The WORST Moment From EVERY WWE SummerSlam

28. Hotly-Anticipated Main = Highway To Hell! (1998)

WWE WWF SummerSlam 1998 Steve Austin The Undertaker
WWE.com

WWF 'Attitude' was on fire by the summer of 1998. Austin had bounced back from disaster at the prior year's event, won the title at WrestleMania XIV, and he'd even elevated Kane by trading the belt with him before SummerSlam's clash with The Undertaker. Life was good, and it looked certain that Austin and 'Taker would rip the roof off Madison Square Garden that August.

The best laid plans of mice and men, and all that.

Austin ate a concussion during his so-so headliner vs. 'Taker, but there's another point worth making: The pair just didn’t click, and then things were worsened by the bell-ringer ‘Stone Cold’ suffered. This was the second consecutive SummerSlam with an injury for him, so Steve must've thought 'Slam was cursed.

Others like Bruce Prichard and Jim Ross have admitted that the WWF Title showdown between these legends proved to be a slight letdown. It should've been awesome, but follow up matches in years to come proved that they didn't have much chemistry as rivals. That's remarkable when you considered how damn good both were with other workers (Austin with Bret, Shawn, Mick Foley, The Rock, Triple H etc, and Undertaker with Foley, Rock, Hunter, Shawn too).

As it turned out, SummerSlam '98's best match wasn't its last. Hunter vs. Rocky in a ladder bout for the IC belt was 10x the match this WWF Title effort was. That cannot be denied. Worse, the fed watched their meal ticket take another pounding on one of the biggest supercards of the year.


27. Billy Gunn Eats “Mrs. Ass” (1999)

The Rock Billy Gunn
WWE.com

Nobody should sling blame at the company for trying to create fresh main event stars in 1999, and it made sense to try that on for size with Billy Gunn. After all, he'd been over for years as part of D-Generation X and the New Age Outlaws duo, so attempting to turn him from over tag star into over singles star wasn't far-fetched.

It didn't work though.

Gunn's King Of The Ring win didn't magically teleport him to the top of cards, and management gave up on him quickly. By August. he was jobbing to The Rock at SummerSlam and having his face shoved into someone's rear for good measure. The whole shindig was played for laughs as the WWF got experimental with Rocky throughout the second half of the year.

Billy bringing a lady to ringside for this 'Kiss My Ass' match proved to be the worst SummerSlam moment by a mile. Naturally, it was Gunn himself who planted his lips on that woman's behind as Rock turned the tables, McMahons laughed behind the scenes, and fans soaked in the fed's latest obsession with people's faces being rammed into butts.

Sadly for Billy, the match sucked, and his main event push was scrapped overnight. He went back to teaming with Road Dogg (admittedly picking right back up where he'd left off), presumably after devouring some breath mints and washing his face.

'Attitude's' love of toilet humour and all it entailed somehow failed to make him a viable addition to the top line mix. Somehow.


26. Brothers Of Disappointment (2000)

Kane Unmasked SummerSlam 2000
WWE

WrestleMania XIV's brotherly war between The Undertaker and Kane was never going to win any 'Match Of The Year' awards, but it was functional and told a good story going in. By 2000, 'Taker had rebranded as a badass biker, and Kane wasn't the same one-dimensional monster he'd been in 1998. So, in theory, this SummerSlam 2000 clash should've been better.

Nope.

The rematch (one of many) was short, unsatisfying and ended with Kane being unmasked in one of the most pointless moments throughout the entire year. This conjured up memories of Mayhem In Manchester and 'Taker's ring gear going missing before he worked his kayfabe sibling in another clunky effort.

At least they had an excuse, and that was more of a house show feel (despite later being released in highlights form on VHS) anyway. At SummerSlam 2000, people rightly expected more from the pair than what they'd end up getting. Their bout was one of the worst on the show, to be blunt.

The main event Triple Threat survived Kurt Angle's concussion to thrill, the first TLC match was amazing, and even Shane McMahon battling Steve Blackman had some highlights. Sure, Terri vs. The Kat in a 'Stinkface Match' sucked, but that was never predicted to be any use. 'Taker vs. Kane felt the weight of expectations, but they didn't deliver.

In fact, their match was every bit as sucky as its predecessor involving the Divas, which really speaks volumes. Also, why bother ripping Kane's mask off for no reason? There was zero payoff to this.


25. DDP & Kanyon Get Squashed (2001)

WWE WWF SummerSlam 2001 DDP Kanyon
WWE

Oh boy. The only "Feel The Bang" vibes poor Diamond Dallas Page experienced in 2001 was his jaw banging the floor as he found out what the WWF wanted from him. First, they turned him into a creepy stalker and completely dismissed his 'People's Champion' gimmick from WCW. Then, they made him look like a total loser alongside good pal Kanyon at SummerSlam.

Page and Kanyon got mauled by The Undertaker and Kane in a double WWF/WCW Tag-Team Title steel cage match on the undercard. It was 10 minutes of the federation's big boys flexing their dominance over those World Championship W***ers from down south, and nobody was there to tell them: 'Hey, maybe it'd be a better idea if you all worked together for a common goal'.

The match was brutally bad, and it turned out to be the latest example of the WWF ridiculing WCW. Nothing else. It was all senseless stuff. Fans didn’t even get to see a good match out of it, which is arguably the biggest crime any segment can commit. Run your peacocking contest all you like, but at least give people buying your pay-per-view some entertaining back and forth.

Most things on SummerSlam 2001 showcased the dying WCW threat, but none were as egregious as this cage-based murder scene. Apparently, Kanyon's "Alliance MVP" t-shirt stood for, "Alliance Must Vanish Pronto". There was no excuse for how lame the WCW squad were made to look here.

It's hardly like the Brothers Of Destruction needed a squash to get them over with crowds.


24. Fans Turn On The Rock (Again!) (2002)

Brock Lesnar The Rock
WWE

The Rock and Hollywood Hogan knew they had to pivot mid-match at WrestleMania X8. Going in, nWo leader Hulk was supposed to be the heel and WWF saviour Rocky was meant to be the babyface, but Toronto was having none of it. Smartly, both guys called things on the fly and gave the live crowd some more nostalgic Hogan magic.

That set a precedent amongst supporters. They knew they could rebel against the formatting and things might change, but those within the company (including Rock himself) didn't think that'd happen when new 'Beast' Brock Lesnar hit the scene in time for SummerSlam 2002.

Sure, people forced change at 'Mania X8, but that was understandable due to Hulk’s comeback. Here, against a new force like Brock, Rocky was fully expected to be 100% baby. Surprisingly, the live audience in New York made that mission impossible, and The Rock did not look happy about it at all.

He visibly scowled at punters and mouthed some abuse as they booed his comebacks vs. Lesnar. Then, those same folks cheered wildly as Brock took the WWE Title from 'The Great One' and sent him spinning back to Hollywood. That'd provide the basis for a memorable Rock heel turn when he returned in 2003, but he didn't want the backlash in '02.

Maybe it says everything for SummerSlam that year when this is considered the "worst moment". It didn't ruin the main event, but it probably kept ol' Dwayne Johnson awake for a few extra hours in a hotel bed someplace. How dare those people reject him. How bloody dare they!


23. Goldberg’s Unfortunate Slip (2003)

SummerSlam 2003 Goldberg
WWE.com

A-Train unconvincingly tangling with The Undertaker and parts of a 'Falls Count Anywhere' match between Shane McMahon and Eric Bischoff could be considered lows from SummerSlam 2003, but they weren't outright embarrassing. Meanwhile, poor Bill Goldberg looked into the future at Ultimo Dragon from 'Mania XX and said: 'Hold my beer'.

His unfortunate slip was aura-shattering for someone painstakingly designed to be a total badass from head to toe. During his pyro-laden entrance, big Bill (not that one) stumbled and fell over whilst kicking the air. It was the kind of demonstration that gives PE teachers nightmares, except Goldberg didn't fall in front of laughing schoolchildren. Nah, he fell in front of thousands in the arena and countless more watching back home.

Already in their pods and bracing for a punishing Elimination Chamber match, some of his peers must've laughed internally. Part of them might've felt just a tad sorry for Bill too, because that sort of thing is any wrestler's hell, and it could realistically happen to anyone on any show. Sadly for Goldberg, it was his turn to look foolish.

Being honest, someone like Chris Jericho could've rolled with it and jawed off with giggling fans as he composed himself, but Goldberg didn't have that luxury. He was meant to be one of the most unflappably cool babyface heroes around, and yet here he was stumbling around the place like someone had suggested a few pre-show pints down at the local in Phoenix, Arizona before the pay-per-view kicked off.

Yikes.


22. Kane…Wins Lita’s Heart? (2004)

WWE SummerSlam Matt Hardy Lita Kane
WWE

This travesty was one of the worst angles WWE has ever committed to tape. Lord only knows what they were thinking by casting Kane as a "babyface" after forcibly impregnating Lita then forcing her to marry him on top of that, but that was the story. Similarly, heck only knows why someone thought putting Lita on the line as a prize for some SummerSlam match was the way to go.

'It was a different time'. Get out of here with that rubbish. This was shockingly ill-advised even back in 2004.

However, live on PPV, Kane beat Matt Hardy in a ‘Till Death Do Us Part’ match to earn the right to wed Lita. It only developed further into one of WWE’s most offensively crude stories - one which eventually, and nonsensically, led to Kane becoming a babyface rapist.

Diva Dodgeball on the same show gets a lot of hate, but this was worse. Way worse. No amount of women's division silliness could match the fact that one of the locker room's top stars was about to become personal property of the 'Big Red Machine'. Everybody was tasked with rolling along and accepting the idea like it was the most normal thing in the world.

This entire plot line was, without hyperbole, one of the most sickening things the promotion played around with this century. It wasn't fun in a 'oh that's crap but endearing' kind of way. It was downright tasteless, and this was just the tip of the iceberg. Argh! What were they even thinking?!


21. HBK Gets Disrespectful, Brother! (2005)

Shawn Michaels Hulk Hogan
WWE

It was real tempting to put Vickie Guerrero’s late run in on Eddie vs. Rey Mysterio ladder match here, but no. The spot goes to Shawn Michaels for turning the clock back to his 1996-style temper tantrums and refusing to do solid business with Hulk Hogan. They weren’t getting along, so Shawn decided to go into hyper-sell mode.

That made a mockery of the clash, and the irony here is that Michaels wanted to poke back at Hulk's own selfishness...by being the most selfish between both of them. Think about it for a second: HBK turned into everything he claimed to stand against at that point in his career, and he did it because he could.

He was still untouchable. In fact, he was arguably even more so than he'd been during the 90s. That's not to suggest that Hogan was a saint who didn't rub many the wrong way by vetoing booking ('That doesn't work for me, brother') or making sure he was the focal point, but Shawn's 'fight fire with fire' mentality threatened the bout's quality.

That's something he had always stood against where possible. His pay-per-view performances had to be top class even if his private life or body was falling apart. This is a man who even put in strong workrate at Survivor Series 1997 when he knew he'd be screwing over Bret Hart in mere minutes!

At SummerSlam 2005, Michaels got a petted lip and went into business for himself. Somehow, Hulk was able to keep it together instead of just throwing his hands up and walking out of there like it was Bash The Beach 2000.


20. DX Buries The Spirit Squad For No Good Reason (2006)

WWE SummerSlam 2006 D-Generation X DX Shawn Michaels Triple H
WWE.com

It's challenging to pinpoint the dirt worst moment from SummerSlam 2006. Hardcore fans of Paul Heyman's original outfit would point to Big Show beating Sabu in an ECW Title bout, and there were some who didn't like a crusty battle between Ric Flair and Mick Foley later on. However, here, the nod goes to D-Generation X letting the world know what WWE thought of some young aspiring stars.

Shawn and Hunter pasted the entire Spirit Squad faction before working Vince and Shane McMahon in a tag bout. Yes, they also kicked lumps out of other heels interfering on the McMahon's behalf too (it was like a rehash of Royal Rumble '94 at times!), but most of the damage was reserved for Kenny, Johnny, Mitch, Nicky and Mikey.

It wouldn’t be long until the Spirit Squad were literally placed in a container shipped off to OVW as a symbolic demotion on TV. Apparently, ridiculing a gimmick you'd literally created for these fledgling workers was the way to go, at least in the minds of WWE's higher-ups. Luckily for them, DX vets had no problem making the Squad look like total losers.

After all, why bother focusing on the future Dolph Ziggler at all when Shane McMahon needed some more eyeballs on him. Seriously, those cheerleading boys had to be wondering why they'd suddenly fallen so foul of the creative team. The writing was on the wall for them after being treated like lowly jobbers by HBK and Triple H at SummerSlam.

The Squad was off to developmental mere months later.


19. The Great Khali’s Awful Performance (2007)

WWE SummerSlam The Great Khali Batista
WWE.com

Bless him for trying, but big Dave Batista was never going to squeeze much of anything from The Great Khali at SummerSlam 2007. It's easy to forget just how rubbish Khali was with most guys in-ring. He could barely even move around freely or maintain his balance on wounded knees during most performances, and it was painful to witness.

At nearly 7 minutes, Khali's World Heavyweight Title defence vs. Big Dave felt like it went 77 mins. Worse, it finished with the reigning champ getting himself intentionally disqualified so he'd hold onto the belt and continue torturing weekly SmackDown audiences with a longer title reign than anyone wanted.

People really hoped (and prayed) that Batista would score the win and the belt here. Nope, creative decreed that Khali had to march on...and on...and on....and, yeah - you get the point. Imagine they'd put the WWF Title on Giant Gonzalez in 1993. That's the kind of rotten fare WWE handed out like it was must-see in '07.

Everyone knew Khali sucked between the ropes, but he was physically massive and "an attraction". So, Vince was willing to turn a blind eye to some of the worst matches he'd ever willingly promoted. John Cena and Randy Orton must've been thanking their lucky stars that this car crash went on right before their own main event.

They couldn't fail after watching Khali flounder around the place. Cena and Orton could've played a round of dominoes out there and still received a higher star rating than the World Title clash.


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.