rey Mysterio, Eddie Guerrero, and others in American wrestling drives this, but labelling a wrestler "the new Guerrero/Mysterio" is as big a curse as calling somebody that "next Undertaker." It places immeasurable expectations on the performer's shoulders, whether it comes from the media or WWE itself, and nobody has ever lived up to it.
Luis Alvirde, the original Sin Cara, was a huge star in his native Mexico, to the extent that he rightfully won the Wrestling Observer's Best Box Office Draw award in 2006, sandwiched between Kenta Kobashi the previous year and John Cena in 2007. He remains an elite high-flyer to this date but ultimately failed in a promotion that thrust him onto American television without adequate preparation, forcing the difficult adaptation from Lucha Libre to Sports Entertainment on the job, spawning the botches that killed his credibility. Reported attitude issues played a similar role in his demise, and Alvirde was gone within three years.
Alberto Del Rio had the size, technique, and for a long time, the office support, but was an unengaging performer for long periods and suffered from his own behavioural problems. Kalisto was once labelled the next Rey and Eddie but has never broken out of the undercard.
Andrade would have been in a better position to succeed had WWE learned from these failures, but they didn't, and unlike Del Rio, Kalisto, and Sin Cara, he didn't have the botches, reported bad attitude, or lack of size. With Vega, he was the total package.
There are no excuses. The system failed him.
CONT'd...
The current WWE roster isn't short of Hispanic and Latino wrestlers who the promotion has failed to make money-drawing stars of.
Garza got the cursed Guerrero comparison in June 2020, with Vince personally drawing that line, presumably for his combination of magnetic charisma and high-level wrestling ability. Less than a year later, the former NXT Cruiserweight Champion wrestles exclusively on Main Event. Joining him on the D-show is his cousin, Humberto Carrillo, whose last Raw singles match was in August.
Bad Bunny is currently given as much television time as WWE can afford him as the promotion believes the more he is onscreen, the more their Hispanic and Latino audience is going to be engaged. Alongside him his Damian Priest, who has been pinpointed as another future star and has benefitted from featuring with Bunny, whose audience is huge. Priest certainly has the right combination of skills to succeed where others failed.
But so did Andrade.
This is part of a wider problem: a broken star-making system that hasn't created a genuine game-changer since John Cena, and has left a WWE roster barren of star power. You can count on one hand the number of Raw, SmackDown, and NXT wrestlers with a recent track record of pushing ratings and other consumer metrics in the right direction.
For his own sake, let's hope Andrade is soon free of this mess.
CONT'd...
A hungry Andrade unleashed on the wider wrestling world is an exciting proposition.
Whether he landed in New Japan, AEW, Impact Wrestling, or CMLL, he'd immediately be a top-five worker on the roster and a pushable commodity right out the gates. If he signs with an American promotion and he and the former Zelina Vega end up on the same roster, tremendous. They can pick up exactly where they left off. If he goes full-time in Mexico or Japan, no problem: he has gotten over in these countries on his own before.
And we know he's hungry because he asked for his release rather than sitting around, waiting for a pink slip that may never come. Andrade doesn't want to sit in catering and gather dust. He wants to work, and if he didn't, he wouldn't be trying to engineer an exit.
Barring a disaster, Andrade will become a bigger asset to another wrestling promotion than he ever was to Vince McMahon's company. The market leaders will again learn nothing from this, and their giant vaults of money will tell them they don't have to.
Strictly, they don't.
But it'd be nice if the world's largest wrestling promotion could learn how to build wrestling stars again.