TNA’s 2024 Return: 10 Things That MUST Happen

Total Nonstop Action Wrestling MUST pull off some major moves come 2024.

TNA IMPACT CM Punk AJ Styles
AEW/WWE/TNA/IMPACT

The power of nostalgia should never be overlooked.

Yes, yes it should make fans of a certain vintage sick that TNA is now considered retro, but the response to IMPACT Wrestling's recent "WE'RE BACK" announcement was greeted with tears of nostalgic joy from all-comers. Something feels right about those three little letters, and that's just the way it is.

TNA will officially return in January 2024, so attention now turns to what Scott D'Amore and the management team at Anthem can do to make that relaunch truly special. Beyond the inevitable early flurry, the folks in charge will have to make sure that TNA doesn't fizzle out by stepping up their game when it comes to live event promotion and production too.

Key signings (no matter how far-fetched) could help there, and so could continuing to blend the retro buzz with more of the solid groundwork IMPACT has quietly been doing over the past few years. The days of "LOL TNA" should be over - this company has a product and roster worth your time.

Is all of this what the future holds come next year?!

10. Genesis On PPV

TNA Genesis
TNA/IMPACT

This makes perfect sense.

Bringing back the Genesis pay-per-view series, which hasn't been seen since 2021, would be a nifty move from D'Amore and staff. Currently, Hard To Kill on 13 January is being touted as the relaunch for TNA. Being fair, that name is also fitting for the brand's comeback, because most figured IMPACT would've vanished long before now.

The company literally is hard to kill then. Either name works, but there's something grander about the Genesis title. It'd take older fans back to the peak era of TNA, and it'd remind them of classic bouts like Kurt Angle vs. Samoa Joe (2006), or a sh*t hot tag effort pitting the Motor City Machine Guns vs. Team 3D (2007).

Besides, the word genesis means "the origin or coming into being of something". This TNA revamp is the culmination of years of hard graft, and it pays homage to the origins of a promotional name once thought dead.


9. Updated "Classic" Belt Designs

TNA World Title
ImpactWrestling.com

A return to old belt designs has been pretty much confirmed by TNA, and that's great. Being brutally honest about it, the current IMPACT lineup is...a bit rubbish. Those washed out red designs are uninspiring, and don't pop the same way the classics did.

By comparison to WWE and AEW belts, they're cheap-looking.

The "Big Gold" template used by the old TNA Heavyweight strap is a must, and so is a the big red "X" splashed across the (you guessed it) X Division Title. Dixie Carter changed that to blue in 2013, then IMPACT went with a green motif in 2015 that always looked kinda naff. The newer variation doesn't cut it either.

It's important that TNA recognises the value of belts that get people talking. These designs really are make or break, because the promotion will want social media to gush over them rather than hate. You can't please everybody, but a neat mix of old and new should do the trick.


8. Regular International Jaunts

IMPACT Wrestling UK Tour
IMPACT

IMPACT will hit UK shores for the first time in approx eight years this week (shows might've already happened by the time you read this). Three shows in Glasgow, Newcastle and Coventry mark a quasi-homecoming of sorts; TNA previously experienced great successes on this side of the Atlantic.

Obviously, booking more dates in 2024 is wholly dependent on the success of these 2023 dates. Fingers crossed they're a success though, and the same goes for any TNA jaunts to Australia and elsewhere. Wrestling fans should want all of these shows to smash it, because having more viable touring companies would be excellent news for the industry at large.

Come 2024, it'd be amazing if TNA announced even bigger venues in Scotland, England, Wales and maybe even Ireland too. Why not? There will always be demand for wrestling in these nations, so TNA Impact tapings/pay-per-views can satisfy that craving and (hopefully) grow their business again too.

Bring it on.


7. Aggressively Promote Ticket Sales

AJ Styles TNA Bound For Glory 2013
ImpactWrestling.com

This will be unavoidable, especially if TNA is going to run bigger buildings.

Bums in seats will be the main metric for success there. One thing the company absolutely must do is tear up the old script and get more aggressive than ever before about selling tickets. Honestly, that's something they always sucked at during the original run, and that needs to change immediately.

Management, wrestlers, staff and even fans must shout from the rooftops about the kind of product they've got to sell. It was depressing as all f*ck to see TNA house shows starring names like Kurt Angle and Jeff Hardy struggling to sell out high school gyms many moons ago.

That can never be allowed to happen again. A savvy marketing strategy is essential, 'cause people must be made aware of when TNA is coming to town. No more, 'Oh, there's live wrestling on tonight?' when workers check into hotels nearby. That's just embarrassing!


6. Embrace “Stepping Stone” Status

Jordynne Grace
IMPACT Wrestling

It’s absolutely fine if TNA becomes an unofficial feeder to WWE and AEW. No, really. That doesn’t mean the company will tank or won't thrive as a valid alternative. Being third in North America isn’t exactly a bad spot so long as the place has an identity and a fanbase that leaves shows satisfied with the product.

Realistically, no matter how good this relaunch is, rising stars like Jordynne Grace, Joe Hendry, Josh Alexander and others will catch attention from WWE or AEW. That's business, and there's pretty much nothing TNA can do to stop it. The sooner they accept that, the better it'll be for everyone.

Let's not pretend that TNA is going to be the must visit destination for talent biz-wide.

It isn't even some dreadful thing if Total Nonstop Action readies workers for bigger spots elsewhere. In fact, it could help put eyeballs on the product. 'Come see the place where stars are made'. That sort of thing. There are worse ideas.


5. A Retro-Filled One-Off

TNA Wrestling 2024
IMPACT Wrestling

It was smart to showcase a blend of familiar names (Mickie James and Trinity, mainly) with others such as Josh Alexander and Mike Bailey on the "WE'RE BACK" splash. The alternative would've been spotlighting old promo images of talents who no longer work for IMPACT/TNA, and that would've sent out mixed messages.

However, nostalgia is going to be a powerful tool for TNA's relaunch.

A return to the old Impact Zone for a nostalgic party stacked full of Easter egg moments and retro goodies sounds fun. Or, if they're feeling up to it and the venue's infrastructure allows for it, then TNA could even go back to where it all began at the quaint Nashville Fairgrounds and go proper old-school.

Hosting the occasional "TNA Old-School" special would be perfectly fine provided there's still more emphasis placed on the current crop and ongoing storylines creative wants fans to invest in. WWE has already shown just how intoxicating nostalgia can be, so why not?


4. Sell AJ Styles On The Hall Of Fame

AJ Styles
WWE.com

Right, so this is going to be tough at best and could prove to be a no-goer.

Things ended on a sour note for AJ Styles with TNA/IMPACT, and the man is currently under contract with WWE. The OC leader might even finish his career under Triple H's watchful gaze, but this is pro wrestling and pretty much nothing is off the table. On that note, TNA has to at least try sell AJ on a Hall Of Fame berth.

Nobody's expecting Styles to go back and wrestle (surely WWE wouldn't green light that), but it's true the TNA HOF doesn't feel complete without him. 12 inductions have taken place so far (Sting, Kurt Angle, Jeff Jarrett, Earl Hebner, Gail Kim, Abyss, Ken Shamrock, Awesome Kong, Raven, Traci Brooks, Team 3D and the old announce team of Mike Tenay and Don West), but AJ would arguably trump all of them.

He was a true TNA original, and one of the leading lights of the promotion right up until his departure in 2014. Also, Styles did appear on-screen at Slammiversary 2022 to congratulate TNA/IMPACT on 20 years, so perhaps some ill will has faded.


3. Announce A Few Buzz-Worthy Signings

Kurt Angle 2016 return
WWE

Wrestling is all about creating that buzz and trying to turn it into sustained viewership, pay-per-view buys or ticket sales. There are several free agents on the market who'd be available to come in and help TNA relaunch in style in the short-term, and it'd be wise for D'Amore to explore that option.

Nick Nemeth/Dolph Ziggler is the kind of ex-WWE star who'd be ideally placed to come in, make a splash and help several homegrown stars reach the next level. He'd likely relish the challenge of working with some on the TNA roster, and could have several banging matches in 2024.

Kurt Angle as a temp GM would get some eyeballs too. The Olympian speaks highly of IMPACT on his podcast, so he may well be willing to cut a deal. Then, there are lightning rod signings like Will Ospreay (unlikely with WWE and AEW interest, but would be huge), and...one CM Punk.

Is he in that last chance saloon? Yes. Would he be a high profile get? No doubt.


2. Launch With A Motivated CM Punk

CM Punk TNA
TNA/AEW

Let's examine the Punk point further.

Everyone knows by now how controversial CM's final days in both WWE and AEW were. It'd be foolish to ignore the obvious (that he was the common denominator), but things are rarely one-sided when it comes to wrestling politics or backstage bullsh*t. There is always a chance Punk could put all of that behind him, move on and contribute.

Announcing that he's inked a deal alone would get people talking. That's the impact (ahem) CM Punk's name has on the wrestling community even in 2023. If D'Amore could only get the best version of Phil Brooks, one free of any nonsense, then this TNA revamp would be extra special with his involvement.

WWE doesn't necessarily need Punk going forwards. That's valid. Does TNA? Meh, it's up for debate, but he is a bigger name than anybody else on the active roster right now and would bring those three letters to the lips of a more casual/lapsed fan market.


1. Entertain A Six-Sided Ring Comeback

TNA Six Sided Ring
TNA

It appears TNA fancies shutting this argument down before it even gets started. Fair enough, but they shouldn't expect fans to stop talking about a six-sided ring comeback any time soon. This is something people have moaned about since Hulk Hogan dissed the hexagonal beauty back in 2010.

By all accounts, the six-sided ring wasn't pleasant to work in either, so today's management would have to rejig the build to ensure wrestler safety and happiness. That's crucial, and won't be overlooked. However, if TNA can drum something up, then hardcore old-schoolers would welcome a return to the classic TNA look.

It'd even work for a one-off themed show centred around retro vibes or the chaotic X Division. Again, like almost everything else listed here (old PPV names, title designs, international tours, fan-pleasing returns etc), going six sides again would create some more online buzz.

Then they should make Hogan bump in it. OK, only joking.

What else do you think must happen during TNA's return in 2024? For more like this, check out 10 Lost Gimmicks WWE Should Bring Back and 2 Ups & 5 Downs From AEW Rampage (Oct 20 - Results & Review)!


In this post: 
TNA
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.