10 Lost Gimmicks WWE Should Bring Back

Triple H should plunder WWE history and bring back these forgotten gimmicks.

Batista Simon Dean
WWE

WWE's roster isn't the gimmick-filled circus of the mid-1990s. Back then, occupations were the general rule. Most midcarders had to be something, which is why Vince McMahon tried out plumbers, garbage men, dentists, race car drivers, preachers and almost everything in between.

Hell, even The Undertaker was cast as a mortician originally. Supernatural tweaks eventually led 'Taker to shooting lightning bolts from his hands and being able to teleport just because the lights went out. That's the kind of crazy stuff wrestling gets away with, but such cartoony elements have been largely downplayed in the modern era.

Bray Wyatt's 'Fiend' was an obvious exception. That character stood out because it was different to everything else on TV and felt like a throwback all at once. Should WWE revisit Bray's alter ego with somebody else? No, of course not, but Triple H's creative team can pay homage to the man by reimagining one of his forgotten offshoots.

There are loads of other forgotten gimmicks to plunder too, and the best of them will be included here. Repeating history might work for current members of the main roster, and for those looking to make a splash coming up from NXT.

Time to get gimmicky!

10. The Wyatt 6

The Wyatt 6 Bray Wyatt
WWE

Let's start with Bray's tribute.

Wyatt's recent passing hit the pro wrestling community hard. Not everybody adored his in-ring work or 'Fiend' gimmick, but you'd be hard-pressed to find many who didn't respect the man's creativity. WWE could do way worse than paying homage to Bray by revisiting the abandoned 'Wyatt 6' concept.

This wouldn't need to be some epic story that lasts 3-5 years, or anything. However, it'd be lovely to see Wyatt's brother Bo involved, and to see some breakout stars emerge from underneath the costumes of Huskus, Rabbit, Mercy and the like. That'd be a cool way to honour Bray's memory and for creative to spin out of things with some new wrestlers to work with.

Several struggling main roster scrubs would benefit from this (the Hit Row lot are looking for something new to do, for example), and few on NXT would sniff at the chance to be part of something so historic and touching.


9. Vampire

WWE ECW Kevin Thorn
WWE.com

There isn't much from WWE's version of ECW that's worth remembering. Vince McMahon set the tone for things in 2006 by introducing zombies, then turned Paul Heyman's original hardcore vision into a 'C' show more worthy of the name Heat than ECW. Still, it did throw up something interesting.

Kevin Thorn. Yeah, the vampire guy.

Thorn was the ex-Mordecai's second crack at success in the company. Did it work? Nah, not really, but that's because everything was a little too cartoony and clashed with what fans wanted from a revived ECW brand. Fast forward to 2023, trim off some of the cartoonish elements, slap it on Karrion Kross and...voilá.

Kross and Scarlett already have a splash of the supernatural about them anyway, but they're crying out for something more from WWE's creative team. You could even say they're crying out for something to sink their teeth into. Sorry.

Not actually sorry. Bring back the vamps!


8. Locker Room Snitch

Just Joe
WWE.com

Joe E Legend's brief time as "Just Joe" is perfect for lists like this, because barely anybody talks about the guy's run as a locker room rabble rouser in 2000. His character was as peripheral as you're gonna get, but it did have serious potential and could've gone somewhere had it been handed to somebody the WWF believed in.

Fingers crossed Triple H was a secret admirer.

A wrestler who listens in on conversations and then deliberately snitches on others could work these days. It'd certainly give the writers an excuse to pad Raw's three-hour length with various segments and promos dedicated to this behind the scenes troublemaker who delighted in causing problems for his peers.

It really doesn't matter if the worker in question is on the male or female side either. WWE would just need to be careful not to revert to type with the latter by casting yet another bitchy women's division heel. That's a little tired.


7. The Resident Conspiracist

R Truth Heel
WWE.com

OK, so R-Truth circa 2011 went the wacky route by playing dress-up to promote one off pay-per-view battles with John Cena. That was classic Truth, and set the tone for his delusional, 'what the hell is going on?!' character to come. It did raise something intriguing though.

What if another heel hit the scene now and claimed that WWE's power players did everything they could to hold them down behind the curtain? Kayfabe wouldn't be much of a worry in an era when fans know a lot about what goes on backstage, and it could inevitably lead to some rating-popping skits opposite Triple H.

Just a thought.

If creative fancies going further, then why not have this conspiracy theorist allege that they've heard top stars like Roman Reigns or Charlotte Flair verbally bury other workers to management. If nothing else, it'd give someone fresh a weekly platform to vent and get themselves over with fans.


6. Bad Boy Rapper

John Cena Rap
WWE.com

John Cena hit the sweet spot of Eminem-inspired obsession with the bad boy rap game when he traded Vanilla Ice for a harder edge in late-2002. Naturally, pop culture has moved on since the days of Slim Shady, but clever rhymes will always get a reaction; just look at Max Caster of Acclaimed fame over in AEW.

People love those witty putdowns.

WWE should steal back some of that magic for themselves by debuting a lyrical genius on Raw, SmackDown or NXT again. Has this writer been watching too many classic Cena rap battles and promos from yesteryear on the Network/Peacock? Maybe, but it'd be a ticket to main roster success for someone if done right.

Nobody springs to mind immediately from the current crop, but that doesn't mean there isn't a trainee at the Performance Center capable of ringing off a few verses and making a name for themselves. Somebody would make the most of this if WWE put out feelers.


5. Social Media Influencer

Zack Ryder Z! True Long Island Story Matt Cardona
Matt Cardona

What was YouTube specialist Zack Ryder if not one of WWE's first social media influencers? The dude was way ahead of the game in that respect (so much so that even his own employers didn't really understand what he was trying to do), and he deserves a ton of praise for being so smart/seeing into the future.

It's mind-boggling that WWE has largely steered clear of the influencer idea ever since. They've had workers reference Twitter, Facebook, Twitch and the like, but the general attitude of most people towards anyone who'd dare call themselves a "social media influencer" is ideal for heels who want easy heat on themselves.

Woo woo woo. You know it.

If any wrestlers out there have the same crystal ball as Matt Cardona, then they might even be able to see what's coming down the pipe next. Capitalising on the upturn in popularity of a new app, or simply using a pre-existing one (TikTok) would be smart.


4. OTT Fitness Freak

Simon Dean WWE
WWE.com

Hands up any fellow Simon Dean marks out there.

That...isn't a lot of hands. Anyway, WWE should definitely re-air the glory of the "Simon System" and spark a fitness instructor gimmick comeback for the ages. Being honest, this could go hand in hand with the prior entry about social media influencers and their clear 'me, me, me' vibes.

Body shaming is obviously a very sensitive subject in 2023, so creative would have to be real careful here. They couldn't, for example, have Simon Dean 2K23 come out on SmackDown and cruelly poke fun at anyone's weight. So, how could it work? Well, to sum it up, they'd simply talk about themselves first and foremost whilst pretending to be the apex of physical conditioning.

The fact this Dean knock off would be accidentally-on-purpose chastising wrestlers who are already fit and firing would make this revised gimmick the butt of their own jokes. To be clear, this fan just fancies seeing someone have another stab at a character WWE didn't seem to get back in 2004-2005.


3. Magician

Phantasio WWE
WWE.com

Phantasio sucked.

Yes, it's true. The 1995 magician act tanked on 'C' level programming and infamously almost set fire to the Gorilla Position backstage before his match. So, why the heck would anybody want to mimic some kid's party-esque magic man who failed to get the job done? To do it properly, of course.

WWE's use of props and ye olde 'smoke and mirrors' stuff has moved on significantly since the mid-90s. If carefully handled and well thought out, a Phantasio rip off could do the magic gimmick justice. That's especially true assuming Trips tacked on some darker/creepier vibes that also reminded fans of classic Doink The Clown hijinkery (not a real word, but roll with it).

It just seems like practioners of the magic game got a bad name after Phantasio's flop. WWE has played around with illusion and magic with several characters since, but they've never had an out and out magician. Time to change that?


2. Stunt Double

Miz Mizdow
WWE.com

The slightly lower-quality sunglasses, the way he walked like a goof, the toy replica versions of titles - oh yes, Damien Sandow nailed his time as The Miz's stunt double. The renamed Damien Mizdow (which was also fantastic) will never get enough credit for the thought he put into that character.

It needs to happen again for somebody else.

A midcard heel such as Chelsea Green would be perfect for this. Chelsea's on screen behaviour is absurd anyway, so it'd be fun to see someone else mimic her actions and go even more over the top with them for a laugh. WWE could get some proper laughs out of this gimmick.

If not Green, then perhaps Pretty Deadly would cut it. They're already OTT, so having a young upstart tag team shadow them and go even further overboard would produce some hilarious TV. Just make sure they call Damien for tips ahead of the grand debut.


1. Legend Killer

Mick Foley Randy Orton WrestleMania XX
WWE.com

Some folks on socials say Randy Orton should return to his old 'Legend Killer' character when he's ready to return. That doesn't make any sense. Randy is a legend himself, so he'd have nothing to gain by mowing down icons of the biz in 2023/2024. If anything, someone else needs to take the gig and target him.

Going after heroes like Mick Foley, The Undertaker and others worked wonders for Orton approx 20 years ago. It was a simple way to garner heat from audiences, and heaped sympathy on the golden oldies Randy was gunning for by default. Surely that formula would work well again.

Besides, WWE has a new breed of legends to mark.

The Miz, Seth Rollins, Roman Reigns, Brock Lesnar, Becky Lynch, Trish Stratus (assuming she comes back), John Cena, Orton himself - the list goes on and on. Yep, have a vicious heel start with a few part-timers, then book them opposite Randy/Trish for the blow off.

Which other lost gimmicks should WWE revisit? For more wrestling, check out 10 New Directions For WWE After Fastlane 2023 and 10 Things WWE MUST Do Before 2024!


Watch Next


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.