4. Colt Cabana
There's a bit of a twist here for this one, folks. I think Cabana should be signed, but I think he should be signed as a commentator, only used to occasionally wrestle, not unlike Booker T in one of his more recent stints with the company. Don't get me wrong... Colt is a really solid in-ring performer, but his true calling is his mix of comedic timing, charisma and wrestling knowledge. That's the kind of thing that can really shine on commentary, especially in a promotion where the stale humor of Jerry Lawler is mixed with the lack of humor of JBL and the forced humor of Michael Cole every Monday night. As an added bonus, you'd have to like this move if you're a CM Punk fan, as you would assume that Punk would like to have his best friend back in the company. Getting to travel with his best friend and his soon-to-be wife every night? If you're trying to entice Punk into returning, there probably aren't many better pitches out there than that. I'm not saying that Punk will be back, or even that this would for sure make it happen, but it certainly couldn't hurt to give it a shot if WWE wants him back.