The Terrifying Decline Of NJPW

A New Beginning is needed - a but a New Beginning, for now, is impossible.

AEW

The Rainmaker Shock was probably the greatest booking decision of all-time.

At The New Beginning 2012, with Hiroshi Tanahashi in his prime as Ace, he lost to Kazuchika Okada, who had wrestled just one (dismal) singles match upon returning from a dire TNA excursion. Okada was very young at the time - 24 - but looked even younger on the match graphic. Underscoring how unprepared he seemed for the role, he looked like a gawky, awkward teenager, his face trapped in the mutation between boyhood and adulthood. And yet, he was incredible in that match and sprinted towards megastardom the second the bell rang. It was so effective that it reverberated well into the proceeding decade.

11 full years later, the precedent of the Rainmaker Shock encouraged many fans to believe that, when NJPW really needed a lift, the returning Yota Tsuji - one of the three Reiwa Musketeers tasked with leading NJPW into a new era - would defeat IWGP World champion SANADA at Dominion 2023.

It was easy to lead a promotion into a bold new era. On February 12, 2012, Gedo needed just 23 minutes and 23 seconds.

Something like it had happened before; it was almost necessary that something like it would happen again. It didn't happen. A nostalgic memory had blinded fans from both the current reality and indeed the truth of how becoming a star actually works. Gedo in some ways is a victim of his own success.

If it was all just as easy as picking a talented wrestler with significant potential to be a star to cleanly defeat an established star, really, no promotion ever would find itself in a down period. A booker would simply handpick a talented wrestler with significant potential to be a star to cleanly defeat an established star, and repeat the cycle ad nauseam. Obviously, it isn't that simple. Gedo, to his immense credit, just made it look that simple.

A lot of factors make the process very complicated. Not all wrestlers are Hiroshi Tanahashi. That decision wasn't entirely altruistic; while Tanahashi was driven to do business the right way after enduring political nightmares of his own, he was smart enough to identify and help make a guy he could make money with over the long-term. Politics get in the way. Why, for example, would Okada do a job for jobs for the new generation of Musketeers?

He isn't working with them over the next few years. He's off, and taking a loss to a wrestler who isn't over might have damaged his brand as an independent contractor. If he cared, Okada might also point out, in his defence, that the process of losing to one's potential replacement need not actually happen.

CONT'D...(1 of 5)


WWE WrestleMania 38 Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE.com

Amid the fury aimed at Okada over the last few weeks, it's easy to overlook that Shinsuke Nakamura simply vacated the Intercontinental title before departing for WWE in 2016, and in a notable parallel, he went out in the exact same manner as Okada. Both Nakamura and Okada represented CHAOS eight years apart in a multi-man and won on their last night. That the CHAOS stable has existed between those two dates, incidentally, highlights yet another issue.

The difference is that Kenny Omega, who won the vacated title, was actually ready. Also: Omega disclosed on the short-lived Wrestlers On The Road Ordering Room Service YouTube series that Nakamura not doing a job was a WWE demand. Nakamura might well have done the job, were it up to him, but ultimately, it didn't happen. Nor did it matter: Omega very, very quickly became one of the top stars in the company. He and Tetsuya Naito, reborn as a member of Los Ingobernables having joined on a tour of CMLL, replaced Nakamura and AJ Styles at the top of the card, driving the resurgence yet further. Naito wrestled three singles matches against Styles, and while the record was 2-1 in his favour, Styles won their most significant meeting at Wrestle Kingdom 9. Naito last defeated Styles half a year before Styles left. There was no ceremonial passing of the torch. Naito was booked well and consistently and had truly earned the push; he did not need a symbolic last-ditch win even if it were that easy. Styles was battered out of New Japan by the Bullet Club Elite, yes, but that fabled last big job?

Neither AJ nor Nakamura did it.

All of which is to state that NJPW is in deep sh*t, and the solution that never ended up happening probably wouldn't have made an iota of a difference. This is Gedo's fault, not Okada's.

The Reiwa Musketeers branding exercise of Shota Umino, Ren Narita and Yota Tsuj is a betrayal of show-don't-tell, and worse still, Gedo is barely telling the audience that these young men are stars capable of replacing Okada nor Will Ospreay. The rot - that cannot be reversed with a token win - set in long before Okada even entertained the notion of leaving. Even before the pandemic, NJPW was declining slowly. By 2019, many of the key combinations of top guys felt very familiar, and the likes of Tanahashi and Naito and Ibushi looked battle-worn in particular. Even when it was great, it was an echo of itself.

Omega departed for the nascent All Elite Wrestling in early 2019. He did his last job for up-and-comer...Hiroshi Tanahashi. He famously tasked Ospreay and Jay White with leading New Japan into the next decade. Ospreay took the challenge more literally, becoming the consensus best wrestler in the world amongst critics (although some continue to loathe what they perceive to be a heavily indulgent and transparent composite approach of what all great wrestling should look like).

White is altogether more difficult to judge.

CONT'D...(2 of 5)


Jay White Mark Briscoe
AEW

There is no consensus with a contrarian backlash.

Everybody seemed to struggle to determine how good and effective he really was. Was White a true heel who really "got" how to draw heat in an era of fan service acclaim? Or was his relentless stalling cheap? White is technically superb, an expert in the "when" to do something in a big dramatic match, but did he reach the emotional crescendo of the 2019 G1 Climax final ever again?

The blunt truth is that, if you were to write a list of the best NJPW wrestlers of the Bushiroad era, White would rank below every other name that enjoyed a stint with the IWGP title. He was excellent, but his matches were often dense and soulless. Ironically, the wrestler who sought to strip the workrate back was himself a bit much.

The COVID-19 pandemic was instrumental in the downfall even if the creative decline predated it. After a brief hiatus, New Japan returned to "clap crowds" reduced in number that weren't allowed to vocalise their emotion. Gedo did something more shocking than Okada's maiden title win at Dominion '20: he strapped up EVIL. EVIL was a fun, sullen midcard brute and absolutely nothing more. This was a diabolical decision, as high a shark-jump as you'll ever see: the sort of decision a booker makes when they shouldn't be booking anymore.

Even the inexplicable greatness yielded throughout this period, on occasion, was bittersweet. The clapping lasted for ages too. Japan was far more stringent than the US with its protocols; it was only at Wrestle Kingdom 17, on January 4, 2023, that something close to true noise returned. By this point, the damage was done. That was Jay White's last big night. He lost to Okada in a main event that almost definitely concluded that the "Okada match" had peaked. Ospreay would be gone in just over a year. Naito was still hugely popular, but was broken-down, his latest stab at the Ace position driven as much by sentiment as anything else. Tanahashi had long since become an athritic New Japan "dad", working his last worthy main event at AEW x NJPW Forbidden Door 2022 against Jon Moxley. Shingo Takagi and Tomohiro Ishii were still fantastic, the latter almost inexplicably so, but had been stigmatised as wrestlers who (somehow) would never be true Ace figures.

Underneath, oh boy.

KENTA wasn't just washed; he took a perverse pride in it. Chase Owens stuck around. David Finlay as a key member of Bullet Club was workrate Vincent. Hikuleo's ceiling was never that high, and yet he positively stormed last year's flabby, depressing G1 Climax. NJPW put the mid in midcard as its main event scene reached an event horizon of sameness. It wasn't all bad - El Desperado and Taichi deserve immense credit for improving beyond all recognition and expectation - and Bishamon saw two no-hopers find success together against all odds. Zack Sabre, Jr. was never not great either. The overall vibe however was bleak, and with every passing gruelling "epic" match, the lure of the promotion faded. Ultimately, the standard set throughout the 2010s resurgence was too high.

Where do you go from there?

CONT'D...(3 of 5)


SANADA Jack Perry
AEW

It's very difficult for fans to care about inferior versions of long, 30 minute-plus matches in the same format. As great as New Japan was for years, the main event style was daunting even then. It's daunting, very familiar and simply not as good now. A decade and change of the Okada main event style was, particularly in the last few years, all a bit much. It's hard to emulate that formula. Has it been mentioned that Gedo's NJPW promoted countless incredibly long main event matches? The last thing you'd want to do after reading a 500,000 word book is read another 500,000 book by an inferior author.

Tsuji, Umino, all those guys simply aren't as good. They really aren't anywhere close yet. It will take NJPW years to become as great as it once was. It would also take a complete philosophical overhaul for NJPW to even feel refreshing. That's the hard part. For many, there just isn't an incentive to dive back in. NJPW is stuck. And on those Musketeers again...

Gedo perhaps didn't feel like he had to be bold because SANADA was his guy; he just built him more slowly than he had Okada and Omega. He persevered, much like he had with Naito. SANADA, the recent winner of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter Most Overrated award, is getting a kicking domestically and internationally. He's not as great in the ring as the last fleet of top guys technically, and to be blunt, he shows such little emotion that it's a mystery he was ever deemed capable of leading the promotion. SANADA is a factory-made version of what somebody thinks a top NJPW guy is: an eerily, perfectly handsome void. Not to go two-footed on the guy when he's down, but really, he's such a nonentity, amid this talk of the Musketeers and the lack of conviction there, that it's easy to forget NJPW has pushed a talent into the main event bracket. That talent is just that forgettable.

Gedo is at fault too. He probably should have realised that SANADA has given every indication that he just doesn't want it. New Japan is less bound by tradition than it once was - the creation of the IWGP Women's title evidence of that - but the promotion is still weirdly stubborn about certain things. The charismatic superstar Hiromu Takahashi should have graduated to the heavyweight ranks ages in ago in anticipation of this malaise, but that sort of move usually takes forever, too long, if it actually happens.

Worse still, as often happens when a promotion suddenly realises how highly the water is rising, NJPW is now desperate.

CONT'D...(4 of 5)


Kazuchika Okada Bryan Danielson
AEW

The promotion is firmly locked in two states that each mirror the worst of two developments that unfolded in the west in the same decade of Gedo's triumph.

NJPW enjoyed its most recent success when visited by AEW's Kenny Omega and Bryan Danielson across the last two Wrestle Kingdom events. Something not too dissimilar to WWE's "part-timer" phase is happening. In parallel, looking at the absolute state of the recent New Beginning tour, NJPW is also in its Total Nonstop Shin Nihon era. Nick Nemeth and Matt Riddle both emerged with gold at the New Beginning recently. Nemeth to his credit really seems to want it, but...come on. Belting up an ageing veteran synonymous with WWE is such a TNA cliché. The optics are terrible. It was difficult enough to invest in the Musketeers, dwarfed as they are in the shadow of their predecessors; now, a desperate Gedo would rather go the short-term route rather than believe in his young crew.

Maybe that young crew does have the potential to star, and Gedo simply isn't the man to promote them. He is devoid entirely of new ideas. He's scrambling. He isn't bold enough. He's getting stubborn, too, looking at the House of Torture. He's backing the wrong talent. He deserves credit for being great for longer than the rest, but like every wrestling booker ever, he has lost the plot.

The title of this editorial isn't hyperbolic.

Every long-established market-leading promotion will at some point or another enter a cold period, even a tailspin, and recover. WWE was thrashed by WCW once upon a time. AAA once threatened to unseat CMLL, the oldest promotion on the planet. That seems impossible, but it happened. NJPW itself experienced a tumultuous period throughout the 2000s.

This latest cooling off is more scary, though, because the knock-on effect of the pandemic was exponential. The right thing to do often comes at a cost, and this was literally true of Japan's approach to COVID. The economy was annihilated.

There's very little big money to be made in Japan now as, in parallel, the two US majors have never had more of it to throw around. As Dave Meltzer first pointed out, a Japanese star on Okada's level has never left Japan to star in the US. The new economic reality is so brutal that it has uprooted the very culture of loyalty at the core of Japanese pro wrestling. At this rate, Forbidden Door 2023 will look remarkably like the WWF lending Smoky Mountain Wrestling a hand in the mid-'90s. The only way out is the long route. The memories of New Japan's seminal resurgence are too vivid for anything to look worthy in contrast. NJPW is haunted by its own brilliance.

NJPW might have to endure a very sh*tty present for its future, through perspective alone, to feel anywhere as vital as the past.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!