The Problem With Bray Wyatt That No One Wants To Talk About
AEW, NJPW, and IMPACT are right there, but forecasting Bray Wyatt's next wrestling move isn't easy.
WWE has released 41 wrestlers in 2021. Of this number, two stand out as the most surprising.
Braun Strowman’s name looked like a typo on WWE’s 2 June cut list. The 37-year-old was just two weeks removed from a WWE Title program, held the Universal Championship as recently August 2020, and at one point resembled everything Vince McMahon looks for in a giant. When his 2017 breakout year revealed almost shocking levels of charisma and explosiveness for a man initially written off as a big, lumbering stiff, Strowman looked better equipped to become ‘The Guy’ than his best opponent, Roman Reigns, who remained in the midst of WWE’s most toxic modern push.
Furthermore, Braun was a system guy. A ground-up project. Developmental laid the foundations around his million-dollar look and powerlifting background. Even though his knees were ground to chalk by the end, WWE invested the best part of a decade into making Braun Strowman a thing. Their thing.
None of this mattered when budget cut season rolled back around. Indeed, all that mattered to WWE’s axe-swingers was Braun’s reported $1.2 million contract.
31 July saw Strowman usurped as 2021’s most surprising WWE release when his former stablemate, Bray Wyatt, was let go. This was a shock. A genuine, internet-breaking shock in a different stratosphere to the others, given his tenure (Bray’s run lasted over 12 years), popularity, and uniqueness.
Like Braun, Bray entered WWE with no wrestling experience and was built to world championship level. Also like Braun, Bray was fed that old chestnut, “budget cuts”, upon release.
This was despite his status as a proven money-maker for McMahon’s enterprise.
CONT’d...
Sean Ross Sapp confirmed in his first post-release report that whenever Wyatt was active, he made WWE money. This shouldn’t come as a huge surprise. Bray’s name was a lock to appear on any list of top merchandise sellers to be published while he was on television. Whatever your subjective thoughts on his creations, they were marketable - and Wyatt’s passionate fanbase needed little convincing to trade cash for Fiend masks, “let me in” shirts, and other trinkets.
The “budget cuts” excuse is therefore hard to accept. It’s hard to accept in any case, of course, but if the company’s top merch-shifter isn’t safe, who is?
We now know that a considerable chunk of the WWE locker-room is as dubious of the company’s reasoning as the fans. Unfortunately for Wyatt, however, selling truckloads of t-shirts and $7,000 replica belts doesn’t mean what it used to.
Per Wrestlenomics’ Brandon Thurston , only 30% of WWE’s revenue came from direct-to-consumer sources in 2020. Thurston estimates that the number will fall to 21% in 2021. In 2012, when Bray debuted on the main roster, it was 67%. The game is changing. As time passes, an increasing majority of WWE’s revenue comes from other businesses, not wrestling fans. Merchandise sales are a shrinking drop in a growing ocean.
This isn’t the case everywhere in wrestling. If Wyatt retains his merch-shifting prowess in his next wrestling home, wherever that may be, he will likely be an even bigger financial asset to that company than he was to WWE.
CONT’d
WWE risked alienating a considerable chunk of its fanbase by cutting Bray Wyatt, even though he split opinion
Especially online, people who like The Fiend really like The Fiend. The character’s detractors are as passionate as those who love it, making it the most divisive in wrestling today, and Wyatt inspires unbreaking devotion in some and fierce disdain in others. Rarely will you meet someone who will answer “eh, he’s okay,” when asked for their opinion on the 34-year-old.
Bray’s fans’ passion is such that it’s reasonable to assume a sizeable number will follow him to wherever he lands next. This is a credit to him, particularly as so much of what made it to WWE television came from his mind.
The issue is that pinpointing Windham Rotunda’s next wrestling destination isn’t easy.
Indeed, the problem with Bray Wyatt that no one wants to talk about is that he has just been cut from the one wrestling promotion that fit him better than any other. In 2021, no other company that could realistically sign Bray is as welcoming to his specific brand of creativity, the supernatural, and stretching the definition of “professional wrestling” as the McMahon Content House.
This is particularly true of WWE's closest wrestling competition.
CONT'd...
Roughly 24 hours after Wyatt's WWE release, your writer tweeted a poll asking fans where they expected the former Fiend to show up next. Perhaps predictably, 55.7% of the 2,601 respondees chose AEW.
This is understandable. AEW is the world's second-largest promotion, has the financial clout to secure a name of Bray's size, and, crucially, offers greater creative freedom to its talents compared to WWE. The phrase "creative genius" came out a lot in the wake of Wyatt getting cut. Whatever you think of that generous appraisal, Windham Rotunda is unquestionably a man of many ideas, a lot of which made it to television, and is now perceived as somebody hamstrung by WWE's famously restrictive system.
But AEW's system doesn't suit him either.
Speaking on Talk is Jericho in February, Tony Khan admitted his regret at allowing Matt Hardy to teleport to the ring in his AEW debut, saying he should have rejected the idea. The reality-bending Broken Matt character has since been shuttered. Meanwhile, AEW announcers have stressed that the company's other supernatural adjacent character, Abadon, isn't supposed to be a zombie, but a crazy person who thinks she's a zombie. While a reanimated corpse cannot believably exist in AEW's more sport-centric universe, this portrayal fits its rules.
Even in NXT, when his character's more mysterious elements were left to the viewer's imagination rather than stated outright, Wyatt skirted the line. It's unlikely that he'd have that freedom in AEW. Bray might not be able to flex the full range of his creativity - which could lead to frustration.
Windham Rotunda and All Elite Wrestling is a poor fit. But not the worst.
CONT'd...
New Japan Pro Wrestling isn't New Japan Pro Wrestling anymore. The golden era is over, brought down by Dick Togo's increased influence in the creative room, Gedo's overreliance on tedious western tropes, misguided main event pushes (hello, EVIL), and the recent cannibalisation of the IWGP Heavyweight Title's legacy. Regardless, it remains the most reality-driven of wrestling's three biggest promotions. It's hard to see a character in the vein of those typically concocted by Wyatt fitting in.
It would break NJPW's universe.
And with all due respect to Bray, for all his positive attributes as a performer, he doesn't exactly have a long list of traditionally great singles matches to use as evidence when making a case for a New Japan run. Come G1 season, he would likely be a fish out of water. That's a problem - and NJPW would risk alienating much of its core fanbase by booking Wyatt in the heavily-gimmicked stipulations that sustained Bray for much of his WWE run.
Which leaves us with IMPACT Wrestling: another imperfect choice, given the promotion's low viewership and unknown financial situation. Signing Wyatt, who is coming off a big-money contract, could be a stretch too far for that company's accountants.
But through gimmicks like the Undead Realm and characters like Decay, IMPACT has shown its willingness to dabble in the supernatural. There's reason to believe that Wyatt would have freer rein there than anywhere else. He'd likely be happier, more fulfilled, and at home on this smaller platform, as imperfect as it is.
Really, though, the saddest part of all this isn't that Wyatt was jettisoned from the one company best suited to his abilities.
It's that the perfect wrestling promotion for him and his characters isn't around anymore.
CONT'd...
With its man-eating monsters, dragons, Aztecian warriors, and other wild characters, Lucha Underground would have been ideal for Bray Wyatt. More a fantasy show than a wrestling promotion, Dario Cueto's temple and Windham Rotunda would have been a match made in whatever Boyle Heights' equivalent of heaven is.
Sadly, that company is no longer with us. It lives on through the elements borrowed by MLW's Azteca Underground group (including Cueto himself), but it's hard to see that company having the resources to scoop Wyatt up.
The counterpoint to all of this is that Bray's most fervent supporters are likely to follow him wherever he goes next. While never a major ratings draw for WWE, Wyatt could conceivably benefit a promotion like IMPACT should his fanbase's loyalty hold firm through his free agency and beyond, potentially boosting their business. The Anthem-helmed group could probably use the extra t-shirt sales.
But the cost to a more reality-driven product like AEW or NJPW's could be greater than any money brought in through the merch store. Existing viewers may be alienated by horror movie tropes and supernatural flirtations, which is where the bulk of Wyatt's creativity seems to lie, and who knows if Bray is capable of or even wants to play a straighter character. What makes him so appealing to some is exactly what drives others away.
Finding Bray Wyatt's next professional wrestling home will likely be a game of compromises. There isn't an easy answer to the question of where he'll end up next when so few of the industry's major companies feel like good fits, because his identity is both his biggest strength and his biggest weakness.