The Wrestler Who Was Cancelled

Pity the fool who messed with Mr. T...

David Schultz
WWE

David Schultz was a super credible wrestler.

In the modern era, the grizzled wrestlers of yore are held aloft as real men who made it all feel real, mostly to counter positive arguments about today's scene in bad faith. Even if the heel teams of the 1980s were great slapstick comedians, even if the ten punches to the head spot never resulted in a black eye, even if the histrionic babyface appeals were more corny than an episode of Being The Elite, the "old school" wrestler has been lionised through the lens of totally unreliable and very childish nostalgia.

Read the following quote:

"A lot of wrestlers nowadays look like a trampoline act. Nowhere could you ever see a guy crawl up on the turnbuckles. It's just like the Empire State building. Just stand there and wait for someone to push you off. Where is it ever logical to put a guy on the turnbuckle while you stand on the second rope?"

This wasn't what Jim Ross had to say about AEW's multi-man tag style in 2020, though it reads very much like his critique of the modern dive to the outside spot back in 2020; this was from Karl Gotch, burying Harley Race to the Wrestling Observer Newsletter in 1990. JR's problems with the modern style weren't too far removed from it, as he disclosed on Grilling JR:

"All you guys go outside. You cluster up like coils. You stand there in a huddle, friends and foes together, side by side so you can catch some leaping idiot going over the top who never wins with this move."

Ross even used almost identical verbiage to Gotch by saying "It's a trapeze act", and, out of nowhere, said that the DDT should be a finish. Ross believes that wrestling in the 1980s was the most logical and believable version of the form. Harley Race is enshrined in legend as a mutton-chopped hard bastard. Schultz was nowhere near Race's level as a worker, but the man was equipped with a formidable aura like few others.

If the fabled 1980s wrestler actually existed, David Schultz, who worked for the WWF at the cusp of its national expansion, would look rather a lot like him.

CONT'D...(1 of 5)


Mr. T
WWE

Elements of his act have dated horrendously - like many wrestlers of that era, he was homophobic to a vile extent - but then, certain old school fans you find online might like that about him. He was intensely threatening, but funny with it. He intersected the intimidation and charisma of a hard-ass heel to perfection. When taking Sgt. Slaughter to task, Schultz said, with his brutal southern brogue, "And I don't care if you bring your momma with you, Sgt. Slaughter, I'll slap her like a dog. And I don't care if you bring your daddy, I'll beat him like a dog. See, I just don't care..."

He was so funny that he made Mean Gene Okerlund corpse more than once, but was so terrifying that, watching his promos back now, you fear for the interviewer some 40 years after you know fine well that he didn't get a slap to the face.

So why, then, did Schultz, as legitimate as it gets, all but vanish from a scene that was supposedly built in his image?

Because somebody did get a slap to the face: John Stossel, a 20/20 reporter who was present at Madison Square Garden in 1984 to film a notorious exposé of wrestling's closely guarded trade secrets. Schultz even by the standards of a very secretive era held kayfabe and the fake notion of legitimacy in sacred reverence, and when this was questioned, he exploded. Stossel said to Schultz that he thought wrestling was fake; Schultz slapped him very hard, twice, in the face. Stossel was the victim of an assault. There was no justification for Shultz's actions, even if "the boys" - those among them, Bret Hart - reckoned that he got what he deserved.

Schultz was immediately suspended by the New York State Athletic Commission for his conduct and was promptly fired by the WWF following the furore - though not necessarily as a result. This incident forms only part of the David Schultz story; an early 1985 altercation with Mr. T is what drove his exit from the WWF.

Schultz maintains that the altercation wasn't physical, and when profiled on Vice's Dark Side of the Ring didn't offer any real information about it. He said he simply talked with Mr. T in the corridor, and was told by then-agent Jay Strongbow that, if he were to keep "bothering" Mr. T, he'd be fired. "You better fire me, then," Schultz said, and that was that. In the "never say never" business, Schultz was never seen in the WWF again.

CONT'D...(2 of 5)


Dave Schultz Vice
Vice

Schultz resented the fact that T, a non-wrestler, was getting the WrestleMania main event. Hulk Hogan claimed in a 2019 interview with Steve Austin that Schultz "bitch-slapped the hell out" of Mr. T with a "shoot slap", but Hogan believes himself capable of time travel, so there's nothing in that. It would have made the national news, too, obviously.

Schultz didn't think the Mr. T incident had anything to do with his firing, and questioned the Stossel incident, too, citing Hulk Hogan choking out Richard Belzer on Hot Properties days removed from WrestleMania on the media rounds. What, Schultz reasoned, was the difference? Did Hogan grow jealous of Schultz? Was Schultz held back?

The difference, in addition to the fact that it was an accident and that Belzer was nice to Hogan before the prearranged skit went awry, is that Hogan was a megastar draw; if anything, the Belzer controversy helped drive the success of WrestleMania, the early projections for which threatened a disaster.

As a result of his sudden, controversial exit from the industry - his banishment, as the story goes - Schultz's aura has only intensified as the years have passed. He wasn't just a shoe-leather tough 1980s badass; he was too much even for that era, and only the vocation of bounty hunting, to which Schutlz was drawn after his star faded, could contain him and make use his frightening assets.

Towards the end of his Dark Side episode, Schultz intimated that old friend Hogan, who had suggested him as a heel opponent to Vince McMahon, turned his back on him. He also said that he was blackballed from the industry "because of Vince". This isn't just the defensive, deluded position taken by an embittered former star. Many within the industry have echoed this opinion so often that it has become the dominant narrative; after the Schultz dark side aired, CM Punk on April 29, 2020 tweeted "Wrestlers and fans who spend the energy to applaud Shultz slapping Stossel, stop and think, and spend half that wishing there was a way to stick together and stand up for Shultz being black balled."

There may be a degree of truth to this.

CONT'D...(3 of 5)


David Schultz John Stossel
ABC

There is talk of a fabled 1985 Memphis promo, in which the filterless Schultz buried the WWF and incurred a legal threat in the process, which substantiates that narrative (this, supposedly, was how the WWF happened upon Randy Savage; the tape was not watched in order to recruit him, rather learn what Schultz had said, but Savage's performance generated buzz within the organisation).

The Memphis tape library however is scattered, the full extent of it probably no longer exists, and the footage hasn't been located. Still, it must exist, and its existence lends some credence to the "blackballed" narrative. If Schultz was enough of a liability to get promoters in trouble, it's easy to see why he was deemed not to be worth the hassle.

Dave Meltzer of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter used Occam's razor to make a great point when writing up the DSOTR episode. Why would a group of wrestling promoters band together and support Vince McMahon in excommunicating a wrestler from the entire North American industry?

In 1985, two years after McMahon had seceded from the NWA, and was months away from making his boldest attempt at the national expansion that would doom them?

If anything, with Vince gutting his competitors of their star talent with New York money, a great worker whom New York wanted nothing to do with was a "get", controversy or no. It never happened; after bouncing between Memphis and New Japan Pro Wrestling in '85, Schultz ventured north to Canada in 1986 before working sporadically and retiring in 1989.

Meltzer downplayed the legend of David Schultz in the same piece.

CONT'D...(4 of 5)


Paul Orndorff
WWE.com

Meltzer wrote:

"Schultz had gotten notoriety from slapping Stossel that he was a scary violent guy. Plus, he could talk. As a wrestler, he was below average, but he had the size, the talk, and a mean scary face and great heel demeanor. But the fear of his temper was what made promotions not book him."

And while this is a subjective opinion, it isn't without merit. Even if Schultz never slapped Stossel, it is difficult to foresee Vince going with him over the excessively charismatic Roddy Piper, the arrogant and immaculately sculpted Paul Orndorff, or one of the all-time greatest attractions, irrespective of his physical condition, in André the Giant. Schultz wasn't on Tully Blanchard's level either, much less Ric Flair's, which meant he wouldn't have fared particularly well in Jim Crockett Promotions.

David Schultz was a legitimate tough guy who was hardly going to lose a fight and disgrace the business: doesn't that read as exactly the sort of wrestler Bill Watts would have adored in Mid-South Wrestling?

Could it be that even Schultz is the mythical 1980s wrestler?

That the inflammatory Stossel incident lionised his tough guy aura well above his talent and drawing ability?

In a 2006 RF Video shoot interview with Schultz, Meltzer's narrative is brought further into focus - by Schultz himself, unwittingly. He said he left Memphis in his first run there because he was held back by Jerry Lawler. He reckoned that he verbally threatened Verne Gagne when, after he told the AWA owner that he was quitting for the WWF, Gagne threatened to kick him out of the building. Schultz also claims that he told NJPW founder and top star Antonio Inoki that he wouldn't do a televised job for him, which was yet another very reckless career decision.

Schultz might have been talking sh*t in a bid to amuse himself or maintain his dangerous, unhinged aura in wrestling circles. The shoot interview is as ironic a term as it gets. Still, his own narrative corresponds with Meltzer's, which says rather a lot. The old 1980s heel cliché was of a man "mad, bad, and dangerous to know". Schultz, it would seem, lived the gimmick. This isn't intended to read as a hit piece, but the myth surrounding David Schultz is embellished.

If he truly is the Wrestler Who Was Cancelled, that last word carries about as much meaning as it does elsewhere.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!