Top 20 Draft Picks For WWE's Brand Split 2016

Who should go where?

seth rollins extreme rules
WWE.com

WWE.com officially announced Wednesday morning that, starting July 19, Smackdown will be broadcast live on Tuesday evening with a unique roster and storylines - in other words, the brand extension is returning! From 2002 to 2011, Raw and Smackdown each had separate rosters and champions, and though the premise wore thin in the end, WWE is now a totally different company with a much more talented roster. This decision will not only make Smackdown important again, but it could provide a career boost to several of WWE's undercard stars.

With that in mind, why not indulge in a bit of fantasy booking? This brand extension can be a huge success if done properly, but that will take careful planning and an eye toward the future. Each roster will need to be properly balanced, featuring a mix of veterans and up-and-comers for the right blend of star power and new era excitement. With that in mind, here are the top 20 draft picks for the upcoming WWE brand split:

Before we start, a few background items and rules the company would do well to follow:

1. Only the U.S. and Intercontinental Titles will be brand-exclusive - the WWE, WWE Tag Team, and Women's Champions will be able to go back and forth between brands as long as they're reigning champs. Those titleholders will still be eligible for drafting, though, as they'll need a place to end up when they lose their belts.

2. As such, no new championships will be added.

3. Shane McMahon will control Raw (which will get the first draft pick), while Stephanie will control Smackdown.

4. All tag teams will be drafted as units, as well as the Balor Club stable.

5. Each side will select 10 superstars, with the rest of the split to be announced on WWE.com later.

6. As per the demands of Paul Heyman, Brock Lesnar will not be eligible for the draft; he will negotiate his own contract when he returns.

7. No trades or substitutions.

20. Raw - WWE World Heavyweight Champion Roman Reigns

Roman Reigns
www.wwe.com

Roman Reigns may be the reigning and defending WWE World Heavyweight Champion, but he's got to lose the title at some point (well, probably). With that in mind, it makes sense for WWE's flagship show to choose the number one man in the company to use as the centerpiece of the brand.

Shane McMahon - who won a coin toss to get the right to make the first selection - will open up the draft show by explaining that now that he's finally gotten sole control of Raw, it's his responsibility to make the show as big as it can possibly be. With that in mind, and knowing it may not be the most popular decision he could make, he's using his pick to grab Reigns.

If back-to-back WrestleMania main events didn't do it, this decision will prove once and for all that Reigns is the top man in WWE. For his fans, that'll cement how bright the future is for "The Guy." For his detractors, there's also good news - once he loses the belt, Smackdown will become a Reigns-free sanctuary.


19. SmackDown - United States Champion John Cena

John Cena Smackdown
WWE.com

Stephanie McMahon, despite her history with Roman Reigns, will admit that Shane McMahon made a great choice with his first selection. Reigns is a champion, a franchise player, and a worldwide sensation - but she's got somebody who's all that and more: John Cena! The United States Champion will be Stephanie's first official pick, ending his decade-plus tenure as the face of Raw.

Cena was actually a Smackdown-exclusive talent for several years. He first came up to the main roster as part of the blue brand in 2002, just months after the initial split. It was on Smackdown that he rose to superstardom, capturing the U.S. Title three times and eventually defeating JBL to become WWE Champion. In 2005, he was moved over to Raw when the company decided to focus on him as the number one star, and he hasn't looked back since (apart from being drafted back to Smackdown for a couple of hours in 2011).

Cena's anchoring of Smackdown shows that he may not be the top man in WWE anymore, but he's still worthy of being the centerpiece of a brand. It also establishes the U.S. Title as property of Smackdown, and that brand's highest exclusive honor.


18. Raw - Seth Rollins

seth rollins raw return
WWE.com

With the top two stars (and babyfaces) in WWE spoken for, Shane McMahon will have to think like a businessman. With that in mind, he'll use his next draft pick to secure a star who's arguably the most talented in the entire company, but isn't exactly easy to deal with - former WWE World Heavyweight Champion Seth Rollins. Rollins will be disappointed by his selection, as he would have preferred the favoritism Stephanie McMahon could offer, but he'll vow to use the opportunity to make Roman Reigns's life a living hell.

Putting Reigns and Rollins on the same show will cement the two men as career-long archrivals and will allow their feud to continue even when the WWE World Heavyweight Championship isn't part of the mix. This draft pick will also show that, even though Rollins may be beneath Reigns in the company's pecking order, he's still got a safe and valued spot as the top heel in the entire organization. Yes, in a perfect world, Rollins would be the top babyface, but being number one heel is nothing to sneeze at - especially when it gets you into a WrestleMania main event.


17. SmackDown - AJ Styles

aj styles wrestlemania.jpg
WWE.com

Once again, Stephanie McMahon will be forced to admit that Shane dealt Smackdown a devastating blow - Seth Rollins is one of the most incredible wrestlers in the entire world, and either show would be lucky to have him. Still, Stephanie's not sweating it too much, because once again, she'll have managed to outdo him - according to Stephanie, she'll be drafting a star more talented, more exciting, and more phenomenal than Rollins - AJ Styles.

As a newcomer to WWE whose skills immediately took him into the main event, Styles makes a perfect fit for Smackdown. In the eyes of many, he's still not seen as a "WWE guy," so putting him on the brand that feels more like a fledgling promotion allows him to help shape its future as he himself builds a legacy.

Of course, putting Styles on Smackdown means that he'll be on the same show as John Cena. Though the two men would do well to stand together against some of the heels looking to make an impact on the blue brand (more on them later), the inevitable showdown between them will be an outstanding, WrestleMania-worthy contest.


16. Raw - WWE Tag Team Champions The New Day

The New Day
WWE.com

Shane McMahon will be the first General Manager to draft more than one superstar at a time when he uses his third selection to pick WWE Tag Team Champions The New Day. Like with Reigns, The New Day will still be able to appear on Smackdown for as long as they hold the titles (and subsequent Tag Team Champions will also jump between shows), but they'll be Raw-exclusive after their reign ends.

Over the past year, The New Day has been the most consistently-entertaining part of WWE TV. No matter where on the card they've been positioned, the reactions they get and their merchandise sales have proven that they're true main eventers, every bit as much as Reigns, Cena, and anyone else who gets more high-profile matches.

As strong as Smackdown needs to be in order to set it apart as a real rival for Raw, the Monday show will always be the company's flagship - that's why Reigns should be a part of Raw, and that's why The New Day should also be a part of the red brand. Plus, those three-hour shows don't seem to drag on so badly when Kofi Kingston, Big E, and Xavier Woods are on.


15. SmackDown - WWE Women's Champion Charlotte

Charlotte WWE Womens Title
WWE.com

Shane may have pulled off a coup by snatching up the WWE Tag Team Champions, but Stephanie will respond by selecting the centerpiece of the ever-improving Women's Division, Charlotte. The champion will be coming up on a year as the division's titleholder by July, and she'll be proud of the fact that her achievements have garnered her such a high pick.

Back during the initial brand extension, the WWE Women's Champion was initially allowed to go on either show, but within a few months, the rules were amended and Raw became the title's sole home (as a counterpart, Smackdown got the Cruiserweight Championship). There was still women's action on Smackdown, but there wasn't any ultimate goal for the competitors.

Finally, WWE decided to introduce the Divas' Title in 2008, giving the women of Smackdown a prize of their own. The belts were unified under the "Divas'" branding in 2010. Now that there's one title and it's not a stupid butterfly, there's no reason to start devaluing it again. The champion can go back and forth between brands, and Charlotte can be treated as a major pick in the draft.


14. Raw - Dean Ambrose

Dean Ambrose
WWE.com

With Shane McMahon's fourth pick, he'll complete his run-through of the three former members of The Shield by drafting Dean Ambrose to Raw. An angry Seth Rollins will be the first man on the scene, arguing with Shane to try and get him to change his mind, but there'll be nothing doing - "The Lunatic Fringe" (and the current Mr. Money in the Bank) will be a member of the Raw roster.

It can be argued that Dean Ambrose would be better served on Smackdown - after all, despite his talent and his popularity, he's been consistently overshadowed by his former Shield partners since the group's break-up. He's been repeatedly beaten by Rollins and consistently portrayed as weaker than best friend Roman Reigns. Away from the two of them, Ambrose could finally break out on his own.

Despite that, the idea of all three Shield members being on the same brand - able to team and feud at will - is too good to pass up. The Shield was such a well-booked group that Ambrose, Rollins, and Reigns will be inextricably linked for the entirety of their careers. Plus, having Ambrose with the Money in the Bank briefcase while Reigns and Rollins feud over the title creates quite an interesting situation.


13. SmackDown - Kevin Owens

kevin owens
WWE.com

Stephanie McMahon will offer Shane a tongue-in-cheek congratulations on selecting the most unstable, hard-to-deal-with superstar on the entire roster for the Raw brand, then go on to bury Ambrose, Rollins, and Reigns - The Shield, she'll say, is just so 2013. Stephanie McMahon's Smackdown is about putting a focus on the superstars of the future, and to that end, she'll announce her choice for Smackdown's first main event heel: Kevin Owens.

Owens deserves a chance to be the top heel on one of WWE's brands, and on Smackdown - away from Seth Rollins - he can get that chance. The past 12 months have admittedly been a mixed bag for the former Intercontinental Champion - on the one hand, his feud with John Cena didn't make him an untouchable main event star like many thought it was going to, but at the same time, he proved himself to be WWE's MVP during a time period laden with high-profile injuries and bad luck.

On Smackdown, Owens can start a program with AJ Styles, or rekindle his feud with John Cena en route to winning the U.S. Title and reigning over the blue brand.


12. Raw - Balor Club

Bullet Club
NJPW.com

Once again, Shane McMahon will add multiple wrestlers to the Raw roster by using his fifth overall draft pick to select Balor Club - Finn Balor, Luke Gallows, and Karl Anderson - as a unit. He'll acknowledge that, in all likelihood, the three New Japan alumni will cause havoc on the program, but that chaos will translate into some very interesting TV. To borrow a phrase from his sister, the results will be best for business.

Giving Raw Balor Club in addition to all the talent the show's already got may make it seem unfairly stacked, but putting the stable on Smackdown would be a waste - after all, The New Day is on Raw, and a feud between the two trios would make a great program for SummerSlam and beyond. There's also the potential for an eventual Shield reunion and a six-man tag team match between those two units.

As for the bad blood with AJ Styles, Balor Club will still get a chance to show their old friend what they're all about - Finn Balor versus AJ Styles will already have been booked for July 24's Battleground show, and despite the fact that the men are on two separate brands, the match will still take place.


11. SmackDown - The Wyatt Family

The Wyatt Family
WWE.com

At this point, Shane McMahon's Raw will have nine superstars as compared to Smackdown's four, but that won't seem to phase Stephanie McMahon as she makes her way to the podium with a smile on her face. The reason for her smugness will soon be revealed when she uses her fifth pick to draft the entire Wyatt Family!

Her announcement will cause a stir for a couple of reasons - first of all, as of July 19, only Bray Wyatt will have been on TV at any point recently (he'll return from injury in June, but he won't bring the family with him). Also, there was no prior allowance made for the stable to be drafted as a unit like there was for Balor Club.

Eventually, Vince McMahon will interject, announcing that Stephanie's pick of The Wyatt Family will indeed stand. That means that Bray Wyatt, Braun Strowman, Erick Rowan, and (upon his return from injury) Luke Harper are officially part of the Smackdown roster. Not only will Bray be another top heel for the brand, but the family as a whole will cast a huge shadow over the show, providing rivalries for many of Smackdown's top babyfaces.


10. Raw - Intercontinental Champion The Miz

The Miz, Maryse
www.wwe.com

With his sixth pick, Shane McMahon will snatch up WWE Intercontinental Champion The Miz (and his wife/valet, Maryse), giving Raw sole ownership over the Intercontinental Title. Shane McMahon will remark that the competition over the championship has been as intense as it's ever been lately, continuing in the tradition of men like Randy Savage, Bret Hart, Shawn Michaels, and The Rock, and that he's proud to bring that action to Raw.

The Miz won't be as excited. He'll remind Shane McMahon that none of that would be possible without him as Intercontinental Champion, and despite all that, he wasn't one of the top ten overall selections in the draft. He'll vow to keep defending his championship not to help Raw, but to spite it and Shane McMahon, and promise that just as Shane wants to use him to make Raw more popular, he'll use the show to become an even larger star.

As for the title, Raw needs a secondary belt, and the Intercontinental Championship is just as synonymous with WWE as the red brand itself. They're a perfect fit, just as they were during the original split.


9. SmackDown - Sami Zayn

Sami Zayn
WWE.com

With Stephanie's next draft pick - her sixth and the 12th overall - she'll select another former NXT Champion in the form of Sami Zayn. Happy but humble, Zayn will come out and shake her hand, then make a promise to fans - during the early days of the original brand split, he'll say, Smackdown was famous for having the best wrestling in the world. He'll do his best to make sure that's the case once again.

The camera will cut backstage to Kevin Owens, who will be absolutely furious that his hated rival ended up on the same brand as him. Of course, that's no accident - just like The Shield are fated to be tied together for their careers, so are Zayn and Owens. The two have been tag team champions and had wars in a variety of organizations, and their link will be as apparent as ever on Smackdown.

John Cena may be the United States Champion heading into this brand split, but with Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn on his tail, that might not be true for long. Either way, the matches will help define Smackdown in the split's infancy.


8. Raw - Sasha Banks

Sasha Banks
WWE.com

With Shane's next pick, he'll take someone who's not just a future WWE Women's Champion, but one of the best workers of any gender on today's roster - Sasha Banks. Banks is only 24 years old, but she has experience stealing the show and headlining in WWE. Shane McMahon will mention all that, and say that he hopes Sasha will anchor Raw's Women's Division for many, many years to come.

With Charlotte on Smackdown and Sasha on Raw, both of the shows are guaranteed some great women's action. That also means that the upcoming Women's Championship match between the two (which won't be announced by that point, but has to be coming at SummerSlam) will be about brand bragging rights, as well.

Expect Charlotte to interrupt Sasha's drafting, coming out on stage and getting face to face with her longtime rival. With Shane already on the stage, that'll bring out Stephanie, showing that even though there's nothing officially signed between the two women, both of the general managers have a very vested interest in the outcome of that eventual title match.


7. SmackDown - Randy Orton

randy orton.jpg
WWE.com

It seems like the likeliest date for this draft would be the July 11 Raw, giving the company a week to get things in order before actually implementing the split. That means that the draft show would be filled with matches as well as selections. Imagine, then, that Sami Zayn is having one last Raw match against some heel, when all of a sudden, Randy Orton makes a surprise return to WWE, running in and nailing Zayn with a surprise RKO.

All of a sudden, the entire WWE Universe would know that Randy Orton is back, and that he's a heel. Orton's always been vocal about preferring to work as a bad guy, and even though his babyface run from 2010 to 2013 was great, his run as a face last year was less inspired. It's time to turn Orton heel once more, and an unprovoked attack on a popular face would do just that.

Of course, Randy Orton's appearance would also alert the General Managers that he's back in play, and Stephanie McMahon - who has the next pick - wouldn't waste a moment in snatching him up. Orton would be Stephanie's seventh pick, giving Smackdown another star and Zayn the opportunity for revenge.


6. Raw - Cesaro

Cesaro SmackDown
www.wwe.com

There's no doubt that Raw's roster thus far is shaping up to be incredibly strong, but Shane will boost the brand up even more when he uses his eighth draft pick to take "The Swiss Superman," Cesaro. Cesaro will come out in a suit and sunglasses, shake Shane's hand, then step to the podium to address the crowd, telling them that - with all due respect to Sami Zayn - Raw is going to be the stronger brand when it comes to in-ring action.

He may not be right, but he won't be wrong - WWE has so many amazing wrestlers on the roster right now that there's no need for one brand to eclipse the other in terms of wrestling. Both Raw and Smackdown can be "workers'" brands, and Cesaro will help attest to that on the red side.

As for his role, WWE would be smart to put the Intercontinental Title on him shortly after the split in order to build interest for Raw. Miz has done a great job as IC Champ and Cesaro has challenged him before, but putting the now even-more-important title on a babyface will generate some good buzz.


5. SmackDown - Enzo And Big Cass

Enzo Amore Big Cass
WWE.com

Raw may have scored huge when Shane McMahon drafted The New Day in the third round, but Stephanie will give Smackdown its own top tag team when she selects Enzo Amore and Big Cass as a unit in round eight.

Enzo and Cass may not be as entertaining as The New Day, but they're still a lot of fun. As another popular babyface tandem, they belong on the opposite show, giving Smackdown its own tag team centerpiece. Enzo and Cass may not be the workers that The New Day are, but they've quickly become fan favorites who are booked well - fans love Enzo because he's one of the best talkers in the company, and management loves Cass because he's humongous.

A good opening feud for Enzo and Cass on Smackdown can be with The Wyatt Family. The Wyatts were turning babyface the last time they were all on TV, but with the lack of heels in the company, it makes sense to keep them as bad guys. Enzo and Cass may be in over their heads feuding with Wyatt, Strowman, and Rowan, but there's no reason they can't enlist some help - maybe in the form of John Cena?


4. Raw - Chris Jericho

Chris Jericho
WWE.com

With the ball in Raw's court once again, Shane McMahon will select one of the greatest stars in WWE history - former Undisputed WWE Champion Chris Jericho. Like The Miz, Jericho will be annoyed at his late selection, and he'll give Shane the brush-off. He will say, though, that he's putting the WWE World Heavyweight and Intercontinental Champions on notice, as well as everyone else on the roster. Raw is, was, and always will be Jericho, and Jericho is the gift that keeps on giving (drink it in, man).

Jericho, who's celebrating his 26th year in pro wrestling, will provide a much needed veteran's presence on Raw (Smackdown will benefit from Cena and Orton). More than that, though, he's an amazing asset as a wrestler - Jericho hasn't lost a step in the ring and he's still capable of stealing the show in matches with men half his age.

A great place for Jericho would be in a feud with Cesaro after "The Swiss Superman" captures the Intercontinental Title. It's a fresh feud, and Y2J deserves a 10th reign with the IC Title. This might not be the time for that, as Cesaro's reign should be a lengthy one, but the matches will still be most memorable.


3. SmackDown - Baron Corbin

baron corbin.jpg
WWE.com

With Stephanie's penultimate pick, she'll take someone whom she describes as chock full of the "It" factor - a former Golden Gloves winner, NFL lineman, WrestleMania battle royal winner, and the toughest man in all of WWE: Baron Corbin. Corbin will come out on stage, shake Stephanie's hand, and put everyone on Smackdown on notice: whether it's John Cena, AJ Styles, or Randy Orton, all of the Smackdown superstars are just stepping stones on Baron Corbin's path to becoming WWE World Heavyweight Champion.

There's nothing pretty about Corbin (in any sense of the word), but being on Smackdown would do him good. Even though the shows are being portrayed as equal, by default there'd be less of a magnifying glass on the stars of Smackdown. Being a bit more under-the-rader would allow Corbin to develop at his own pace, and working with veterans like Cena and Orton could teach him a lot. Likewise, there would be no shortage of really talented up-and-comers for Corbin to battle on the show, hiding his weaknesses.

WWE clearly has plans for Baron Corbin in the future. Putting him on Smackdown now is the best way to ensure the a good return on investment.


2. Raw - Dolph Ziggler

Dolph Ziggle4
WWE.com

With his final selection, Shane McMahon will select someone who's seen a lot of ups and downs over the past several years - Dolph Ziggler. Dolph will come out onto the stage and step to the podium to speak, but Shane won't allow it.

Shane will respectfully - but forcefully - pull the microphone over to his own face and dress "The Showoff" down, telling him that he has as much talent as anyone on the roster, but he hasn't been using it properly. Shane will go on to say that he didn't use his last pick on the Dolph Ziggler of today, he used it on the Dolph who cashed in the Money in the Bank briefcase on Alberto Del Rio to become World Heavyweight Champion.

Dolph will simply nod and head backstage - then, on the first Raw of the new split, he'll turn heel by drilling Shane with the Zig Zag. After that, Dolph will leap up the pecking order, becoming relevant once again as a top heel on the Raw brand. Men like Dean Ambrose and Cesaro will be great opponents for the new (old) Dolph Ziggler, helping put the exclamation point on his career boost.


1. SmackDown - Apollo Crews

apollo crews.jpg
WWE.com

Stephanie McMahon will take the stage one last time to make her final draft pick, but before she announces who she's hiring, she'll take another opportunity to run down Raw. Even though she'll admit that Shane made some strong choices throughout the evening, she'll say that he missed the mark big-time with Dolph.

According to her, "The Showoff" is damaged goods and he consistently under-delivers. Stephanie, in the meantime, will use her last selection to draft someone who doesn't need a pep talk or a time machine to be great - Apollo Crews. Crews will gladly accept his membership on the Smackdown roster, promising that he and the rest of the great talent on the show will help carry the brand into the future and make Smackdown the best thing in wrestling.

There will be no shortage of programs for Crews on Smackdown, with heels like Kevin Owens, Bray Wyatt, and Randy Orton all available for feuds with the former NXT star. Crews should pick up more than just some major wins, though - within a year of the split, he should be the reigning and defending United States Champion, holding the unofficial position of leader of Smackdown and cementing himself in fans' minds as a sure-fire future WWE Champion.


In this post: 
seth rollins
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Scott Fried is a Slammy Award-winning* writer living and working in New York City. He has been following/writing about professional wrestling for many years and is a graduate of Lance Storm's Storm Wrestling Academy. Follow him on Twitter at https://twitter.com/scottfried. *Best Crowd of the Year, 2013