Vince McMahon’s Ideal WWE Superstar Body Type Through The Ages
Big Daddies.
If you were to use just one word to describe Vince McMahon, “insane” would be it. If you were to use another, you’d think “big”. McMahon himself is an impressive physical specimen, a “workout” fiend. Even his grapefruit-sized balls are big, figuratively and, you’d have to imagine, literally.
Vince McMahon thought big when he reimagined pro wrestling as a glamorous, worldwide enterprise of sports entertainment. Insidiously purchasing the various North American wrestling territories to create one big national - and subsequently international - company, Vince McMahon selected a big talisman to carry the whole thing across his tanned, rippling shoulders: Hulk Hogan. Vince knew that the ethnic regional stars of the old WWWF, the Italian-American Bruno Sammartino and the Puerto Rican Pedro Morales, were no longer fit for purpose. Vince McMahon instead went with Hogan, a living superhero with the moral compass to convince Middle America to fall for Vince’s shiny and repurposed blood sport.
Hogan modelled himself after the equally big Superstar Billy Graham, using his own heroic charisma to become a big household name. His act was practically magic. Who else but Hogan, the very sight of whom inspired goosebumps, could get away with the hokey “hulk up” routine?
This routine was a sensation, and turned the regional WWWF into the big WWF - a national mainstream powerhouse. The underrated commercial run of the muscled Macho Man Randy Savage not withstanding, it was Hogan who built that house.
We mock Vince for falling behind the times, but he grasped the wider zeitgeist perfectly in the 1980s; the stars of the squared circle and silver screen alike were über-inflated action heroes, the pinnacle of masculinity.
When Hogan attempted to join his spiritual brothers Arnold Schwarzenegger and Sly Stallone in Hollywood, McMahon thought big when appointing his replacement. That replacement was the equally rippled Ultimate Warrior. Warrior had muscles on top of muscles on top of problematic opinions. He had muscles where his talent should have been. That, to McMahon, was enough. CONT'D...
Warrior was a man so muscled people thought he had died and been replaced by a skinny doppelgänger when he stopped - and it’s safe to write this now - injecting himself with steroids, the not-so-secret agent behind the whole WWF enterprise.
The steroids spelled the end - very briefly - of the big man. The early 1990s scandal forced Vince into a re-think. Despite the fan-appointed Bret Hart earning raves for his workrate, Vince’s desire for “big” went unfulfilled. Unable to push performers boasting “enhanced” physiques, Vince happened upon the idea of pushing, ahem, rotund gentlemen in their place. The girth giant that was Yokozuna and the let’s-face-it-obese Mabel occupied the headliner ranks throughout the New Generation, at least until it became apparent that slow and tedious matches were slow and tedious. Muscles were too risky, blubber was too boring. McMahon, with no other option, had to rely on in-ring talent when height failed, too.
The very tall Diesel represented an all-time commercial low for the company throughout his 1994-95 run as WWF Champion. Diesel, at a billed height of 6’ 10”, failed to heighten the excitement of WWF fans - possibly because Vince stripped him of his badass aura and repositioned him as a smiling jackass. Or because SummerSlam 1995 was sold on the strength of Tall Vs. Fat, Diesel Vs. Mabel. Even with business on its a*se, McMahon played to an audience of one. You almost had to admire the man, at least until you watched the match. It was a big bust.
It was up to Hart, again, to carry the company, with the equally athletic and talented and comparatively diminutive Shawn Michaels acting as talisman throughout 1996. Miraculously, Vince didn’t march them out to the ring on stilts.
In the years that followed, the furore surrounding the steroid scandal dissipated. Slowly, the top stars of the WWF grew big once again. The Attitude Era headline acts, Mick Foley excepted, were very…defined. Though nobody was on trial, and thus nobody testified, you’d have to live in Hulk Hogan’s fantasy land to deny that the culture was back. Big time.
As the popularity of the Attitude Era waned, and the muscle monsters of the Ruthless Aggression era quietly honed their skills in Ohio Valley Wrestling, McMahon was forced to settle for Chris Benoit and Eddie Guerrero in the interim. They were juiced to the gills, but that wasn’t enough because they weren’t tall enough.
Brock Lesnar, John Cena, Batista: they were more like it, pal. For a brief time, McMahon revelled once again in big stars and big gates - the OVW star vehicle that was WrestleMania 21 became the biggest-drawing pay-per-view ever for its time - but the events of the Benoit double murder suicide in 2007 and the subsequent Signature Pharmacy Scandal set in motion the definitive end of steroid use in WWE.
Maybe. CONT'D...
Soon, though not ideal for the macrophiliac Vince McMahon, the ideal of a WWE Superstar changed forever. As the years rolled by, the smaller likes of CM Punk and Daniel Bryan represented Cena’s only viable competition. The rise of the “workrate” era, in parallel with the cleansing of the company, converged to curb the physiques of the top WWE acts. The shrunken but fiercely loyal WWE fanbase - naturally referred to as a “Universe” by McMahon - grew to prefer big matches to big stars.
In 2015, rumours circulated that Vince McMahon was going blind. Though quickly quashed, this might explain his affection for Jinder Mahal two years later. Selected for his heritage and insane vascularity, Vince must have done so through the process of braille reading. Unfortunately for Vince, who never changed, wrestling changed around him. In-the-know fans resented and rejected WWE Champion Jinder Mahal as a transparent attempt to venture into an emerging market - and as an unremarkable, by-the-numbers plodder.
Mahal called into question both McMahon’s decision-making and the integrity of the Wellness Policy introduced after Eddie Guerrero’s 2005 death. How Mahal arrived at a physique drier than an Alberto Del Rio promo is a mystery. Chicken? Broccoli? A substance undetected by a Wellness Policy that, visibly, isn’t big on being foolproof?
We know with some certainty that the Wellness Policy is at least selective in its coverage. Vince’s “boy”, Brock Lesnar, is not immune to it. Lesnar is one spray tan away from representing McMahon’s platonic ideal, which explains why he is positioned so ludicrously. The Lesnar loophole is not in effect elsewhere. Only Braun Strowman meets the traditional McMahon remit in 2018 - weirdly, his real boy, Roman Reigns, covers his chest - but stubbornness seems to have superseded “big” as Vince’s default mentality.
Vince McMahon’s ideal body type is and always was big. Nowadays, the majority of the roster are no longer allowed to become big.
Perhaps that’s why he seems to hate them so much.