The Problem With Keith Lee That No One Wants To Talk About

From Limitless to Limited.

Keith Lee
WWE.com

Even for Vince McMahon, booking Keith Lee should be one of the easiest jobs in professional wrestling.

The many flaws of WWE's broken star-making machine make it difficult for anyone to stay over beyond the initial honeymoon period, but Lee has the sport's most appropriate nickname. He is 'Limitless'. There isn't a single hole in his game and while any improvements made during his two-year stint in the WWE system are negligible, NXT and the Performance Center at least helped him acclimate to the promotion's oft arcane methods before jumping to the main roster.

"Athletic big man" is almost cliché in 2020, given how many wrestling giants are so light on their feet these days, but none of them are like Lee. Dominik Slapjackovic can match his athleticism but can't talk as well, isn't as physically imposing, and doesn't project superstar charisma. Damian Priest does, though Lee is smoother and more adept at laying out a match. Luchasaurus is considerably slower and his gimmick has a lower ceiling. Braun Strowman lost his explosiveness a long time ago. While Brock Lesnar's aura and presence are unmatched, he'll never be tied to a full-time schedule.

So Lee is a unique, versatile, and infinitely marketable commodity, who carries himself like a star, exudes confidence, is well-regarded behind the scenes, and has a record of great matches that speaks for itself. Getting him right should be easy: he'll do most of the hard work himself.

Why, then, is his main roster already stuttering less than six weeks removed from his call-up?

(Author's note: nobody is saying Keith Lee is being "buried" here. Let's make that immediately clear. He isn't "ruined," either: this is just a middling main roster run that should be an excellent one.)

CONT'd...


Keith Lee Randy Orton
WWE.com

Everybody wants to talk about the changes made to Keith Lee's presentation since he transitioned from NXT to Raw; nobody wants to talk about the reason for them.

The new entrance music sucks, yes, but it's irrelevant to this discussion. WWE pitched the move to escape a "terrible deal" their old themesters, CFO$, struck with their publishers, forgoing around 50% of all royalty payments. When given a say on the matter, Lee reportedly okayed it.

Switching Lee's gear raises bigger questions.

When 'The Limitless One' walked out for his debut match against Randy Orton on Raw's 24 August episode, he did so wearing what looked like a wrestling-themed babygro. Rather than wearing the tight shorts he'd sported for the bulk of his career, Lee sported a looser pair and, crucially, had his torso covered up by a sleeveless rashguard. Clad in attire more fit for practise or the gym than the ThunderDome's bright lights, it was an immediate red flag.

This was Vince McMahon solving a problem that didn't exist. Though we are long removed from the days of aesthetics being a prerequisite for high-level success, wrestling remains an aesthetic-driven business. These things still matter. Lee looks significantly less imposing covered up than when he fought bare-chested, as he'd done for the entirety of his NXT run - and before that as well. It was a needless, shortsighted move from a mind stuck several decades in the past, and while WWE has since improved the attire by having Lee switch to a singlet with tighter shorts, they are still undermining his physical presence.

Keith Lee is a brick of a human being. With this change, Vince is inadvertently diminishing an important part of his aesthetic.

And as for his booking...

CONT'd...


Drew McIntyre Keith Lee
WWE.com

First, the good.

Rubbing shoulders with Randy Orton and Drew McIntyre throughout his first month-and-a-half on Raw was a good sign that WWE saw something special in Lee. Few wrestlers enjoy the luxury of diving straight into the main event scene, so sharing airtime with a company legend and the current, credible World Champion in the midst of a well-received headlining program suggests WWE is earnestly well-intentioned. They'd like him to be a big deal.

Wrestling the 'Legend Killer' to a disqualification on night one was an acceptable first step because, well, it was the first step. Six days later, Lee took a huge leap forward. 'The Limitless One' defeated a 13-time World Champion without a whiff of shenanigans at Payback 2020. The bout lasted less than seven minutes in total and its layout may have come from Orton himself, who was reported to have pitched putting his opponent over strong. If he did, fair play to him. WWE has an urgent need to make new stars: defeating a company legend and future Hall of Famer so soundly is a great way to kickstart that process.

Lee has wrestled eight "main roster" matches at the time of writing. Six of those have involved McIntyre or Orton, and his latest was a three-minute trouncing of former United States Champion and Andrade. On 31 August, he came within a hair of becoming number one contender to McIntyre's WWE Championship, only "losing" a Triple Threat when Seth Rollins was pinned by Orton.

Good signs, all of them. It's a shame that none of them were executed with any conviction.

CONT'd...


WWE Payback 2020 Randy Orton Keith Lee
WWE.com

Keith Lee d. Randy Orton (6:40)? That's booking with balls.

Four of his first seven main roster matches ending via disqualification or countout? That, most certainly, is not.

Payback aside, each of Lee's singles clashes with Orton and McIntyre has ended in shenanigans. A common rebuttal to this is "neither man can afford to lose," but if that's the case, why book the match in the first place? If you don't want to have the former NXT Champion score more than one clear, decisive victory, then find somebody else for him to defeat. To date, his only clean wins have come over a squashed Andrade and the weird 2020 version of Dolph Ziggler.

Dirty finishes are a company-wide problem, of course. Rather than keeping the loser "protected," they inspire fatigue in a jaded audience that grew tired of them many moons ago, particularly amongst fans who remember what the artform was like before such things became the norm. It is a lame, raisin-balled booked practice and a total cop-out, putting heat on the writers and detracting attention from the people who are supposed to be getting a "rub."

Like Keith Lee.

A gutsier booking team would have used Lee's victory over Orton to launch him towards the WWE Title feud, making it a Triple Threat. This would have freshened up the already-strong McIntyre feud and given Keith an actual rub: he would have become a joint protagonist in the story, not a secondary character killed off in the second act, even if he failed to win (and realistically, he probably shouldn't have become WWE Champion so quickly).

Still, it feels increasingly like those penning this "push" are asleep at the wheel.

CONT'd...


Keith Lee
WWE.com

22 September saw the Wrestling Observer's Dave Meltzer come through with a new report on WWE's plans for Lee, stating that the promotion wanted to keep presenting him as something resembling a top star without scripting anything specific to him.

This is another red flag.

WWE books for goldfish, largely dropping long-term planning for moment-to-moment pops, hoping their audience will conveniently forget about Raw and SmackDown's weekly logic leaps. This has created a toxic fan culture in which anyone who points these logic leaps out is accused of overanalysing things and told to "just enjoy" weak storytelling, which is absurd. Audiences deserve more than to be taken as absent-minded children.

"Make him look like a star" is too vague and unassertive to yield positive results, particularly in this universe, where great long-term stories like Bayley vs. Sasha Banks are the exception rather than the rule. Keith needs something concrete. Rubbing shoulders with main-eventers for six straight weeks doesn't constitute a rub in itself, though successfully following up on Payback would have.

WWE didn't do that, though. Instead, they had this potential "top star" wallow through the muck of three non-finishes in a row, then slip back down the ladder, left drifting towards a midcard ocean few are ever fortunate to truly break away from.

CONT'd...


Keith Lee
WWE.com

Again, Keith Lee has not been ruined. He isn't buried. We aren't talking about a disastrous main roster run here: as far as introductions go, this is one of the better ones WWE has pulled off in recent years.

But the problems can't be ignored.

Lee is a fantastic five-tool player who suffered similarly slipshod booking early in his NXT run, where he was forgotten about for weeks before being used to put Lars Sullivan (of all people) over. In the end, he dethroned the longest-reigning NXT Champion of all time, held the top belt simultaneously with the North American strap, and played a key role in getting the next guy (Karrion Kross) to where he needed to be. Unquestionably, Lee became an NXT stud. This point could have been dismissed as a positive by pointing towards the black and gold brand's superior booking a few years ago, though this is necessarily the case in 2020, where WWE's sacred cow show is often as contrived and rife with bunk writing as Raw and SmackDown.

That he took full flight in Full Sail is a good sign he can prosper on Raw. He'll get new entrance music, we'll get used to the attire, and there's every chance we'll see him holding a World Title within the next couple of years. Moving to SmackDown in the upcoming draft could kickstart this process.

First, however, WWE must shred its own red flags.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Keith Lee
 
Posted On: 
Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.